You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour hypocrisy
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour hypocrisy


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 22 9.23am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Unfortunately, whilst the 'brightest minds doing the hardest jobs' may seem for all the world the most logical approach, as soon as quotas for diversity are not hit you'll have those who have failed by every other means storming social media and so forth to claim 'facism'.

The education system will then be reformed so as not to favour the groups that are succeeding and before you know it somebody belonging to a gender you have never heard of, with hair died all the colours of the rainbow, dressed like a 1960's ragdoll, who cries at every discussion about anything when things don't go their way and their every whim is not catered to, will be in charge of the aforementioned reform. Welcome to the 'new world'.

I garland your comments with praise.
I doff my hat.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 30 Nov 22 9.28am

A friend's son is at Oxford after attending Dulwich College which is a well known private school. He is a nice kid but is finding it hard to fit in.

Apparently there is quite a large intake from state schools these students do not like kids from the private schools and let them no it.

They have even looked up the fees and demanded to know how he's parents could afford it.*

Once upon a time a poor kid at Oxford was the odd one out soon it will be kids who went to private schools and neither case has anything to do with ability.

This is the new world we live in.


*His dad has his own architect business and his mum (my friend) is a writer both came from poor backgrounds worked hard and wanted the best for their kids. The whole family are thoroughly decent well balanced fair people. His twin sister is at Edinburgh University they are both smart kids who worked bloody hard for their excellent grades, in fact I remember his mother complaining that they worked too hard and not enough play time with their mates.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Nov 22 5.26pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Unfortunately, whilst the 'brightest minds doing the hardest jobs' may seem for all the world the most logical approach, as soon as quotas for diversity are not hit you'll have those who have failed by every other means storming social media and so forth to claim 'facism'.

The education system will then be reformed so as not to favour the groups that are succeeding and before you know it somebody belonging to a gender you have never heard of, with hair died all the colours of the rainbow, dressed like a 1960's ragdoll, who cries at every discussion about anything when things don't go their way and their every whim is not catered to, will be in charge of the aforementioned reform. Welcome to the 'new world'.

Indeed sir, it's been a terrible blight on what should have been beneficial to society in general.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 30 Nov 22 7.26pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

This question was always a hard one for me as I feel the arguments on both sides of the aisle have legitimate points of worth.

So at various points I've been on both sides of this topic.

So being someone who believes in natural law I have to go back to first principles. In that case it's the acknowledgement that hierarchy will always be with us and that default equality results in more harm than good.

So I want the brightest minds doing the hardest jobs within the national talent pool that's available. That should be independent of money or status.

So I would go back to the original aims of grammar schools....I would set regulations so the sharp elbowed middle class couldn't fill all the spaces; if the working class child was bright enough they were going independent of means.

I think for many years the grammar system was used to extend advantage for those with means to gerrymander the system.

So I believe in a grammar school system that operates on the IQ system not the class system. But again, that is not an invite for progressive ideologies like CRT and all the rest of it.

It is purely an education device for ensuring the brightest minds are doing the hardest jobs for the betterment of both themselves and for society in general.

Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Nov 2022 8.11am)

It's nice to be able to agree with you on something. I too believe in a meritocracy and if the academically gifted will benefit from a grammar school then it's in all our interests that they do. That though doesn't seem to have any connection to private education! Grammar schools can be, and are, state funded.

In fact I am instinctively opposed to private education, which I regard, as with health provision, as something that should be the exclusive responsibility of us collectively and not individually.

I am also opposed to any kind of positive discrimination, or quotas. I find such concepts totally at odds with the principles of a meritocracy. If that results in an uneven distribution of places being allocated between men and women, racial groups or whatever, then the reasons why need to dealt with at source and not the sticking plaster of quotas. The way the better off should pay more is through taxation.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Matov Flag 30 Nov 22 9.16pm

Originally posted by Badger11

A friend's son is at Oxford after attending Dulwich College which is a well known private school. He is a nice kid but is finding it hard to fit in.

Apparently there is quite a large intake from state schools these students do not like kids from the private schools and let them no it.

Fantastic to read.

When my kids where looking at University we went up to Oxford for one of the open days. Now much to my chagrin neither decided it was for them (and both got the kind of grades necessary) but that was their choice and made for the right reasons.

But the people at Oxford were almost pleading for kids from state schools to apply. There was no dropping of standards in terms of grades but they wanted the brightest and the best and the reality is that the public schools effectively coach their pupils to get into Oxford and Cambridge and it is a policy clearly screwing this country over given the state of our current elites who did go there.

Oxford blew me away. Left me speechless because there is a genuine magic to the colleges. Just those few hours spend walking around made me realise why it is so special but also bloody dangerous because I really got why it fosters the elites it does.

