You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Local Elections May 2023.
November 21 2026 9.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Local Elections May 2023.


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 06 May 23 9.22am

Originally posted by YT

What the f*** has a 16th century proverb got to do with anything?

What has 16th century got to do with it? It's as pertinent today as at any other time!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 06 May 23 9.53am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

For stupid reasons!

I don’t understand your logic. You berate leavers but in other posts remainers are great. Did they need a reason? Clearly not had your meds

Edited by cryrst (06 May 2023 9.53am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 May 23 9.54am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That has to be done in a democracy. Even the brainless have a right to an opinion on who should represent them. We can though, of course, change our minds every 5 years. I would happily settle for the same deal on Brexit, if it was practical to do so, which it clearly isn't.

Must be brainless to vote for such incompetent and/or corrupt nonentities.

 

YT Flag Oxford 06 May 23 10.38am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

What has 16th century got to do with it? It's as pertinent today as at any other time!

Pertinent in what way?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 07 May 23 12.47pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No. Because no government in the UK would accept such terms and should they first decide to consult the people directly in an advisory referendum it would not therefore be an option.

Who said anything about "advisory referendum'? Would be the same as the one you lost, in or out! IF it was a condition of entry would you vote in or out?

 

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 07 May 23 3.25pm

Very predictable results considering how the past few years have gone.

If people aren't willing to withhold their vote from a party they're being actively mugged off by through fear of another getting in, they ought realise that it's outlooks like that which bring about such zero accountability governance to begin with.

There is definitely a good argument that how effective a party is locally should be the primary factor, but that makes the assumption that many councils are effective locally rather than are exceptions to the rule when they are. That and people have always used local elections to punish a party in power - and they share an outlook so that's understandable to a point anyway.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 07 May 23 8.15pm

Labour look to be cheeky with their claim that they have are onn track for a majority, but they may be right.

It is not a given that the tories can recover, particularly in areas that were not traditionally tory before the Johnson win.

And people vote nationally in a general election, the libdems may lose seats to labour, not the conservatives.

And its been so long with the conservatives, their ministers on Kuessenburg trot out tired old failed policies, police powers and small boats who cares?

They say they will halve inflation, but it going to happen anyway.


 

Matov Flag 09 May 23 5.36pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Labour look to be cheeky with their claim that they have are onn track for a majority, but they may be right.

It is not a given that the tories can recover, particularly in areas that were not traditionally tory before the Johnson win.

And people vote nationally in a general election, the libdems may lose seats to labour, not the conservatives.

And its been so long with the conservatives, their ministers on Kuessenburg trot out tired old failed policies, police powers and small boats who cares?

They say they will halve inflation, but it going to happen anyway.



Thought this an interesting take...

[Link]

Wondering if this might be the preferred outcomes for the people pulling Starmers strings? Will give Starmer the excuse of having to acquiesce to the almost invariable Lib-Dem demand for us rejoining the EU, especially if they make a song and dance about it in the run-up to the actual election, especially given the tactical voting opportunities it might throw up (and that would make for some interesting data extrapolation in terms of what seats it might swing).

What I still cannot get out of my head is how people claim that this is Labours most successful electoral showing since 1997. Especially since even with all the hype, Starmer still only got 35% of the vote compared to the 40 that Corbyn pulled in in the 2017 GE.

But not my circus, not my monkeys.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 09 May 23 8.43pm

Originally posted by Matov


Thought this an interesting take...

[Link]

Wondering if this might be the preferred outcomes for the people pulling Starmers strings? Will give Starmer the excuse of having to acquiesce to the almost invariable Lib-Dem demand for us rejoining the EU, especially if they make a song and dance about it in the run-up to the actual election, especially given the tactical voting opportunities it might throw up (and that would make for some interesting data extrapolation in terms of what seats it might swing).

What I still cannot get out of my head is how people claim that this is Labours most successful electoral showing since 1997. Especially since even with all the hype, Starmer still only got 35% of the vote compared to the 40 that Corbyn pulled in in the 2017 GE.

But not my circus, not my monkeys.

It's pointless to rule in or out any political coalition, because events dictate. Just look at the Lib-Con government, who couldn't seen that one coming?

Realistically he shouldn't the LidDems, and intuitively it seems early and pointless to try to gravitate back towards the EU, when leaving doesn't particularly seem to have been anything like people would've hoped for anyway. By which I mean it makes more sense to drift along with the status quo and act if or when a public opinion on it becomes especially clear.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 09 May 23 9.10pm

local elections and by-elections have historically seen a high proportion of protest voting against Governments, particularly mid-term.
General Elections generally see much more alignment with historical voting patterns, with the floating voters electing which party triumphs.
The Tories have been c0cking it right up for years, but the electorate don't seem overly swayed to vote Labour. I don't know why. The Tories just seemed to have a larger base of loyal voters. Until now.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Matov Flag 09 May 23 9.17pm

Originally posted by footythoughts

It's pointless to rule in or out any political coalition, because events dictate. Just look at the Lib-Con government, who couldn't seen that one coming?

