You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs. Brighton match thread
November 16 2026 3.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs. Brighton match thread


Page 15 of 15 << First< 11 12 13 14 15
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 12 Feb 23 8.48pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Arsenal, West Ham and Brighton denied victories by VAR.

The West Ham one stands out, where the spam defender tipped a goal-bound ball expertly round the post.

However somehow that was 'not handball'!

To my mind the Brighton scorer was not offside but their player in front of him to the left was, when the ball was last kicked.

But it's all become totally bonkers.

Scrap VAR completely and change handball to be deliberate and offside to be a player completely in front of the last defender when the ball last kicked.

Just a thought.



Ridiculous.

Just put people in charge who know how to use it properly.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 13 Feb 23 2.38am

This was typical of our recent play and we were so lucky to get a point thanks to the VAR decision and a goalkeeping howler which was no doubt probably induced by a lack of concentration having had nothing to do until that point.
The most disappointing thing from the game for me was that having been gifted an equaliser and having subs ready to come on to try and change the game before we equalised, how poor we were in the final 15 - 20 minutes and how little we created.
If we sack Viera can we at least line up a decent replacement before doing so?
Over the last few weeks from the matches i have seen we are currently the worst team in the division.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Feb 23 6.14am

Originally posted by viveasheagle


If we sack Viera can we at least line up a decent replacement before doing so?

Will there be a queue of people wanting to manage Crystal Parish?

 

YT Flag Oxford 13 Feb 23 7.30am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Tompkins, also known as 'Tonks', bestrode the match like a colossus.

Surging forward in the 69th minute, he raced into the Albion box and planted a bullet header past the demoralised defenders into the gaping empty net.

With typical modesty reminiscent of Sir Bobby Moore deceased he just said he thought it was what the Selhurst Park faithful wanted.

And he doesn't even have a VPN.

Remarkable.

COYP.

And also known as Tomkins.

Edited by YT (13 Feb 2023 7.31am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Feb 23 8.08am

Originally posted by YT

And also known as Tomkins.

Edited by YT (13 Feb 2023 7.31am)

That comes up time and time again.

I genuinely thought it was some sort of 'in' nickname for a long time but every now and then it still makes me question my reality... more so than usual.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Den1923 Flag 13 Feb 23 10.13am

I cannot understand PV in his post match interviews when he says our discipline enabled us to get a point (instead of VAR). What he should have said is that we were awful 25% possession, shots on target 1 (Brighton 7), total passes 229(BHA 695),passing success 71% (BHA 90%). both our L&R backs only made one tackle between them during the whole match and as usual sleepy and error prone Mitchell gets caught out every time at the back post which usually costs us a goal as it did again on Saturday.

We are in trouble despite our mid table position (12th) as we are just 7 points above 18th and have a plus two goal difference margin of over the team currently in 18th spot. We have managed just 3 from 15 points in our last five games and the bottom of the table is coming up to our level fast.

It's hard to see where the points are going to come from, between now and 1st April:- (away, Brentford, Aston Villa, BHA, Arsenal & home, Liverpool, Man City, Leicester). Especially so, when you take in to consideration our poor defending, passing and our inability to score goals.

I really do not blame PV for the current poor form as he did make it clear in the summer what he wanted and again in this past window. clearly what he has got, he seems not to be unhappy with as he shows a reluctance to give them a start. Those clubs around us have strengthened, leaving PV to virtually get on with what he has available ( recurring theme at Palace). If we do get relegated this year (and I really hope not!), then the balme sits squarely with Parish, it really is time for him to step aside, thank him for his past endeavours but at the same time acknowledge that he has reached his level of incompetence.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Feb 23 10.21am

Originally posted by Den1923

I cannot understand PV in his post match interviews when he says our discipline enabled us to get a point (instead of VAR). What he should have said is that we were awful 25% possession, shots on target 1 (Brighton 7), total passes 229(BHA 695),passing success 71% (BHA 90%). both our L&R backs only made one tackle between them during the whole match and as usual sleepy and error prone Mitchell gets caught out every time at the back post which usually costs us a goal as it did again on Saturday.

We are in trouble despite our mid table position (12th) as we are just 7 points above 18th and have a plus two goal difference margin of over the team currently in 18th spot. We have managed just 3 from 15 points in our last five games and the bottom of the table is coming up to our level fast.

It's hard to see where the points are going to come from, between now and 1st April:- (away, Brentford, Aston Villa, BHA, Arsenal & home, Liverpool, Man City, Leicester). Especially so, when you take in to consideration our poor defending, passing and our inability to score goals.

I really do not blame PV for the current poor form as he did make it clear in the summer what he wanted and again in this past window. clearly what he has got, he seems not to be unhappy with as he shows a reluctance to give them a start. Those clubs around us have strengthened, leaving PV to virtually get on with what he has available ( recurring theme at Palace). If we do get relegated this year (and I really hope not!), then the balme sits squarely with Parish, it really is time for him to step aside, thank him for his past endeavours but at the same time acknowledge that he has reached his level of incompetence.

Under Steve's 'Watch' we have reached an FA Cup final and this is our 10th season in the PL.
A club which almost went out of existence prior to his arrival.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 13 Feb 23 10.25am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

I think PV he’s been found out tactically, there is one thing managing in a laid back, I couldn’t give a s*** French league to a full on high intensity Premier league.

The Brighton manager had him on toast for 90 minutes, I can’t believe we got a point at the end. Then his post match interview was bizarre, how can he say “ we were solid and defended well against a good Brighton team”

When the post match interview should have been “ we were run ragged for 94 minutes and some how we stole a point against a team who we normally have the better of time and again”

I am not sure I would place too much significance to post-match interviews.

