You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish is the problem
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Parish is the problem


Page 9 of 9 << First< 5 6 7 8 9
deflemonkid Flag 07 Oct 23 8.07am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This is a very interesting post SnapperKain, thanks.

On your very first point (and I appreciate you are not suggesting otherwise, but just for clarity) if someone with a billion in the bank did buy CPFC tomorrow our transfer budget would not change. FFP requires that CPFC only spend what CPFC earns, regardless of what personal money the owner may want to throw around.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (05 Oct 2023 12.16pm)


This is a murky point in terms of FFP, been listening to the Price of football podcast the last couple of years and i keep hearing the term "converting a loan into shares" which is what's happened down on the south coast. Tony Bloom basically pumps loads of his own cash into the club as a "loan" and then down the road converts that loan to shares. It dilutes the value of a share but if you own them all and your not really in it to make a profit then its apparently above board.

I also think if Parish had such a suitor knocking on the door he'd gladly hand over the reins but as it stands he's definitely kept us punching above our weight as far as I can see.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 07 Oct 23 9.45am

Its certainly true that if the man with a £ billion burning a hole in his pocket did turn up on our door that we couldn't suddenly splash out of transfers (courtesy of FFP) but there are areas where we could improve our financial standing which in turn would improve our FFP position & then we could spend more on transfers because our revenue stream had improved along the way -

a) Naming rights for Selhurst Park
b) Naming rights for the Academy
c) Shirt sponsor - New deal with a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value -
d) In ground advertising favouring prime locations to a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value.

Of course now that these avenues are a more well trodden path from the days when Chelsea & Man City were able to name their price & inflate their balance sheet accordingly (to obtain better FFP positioning) even at todays "norm" they can still be a considerable leveraging tool for a PL club.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 07 Oct 23 10.05am

Originally posted by eaglesdare

A year or two in the championship would do some of our fans the world of good.

It wouldn't change a thing, we would be demanding prem football, like now we're demanding a push into the top 10/Europe. If you don't have ambition to be better then there's probably no point supporting a competitive sporting club.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 07 Oct 23 2.27pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle


c) Shirt sponsor - New deal with a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value -

The powers that be are supposed to have cut down on that with all commercial deals having to be at normal market rates although I'm sure that some of the big boys get away with it

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 07 Oct 23 3.20pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Its certainly true that if the man with a £ billion burning a hole in his pocket did turn up on our door that we couldn't suddenly splash out of transfers (courtesy of FFP) but there are areas where we could improve our financial standing which in turn would improve our FFP position & then we could spend more on transfers because our revenue stream had improved along the way -

a) Naming rights for Selhurst Park
b) Naming rights for the Academy
c) Shirt sponsor - New deal with a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value -
d) In ground advertising favouring prime locations to a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value.

Of course now that these avenues are a more well trodden path from the days when Chelsea & Man City were able to name their price & inflate their balance sheet accordingly (to obtain better FFP positioning) even at todays "norm" they can still be a considerable leveraging tool for a PL club.


FFP doesn't mean a great deal.

If you have the money you can spend and pay the fine this has been done by clubs before.

That list is what we should already be doing and a good business man in charge would have done this another bunch of reasons for SP out from his current role (no issue with him owning part of the club)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

est1905 Flag 09 Oct 23 5.30pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Its certainly true that if the man with a £ billion burning a hole in his pocket did turn up on our door that we couldn't suddenly splash out of transfers (courtesy of FFP) but there are areas where we could improve our financial standing which in turn would improve our FFP position & then we could spend more on transfers because our revenue stream had improved along the way -

a) Naming rights for Selhurst Park
b) Naming rights for the Academy
c) Shirt sponsor - New deal with a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value -
d) In ground advertising favouring prime locations to a company owned by our new benefactor at enhanced contract value.

Of course now that these avenues are a more well trodden path from the days when Chelsea & Man City were able to name their price & inflate their balance sheet accordingly (to obtain better FFP positioning) even at todays "norm" they can still be a considerable leveraging tool for a PL club.

