This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I've always loved Peters & Lee's 'Welcome Home' song.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You may even eventually see a split between the US (a huge financial and military support base for Israel) and Israel.....which is hard to imagine given the circumstances but probably eventually inevitable if the political trajectory stays the same......which demographics will have the largest say over.
without US backing ? you can debate whether Israel would survive for 5 minutes or 10 minutes. Cos they got more enemies than Gary Linekar
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Errrr....are you kidding Steely? Haven't you been watching these last seventy years? I make no particular comment on the rights or wrongs of the nation of Israel because I'm not a globalist and I learned from the Iraqi war that interfering only creates resentment and larger problems. So I forgo stating the obvious fact that Israel operates as an apartheid and almost amusingly racist state and that the west are in complete hypocrisy because.....well...let's leave it there. However, just as I don't spend my time wailing over how Saudi internally operates thinking we need to interfere (modern imperialism) I don't spend my time wailing over Israel either. However, I will make this observation on the future of Israel's politics.....and it's not going to please the left....but it reflects the reality consequence of demographics. Israel has been becoming increasingly right wing since its formation.....For example, its first PM (Ben-Gurion) was quite liberal and secular, a 40s version of your New York Jews today....people can point towards how this was allied with extreme ethnocentrism (pretty much essential when fighting for a new state) and how hypocritical that is... but I couldn't possibly comment. However, the problem the left have is that their middle and higher class don't have children at anything like the rate of conservatives....especially the religious. So in Israel....a country....and I almost have to stop myself from laughing when I write this....a country which restricts who can become Israeli for obvious reasons....it is the religious right who have been gaining in power since its formation. Netanyahu is just the manifestation of the power dymanics that Israel is undergoing and the reality is that Israel will becoming more right wing not less due to these demographical realities.....demographics is destiny just as much there as it is here. It doesn't matter how many Arabs live in Israel (one third) if they can't vote on who leads it. This obviously creates a rift between the highly socially liberal and increasingly globalist power base in the west, often with liberal secular Jews within that power base as well.....and the direction that Israel is heading down. You may even eventually see a split between the US (a huge financial and military support base for Israel) and Israel.....which is hard to imagine given the circumstances but probably eventually inevitable if the political trajectory stays the same......which demographics will have the largest say over. Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Jul 2023 11.45am) That's a good point about the shift to the right dictated by demographics. Kind of how this country has moved right due to the aging population, although in their case it is about right wing conservatives knocking them out for God v middle class liberals behaving like... well... middle class liberals the West over. Perhaps Northern Ireland and the large protestant families is a better example? However, I am not sure if it is just that. You highlight US support and, frankly, that also has a great deal to do with all the problems of Israel and the middle east in general. There is a regular poster on here (Jiminez? - I am not attacking him!) who has, as his strap line, something like "Support for the USA and Israel". And that is it. Blind support irrespective of the conduct of Israel or other moral complexities. From the Jewish Diaspora this is something you might expect and understand. However, from many Americans, it is religious, but not the Jewish lobby. Alone, they have the influence but not the numbers. Those who blindly support Israel, tend to be hard right fundamental Christians. They believe the land was given to Israelis by God. There is no arguing or rationing with this. It is black and white, night and day. No US party of any colour can ignore or upset this huge power base of around 40% of the country, all of whom strongly believe in their democratic duty to vote i.e. in practice a great deal more than 40% of those who bother to turn up to put an X on the card. The Democrats tend to be a little more sensitive to e.g. Palestinian rights which is why Israel will bomb a site where terror suspects are believed to be held up - irrespective of collateral damage to women and kids - the millisecond a Republican GE win is announced; but otherwise there is precious little between them. With all the resources from American evangelists pouring into the coffers of Israeli conservatives in addition to demographic changes and (I am guessing) a propensity to vote, small wonder the right have held power in Israel for so long. There are, of course, knock on effects. The generally liberal Europe and other powers are powerless to change things while US support is so strong and unwavering. This has brought the West and the Arab worlds into conflict. A difficult one for us who spent so long fostering strong links with Arab countries (for obvious