You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 15 Minute Cities.
November 21 2026 9.35pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

15 Minute Cities.


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 22 Feb 23 4.45pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

A film that always made me shiver was Logan's Run. It was released in 1976, those of a certain age may remember it.

Set in 2274 in a 'utopian' city within an enclosed dome, where there is little or no work for humans to perform, and inhabitants are free to pursue all of the pleasures of life. The one catch: your life is limited to the age of thirty, then you are terminated.

To be honest all this ULEZ and 15 minute city nonsense sounds like life is beginning to follow art. The concept of being encouraged to keep within a close radius of home is alien to most and although, for various reasons I am not as mobile as I once was, it feels like the future is going to become a very dull and restricted place.

Bah Humbug!

POG,
this film gave rise to the term ' to do a Logans' in the 70s/80s
which was a runner from the curry house.
A popular sport with young men in late teens, early 20s (with some risk of a wack if caught) at the time.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 22 Feb 23 5.26pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

During the Medieval, Serfs were tied to the land they tilled. Not allowed to wander far away.....without the express permission of the Lord of the Manor. You must stay in your little cottage and do your work. Failure or refusal to be brainwashed by the Church was strongly discouraged.

The Black Death pandemic did away with that as Labour became scarce and wages needed to be competitive. Which indirectly fed into the Peasant's Revolt.


The Covid pandemic has enslaved us again. ID cards, vaccination certs, the BBC licence fee. 15 minute Cities.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (22 Feb 2023 12.59pm)

Jesus

Enslaved? The only thing enslaving people is the same thing that's been enslaving them for centuries. Money. Have less, do less. Have more, do more. Fairly simple.

On the subject of your list, if we're talking about the UK

ID cards
Most of our essential 'keys' are now on our phones anyway. Absorbing an ID, drivers license and passport into them is a natural, logical step. It would also save a big chunk of money.

Vaccination certs
Long gone

License fee
Struggling to see how this is 'enslaving' me in the age of youtube/streaming

The only thing that will generate a peasants revolt is the ever increasing gap between the affluent and the poverty stricken, and automation.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 22 Feb 23 5.36pm

From what I understand this is simply a glorified planning initiative.

'Plan your city around making sure all necessary amenities are within a 15-minute walk'

Translation, make peoples lives easier and ensure it's less about luck or status as to whether you have access to essential and beneficial amenities.

Personally I think it's more of a planning concept, i.e. have hubs within cities so most of the time you're 15-20 mins walk away from the essentials.

However, I don't think this is particularly cost effective to retrofit. Planning a new city or town, fine. Makes sense.

Weirdly people have taken it to mean dystopian fenced off quarantine zones, guarded by the military and where you need to show ID to leave and enter. Riiight

'A 15-minute city does not confine us to our neighbourhoods or restrict our ability to travel. If your city adopts a 15-minute city approach, it simply means that it will become more possible and pleasant to meet more of your day-to-day needs, like buying groceries, within a short walk or bike ride from home if you want to. It means creating the conditions for local businesses, that rely on local custom, to thrive. Millions of people in cities around the world already live like this, and always have done; others are forced to travel to meet basic needs. Being able to do more close to home does not change to your freedom to travel further whenever you would like to.'

Sounds good to me, as long as the area in question is easy to develop according to that approach. Needs to be applied to suitable candidate areas only to avoid massive waste on consultancy fees and ballooning budgets.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Matov Flag 22 Feb 23 9.15pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

any other retirement-cities that Eagles would recommend ?


Edited by PalazioVecchio (22 Feb 2023 1.16pm)

Oddly enough, Albania, almost anywhere along its coast line. Never been but from what I understand, a real gem. Plus it must be half empty by now.

Or Belgrade. Again, not an obvious choice but only hear good things about it.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Grumbles 22 Feb 23 9.27pm

Originally posted by Matov

Oddly enough, Albania, almost anywhere along its coast line. Never been but from what I understand, a real gem. Plus it must be half empty by now.

Or Belgrade. Again, not an obvious choice but only hear good things about it.

it is good, you could even see your stolen car drive down the road.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Feb 23 1.46pm


An article against.


[Link]

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 23 Feb 23 6.39pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


An article against.


[Link]

mmmm – it appears to be more against the separate policy being introduced increasing traffic / car restrictions, which the article itself states is not the same policy as the '15 minute city' concept. I don't see the causality link there, TBH, other than that's how Oxford have chosen to implement it by dovetailing with vehicle restrictions. Doesn't Oxford have the highest bike use or journeys by bike in the UK? Sort of makes sense for them to develop that and accommodate it somehow. Their bike first approach would never work in Croydon, for example.

Cars are pretty important generally, even to wealthy people – I think if you said no cars at all in this zone it wouldn't just be tradies and the poor kicking off. It would be dysfunctional and penal economically.

