You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Church and State
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Church and State


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 May 23 11.17am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Whereas "complexity apparently comes from nowhere" isn't?

Sigh.

That is my one sentence description of an entire book on the subject of evolution. Complexity obviously comes from somewhere.

Unlike the 'God' made everything argument, it actually presents a hypothesis based on science.

In the time-honoured tradition of 'believers', you are only interested in word play and diversion on this subject.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 May 23 11.34am

Originally posted by footythoughts

I would think he's saying that there is a different between believing ancient religious texts are the word of God, and holding a broader view that there may be a God.

Personally I don't think there is, but where a person uses their beliefs in a benign or personal way, it's not really anyone elses business. I would agree that it may not be rational, but I'm not sure that we should close the door or have complete hostility for anything spritual or 'greater than us' above making ourselves central.

If we're to do that then a 'rational' alternative would be to look after our planet, you know, our home. But any views in that direction have been politicised to hell too left and right. What's next in line, viewing DNA as king? What, happily conversing with Black or Jew hating Twitter extremists about race? Great. Or perhaps basing our entire self on he/she/them/whatever pronouns or diversity quotas and shouting down or blotting out anyone who doesn't instantly get or adhere to that?

When peoples God is to become especially politicised in either direction, realistically what you see is them gradually losing touch with their humanity, with others, any potentially genuine interaction passes through a contrived filter or bubble that is removed from actually ever knowing a person, one which they fail to realise remains even in their dream outcome version of society. These outlooks become little different from a cult or religion anyway. So yes, there are certainly big issues with where fire and brimstone religions can take people, but a spiritual view of life, a bigger than us, a less me, me , me, wonderment. Is that really so bad in the big picture?


'Love' isn't rational either but I doubt you're kicking your mrs out of the door as result . We most certainly don't all need a God, but 'my God' some people clearly need something they're not getting from whatever (often social media) filter they knowingly, unknowingly, but certainly hopelessly, apply to life and believe to be 'rational'. So I think your outright dismissal and belittlement is somewhat misplaced even though I'm certainly not big on religion by any means.


Edited by footythoughts (14 May 2023 10.23pm)

I would have thought that my responses would have made it clear that I'm perfectly aware of that.

I'm not sure where all the rest of this comes from.

I have a blanket attitude toward all forms of religion, although some are more troublesome than others, it has to be said.

The concept of a God being can be argued about endlessly, but it is completely pointless and irrelevant to the real world. It has no evidential basis beyond archaic religious concepts.

Religion is a blight on humanity. Its ability to inspire, control and encourage moral behaviour in a society can be achieved without the dogma, the fear, the fairy tales or the piety.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 15 May 23 12.36pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Sigh.

That is my one sentence description of an entire book on the subject of evolution. Complexity obviously comes from somewhere.

Unlike the 'God' made everything argument, it actually presents a hypothesis based on science.

In the time-honoured tradition of 'believers', you are only interested in word play and diversion on this subject.

Who said I'm a 'believer'? All I have said is that God (whatever that might be) is a more plausible cause of the Universe coming into being than it spontaneously creating itself. Perhaps God is everything that exists and that we are all part of God!

Edited by georgenorman (15 May 2023 12.38pm)

 

footythoughts Flag Beckenham 15 May 23 1.06pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I would have thought that my responses would have made it clear that I'm perfectly aware of that.

I'm not sure where all the rest of this comes from.

I have a blanket attitude toward all forms of religion, although some are more troublesome than others, it has to be said.

The concept of a God being can be argued about endlessly, but it is completely pointless and irrelevant to the real world. It has no evidential basis beyond archaic religious concepts.

Religion is a blight on humanity. Its ability to inspire, control and encourage moral behaviour in a society can be achieved without the dogma, the fear, the fairy tales or the piety.

My thought is that people have to believe in 'something', and one form of irrationality is unfortunately often exchanged for another form which people inevitably declare to be 'the truth' or all that matters. That's because there are so many different lenses through which to live life. While that doesn't have to be the case as many have a balanced outlook, the uncertainly of life can often be co-opted and filled with meaningless political sh!te that arbitrarily detaches a person from others, as we often see.

As you say there's little point believing in a God if you see no reason to, or see it as irrational. Many sit there. Nothing is all bad though, and some have touched on the feeling of a greater purpose or wonderment and clearly those traits in and of itself is hardly a bad thing, only if misused. Do you find much wonderment in your life, Hrolf? Or is that a childish shielding from depressing realities? Or are there many varied ways of viewing life, rather than one size fits all? People find their own way and if they personally mean well and treat others with respect who cares what they believe. There will always be war, hatred and control, you certainly don't need religion for that and often in todays global conflicts it barely factors in.

Besides, lots of people are more spiritual, a belief in something greater or unknown doesn't always comes with a finger point or prescribed list of ideas of how other people should behave.

Edited by footythoughts (15 May 2023 1.14pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 May 23 1.14pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Who said I'm a 'believer'? All I have said is that God (whatever that might be) is a more plausible cause of the Universe coming into being than it spontaneously creating itself. Perhaps God is everything that exists and that we are all part of God!

Edited by georgenorman (15 May 2023 12.38pm)

Where did I say you were? You are playing, ahem, Devil's advocate with a believer argument.

I completely disagree with your statement. Firstly, no one has claimed that the universe was spontaneously created. No one actually knows. The Big Bang is not seen as the beginning in modern cosmology.

You balk at the idea of the universe creating itself in some way, and then you grab a concept like God out of the air and then suggest that it might be the universe.

If that is what God is, then you might as well call it nature or physics or energy.

What most like to debate is the idea of intelligent design. That is where the root of the issue lies.
The problem is how you define intelligent. Organisation and intelligence don't mean the same thing and only science can answer those questions, if we are capable of comprehending the answers.
Some may claim to find answers elsewhere, but proof will not come from mumbo jumbo.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 15 May 23 1.49pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Where did I say you were? You are playing, ahem, Devil's advocate with a believer argument.

I completely disagree with your statement. Firstly, no one has claimed that the universe was spontaneously created. No one actually knows. The Big Bang is not seen as the beginning in modern cosmology.

You balk at the idea of the universe creating itself in some way, and then you grab a concept like God out of the air and then suggest that it might be the universe.

If that is what God is, then you might as well call it nature or physics or energy.

What most like to debate is the idea of intelligent design. That is where the root of the issue lies.
The problem is how you define intelligent. Organisation and intelligence don't mean the same thing and only science can answer those questions, if we are capable of comprehending the answers.
Some may claim to find answers elsewhere, but proof will not come from mumbo jumbo.

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio,
Than are dreamt of in your philosophy."
[Bill Shakespeare, Hamlet]

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 May 23 2.34pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio,
Than are dreamt of in your philosophy."
[Bill Shakespeare, Hamlet]

Quoting Shakespeare won't help find them.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 15 May 23 2.55pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Quoting Shakespeare won't help find them.

I hope there is a Last Judgement though, I want to hear Benteke justify his £27 million+ fee.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 May 23 3.05pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I hope there is a Last Judgement though, I want to hear Benteke justify his £27 million+ fee.

it was That Goal against Brighton. Proof positive that a God does exist. Cos it was a feckin miracle that that useless fecker could score.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Church and State