reasons). Iran, in particular, feels an affinity to their Shiite brothers and their support for Palestine is the reason they are demonized in the West, not for their support for "terrorism" which tends to come from the Suni Gulf states (who, perversely, we must pretend to love while the Petro-world exists). All the nations neighbouring Israel would happily wipe it off the map and replace it with the Palestinian state that pre-dated the War. Therefore, they hate the West and, especially, the US that keeps it there and them away. They may have been appeased had Israel actually adhered to any of the UN treaties that preserved at least some Palestinian sovereignty, but Israel breached them all with impunity and with full US support. And all the while, the West is fed an endless diet of anti-Arab propaganda not helped, of course, by that colossal own goal that was 9/11. The other great irony is that those Christian US citizens who believe, without question, in the divine right of Israelis in Israel, are probably antisemitic to a man! And Israelis probably hate them in return. Not a subtlety they will ever appreciate. Thus, I do not share your belief that the US will pull out or withdraw their support. The situation set out above shows no sign of abating. Indeed, the current all but unopposed charge of Trump to the White House and the expansion of populism and evangelism indicates that the shift to unbending support in the US is actually growing, not diminishing. It seems extraordinary to be saying this in 2023, but for so long as people believe that the nation was a gift from God, there is no chance the problem will go anywhere. Perhaps (and I cant believe I am saying this) salvation comes from the growth of secular China as a global power? Discuss.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
That's a good point about the shift to the right dictated by demographics. Kind of how this country has moved right due to the aging population, although in their case it is about right wing conservatives knocking them out for God v middle class liberals behaving like... well... middle class liberals the West over. Perhaps Northern Ireland and the large protestant families is a better example? However, I am not sure if it is just that. You highlight US support and, frankly, that also has a great deal to do with all the problems of Israel and the middle east in general. There is a regular poster on here (Jiminez? - I am not attacking him!) who has, as his strap line, something like "Support for the USA and Israel". And that is it. Blind support irrespective of the conduct of Israel or other moral complexities. From the Jewish Diaspora this is something you might expect and understand. However, from many Americans, it is religious, but not the Jewish lobby. Alone, they have the influence but not the numbers. Those who blindly support Israel, tend to be hard right fundamental Christians. They believe the land was given to Israelis by God. There is no arguing or rationing with this. It is black and white, night and day. No US party of any colour can ignore or upset this huge power base of around 40% of the country, all of whom strongly believe in their democratic duty to vote i.e. in practice a great deal more than 40% of those who bother to turn up to put an X on the card. The Democrats tend to be a little more sensitive to e.g. Palestinian rights which is why Israel will bomb a site where terror suspects are believed to be held up - irrespective of collateral damage to women and kids - the millisecond a Republican GE win is announced; but otherwise there is precious little between them. With all the resources from American evangelists pouring into the coffers of Israeli conservatives in addition to demographic changes and (I am guessing) a propensity to vote, small wonder the right have held power in Israel for so long. There are, of course, knock on effects. The generally liberal Europe and other powers are powerless to change things while US support is so strong and unwavering. This has brought the West and the Arab worlds into conflict. A difficult one for us who spent so long fostering strong links with Arab countries (for obvious reasons). Iran, in particular, feels an affinity to their Shiite brothers and their support for Palestine is the reason they are demonized in the West, not for their support for "terrorism" which tends to come from the Suni Gulf states (who, perversely, we must pretend to love while the Petro-world exists). All the nations neighbouring Israel would happily wipe it off the map and replace it with the Palestinian state that pre-dated the War. Therefore, they hate the West and, especially, the US that keeps it there and them away. They may have been appeased had Israel actually adhered to any of the UN treaties that preserved at least some Palestinian sovereignty, but Israel breached them all with impunity and with full US support. And all the while, the West is fed an endless diet of anti-Arab propaganda not helped, of course, by that colossal own goal that was 9/11. The other great irony is that those Christian US citizens who believe, without question, in the divine right of Israelis in Israel, are probably antisemitic to a man! And Israelis probably hate them in return. Not a subtlety they will ever appreciate. Thus, I do not share your belief that the US will pull out or withdraw their support. The situation set out above shows no sign of abating. Indeed, the current all but unopposed charge of Trump to the White House and the expansion of populism and evangelism indicates that the shift to