Premiership rules strictly now prohibit owners/investors/directors of a club having any connection whatsoever to income. IE: they are not allowed to buy naming rights for one of their companies and they are not allowed to use one of their companies to sponsor the club at a way inflated figure just to get the club's turnover/income up. This was pushed hard by Daniel Levy when Newcastle's takeover was completed (for obvious reasons). The thing that is unfair on everyone else is deals that are already in place at clubs such as Chelsea, Man City, Liverpool, United are allowed to not only stay in place but are also allowed to be renewed!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 09 Oct 23 6.42pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

This is a very interesting post SnapperKain, thanks.

On your very first point (and I appreciate you are not suggesting otherwise, but just for clarity) if someone with a billion in the bank did buy CPFC tomorrow our transfer budget would not change. FFP requires that CPFC only spend what CPFC earns, regardless of what personal money the owner may want to throw around.

Leaving aside the idea of 'doing a Newcastle' at Palace (i.e. spending big sums quickly on players in the hope of getting into the top four, thereby increasing revenue so the original spending becomes permissible), a billionaire owner (or just any new owner, or just our current owners acting differently) might change our transfer strategy, but not our transfer budget. I think that is where Textor, and the points you make about him, become most significant.

Some pine for the semi-high risk, high-turnover, speculative approach Brighton have taken, for instance. Perhaps Textor is one of them.

Personally, I don't think it's wise. Southampton did something very similar, they got into the Europa League (maybe twice?) whilst buying low and selling high. It didn't last, didn't get them to the next level, and then it all caught up with them. I expect the same at Brighton. More to the point, we have the largest metropolitan catchment area in the UK (maybe the world) to try and find future players in. Brighton and Southampton don't. Focusing on the academy makes as much sense for us as speculative international transfers makes for them.

Even so, there was some suggestion that Textor had funded the purchases of Andersen, Geuhi, Dacoure etc. I presume that was in the form of a loan to CPFC, as a gift would not be allowed. Perhaps he did give those funds on the basis that the players get sold at profit, and that he gets his money back plus a bit more. Only Textor and Parish will know the details, but I'm not sure how that would be at odds with the new general strategy anyway - whoever's money has been spent, it has been spent by CPFC who must meet FFP requirements. I'm not sure what difference it would make if Textor was pressing Parish to sell players at profit - he is going to try and do that anyway - although I totally take your point about not having Textor running the club. All the more reason to have Parish there, as far as I a concerned.

The great unknown in all of this is who, if anyone, has put their own money into the bricks and mortar. The original Americans lent CPFC money to tide the club over during covid, and also for the Allardyce-era transfer spend. It seems Textor helped with the Vieria-era transfer spend. A top-rate academy has been built and paid for (I would urge anyone who hasn't already to watch the interview Parish gave to Gary Neville about the mind-blowing costs of that), whilst a new main stand has stalled. Parish has described the involvement of the Americans (including Textor) as a means by which to speed-up his development plans for the club, but none of us know the specifics. Did any of them come on board especially to spend their own money on bricks and mortar? If so, perhaps we have already done well out of them to get the academy built, but perhaps a different investor would have built the stand by now too. If they haven't paid for the academy then why are they here, given they can't spend their own money on transfers?

If I had to guess, I would say the original Americans came in to pay for the academy and the stand (fairly safe investments, permissible personal spending under FFP), and then to sell at a profit, and that Textor is more focused on the buying and selling of players at profit.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (05 Oct 2023 12.16pm)

Good post. As was Snapperkain.
Haven't seen sydtheeagle posting this season. Shame. He has good angles.
Hope he is ok.

Edited by dreamwaverider (09 Oct 2023 6.43pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Oct 23 7.10pm

I've not generally been a critic of SP but looked at what we had at the end of last season once Roy had straightened things out and thought that with additions in the full back areas and up front we could have a very good season.

