You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Fan Panic or just nervousness?
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Fan Panic or just nervousness?


doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Jul 23 2.33pm

I sense a degree of panic or is it just nervousness on this site since the Zaha revelation.

But let's stop and ask ourselves:

What has actually happened?

Well
1. Zaha who left the club over 3 weeks ago has signed for another club. Should we really be surprised?
2. There has been a rumour that Olise has agreed terms with Chelsea but this is subject to Palace agreeing to sell him and as far as we are aware, the club have not accepted Chelsea's apparent offer of about 40m.
3. Previously there have been rumours that bigger clubs are after Guehi, Andersen and Doucoure but there have not been any bids of which we are aware - yes lots of speculation of how much would be needed to prise them away from us but no firm evidence of the club's willingness to sell at those prices or even at all.
4. So far we have signed one player on a free (Lerma). There's also a rumour we've signed a young defender who was at Bournemouth (Francis) but no confirmation of this from the club.


We have another 5 weeks of the transfer window and I understand that this fact can make fans nervous when all the talk seems to be about other teams wanting our key players and very little talk about what we're doing.

As things stand, the squad that went out to the USA yesterday (plus a few from the U21 squad) is the squad currently available for our first league game in just under 3 weeks. It is somewhat thin on the ground and we must hope that there will be some incoming movement and no or minimal outward movement.

Let's see how we're placed on Saturday 2nd September. If all the future player movement is outward then that will be the time to panic.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 24 Jul 23 2.56pm

The other factors I think to consider are the appointment of Roy as manager and the amount of time it took. If he was announced on the just before or after the season end, then we would see it as a just reward for how he had done since he came in. As it took so long you could speculate that he either wasn't first choice or after looking at our transfer budget deemed to be a safe pair of hands to look after a low outspend and a few outgoings.

The renewing of contracts for Tomkins, Ward and Clyne and currently just one free transfer coming in, also makes it look like we won't be spending much.

The third factor is time. We never seem to get players across the line quickly. To lose Olise, Guehi or one of the others, how much faith do we have that we can get a replacement in quickly?

Of course we may pull in 2-3 players who will be straight into the squad ready to compete for the first team. However, with more speculation on outgoings than incomings I'm certainly not feeling that positive about the new season at the moment.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 25 Jul 23 2.38pm

I've supported Palace for many years but right now I feel like we're a Poundland West Ham with a sh!t ground.

I really hope there's some encouraging news coming out of Selhurst in the next three weeks because right now I'm depressed.

 

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 25 Jul 23 2.57pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

I've supported Palace for many years but right now I feel like we're a Poundland West Ham with a sh!t ground.

I really hope there's some encouraging news coming out of Selhurst in the next three weeks because right now I'm depressed.

You got a new stand on its way in a few years lol and a new paint job

 

becky Flag over the moon 25 Jul 23 3.20pm

Originally posted by radsyrendot

You got a new stand on its way in a few years lol and a new paint job

Not to forget colour co-ordinated, soft toilet tissue in the Gents......

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 25 Jul 23 3.33pm

Honestly, nothing is known until the window closes. It has been a funny window due to all the Saudi activity.

It's easy to worry, but only time will tell. We may have outgoings to figure out, and that means we need different incoming priorities.

All we can do is wait and hope. I do think our recent record on transfers has been great so I have hope

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 25 Jul 23 3.40pm

Originally posted by radsyrendot

You got a new stand on its way in a few years lol and a new paint job

When I said Poundland West Ham I meant all round, not just the ground...

Edited by Sansbup (25 Jul 2023 3.41pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 25 Jul 23 3.54pm

Originally posted by doombear

I sense a degree of panic or is it just nervousness on this site since the Zaha revelation.

But let's stop and ask ourselves:

What has actually happened?

Well
1. Zaha who left the club over 3 weeks ago has signed for another club. Should we really be surprised?
2. There has been a rumour that Olise has agreed terms with Chelsea but this is subject to Palace agreeing to sell him and as far as we are aware, the club have not accepted Chelsea's apparent offer of about 40m.
3. Previously there have been rumours that bigger clubs are after Guehi, Andersen and Doucoure but there have not been any bids of which we are aware - yes lots of speculation of how much would be needed to prise them away from us but no firm evidence of the club's willingness to sell at those prices or even at all.
4. So far we have signed one player on a free (Lerma). There's also a rumour we've signed a young defender who was at Bournemouth (Francis) but no confirmation of this from the club.