unbending support in the US is actually growing, not diminishing. It seems extraordinary to be saying this in 2023, but for so long as people believe that the nation was a gift from God, there is no chance the problem will go anywhere. Perhaps (and I cant believe I am saying this) salvation comes from the growth of secular China as a global power? Discuss. An excellent and interesting post. I think a lot of why the US is where it is regarding Israel comes down to the donor class feeding both Republicans and Democrats and other factors but I also agree fully with your point regarding the religious Christian right's cheerleading opinion of Israel and its paradoxical nature.......but it should also be noted that religion is rapidly declining in the US. The US is all about the money.....or to be more accurate, the wealth class within it. As for China, they are secular but very ethnocentric.....which I like of course....but as western policy has actually driven Russia and China into each others arms.....rather than salvation I'll accept just avoiding anymore wars. I don't want a drone in my or my children's face.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
An excellent and interesting post. I think a lot of why the US is where it is regarding Israel comes down to the donor class feeding both Republicans and Democrats and other factors but I also agree fully with your point regarding the religious Christian right's cheerleading opinion of Israel and its paradoxical nature.......but it should also be noted that religion is rapidly declining in the US. The US is all about the money.....or to be more accurate, the wealth class within it. As for China, they are secular but very ethnocentric.....which I like of course....but as western policy has actually driven Russia and China into each others arms.....rather than salvation I'll accept just avoiding anymore wars. I don't want a drone in my or my children's face. I don't want one either. However, on the highlighted point, I am not sure that is right. Africa is a battle ground between the West and Russian Wagner assisted client states (note those who still turned up for Putin last week) but the real winner there is China. It has spread its tentacles so thickly within that continent and exerts a considerable influence. Again, for obvious reasons, I suspect it would dearly love to have the same investments and influence on the middle east; it may already have? The question is, if the West Bank and Gaza were offered Chinese factories and infrastructure, would Israel (i.e. the US) block it, or match it? Don't believe the blarney. Northern Ireland was bought out of the Troubles through investment and jobs. You create an environment where people have no hope of employment prospect unless they leave, you create dissent. Palestine is no different. If they have good prospects and where they live is clean, prosperous and safe, they might forget over time what has been taken from them and done to them. Their Chinese backers would do all they could to ensure a stable territory to ensure they have cheap, ready labour and unfettered production. Israel has still not grasped this. They have had one dumb ass right wing government after another (actually the same one) believing the only solution is force, knocking down a convicted terrorist's mother's house and stealing more of their land through that wretched wall and Settlements occupied by American Jewish settlers. All they are doing is feeding a self-defeating solution to a paranoid frightened people and ever stoking the fire.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I don't want one either. However, on the highlighted point, I am not sure that is right. Africa is a battle ground between the West and Russian Wagner assisted client states (note those who still turned up for Putin last week) but the real winner there is China. It has spread its tentacles so thickly within that continent and exerts a considerable influence. Again, for obvious reasons, I suspect it would dearly love to have the same investments and influence on the middle east; it may already have? The question is, if the West Bank and Gaza were offered Chinese factories and infrastructure, would Israel (i.e. the US) block it, or match it? Don't believe the blarney. Northern Ireland was bought out of the Troubles through investment and jobs. You create an environment where people have no hope of employment prospect unless they leave, you create dissent. Palestine is no different. If they have good prospects and where they live is clean, prosperous and safe, they might forget over time what has been taken from them and done to them. Their Chinese backers would do all they could to ensure a stable territory to ensure they have cheap, ready labour and unfettered production. Israel has still not grasped this. They have had one dumb ass right wing government after another (actually the same one) believing the only solution is force, knocking down a convicted terrorist's mother's house and stealing more of their land through that wretched wall and Settlements occupied by American Jewish settlers. All they are doing is feeding a self-defeating solution to a paranoid frightened people and ever stoking the fire. Agreed with your last paragraph in particular. I heard Olmert, PM of Israel 2006-9 saying the 2 state solution was the only way and that he had been in the final stages of an agreement with the Palestinians. Tbh the coalition partner looks like a bunch of right wing thugs. As FH says, the World leaders offer nothing, but avert their