You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sam Johnstone no.1?
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sam Johnstone no.1?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
The Dolphin Flag 26 Apr 23 7.27am

I think it was a yellow and a penalty - just.
The wolves player however, rolled around and twisted like an animal in its death throes - absolutely pathetic.
He was then attended to by his own players - no trainer (from memory) who appeared to tell him that it was okay to stop acting now - the penalty had been won.
Every week we all go and watch 22 cheats on a football field - it is doing my head in!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Apr 23 7.53am

Originally posted by Elpis

As no contact was made a Yellow was the correct decision . The referee would have deemed it as reckless play (yellow) rather than dangerous play or using excessive force (red).He could have seen it as careless play and not given any card at all

It was actually for me borderline if it was even a penalty ,Ive no complaints that it was but was one of those that had it not been given would not have been overturned

I agree but I thought he might get a red as the challenge could have been deemed “out of control”.
My biggest gripe about the decisions last night was no penalty for challenge on Olise, hardly a VAR check, perhaps we need someone in the refs ear, all game like Neves.
Even read some Wolves fans saying how the ref constantly stopping the game, played into their hands and did not help Palace at all.
I believe the VAR official was the ref from Saturday, he obviously does not like Palace

 

becky Flag over the moon 26 Apr 23 8.42am

One plus with Johnstone, that I mentioned on the match thread yesterday, is his accuracy with long kicks upfield - nine times out of ten the ball will drop well for one of our players. Something that we haven't had from a keep in a very long while...

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 26 Apr 23 8.59am

Surprised it wasn't a red TBF, absolutely no need to go in that high.

Could have just cleared it. Luck the game was already over so didnt impact anything

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Apr 23 10.12am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree but I thought he might get a red as the challenge could have been deemed “out of control”.
My biggest gripe about the decisions last night was no penalty for challenge on Olise, hardly a VAR check, perhaps we need someone in the refs ear, all game like Neves.
Even read some Wolves fans saying how the ref constantly stopping the game, played into their hands and did not help Palace at all.
I believe the VAR official was the ref from Saturday, he obviously does not like Palace

How the referee didn’t penalise the blatant use of the elbows by Dawson constantly was no surprise, he just isn’t any good.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 Apr 23 10.19am

Originally posted by Painter

How the referee didn’t penalise the blatant use of the elbows by Dawson constantly was no surprise, he just isn’t any good.

It's a gripe as old as time so I have tried to refrain from expressing it however I will say that it seemed as though the officials were intent on accommodating Wolves' non-footballing tactics yesterday and seeing through their win.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 26 Apr 23 10.22am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree but I thought he might get a red as the challenge could have been deemed “out of control”.
My biggest gripe about the decisions last night was no penalty for challenge on Olise, hardly a VAR check, perhaps we need someone in the refs ear, all game like Neves.
Even read some Wolves fans saying how the ref constantly stopping the game, played into their hands and did not help Palace at all.
I believe the VAR official was the ref from Saturday, he obviously does not like Palace

The one on Olise was never a pen. It was a 50:50 ball which the Wolves defender got to first and shielded with Olise tripping on his leg. For Olise to be fouled he surely has to be in possession? He never got to the ball.

I think the ref got the Johnston decision correct. Initially I was annoyed as he got the ball, but rules are rules with studs up. It was reckless.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Apr 23 10.30am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

The one on Olise was never a pen. It was a 50:50 ball which the Wolves defender got to first and shielded with Olise tripping on his leg. For Olise to be fouled he surely has to be in possession? He never got to the ball.

I think the ref got the Johnston decision correct. Initially I was annoyed as he got the ball, but rules are rules with studs up. It was reckless.

It was a chop tackle by the defender which is ok if you get the ball but stamping your foot in front of another player’s leg from a side on position is still a foul if you don’t get the ball and prevent a players run. If that was a top 6 team then var would have called a penalty all day long.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 26 Apr 23 10.44am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

It's a gripe as old as time so I have tried to refrain from expressing it however I will say that it seemed as though the officials were intent on accommodating Wolves' non-footballing tactics yesterday and seeing through their win.

I agree Nick. Wolves used the mock injury tactic to good effect last night and Lopetegui carefully wasted time with substitutions towards the end which spoiled any momentum we achieved.

Won't be surprised to see Vicente back for the West Ham game on Saturday.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 26 Apr 23 11.11am

Both good keepers. Happy for either.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 26 Apr 23 1.56pm

Originally posted by Elpis

As no contact was made a Yellow was the correct decision . The referee would have deemed it as reckless play (yellow) rather than dangerous play or using excessive force (red).He could have seen it as careless play and not given any card at all

It was actually for me borderline if it was even a penalty ,Ive no complaints that it was but was one of those that had it not been given would not have been overturned

That's interesting that if no contact is made then it's only a yellow for reckless play. It doesn't really discourage those types of challenges if players know they can getaway with it, if no contact is made.

I would have thought, any player jumping in with studs showing gets a red card regardless.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 26 Apr 23 2.24pm

Didn't deserve to lose. Weird goals.

However even though we played them off the park we were not good enough to break through.

Take it move on.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Apr 23 11.11pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

The one on Olise was never a pen. It was a 50:50 ball which the Wolves defender got to first and shielded with Olise tripping on his leg. For Olise to be fouled he surely has to be in possession? He never got to the ball.

I think the ref got the Johnston decision correct. Initially I was annoyed as he got the ball, but rules are rules with studs up. It was reckless.

Very similar to the one on Mitoma at Spurs. Brighton got an apology for it not being given

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sam Johnstone no.1?