Realistically he shouldn't the LidDems, and intuitively it seems early and pointless to try to gravitate back towards the EU, when leaving doesn't particularly seem to have been anything like people would've hoped for anyway. By which I mean it makes more sense to drift along with the status quo and act if or when a public opinion on it becomes especially clear.

Every mainstream institution in the UK campaigned for us to remain in the EU. Every mainstream institution did its very best to stop us leaving. Every mainstream institution did is doing its very best to create the conditions for us to return.

The Tories have a massive majority. They can literally vote anything through they want. We still have an entire slew of EU legislation on our books. We are still in the ECHR (which is NOT part of the EU but to be in the EU, all members need to be signed up), which stops up controlling our own borders.

The Tories had everything in place to give the UK every kind of competitive edge it possibly could. Instead, it keeps us cheek-to-cheek with the EU.

Ever since the morning of June 24th 2016, every major institution has been trying to ensure that we end up back in the EU. And willing to take the long-term view to make it happen. O

You want a time scale? Goes like this.

2024 - General Election. Starmer as PM.
2026 - A second EU referendum. Based on us rejoining or a new 'deal' that takes us back into the single market. And then some kind of legal BS that prevents another referendum on the subject for 20 years at least.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 May 23 8.07am

Originally posted by footythoughts

It's pointless to rule in or out any political coalition, because events dictate. Just look at the Lib-Con government, who couldn't seen that one coming?

Realistically he shouldn't the LidDems, and intuitively it seems early and pointless to try to gravitate back towards the EU, when leaving doesn't particularly seem to have been anything like people would've hoped for anyway. By which I mean it makes more sense to drift along with the status quo and act if or when a public opinion on it becomes especially clear.

Coalitions are fine as long as the parties tell the voters this before any election and indicate their red lines.

In 2010 the Lib Dems betrayed their voters by abandoning the tuition fees pledge a key reason for voting Lib Dem.

Labour is entitled to form a coalition with the SNP and the Lib Dems and the Greens but do the decent thing first and explain to the voters what this would actually mean before the vote.*

I doubt this will happen and more likely there will be some back door deal after the voting and then the electorate will face god knows what.

*In many European countries it is standard practice for parties to lay out their policies and who they would be prepared to go into coalition with and at what price before the voting takes place.

Edited by Badger11 (10 May 2023 8.09am)

 


One more point

Matov Flag 10 May 23 8.22pm

Originally posted by Badger11


*In many European countries it is standard practice for parties to lay out their policies and who they would be prepared to go into coalition with and at what price before the voting takes place.


Edited by Badger11 (10 May 2023 8.09am)


To be fair to our politicians (not something I enjoy doing), coalitions are such a rarity in our system that we don't really have a political culture that means they can be anticipated.

And 2024 is shaping up to have potentially so many variables that it is probably as much a guessing exercise than any kind of viable strategy that could be laid out to voters. I suspect they might even struggle to war-game it.

Where the interesting part comes is if a Lib-Lab pact emerges prior to the election whereby they effectively try to engineer a tactical voting strategy just to deny the Tories a majority.

Now how that might work (and on the ground the Lib-Dems are DETESTED by almost all other activists) is another issue but the results of the local elections did offer some evidence that perhaps it might be happening already, as much by accident as design.

Throw in the relative implosion of the SNP (which has not really been stress tested yet in any kind of meaningful electoral manner) and there are all kinds of shenanigans to be had.

If I was Starmer I would be looking for a straightforward FPTP win. He knows he can rely on virtually every Labour seat as things stand (with perhaps the exception of Islington North) so he can focus on the seats he needs up north.

A lot of twists and turns ahead, and still a huge ask given that on the latest showing they are still struggling to achieve a working majority with a Tory election machine no doubt ready to hammer Starmer on all kinds but even hinting at a stitch up with Lib-Dems offers only snakes. In fact, not a single ladder really.

Edited by Matov (10 May 2023 8.23pm)

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 11 May 23 12.01am

Starmer has an issue with the " red wall " unless he can change their opinions on:

Saville prosecution
Grooming gangs
What is a woman

There is enough anti Starmer on these issues to have a difference on the overall vote switch from Conservative back to Labour.

If Reform get busy on the ground for example they can have a an impact on where votes are cast.

There is a long way to go before the next GE, Starmer's PM in waiting act may be a bit premature.

I am now of the opinion that whoever gets into power the country is in a mess and no sign of improvement

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Local Elections May 2023.