You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If it ain’t broke don’t fix it
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

If it ain’t broke don’t fix it


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Apr 23 8.39pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

What grounds do you have for thinking that Dixie? I was not enthralled by some of the games we watched last time round either, but I'm prepared to believe Roy can utilise the quality players he now has available in a much more attractive and attacking style, much as we have witnessed of late.

Clearly we're not looking at a long term arrangement, but if I were Parish, I'd give the idea very serious consideration.

Of course there is one issue which needs to be addressed, which is; does Roy want to do it? As far as I'm aware he has so far sidestepped the question.

Towards the end of his last season, Mr Hodgson, to my ageing eyes, looked somewhat fatigued.Football management is a 24/7 commitment and can of course be draining. He returned this season looking refreshed and relaxed after a period away from the rigours of management and perhaps at the age of 76 is only prepared to consider a short-term assignment.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 30 Apr 23 10.11pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes of course, why not? I see no reason why Mr Hodgson needs to go anywhere, we should highlight the obvious mistakes that are constantly being made with managers being brought in.

Because this is a premier league job, and by proxy one of the biggest jobs in the sport.

I'm not saying no, never to Paddy. But 100% no after a brief stint looking after the U21's. He needs to go off and cut his teeth. Demonstrate that he's good enough for a top job.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Apr 23 10.20pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Because this is a premier league job, and by proxy one of the biggest jobs in the sport.

I'm not saying no, never to Paddy. But 100% no after a brief stint looking after the U21's. He needs to go off and cut his teeth. Demonstrate that he's good enough for a top job.

I don’t think anyone can argue against this line of thinking. No way is he ready for the rigours of the PL.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 May 23 5.30am

Originally posted by VinceHilaire

The other issue is that whoever does come in, their performance will be compared to Roy and his team….which actually could add pressure to the management position.

In all honesty, taking over from someone who has recently led the club to playing attractive, successful football could be quite daunting.

So perhaps there is a lot of sense by adding a further year of stability to the club by not changing too much?!?!

As well as kicking the can down the road for another year this would surely achieve the very thing you are discussing? At what point would a new managerial appointment become viable?

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 01 May 23 5.45am

Think Parish and Hodgson will have a long conversation about this, making no hasty solution. About the transfers during summer, do we really need that many new players?
For sure a right back and a striker, but we have some younger players to step up. Look at Man City. They play more or less the same 15-16 players in every game, have 3 youngsters to fill up the bench...think we should copy that. Like left-back Adamola, Rak-Suki and that big kid Ozuh.
Should have a pretty decent team to face nest season then - with or without Zaha.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 01 May 23 10.02am

Clearly we have a top experienced team at both managerial and team levels.

 

derfes Flag upper norwood 01 May 23 1.48pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m coming around to Roy staying on next year.
This is not a knee jerk reaction to a few good results and performances, but based on solid evidence.
As far as I can see the only reason not to extend his stay is his age.
However, this in itself is not an issue in isolation with his robust health and unbridled enthusiasm for the game.
Football is like breathing to him and I’ve heard or observed nothing from him to suggest that he wouldn’t accept another year.
In some ways it’s a no brainier for the club too.
The club want to remain in the Premier League first and foremost and retain some form of continuity with a settled staff and there’s nothing to suggest that this wouldn’t be achievable with Roy, Ray and Paddy at the helm.
I’m also at cognisant that we’re nearly in May , not far from pre season planning and decisions on players etc.
To bring in a new manager brings in the uncertainty of upheaval with him wanting his own staff and players potentially unsettling the chemistry that is successful at present and looks like it could be in the future.
Some will say keeping Roy is only postponing the inevitable as he will have to go at some point, but is that in itself sufficient reason to make a change in the summer?

4 more years , 4 more years , 4 more years

If he keeps us up and shows us he can continue to do so until he is 95 , why not another 20 yrs? Continued premier league survival is the goal, i don't much care who is the manager as long as we and they can continue the Glorious run of this last decade and a bit. I'll still support us if we go down, but why bother with getting relegated if you don't have to so bother.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > If it ain’t broke don’t fix it