eyes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I don't want one either. However, on the highlighted point, I am not sure that is right. Africa is a battle ground between the West and Russian Wagner assisted client states (note those who still turned up for Putin last week) but the real winner there is China. It has spread its tentacles so thickly within that continent and exerts a considerable influence. Again, for obvious reasons, I suspect it would dearly love to have the same investments and influence on the middle east; it may already have? The question is, if the West Bank and Gaza were offered Chinese factories and infrastructure, would Israel (i.e. the US) block it, or match it? Don't believe the blarney. Northern Ireland was bought out of the Troubles through investment and jobs. You create an environment where people have no hope of employment prospect unless they leave, you create dissent. Palestine is no different. If they have good prospects and where they live is clean, prosperous and safe, they might forget over time what has been taken from them and done to them. Their Chinese backers would do all they could to ensure a stable territory to ensure they have cheap, ready labour and unfettered production. Israel has still not grasped this. They have had one dumb ass right wing government after another (actually the same one) believing the only solution is force, knocking down a convicted terrorist's mother's house and stealing more of their land through that wretched wall and Settlements occupied by American Jewish settlers. All they are doing is feeding a self-defeating solution to a paranoid frightened people and ever stoking the fire. Personally, being a humble student of history I wouldn't have anything to do with Africa. It has the resources but it's a false horizon.....it's not politically correct to say it but outside of maybe North Africa...in my view it doesn't have the civilisational critical mass required to be what its investors think it should be.....It is what it is. Literally Europeans have spent generations finding that out and still we have fools who haven't learnt the lesson because....Well essentially the stubbornness of the blank slate belief system and money possible with globalism. Trade deals are fine but I wouldn't be trying to complete for the dirty business of buying alignment in Africa. But hey, if Russia and China think Africa is somewhere to fight the west over, personally I would say they are welcome to it.....I know what I would do.....I would be investing elsewhere. You seem to think that secularization and investment can breakdown conflicts and use NI as an example...Investment certainly helps....But I don't really agree that secular apathy is what happened in NI....the troubles were always about a minority in terms of actual fighting anyway. The IRA were still very active and a threat before the Good Friday agreement.....They ended it by essentially surrendering NI over...Having NI family I can tell you that resentments don't go away. What works is forcing change via the law and then waiting for the previous generation to die off.....Forced demographic change is changing Ireland more than people buying Playstations instead of going to church. You seem to think that this process would work in Palestine? No chance in my view. The two state solution won't work either, the right of neither side would accept it.....Palestinians aren't law abiding Europeans like the British and English who can be convinced to lose their own land. No, I see that conflict ending only one way and it aren't pretty and hasn't been for decades.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Personally, being a humble student of history I wouldn't have anything to do with Africa. It has the resources but it's a false horizon.....it's not politically correct to say it but outside of maybe North Africa...in my view it doesn't have the civilisational critical mass required to be what its investors think it should be.....It is what it is. Literally Europeans have spent generations finding that out and still we have fools who haven't learnt the lesson because....Well essentially the stubbornness of the blank slate belief system and money possible with globalism. Trade deals are fine but I wouldn't be trying to complete for the dirty business of buying alignment in Africa. But hey, if Russia and China think Africa is somewhere to fight the west over, personally I would say they are welcome to it.....I know what I would do.....I would be investing elsewhere. You seem to think that secularization and investment can breakdown conflicts and use NI as an example...Investment certainly helps....But I don't really agree that secular apathy is what happened in NI....the troubles were always about a minority in terms of actual fighting anyway. The IRA were still very active and a threat before the Good Friday agreement.....They ended it by essentially surrendering NI over...Having NI family I can tell you that resentments don't go away. What works is forcing change via the law and then waiting for the previous generation to die off.....Forced demographic change is changing Ireland more than people buying Playstations instead of going to church. You seem to think that this process would work in Palestine? No chance in my view. The two state solution won't work either, the right of neither side would accept it.....Palestinians aren't law abiding Europeans like the British and English who can be convinced to lose their own land. No, I see that conflict ending only one way and it aren't pretty and hasn't been for decades.