As it turns out I think that the Board have looked at the three teams that have been promoted and a couple of others they perceive to be strugglers and closed the wallet.

Ultimately I think we'll be the losers as I think, in the end, the better players will get the hump with the lack of ambition and any prospect of European football.

SP and the Board have done well by us but I think that they have struck a bit lucky with Roy and found their goose that lays the golden egg.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 09 Oct 23 7.32pm

Newcastle is owned by PIF
Sela shirt sponsor is owned by PIF
Stadium Naming rights will no doubt follow sometime soon.


Originally posted by est1905

Premiership rules strictly now prohibit owners/investors/directors of a club having any connection whatsoever to income. IE: they are not allowed to buy naming rights for one of their companies and they are not allowed to use one of their companies to sponsor the club at a way inflated figure just to get the club's turnover/income up. This was pushed hard by Daniel Levy when Newcastle's takeover was completed (for obvious reasons). The thing that is unfair on everyone else is deals that are already in place at clubs such as Chelsea, Man City, Liverpool, United are allowed to not only stay in place but are also allowed to be renewed!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Oct 23 7.38pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I've not generally been a critic of SP but looked at what we had at the end of last season once Roy had straightened things out and thought that with additions in the full back areas and up front we could have a very good season.

As it turns out I think that the Board have looked at the three teams that have been promoted and a couple of others they perceive to be strugglers and closed the wallet.

Ultimately I think we'll be the losers as I think, in the end, the better players will get the hump with the lack of ambition and any prospect of European football.

SP and the Board have done well by us but I think that they have struck a bit lucky with Roy and found their goose that lays the golden egg.

I'd include the word 'eventually' in there.

May be slightly delusional and optimistic from me but I am open to believe the management situation is reflected in the window activity and may also correlate with the stadium too.

I get the impression certainly Parish at least is playing a longer game here. Therefore there may be numerous windows and seasons pass by where not much happens, and seemingly reflects a lack of ambition or intent, however if an improved stadium were to come to fruition, and a new manager will certainly have to be sounded out at this season's end, a year sitting back on near guaranteed survival may see the likes of Henderson and Franca arriving as promising players with ROI, alongside perhaps a free transfer for an established player in the midfield, to tide us over for the meantime.

My hope is that the arrival of a new manager will have to be accompanied with a promise and delivery of sincere investment in playing staff. Again, may well be very wishful thinking, but I imagine us finishing this season unexcitingly in 8-15th place, bringing in a new manager and a few new players to bolster what we have now. We may see a few exits too.

This season was all set to be placeholder one for us and is looking to be so, with any over-achievement a huge bonus. Hopefully the 2024-25 season will see a lot more and improved transfer activity to enthuse the club, us as fans, and the players too.

A bottomless pit, Saudi, Emirate style takeover with nothing but the best intentions for the club at heart is a real pipe dream only Citeh and now possibly Newcastle will experience, hasn't even worked for PSG. Until then, we're almost certainly lucky to have Parish and any b!tching about that situation is surely the most removed from reality, especially given our past. It's not perfect by any means, and frustrating at times, but could be considerably worse. There are plenty of examples.

Edited by Nicholas91 (09 Oct 2023 7.40pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Runningman Flag Keston 10 Oct 23 1.59am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I'd include the word 'eventually' in there.

May be slightly delusional and optimistic from me but I am open to believe the management situation is reflected in the window activity and may also correlate with the stadium too.

I get the impression certainly Parish at least is playing a longer game here. Therefore there may be numerous windows and seasons pass by where not much happens, and seemingly reflects a lack of ambition or intent, however if an improved stadium were to come to fruition, and a new manager will certainly have to be sounded out at this season's end, a year sitting back on near guaranteed survival may see the likes of Henderson and Franca arriving as promising players with ROI, alongside perhaps a free transfer for an established player in the midfield, to tide us over for the meantime.

My hope is that the arrival of a new manager will have to be accompanied with a promise and delivery of sincere investment in playing staff. Again, may well be very wishful thinking, but I imagine us finishing this season unexcitingly in 8-15th place, bringing in a new manager and a few new players to bolster what we have now. We may see a few exits too.

