You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bad recruitment


Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8
Jacey Flag 28 Mar 23 4.35pm

Originally posted by Willo

I will alert Steve to my comments and hopefully a Magnum will be dispatched my way.

Hopefully,Champagne,or ice cream,and not a handgun!!

Take care!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Mar 23 4.40pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Hopefully,Champagne,or ice cream,and not a handgun!!

Take care!!

Hopefully a 'Boerl & Kroff' magnum.

 

Jacey Flag 28 Mar 23 4.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hopefully a 'Boerl & Kroff' magnum.

The very least you deserve for lightening the mood!!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Mar 23 4.46pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

His brief as DOF may well be wider than scouting, but nonetheless it is beyond dispute that Freedman has overall control of scouting at the club.
It is clear from Hodgson’s and Vieira’s comments in recent seasons when asked about team strengthening that both Freedman and Parish are the key figures in the decisions on who comes in and goes out.
If they are fairly praised for getting it right with the likes of Guehi and Anderson, it’s surely equally fair to be able to question their decisions on the squad weaknesses which are have been all too evident to the fanbase this season.
To merely say that Freedman has a wider remit or that Parish has been at the helm for 10 years does not give them a free pass to my mind and could be seen as yet more excuses.
On the subject of finance it would clearly be unreasonable to expect us to compete financially with the top clubs ,but there is still value to be had as clubs smaller than us have demonstrated in their acquisition policies.

For what it’s worth I think Parish and Freedman are both doing good jobs, but there is clearly room for improvement and a more professional approach.
Currently we’re in a relegation struggle, have temporarily gone back to a manager who was deemed not the right choice when we did not extend his contract two seasons ago, and have another half dozen senior players out of contract in the summer including our star player.

As I say, clearly room for improvement.


Boom. Nail on head, a straight appraisal of the current state of play.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 28 Mar 23 4.54pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Well somebody identified Mateta and Edouard as strikers.It would be ok if just one of them could find the net occasionally. Alas no they are both proving to be not up to the task.
Surely DF must be held responsible for this fail.

Where it went wrong was not the signing of these anaemic excuses for strikers but failure to address our number one problem since Cabaye left - a ball holding attacking MIDFIELDER.

You only have to admire the skills of one we let go, Barry Bannon, to illustrate our maybe fatal weakness. Every team has such a player, except us.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 Mar 23 5.15pm

I’ve said it before, I think Freedman is a bit lazy. His go to sources are his old celt mates in Scotland and Ireland or he simply looks at the best players one league down. Very rarely do we stray into leagues where you and I wouldn’t know the up and coming players.

I’m pretty sure I could watch all the championship matches on tv and identify who are the best players. Trouble is with that policy, is we tend to pay too much money and we never seem to pick up bargains.

If you look at the Scottish and Irish buys, this is where we are exhibiting more risk with lower price youngsters, but none have made their way through into the first team as yet, so is this really working? I’m willing to give this side of it another season or two to bring players through, but to be honest he’s now had a substantial period of time to get it right and there hasn’t been anyone of note other than an English lad (AWB) and I’m not sure what influence Freedman had in that deal.


 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 Mar 23 5.21pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Where it went wrong was not the signing of these anaemic excuses for strikers but failure to address our number one problem since Cabaye left - a ball holding attacking MIDFIELDER.

You only have to admire the skills of one we let go, Barry Bannon, to illustrate our maybe fatal weakness. Every team has such a player, except us.

I agree. We had a chance to sign Jonjo Shelvey who at the time would have been a good fit for us and we’ve looked at several others every transfer window without signing one (according to click bait articles and news outlets anyway).

I find it so frustrating supporting Palace. Every time we get ourselves in a position to kick on we manage to shoot ourselves in the foot and take a step backwards. Unfortunately, this time it could be a big step backwards.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 29 Mar 23 9.52am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I’ve said it before, I think Freedman is a bit lazy. His go to sources are his old celt mates in Scotland and Ireland or he simply looks at the best players one league down. Very rarely do we stray into leagues where you and I wouldn’t know the up and coming players.

I’m pretty sure I could watch all the championship matches on tv and identify who are the best players. Trouble is with that policy, is we tend to pay too much money and we never seem to pick up bargains.

If you look at the Scottish and Irish buys, this is where we are exhibiting more risk with lower price youngsters, but none have made their way through into the first team as yet, so is this really working? I’m willing to give this side of it another season or two to bring players through, but to be honest he’s now had a substantial period of time to get it right and there hasn’t been anyone of note other than an English lad (AWB) and I’m not sure what influence Freedman had in that deal.

I'm kind of ok with the Scottish and Irish kids. We obviously have a youth scout in Ireland, that is sending some lads our way. Hopefully 1 or 2 develop, but its a relatively low risk strategy.

As you mentioned, my bigger issue with scouting is our first team buys, all IMO recently are good. But didnt take a top class scout to scout. EE, MO, MG all standout performers in the Champ. Its the equivalent of someone scouting Zaha when we were in the championship, the football press have labeled him as the next best thing.

So if we have 1 youth scout in Ireland, another watching Championship highlights. What's the rest of the function doing?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 Mar 23 11.30am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I'm kind of ok with the Scottish and Irish kids. We obviously have a youth scout in Ireland, that is sending some lads our way. Hopefully 1 or 2 develop, but its a relatively low risk strategy.

As you mentioned, my bigger issue with scouting is our first team buys, all IMO recently are good. But didnt take a top class scout to scout. EE, MO, MG all standout performers in the Champ. Its the equivalent of someone scouting Zaha when we were in the championship, the football press have labeled him as the next best thing.

So if we have 1 youth scout in Ireland, another watching Championship highlights. What's the rest of the function doing?

Exactly

 

Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment