This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Think Vieira's obsession with the JJJ players (Schlupp, Ayew and Mateta) will lead to relegation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
Think Vieira's obsession with the JJJ players (Schlupp, Ayew and Mateta) will lead to relegation. ....but he has sussed the lazy Edouard out.
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
Think Vieira's obsession with the JJJ players (Schlupp, Ayew and Mateta) will lead to relegation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by beak
....but he has sussed the lazy Edouard out. Whilst I don't disagree, and I certianly don't think either of them are good enough, Edouard at least gets into positions where he can score a goal from time to time - Mateta doesn't even do that at the moment. If you play that game 3 times, I think Edouard probably scores a goal or two - I don't think that's true of Mateta.
|
|
|
Originally posted by multiclub.thesis
It baffles me how we haven’t gone for a 3ATB and instead stuck with TM (who is the poster boy for one-footedness) and Clyne/Ward (who cannot progress the ball and always turns back and are not that capable defensive-wise except Ward being sort of OK when it comes to aerial duels). Going forward the ball either ends up being nicked due to poor forward passes, goes out to throw-ins or lofted towards our forwards that cannot win an aerial duel to save their life (particularly JP who really has no excuse with his build). It hurts me to say that we actually miss Benteke. Richards should come in in the right cb-spot with and Eze needs to come in in the midfield in a position that allows him to retrieve the ball low in the field to drive forward facing the opposition. Despite poor form riddled with mistakes, Eze cannot be benched when others clearly cannot get the ball into the final third. Because we havent got 2 wing backs, we barely have 2 full backs.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Because we havent got 2 wing backs, we barely have 2 full backs. Ward and Cline have done a very solid job, for several years. I saw them both make their debuts many years ago. But they are not wingbacks and neither is Mitchell. We simply don't have wingbacks on the books. It's part of the summer clearout and overhauling of the squad. It's not Vieira's fault that the squad is limited in many ways. I don't think it's the Palace way to shoot the messenger. So personally I hope Parish gives him a chance to stay until the summer and oversee the necessary revamp of the squad.
|
|
|
PV did a revamp when he took over. Now time for the business to be done again. Freshening up is possible before the summer - from Academy
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Whilst I don't disagree, and I certianly don't think either of them are good enough, Edouard at least gets into positions where he can score a goal from time to time - Mateta doesn't even do that at the moment. If you play that game 3 times, I think Edouard probably scores a goal or two - I don't think that's true of Mateta. Neither of them score, but Mateta offers considerably more comedy value. Since it's fundamentally pointless playing any forward who is incapable of delivering goals, you might as well pick the one who at least gives you a bit of a laugh.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
Neither of them score, but Mateta offers considerably more comedy value. Since it's fundamentally pointless playing any forward who is incapable of delivering goals, you might as well pick the one who at least gives you a bit of a laugh. He is the footballing equivalent of a mate I played basketball with who was 6’10” but couldn’t dunk it. His feet never left the ground when he jumped. Whilst watching our very own Bambi skittering across the pitch and leaping like a tailless salmon I was fondly reminded of ‘big John’. How do we keep finding strikers like Sorloth, Benteke and Mateta that are so poor at finishing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
Neither of them score, but Mateta offers considerably more comedy value. Since it's fundamentally pointless playing any forward who is incapable of delivering goals, you might as well pick the one who at least gives you a bit of a laugh. Excellent point. Goes for half the team. Bring back Reidewald just for the hair too. Though that Wilf styling leaves much to be desired. Who is our funniest player? There are some candidates for funniest ever but of the current lot? It has to be Wilf with the eyes - or Schlupp and his search for a position. Maybe Ayew when he pretends he didn't commit a foul?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Excellent point. Goes for half the team. Bring back Reidewald just for the hair too. Though that Wilf styling leaves much to be desired. Who is our funniest player? There are some candidates for funniest ever but of the current lot? It has to be Wilf with the eyes - or Schlupp and his search for a position. Maybe Ayew when he pretends he didn't commit a foul? In a kind way, Bolasie. No-one, incl himself, knew what he what going to do. At the other end of the spectrum, Rashid Harkouk. Part tricky winger, part goal score, part thug, complete fruit loop.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Excellent point. Goes for half the team. Bring back Reidewald just for the hair too. Though that Wilf styling leaves much to be desired. Who is our funniest player? There are some candidates for funniest ever but of the current lot? It has to be Wilf with the eyes - or Schlupp and his search for a position. Maybe Ayew when he pretends he didn't commit a foul? Kiraly the goalkeeper, totally mad as a box of frogs, but out of the current team I’d say Olise for his tv interviews.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Excellent point. Goes for half the team. Bring back Reidewald just for the hair too. Though that Wilf styling leaves much to be desired. Who is our funniest player? There are some candidates for funniest ever but of the current lot? It has to be Wilf with the eyes - or Schlupp and his search for a position. Maybe Ayew when he pretends he didn't commit a foul? You can't offer up Aylott without mentioning his mate, Tommy "lungs" Langley. Now there was stand-up, or fall-down (take your pick) comedy. There's Andy Preece too, who would have flattered to deceive if he hadn't been so useless that no one was deceived in the first place. There was comedy value in Marco Gabbiadini, who we thought represented a bargain a year after his career-ending injury. Yes, his career went on for a few years notwithstanding that it had already ended but hey ho, he was a bargain. And how could we forget Itzhik Zohar and his penalty (miss)? Still, they all pale in comparison next to Florian Marange, whose stint at Palace was so memorable that no one can remember it. Our board does know how to bring players in. It's just that they have to be a). useless and b). cheap. Maybe a and b are connected? Quick. Someone tell Parish.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
You can't offer up Aylott without mentioning his mate, Tommy "lungs" Langley. Now there was stand-up, or fall-down (take your pick) comedy. There's Andy Preece too, who would have flattered to deceive if he hadn't been so useless that no one was deceived in the first place. There was comedy value in Marco Gabbiadini, who we thought represented a bargain a year after his career-ending injury. Yes, his career went on for a few years notwithstanding that it had already ended but hey ho, he was a bargain. And how could we forget Itzhik Zohar and his penalty (miss)? Still, they all pale in comparison next to Florian Marange, whose stint at Palace was so memorable that no one can remember it. Our board does know how to bring players in. It's just that they have to be a). useless and b). cheap. Maybe a and b are connected? Quick. Someone tell Parish. Just as a counter weight, what about Andy Johnson, he had electric pace and could actually score goals
|
|
|
Originally posted by PJEagle
Just as a counter weight, what about Andy Johnson, he had electric pace and could actually score goals At a time like this, it's deeply offensive to mention competent, hard-working, goal-scoring Palace players. The words "Andy" and "Johnson" should never be included in any sentence or conversation that includes mention of Edouard or Mateta :-)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.