This season was all set to be placeholder one for us and is looking to be so, with any over-achievement a huge bonus. Hopefully the 2024-25 season will see a lot more and improved transfer activity to enthuse the club, us as fans, and the players too.

A bottomless pit, Saudi, Emirate style takeover with nothing but the best intentions for the club at heart is a real pipe dream only Citeh and now possibly Newcastle will experience, hasn't even worked for PSG. Until then, we're almost certainly lucky to have Parish and any b!tching about that situation is surely the most removed from reality, especially given our past. It's not perfect by any means, and frustrating at times, but could be considerably worse. There are plenty of examples.

Edited by Nicholas91 (09 Oct 2023 7.40pm)

Agreed.
In epl terms we are a small club.
Investment may get us 11th place.

SERIOUS investments gets us to 10th. We get another couple of million in prize money but at the expense of debt/future transfer payment commitments. A sad state of affairs but the life of a makeweight epl team.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 10 Oct 23 3.32am

I have been posting for years that the measure of success of a reasonable run in the prem is how the club looks at the end of it. The stadium is desperately in need of upgrading, achieve that, along with the academy and a healthy financial position and I would say that Parish’s tenure was a total success. European football, silverware would be great but not at the expense of the longer term success of the club.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Oct 23 8.00am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Even so, there was some suggestion that Textor had funded the purchases of Andersen, Geuhi, Dacoure etc. I presume that was in the form of a loan to CPFC, as a gift would not be allowed.

I believe that the funds that Textor injected came in the way of an increase in the company's share capital which is one way around FFP

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 10 Oct 23 8.02am

as a 50+ years Palace fan had 3 spells of us going close to going under chasing a dream , and the gods smiled at us and some how we got saved ,
so if you dont understand financial ramification of the dream failing , you could never run a business that effects thousands of people , so stop Parish bashing unless you have the money to buy the club

Edited by mtp1958 (10 Oct 2023 8.04am)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Oct 23 4.03pm

This is a real 'laugh, cry or get angry?' story!

I laughed, which is probably a bit uncaring, but should give some perspective to our current ownership - [Link]

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 31 Oct 23 5.07pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

This is a real 'laugh, cry or get angry?' story!

I laughed, which is probably a bit uncaring, but should give some perspective to our current ownership - [Link]
sport/football/67268518

Simon Jordan was saying this morning he doesn’t mean it he’s just trying to prove a point. The Wednesday fans have pi55ed him off by constantly saying they’re the real owners of the club as fans, this fella is just the most recent custodian, even though he’s pumped up 150 million in his time. So this is him saying it’s their turn if they think they’re the real owners.
Several fans have said there’s nothing even been set up to donate if you wanted too

SJ was a little bit sympathetic with him, because from his obvious experience fans demand this and demand that and keep telling owners how to spend their money and how much they should be spending. Obviously this fella has fcuked it up at Wednesday but it does sound like he’s had enough of putting money into the club

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 31 Oct 23 7.55pm

Originally posted by monkey

Simon Jordan was saying this morning he doesn’t mean it he’s just trying to prove a point. The Wednesday fans have pi55ed him off by constantly saying they’re the real owners of the club as fans, this fella is just the most recent custodian, even though he’s pumped up 150 million in his time. So this is him saying it’s their turn if they think they’re the real owners.
Several fans have said there’s nothing even been set up to donate if you wanted too

SJ was a little bit sympathetic with him, because from his obvious experience fans demand this and demand that and keep telling owners how to spend their money and how much they should be spending. Obviously this fella has fcuked it up at Wednesday but it does sound like he’s had enough of putting money into the club

Yup, he said last month(bbc) he was fed up of the abuse he & his family were getting, he wouldn't put any more money into the club. Guess he's sticking by his statement.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 9 of 9 << First< 5 6 7 8 9

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Parish is the problem