In public, most managers put some gloss on their team's performance even when it has been poor, or are at least very mildly critical in their comments, for fear of alienating themselves from the players.

In public loyalty to the team comes first but it doesn't mean that behind the scenes the manager is saying the same thing - or at least one hopes not.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Feb 23 10.56am

Originally posted by Pete53

I am not sure I would place too much significance to post-match interviews.

In public, most managers put some gloss on their team's performance even when it has been poor, or are at least very mildly critical in their comments, for fear of alienating themselves from the players.

In public loyalty to the team comes first but it doesn't mean that behind the scenes the manager is saying the same thing - or at least one hopes not.


I think you're right. I reacted negatively to his comment in the post-match TV interviews but when I heard the start of his post-match press conference, he said how pleased he was to get a point in a tone and with facial expressions that clearly said that Christmas had come early and he couldn't believe we'd got away with it. He then went on talking the loyalty speak you mention above.

 

PJEagle Flag London 13 Feb 23 11.01am

Originally posted by Willo

Under Steve's 'Watch' we have reached an FA Cup final and this is our 10th season in the PL.
A club which almost went out of existence prior to his arrival.

A very good point Willo. He has achieved a huge amount for Palace

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 13 Feb 23 11.27am

A lot of which is history & currently the club is at best treading water.
We will not make any further progress without a significant shake up in ownership.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 13 Feb 23 11.49am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Tompkins, also known as 'Tonks', bestrode the match like a colossus.

Surging forward in the 69th minute, he raced into the Albion box and planted a bullet header past the demoralised defenders into the gaping empty net.

With typical modesty reminiscent of Sir Bobby Moore deceased he just said he thought it was what the Selhurst Park faithful wanted.

And he doesn't even have a VPN.

Remarkable.

COYP.
___________________________________________________________

I am sure we all realised that your quote about Tompkins bestriding the match like a colossus was channelling the speech by Cassius in Act One Scene Two of Shakespeare's Julius Ceasar. But was there a source for the other phrase you showed in bold, namely gaping empty net?


Edited by peterg (13 Feb 2023 11.49am)

 


The right place at the right time

Den1923 Flag 13 Feb 23 12.51pm

Originally posted by Willo

Under Steve's 'Watch' we have reached an FA Cup final and this is our 10th season in the PL.
A club which almost went out of existence prior to his arrival.

I am not disagreeing with you Willo, however, it is the future that matters, not the past, there are many example of business that were good in the past but they are not around today because they did progress and update as they moved forward. Frankly it's embarrassing seeing the progress of BHA, Brentford etc, whilst we tread water at best. Under Parish our recruiting has been abysmal, we have allowed the sick, lame and useless to extend contracts, we have no succession planning. Our EPL survival is really under threat and that has also happened under SP watch so please lets be honest we need more able and committed owners to take us forward and for that to happen Parish has to go!

 

WJK1960 Flag 13 Feb 23 1.04pm

Originally posted by Den1923

I am not disagreeing with you Willo, however, it is the future that matters, not the past, there are many example of business that were good in the past but they are not around today because they did progress and update as they moved forward. Frankly it's embarrassing seeing the progress of BHA, Brentford etc, whilst we tread water at best. Under Parish our recruiting has been abysmal, we have allowed the sick, lame and useless to extend contracts, we have no succession planning. Our EPL survival is really under threat and that has also happened under SP watch so please lets be honest we need more able and committed owners to take us forward and for that to happen Parish has to go!

For my own interest I checked how much Brighton had paid for certain players and it is clear their talent search and recruitment is absolutely sensational.
Caicedo - £4m
Mitoma - £3m
MacAllister - £7m
Solly March - bought from non league Lewes for a caravan (ok, Ive just made that last bit up). He did come from Lewes however and apparently he was on our books as a teenager too.

We can only look in envy - pound for pound that must be the best recruitment in the Premier League.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Feb 23 1.15pm

Originally posted by WJK1960

For my own interest I checked how much Brighton had paid for certain players and it is clear their talent search and recruitment is absolutely sensational.
Caicedo - £4m
Mitoma - £3m
MacAllister - £7m
Solly March - bought from non league Lewes for a caravan (ok, Ive just made that last bit up). He did come from Lewes however and apparently he was on our books as a teenager too.

We can only look in envy - pound for pound that must be the best recruitment in the Premier League.

From last season's squad :

Cucurella - Bought for £15 Mill. Sold for a sum that could reach £62 Mill.
Bissouma - Bought for £15 Mill. Sold for a sum that could reach £30 Mill.
Trossard - Bought for £18 Mill. Sold for a sum that could reach £27 Mill.

Despite selling these players they are still doing well in the PL.

 

Den1923 Flag 13 Feb 23 1.33pm

Originally posted by Willo

From last season's squad :

Cucurella - Bought for £15 Mill. Sold for a sum that could reach £62 Mill.
Bissouma - Bought for £15 Mill. Sold for a sum that could reach £30 Mill.
Trossard - Bought for £18 Mill. Sold for a sum that could reach £27 Mill.

Despite selling these players they are still doing well in the PL.

Don't forget Ben White, free transfer and sold to the Gunners for £50mil!

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 13 Feb 23 3.47pm

Originally posted by silvertop

PS I know we were crap and it's particularly difficult to watch us being toyed with by that team. But would you really swap with Leeds?

No, would never swap!
But would not mind the energy of this Leeds side. Palace looks like a team full of pensioners in comparison.

 

Page 15 of 15 << First< 11 12 13 14 15

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs. Brighton match thread