We have another 5 weeks of the transfer window and I understand that this fact can make fans nervous when all the talk seems to be about other teams wanting our key players and very little talk about what we're doing.

As things stand, the squad that went out to the USA yesterday (plus a few from the U21 squad) is the squad currently available for our first league game in just under 3 weeks. It is somewhat thin on the ground and we must hope that there will be some incoming movement and no or minimal outward movement.

Let's see how we're placed on Saturday 2nd September. If all the future player movement is outward then that will be the time to panic.

I do agree that we shouldn't be panicking, but there is some cause for concern....

Parish will have known that Wilf was intending to leave years ago. But as yet we don't have a clear replacement.

Not known if the youngsters, Malcom, Plange, RS etc will be able to make the step up to contribute next season

Olise is injured and will miss a chunk of the start of the season

Its clear that our 2 CFs aren't really up to the task.

We havent had a decent RB or years, and have jsut resigned 2 sub standard ones

We have 1 LB in patchy form

We have very little depth....just imagine if Eze gets injured in pre-season. We'll be set up to defend for a few months


 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 25 Jul 23 5.02pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I do agree that we shouldn't be panicking, but there is some cause for concern....

Parish will have known that Wilf was intending to leave years ago. But as yet we don't have a clear replacement.

Not known if the youngsters, Malcom, Plange, RS etc will be able to make the step up to contribute next season

Olise is injured and will miss a chunk of the start of the season

Its clear that our 2 CFs aren't really up to the task.

We havent had a decent RB or years, and have jsut resigned 2 sub standard ones

We have 1 LB in patchy form

We have very little depth....just imagine if Eze gets injured in pre-season. We'll be set up to defend for a few months


That last bit could be a forgone conclusion if we lose our first 3 or 4 !

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Jul 23 5.06pm

The club would be well advised to sign someone like Franca before announcing Demarai Gray.

 


Red and Blue Army!

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 25 Jul 23 5.33pm

I'm starting to think there will be no more incomings before the season starts and it will be a deadline day rush before we announce another 'promising youngster' like Plange and Ebiowei, who will spend 2 seasons out on loan and then released.

Being a Palace fan makes you naturally pessimistic.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 25 Jul 23 5.55pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The club would be well advised to sign someone like Franca before announcing Demarai Gray.

Relax , we have to wait until all the other sides have got their squads together before we make a move on whats left at the end of September

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 25 Jul 23 5.59pm

For me personally, the worst element of this window is constantly reading about the best players leaving…and the way these BS stories are published, like it’s nailed on they are going. I don’t believe any of them! Zaha has been leaving every year according to the same BS reporters.

But when I constantly read articles about losing Guehi, Andersen, Johnston, Olise, Eze and Doucoure…all while we knew Zaha was likely to leave. It’s not been an easy summer for a palace fan so far.

I don’t think Palace would sell more than one star player a season. So if one does go, I think that will be the end of the speculation on the rest.

Dougie has done a superb job of buying all of this talent…and he’s still here looking for more. So there’s reason to be optimistic.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Jul 23 6.01pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Relax , we have to wait until all the other sides have got their squads together before we make a move on whats left at the end of September


Still in the pub Elpis?

 

Charlie B Flag 25 Jul 23 6.03pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

For me personally, the worst element of this window is constantly reading about the best players leaving…and the way these BS stories are published, like it’s nailed on they are going. I don’t believe any of them! Zaha has been leaving every year according to the same BS reporters.

But when I constantly read articles about losing Guehi, Andersen, Johnston, Olise, Eze and Doucoure…all while we knew Zaha was likely to leave. It’s not been an easy summer for a palace fan so far.

I don’t think Palace would sell more than one star player a season. So if one does go, I think that will be the end of the speculation on the rest.

Dougie has done a superb job of buying all of this talent…and he’s still here looking for more. So there’s reason to be optimistic.

Just wish the club would squash some of these rumours

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Jul 23 5.36am

Panic? No need. Just accept this is the season we could arguably hit the relegation spot due to number of timely factors:
Re-employment of Hodgson
Final departure of club talisman Zaha
Injury to Olise
Lack of cover in key areas
Lack of goals between forward line-up
Lack of funds
Potential loss of key players without likewise replacements

No real forward momentum, treading water seems the modus operandi until it finally goes wrong. Our time is up. Maybe.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 26 Jul 23 7.12am

Originally posted by doombear


Still in the pub Elpis?

Ah! being late to the party and missing it all together is a fair point though maybe we will be looking at the out of contract list by then to bolster the squad

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Fan Panic or just nervousness?