You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The farce that is the British Civil Service...
November 21 2026 9.36pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The farce that is the British Civil Service...


Matov Flag 03 Mar 23 6.32am

[Link]

This is beyond parody.

And an example of exactly why the UK is so so screwed.

One of my own 'rules' about trying to comprehend what is going on in British politics is to focus on who is appointed to the 'Chief of Staff' position for the senior leaders. It tells you heaps about what is going on behind the scenes.

To put somebody like this in place beggars belief on a multiple of levels. And makes you question everything this woman has touched beforehand.

Edited by Matov (03 Mar 2023 6.52am)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 03 Mar 23 7.17am

Originally posted by Matov

[Link]

This is beyond parody.

And an example of exactly why the UK is so so screwed.

One of my own 'rules' about trying to comprehend what is going on in British politics is to focus on who is appointed to the 'Chief of Staff' position for the senior leaders. It tells you heaps about what is going on behind the scenes.

To put somebody like this in place beggars belief on a multiple of levels. And makes you question everything this woman has touched beforehand.

Edited by Matov (03 Mar 2023 6.52am)

So she was head of propriety and ethics between 2012 and 2018 but was just as strict when Labour were in Government? Am I missing something or what previous role did she have?
This sort of appointment is not surprising, as I have said many times, the days of an unbiased Civil Service are long gone

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 03 Mar 23 7.19am

Originally posted by Matov

[Link]

This is beyond parody.

And an example of exactly why the UK is so so screwed.

One of my own 'rules' about trying to comprehend what is going on in British politics is to focus on who is appointed to the 'Chief of Staff' position for the senior leaders. It tells you heaps about what is going on behind the scenes.

To put somebody like this in place beggars belief on a multiple of levels. And makes you question everything this woman has touched beforehand.

Edited by Matov (03 Mar 2023 6.52am)

It does now seem obvious that for years Sue Gray pretended to be an impartial civil servant on the instructions of the left, just waiting for a moment at some point when this fake impartiality would lead to a Tory government appointing her to write a report she could use to shaft said leader of the day when on fact that leader was in fact so daft he had no idea what a party was.

They should make a movie.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Mar 23 7.43am

Of course the Cons are now saying "it was a stitch up". By the same token, are they also saying they didn't flout Covid rules and get all their party food and wine on expenses ?

You could also suggest that he appointment is a very astute move by Sir Kier, in order to make sure his own party is in order, and seen to be so.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 03 Mar 23 11.13am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Of course the Cons are now saying "it was a stitch up". By the same token, are they also saying they didn't flout Covid rules and get all their party food and wine on expenses ?

You could also suggest that he appointment is a very astute move by Sir Kier, in order to make sure his own party is in order, and seen to be so.

You coukld say that but it would miss the point entirely.

It calls into question the integrity of the civil service.
This woman's every decision should now be investigated.

In truth, it should be no surprise to anyone who ever left their house, that the civil service is packed with Lefties.

 

Matov Flag 03 Mar 23 11.57am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You coukld say that but it would miss the point entirely.

It calls into question the integrity of the civil service.
This woman's every decision should now be investigated.

In truth, it should be no surprise to anyone who ever left their house, that the civil service is packed with Lefties.

Absolutely. The problem is now that the Tories can now, with perfect legitimacy, ask serious questions about how impartial this lady has been.


 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 03 Mar 23 1.52pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Of course the Cons are now saying "it was a stitch up". By the same token, are they also saying they didn't flout Covid rules and get all their party food and wine on expenses ?

You could also suggest that he appointment is a very astute move by Sir Kier, in order to make sure his own party is in order, and seen to be so.

When Richard Sharp was appointed to the BBC you were critical of that.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Mar 23 3.05pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Of course the Cons are now saying "it was a stitch up". By the same token, are they also saying they didn't flout Covid rules and get all their party food and wine on expenses ?

You could also suggest that he appointment is a very astute move by Sir Kier, in order to make sure his own party is in order, and seen to be so.

You are wasting your breath with all this logic and good sense

 

The Dolphin Flag 03 Mar 23 5.04pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You coukld say that but it would miss the point entirely.

It calls into question the integrity of the civil service.
This woman's every decision should now be investigated.

In truth, it should be no surprise to anyone who ever left their house, that the civil service is packed with Lefties.

This in a nutshell!!
It is dreadful and I only hope that there is a parliamentary committee that will throw it out.
Absolute bias

 

YT Flag Oxford 03 Mar 23 7.09pm

Senior civil servants are perfectly entitled to hold their own political views of whatever colour, provided that they carry out their role in support of the government with impartiality. I wonder, however, whether this lady, when attending cabinet briefings up to a few days ago, declared that she had....errr...landed a job with Sir Keith and the Labour Party!

And on that job securement...which other candidates were interviewed, because surely it was a fair and open recruitment process? Which minority candidates were on the short-list? (etc etc)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 03 Mar 23 8.53pm

Originally posted by YT

Senior civil servants are perfectly entitled to hold their own political views of whatever colour, provided that they carry out their role in support of the government with impartiality. I wonder, however, whether this lady, when attending cabinet briefings up to a few days ago, declared that she had....errr...landed a job with Sir Keith and the Labour Party!