It's also worth pointing out that the concept itself is not inherently anti-car, nor can it be really.

As long as you implement it sensibly and with consideration, then I see no reason why it can't benefit everyone. The problem is, as with everything, people (more specifically councils) implementing it badly.

I get the point about penalising people who can't afford to go electric, for example... and I'd say that phasing out combustion more gradually would be a better idea. It's going to happen anyway because of commercial decisions by carmarkers, but maybe you don't get that universal change without a bit of over legislation. However change always has losers. That's life unfortunately.

There appear to be plenty of cities that have already implemented it successfully, and not all have done so by being predominantly 'anti-car'

Barcelona’s ‘superblock’ approach, first implemented in the Poblenou neighbourhood which has seen a 31% increase in the number of ground-level commercial establishments – rising from 65 to 85 – indicating a positive impact on commercial activity.

Bogotá’s ‘vital neighbourhoods’ vision, which is aiming to improve quality of life by improving streets and communities, including through a series of children’s priority zones centred around childcare centres.

Buenos Aires is working to bring green space, fresh food markets, health services, recycling points and other amenities to every neighbourhood, and improving walking and cycling infrastructure – including by creating one of the world’s largest car-free zones.

Melbourne began implementing a 20-minute pilot programme in three areas, and established a Movement and Place framework that puts people at the centre of transport planning, informed by a Local Liveability study. The city’s research found that 20 minutes is the maximum time that people are willing to walk to meet their daily needs locally.

Milan is upgrading streetscapes through its open squares and roads programmes, sustainable urban mobility plan, and introduction of a 30 km/h city speed limit (down from 50 km/h) on 60% of the road network.

Paris is treating schools as neighbourhood ‘capitals’, enabling these properties to serve multiple functions alongside childhood education, and working to strengthen local commercial networks, services and production under a ‘Produced in Paris’ brand.

Portland benefited from baseline studies that sought to understand the potential of 20-minute neighbourhoods, and an anti-displacement action plan that aims to ensure equitable development and reduce displacement and its impact – both developed with the participation of residents.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 23 Feb 23 7.33pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

mmmm – it appears to be more against the separate policy being introduced increasing traffic / car restrictions, which the article itself states is not the same policy as the '15 minute city' concept. I don't see the causality link there, TBH, other than that's how Oxford have chosen to implement it by dovetailing with vehicle restrictions. Doesn't Oxford have the highest bike use or journeys by bike in the UK? Sort of makes sense for them to develop that and accommodate it somehow. Their bike first approach would never work in Croydon, for example.

Cars are pretty important generally, even to wealthy people – I think if you said no cars at all in this zone it wouldn't just be tradies and the poor kicking off. It would be dysfunctional and penal economically.

It's also worth pointing out that the concept itself is not inherently anti-car, nor can it be really.

As long as you implement it sensibly and with consideration, then I see no reason why it can't benefit everyone. The problem is, as with everything, people (more specifically councils) implementing it badly.

I get the point about penalising people who can't afford to go electric, for example... and I'd say that phasing out combustion more gradually would be a better idea. It's going to happen anyway because of commercial decisions by carmarkers, but maybe you don't get that universal change without a bit of over legislation. However change always has losers. That's life unfortunately.

There appear to be plenty of cities that have already implemented it successfully, and not all have done so by being predominantly 'anti-car'

Barcelona’s ‘superblock’ approach, first implemented in the Poblenou neighbourhood which has seen a 31% increase in the number of ground-level commercial establishments – rising from 65 to 85 – indicating a positive impact on commercial activity.

Bogotá’s ‘vital neighbourhoods’ vision, which is aiming to improve quality of life by improving streets and communities, including through a series of children’s priority zones centred around childcare centres.

Buenos Aires is working to bring green space, fresh food markets, health services, recycling points and other amenities to every neighbourhood, and improving walking and cycling infrastructure – including by creating one of the world’s largest car-free zones.

Melbourne began implementing a 20-minute pilot programme in three areas, and established a Movement and Place framework that puts people at the centre of transport planning, informed by a Local Liveability study. The city’s research found that 20 minutes is the maximum time that people are willing to walk to meet their daily needs locally.

Milan is upgrading streetscapes through its open squares and roads programmes, sustainable urban mobility plan, and introduction of a 30 km/h city speed limit (down from 50 km/h) on 60% of the road network.

Paris is treating schools as neighbourhood ‘capitals’, enabling these properties to serve multiple functions alongside childhood education, and working to strengthen local commercial networks, services and production under a ‘Produced in Paris’ brand.

Portland benefited from baseline studies that sought to understand the potential of 20-minute neighbourhoods, and an anti-displacement action plan that aims to ensure equitable development and reduce displacement and its impact – both developed with the participation of residents.

Portland… the same one that got smashed to bits by antifa you mean.
No one wants to be there more than 20 minutes

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 15 Minute Cities.