Yes, with a sigh, straws were being grasped. And there is no hope of the people who live there turning any corner without external intervention. Annoyingly, a possible solution is Iran. Not now, of course, in its basket case condition, but at some future time if the glacially slow transition from revolutionary government to, at least, mildly sensible world player continues. Even the seriously hard radical element of Palestine might listen to them. Regrettably, the only people the Israelis listen to is the US and I have highlighted the problem that no American government can be seen to be giving an inch to them Muslims (even though one-in-eleven Palestinians are Christian). And they only listen to them because the US props that nation up. Get a decent government in power (and Clinton was the last one in this respect, despite his failings elsewhere) and there is a chance. Put an honest broker in the middle (the Swedes or Norwegians usually suffice for this) and add external investment (where the Chinese may come into play) and there is a hope. The trouble is, people will still be upset. For generations. Clintons enforced reforms (remember the extraordinary scene of Israeli soldiers clearing the settlements of Jews) and 2 state solution have rapidly unraveled through agents of hate and self-service. Absent safeguards in place to prevent that (???) and huge sacrifices from both sides (some hope!), this is a problem with no solution.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It certainly feels like that, which given who is involved is very odd indeed. It will be interesting to observe it first-hand and directly hear opinions. From the reports, it appears this is very widely opposed and not what the people as a whole want. When I was there before, which is a long time ago, I went with some preconceptions which were revised to a degree because the relationships I saw between the Israelis and local Arabs was a lot better than I expected. Human nature overcoming political prejudice in clear view. I am not going there for the politics. I am going for the history, and for my wife. How much do you expect to pay for a wife ? Or are you selling ?
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
A few reflections after my visit. Political action was only noticeable by its absence. I saw one guy carrying a sign but no protests. People were just getting on with their lives. We stayed in East Jerusalem and it was obvious that the local population there are doing ok. They looked fairly prosperous and had an active social life, although culturally it was unfamiliar. They were friendly and helpful though. We felt less welcome in other areas. Indeed the Israeli people we found generally unfriendly and quite rude, to the point of hostility at times. There were many exceptions though. The only tensions that were in any way apparent were between the Jewish secular and religious communities and not between the Jewish and Muslim. Mind you we did not venture into the West Bank. More than 200 Palestinians and nearly 30 Israelis have been killed so far this year in the occupied West Bank and Israel [as at August, Aljazeera]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Indeed the Israeli people we found generally unfriendly and quite rude, to the point of hostility at times. i wouldnt take it personally- them being brusque with you. An Israeli friend told me they are like that to each other also.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
A few reflections after my visit. Political action was only noticeable by its absence. I saw one guy carrying a sign but no protests. People were just getting on with their lives. We stayed in East Jerusalem and it was obvious that the local population there are doing ok. They looked fairly prosperous and had an active social life, although culturally it was unfamiliar. They were friendly and helpful though. We felt less welcome in other areas. Indeed the Israeli people we found generally unfriendly and quite rude, to the point of hostility at times. There were many exceptions though. The only tensions that were in any way apparent were between the Jewish secular and religious communities and not between the Jewish and Muslim. Mind you we did not venture into the West Bank. I hope you have the rude ones a piece of your mind.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.