You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > People's obsession with the academy
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

People's obsession with the academy


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 07 Nov 23 12.35pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I can't remember if Parsh broke down the running costs, but £5m a year seems to be the average. The upfront costs of building it are of course a one-off, but even so, between building it and running it, it will have cost around £100m in ten years' time.

Whereas, all things being equal, the main stand has a good chance of paying for itself in a 10-15 year period, the academy is simply a cost unless it produces players that either get sold for good money (far more than the £1m we apparently made for O'Brien) or which save us from spending money on transfer fees.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (06 Nov 2023 5.24pm)

The EPPP Academy system was brought about to improve the standard of home grown players into the leagues and not just for the parent club - the original plan was to raise the standard of home grown player to a standard that would produce an international team that would win the world cup - During a kids academy journey this is usually outlined to them during their reviews(similar to learning a trade rather than learning to work for one employer). As such clubs receive yearly funding from the Premier league to run and maintain their academies - The funding given is reflects the academy standing (as such Cat 1's get the highest funding - Cat 4's the lowest) If a club unearths a gem that stays or a gem that they can sell on for profit then that's fantastic.

For those interested.

[Link]

[Link]

Can't find PL figures but Fulham has been a Cat 1 for some time and while they were in the championship this was their funding

[Link]

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 07 Nov 23 1.14pm

Originally posted by Isley46

The EPPP Academy system was brought about to improve the standard of home grown players into the leagues and not just for the parent club - the original plan was to raise the standard of home grown player to a standard that would produce an international team that would win the world cup - During a kids academy journey this is usually outlined to them during their reviews(similar to learning a trade rather than learning to work for one employer). As such clubs receive yearly funding from the Premier league to run and maintain their academies - The funding given is reflects the academy standing (as such Cat 1's get the highest funding - Cat 4's the lowest) If a club unearths a gem that stays or a gem that they can sell on for profit then that's fantastic.

For those interested.

[Link]

[Link]

Can't find PL figures but Fulham has been a Cat 1 for some time and while they were in the championship this was their funding

[Link]

Thats very interesting, thanks.

As I understood it, an academy was mandatory for premier league clubs. I recall Brentford scrapping their youth setup altogether when they were out of the EPL (hence we got Mitchell). I presume they have had to set one up again now. I didn't appreciate that they got money towards it.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 07 Nov 23 9.03pm

I haven't heard many obsessed with the Academy. I didn't even watch the series to my chagrin. I'm slightly interested in how our youngsters do, I keep half an eye on it. That's about it. Is everyone else obsessed? Parish maybe, for a while. Maybe I'm the odd one and everyone else is collecting stickers or something?

 


Red and Blue Army!

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 07 Nov 23 9.38pm

Unfortunately it is not that easy .Our under 21 just got beat by Wimbledon 2-0 and our side contained the best we have got including Ebiowei , Ahamada,Franca,Ozoh and the rest.They all need to be more mature and experienced to get to Premiership level let alone League 2. We are doing a good job in producing good footballers but to produce Premiership level at around 21 years of age is very very rare. But if you don’t try you will never succeed.COYP

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 08 Nov 23 4.32pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Sullay KaiKai has nearly 200 football league appearances and is an international for Sierra Leone.

Hiram Boateng also pushing 200 professional games across League One and League Two

Jason Lokilo is with Hull in the Championship.

Rob Street is in league one.

Ryan Innis has 100+ football league appearances and now with Forest Green in League Two.

There's also Keshi Andersen and Freddie Ladapo who are both Championship forwards - we signed both for our academy, as opposed to developed them from kids.

Again to hammer the point, we've had below average academy facilities for nearly all of the last 10 years, so I think it's a poor measuring stick as to what we'll be capable of moving forward.

i think the above just shows the gap between the Prem and lower leagues. Other than Keshi and Freddie who we bought from non league i don't think we got a fee for any of the others.

Chelsea are making millions from some of their youth players, we are making peanuts.