Because as they stressed to us, the difficult part is getting there. But once that is done then literally every door opens up.

And I want more kids from state schools going through those doors. I believe in elites running things. How the world works. But those elites are clearly not up to it as things stand.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Dec 22 8.13am

Originally posted by Matov

Fantastic to read.

When my kids where looking at University we went up to Oxford for one of the open days. Now much to my chagrin neither decided it was for them (and both got the kind of grades necessary) but that was their choice and made for the right reasons.

But the people at Oxford were almost pleading for kids from state schools to apply. There was no dropping of standards in terms of grades but they wanted the brightest and the best and the reality is that the public schools effectively coach their pupils to get into Oxford and Cambridge and it is a policy clearly screwing this country over given the state of our current elites who did go there.

Oxford blew me away. Left me speechless because there is a genuine magic to the colleges. Just those few hours spend walking around made me realise why it is so special but also bloody dangerous because I really got why it fosters the elites it does.

Because as they stressed to us, the difficult part is getting there. But once that is done then literally every door opens up.

And I want more kids from state schools going through those doors. I believe in elites running things. How the world works. But those elites are clearly not up to it as things stand.


Actually you have put it better that I did. Or as the Who sang "Meet the new boss, same as the old boss".

Edited by Badger11 (01 Dec 2022 8.13am)

 


One more point

Matov Flag 01 Dec 22 8.26am

Originally posted by Badger11

Actually you have put it better that I did. Or as the Who sang "Meet the new boss, same as the old boss".

Edited by Badger11 (01 Dec 2022 8.13am)

Maybe. But state educated kids who make it to Oxford do so despite their backgrounds, not because of them.

And ultimately will prove to be more fit for purpose. Essentially they have to be smarter to ultimately make it because they have not been groomed since they were 5 to end up there.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Dec 22 8.32am

Originally posted by Matov

Maybe. But state educated kids who make it to Oxford do so despite their backgrounds, not because of them.

And ultimately will prove to be more fit for purpose. Essentially they have to be smarter to ultimately make it because they have not been groomed since they were 5 to end up there.

Perhaps but like I was saying they are now as bad as the Toffs who used to rule the roost.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Dec 22 8.38am

Originally posted by Matov

Maybe. But state educated kids who make it to Oxford do so despite their backgrounds, not because of them.

And ultimately will prove to be more fit for purpose. Essentially they have to be smarter to ultimately make it because they have not been groomed since they were 5 to end up there.

Excellent points.

There is definitely a point about coaching over natural ability IQ wise. Personally, I feel that when you need to pick out the cream from amongst already very good students natural IQ needs to be the decisive factor put front and centre.

If I had a say on it I'd be looking to devise tests that told me who were naturally the brightest. Once I have that information then I can select the hardest working from amongst those. I wouldn't be waiting until university though....once again, they knew and understood this better in the past.

Then I have the natural elite regardless of background.....though I understand that for other reasons it will still favour the middle and higher classes.


Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Dec 2022 8.41am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Matov Flag 01 Dec 22 8.49am

Originally posted by Badger11

Perhaps but like I was saying they are now as bad as the Toffs who used to rule the roost.

As bad? Really? Look at the current crop of supposed 'Brightest and Best'. Nah.

Brash, smart, aggressive, working class kids bright enough to make it to Oxford is what the country needs. My only, dissident right take on it, is that not enough poor white kids would have received sufficient support to make it but we can work that out later.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Dec 22 9.15am

Originally posted by Matov

As bad? Really? Look at the current crop of supposed 'Brightest and Best'. Nah.

Brash, smart, aggressive, working class kids bright enough to make it to Oxford is what the country needs. My only, dissident right take on it, is that not enough poor white kids would have received sufficient support to make it but we can work that out later.

I absolutely agree.

It is astonishing how many 'top jobs' go to people who come from privileged backgrounds but are just downright thick. And I mean thick.

Has long been my opinion that objective, intelligence based assessment should be determined for the 'best and brightest' and agree regarding they should be elevated and singled out for the 'elite'. It amazes how often I see somebody holds a position that does not align whatsoever to their 'French' degree from Oxbridge. What the f has that got to do with the price of fish?

Equally however, it is why I am so set against 'diversity targets/quotas'. It is my full opinion that objective intelligence/potential assessments would naturally produce a 'diverse pool' of talent. Getting into educational institutions at the top echelon of the field as a result of either a) because of your ticking boxes or b) because of mummmy and daddy, are both equally ridiculous, a waste of opportunity for individuals and the wider society, anti-social and anti-logical.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour hypocrisy