And on that job securement...which other candidates were interviewed, because surely it was a fair and open recruitment process? Which minority candidates were on the short-list? (etc etc)

Civil servants of whatever grade very rarely get anywhere near cabinet meetings or briefings. That is the proviso of ministers and SPADS (who are political appointees and wield a lot of influence. I can say that from experience.

Sue Gray has served at a high level across all governments of all colours and was appointed by Boris as she had the reputation of being more than happy to ask questions to power whoever they were. No one in the Tory party objected to her appointment or at the time suggested her report was anything other than fair. Hindsight is a marvelous thing.

She has not actually taken the job with the labour party yet. She is waiting for an independent panel to clear it.

For Starmer it makes sense to bring her in. Like it or not it looks like he w stands a good chance of being the next PM and to have someone who knows the Whitehall machine can only be good for the country of he becomes PM.

 

YT Flag Oxford 03 Mar 23 9.48pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Civil servants of whatever grade very rarely get anywhere near cabinet meetings or briefings. That is the proviso of ministers and SPADS (who are political appointees and wield a lot of influence. I can say that from experience.

Sue Gray has served at a high level across all governments of all colours and was appointed by Boris as she had the reputation of being more than happy to ask questions to power whoever they were. No one in the Tory party objected to her appointment or at the time suggested her report was anything other than fair. Hindsight is a marvelous thing.

She has not actually taken the job with the labour party yet. She is waiting for an independent panel to clear it.

For Starmer it makes sense to bring her in. Like it or not it looks like he w stands a good chance of being the next PM and to have someone who knows the Whitehall machine can only be good for the country of he becomes PM.

Last week and at the start of this week she was party to discussions with ministers, aka members of the cabinet, about the Northern Ireland trade situation.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 06 Mar 23 12.48pm

Gray's son is a Labour activist campaigning in Uxbridge, you couldn't make it up

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 06 Mar 23 3.03pm

Ms Gray, having experienced at first hand the tories behaviour during partygate, has gone for 'the cleaner alternative'.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Mar 23 4.04pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Civil servants of whatever grade very rarely get anywhere near cabinet meetings or briefings. That is the proviso of ministers and SPADS (who are political appointees and wield a lot of influence. I can say that from experience.

Sue Gray has served at a high level across all governments of all colours and was appointed by Boris as she had the reputation of being more than happy to ask questions to power whoever they were. No one in the Tory party objected to her appointment or at the time suggested her report was anything other than fair. Hindsight is a marvelous thing.

She has not actually taken the job with the labour party yet. She is waiting for an independent panel to clear it.

For Starmer it makes sense to bring her in. Like it or not it looks like he w stands a good chance of being the next PM and to have someone who knows the Whitehall machine can only be good for the country of he becomes PM.

A good post if I compare it with my experiences.

Senior Civil Servants, or the majority of those I have encountered in my professional career certainly, more often than not subscribe to machiavellian self-servitude as opposed to any particular political allegiance in order to progress. For that reason alone I would suggest Sue Gray's loyalty will lie where it would appear to best benefit her beyond anything else and would be less concerned with anything suggesting otherwise.

Her knowledge of the Whitehall machine will certainly be of benefit to anybody looking to employ her therefore she probably is fair game. All subjective conjecture from me of course I suppose time will tell.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 07 Mar 23 4.12pm

Jacob Rees-Mogg calls Sue Gray ‘conniving friend of the socialists’

This is becoming immensely enjoyable....

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 10 Mar 23 10.34am

My Mrs is a civil servant, recently joined from the private sector. She can't get over how many incompetent people there are and those with no interest in working hard or a desire to achieve or accomplish anything. Never mind the amount of money that is wasted, the old boys mentality and how women are treated.

The depressing thing is that there aren't enough good apples to change the current ethic and ways of doing things. She'll be heading back to the private sector soon to be amongst ambitious people who are driven to make a change in a healthy work environment.

 

nead1 Flag 10 Mar 23 8.56pm

What your post, and indeed the whole premise of the thread, fails to recognise is also some of the amazing talent within the CS. For example, clearly todays Anglo/French summit was a major success after the disaster years of Johnson and Truss. Who does all the behind the scenes leg work in making such events a success -highly skilled Civil Servants. Indeed, if you look at the photos from earlier you will see the British Ambassador to France right alongside Sunak as a central player and also Tim Barrow - the man who apparently brokered the recent deal associated with the protocol and a civil servant of vast experience/expertise.

So, to characterise the whole of the CS as "a farce" is clearly so far off the mark as to be absurd. It might also be worth remembering that it was Simon McDonnell who Boris Johnson got rid of after years in the FCO, who actually called him out for his claims of being unaware of the history of Chris Pincher which ultimately led to his downfall. McDonnell confirmed that he had personally briefed Johnson in full.

Another similar example was the decision of Liz Truss to dispense with the senior official in the Treasury - Tom Scholar - who she saw as a blocker to her views; look how well that turned out!

Of course, as in any organisation, the CS can be improved. However, it is worth remembering that it is universally admired world wide and it depends a lot on good political leadership - sadly lacking in the UK for at least a decade.

One final point; the UK press was forever going on about the size of the EU's bureaucracy. In fact, the Commission is about the size of the UK Home Office - not the vast bureaucracy that is claimed.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The farce that is the British Civil Service...