Hopefully as the club and players improve the transfer fees should increase. O'Brien is hopefully the 1st of many 6 or 7 figure fees.
I think Phillips is a good all action midfielder, but probably not Prem standard. However, a decent Championship career is a definite possibility.

Stockport were very interested in buying Banks this summer and a fee of over £300k was mentioned. I thought that was a fair price, but Palace chose to extend his contract and send him out on loan again (where i think he suffered an ACL). At 22 maybe we should have made the call that he won't make Prem league standards.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 09 Nov 23 8.55am

O'Brien supposedly went for one million to Lyon

Seven figures yes but we would not have made much of a profit afet whatever we spent on him.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Nov 23 9.42am

Originally posted by HKOwen

O'Brien supposedly went for one million to Lyon

Seven figures yes but we would not have made much of a profit afet whatever we spent on him.

I have the suspicion that this was to placate Textor.

He gave an interview moaning that he wasn't listened to and by implication that of his multi club ownership wasn't being allowed to prosper.

Some of us wondered why O'Brien wasn't offered a new contract and a chance to fight for a place at Palace.

I just have the feeling that Parish agreed to this odd deal to shut Textor up and allow him to go back to his investors with a "win" for the multi club strategy.

No proof just a feeling.

 


One more point

palace99 Flag New Mills 09 Nov 23 10.51am

Originally posted by martin2412

Do these young kids who are playing in the cages around London even consider the facilities at a professional club ? I doubt it very much.

If they're offered a trial at Chelsea, Arsenal, Spurs or Palace (cat A or not), I'm sure we would be last on their list, purely down to status, history and perception of the clubs.

All of these kids think that they're the next big thing, so they'd rather be a star for Arsenal than Palace. We just might get some cast-offs when reality hits home that they're not as good as they thought they were, and are released from their preferred club.

I disagree. I think getting Cat A status was important so we can show parents our facilities are on a par with other clubs.
Also there is a restriction on travel for young kids (think it's 90 minutes) so getting a club in South London if you are based in South London will reduce travel time.
Then there is the opportunity of 1st team football. Palace need to show there is a pathway, something that will appeal to parents. Palace and Allison used this when we were in the 3rd division in the 70s to build the team of the 80s (remember them!).

Finally, looking at the 6 part documentary on channel 4 some of the parents' behaviour was shocking. I think Palace are engaging more with parents and allowing them more access to training etc to differentiate our offering from other clubs. I suspect other clubs won't let parents thought the door whilst training is taking place.

If a parent of a child based in say Croydon is prepared to let them go to say Arsenal and travel across London twice a week then i suspect that's the parent not putting their child's interests first. The Palace offering should surely tick many boxes and should appeal to most 'sensible' parents

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 09 Nov 23 11.57am

Originally posted by HKOwen

O'Brien supposedly went for one million to Lyon

Seven figures yes but we would not have made much of a profit afet whatever we spent on him.

Considering O’Brian was one that was developing nicely, it was a bit odd to let him go for£1 mill. If you consider we are supposed to have laid that out each on Plange, and Obie.
Maybe he wouldn’t extend his contract, it’s possible because there had been a lot of interest in him and his agent knew it only to well. In general fees have been paid out on quiet a few of our youngsters. Banks was the subject of an offer , some said £500,000, we lashed out not far off that to get him down here as far as what was reported at the time. The thing is if we are bringing them in for substantial fees they must reach Championship level if there is to be any real money made from them, £1 mill tends to be an absolute max for divisions 1&2 rarely happens, and let’s face it that’s were the majority of interest is for our younger players.
Where a six figure ,or even seven figure , fee has been paid to get a lad, we need to get them into the Championship on loan to build a reputation, and then if they just don’t come through for us ,there might be a profit in them.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Nov 23 12.07pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I have the suspicion that this was to placate Textor.

He gave an interview moaning that he wasn't listened to and by implication that of his multi club ownership wasn't being allowed to prosper.

Some of us wondered why O'Brien wasn't offered a new contract and a chance to fight for a place at Palace.

I just have the feeling that Parish agreed to this odd deal to shut Textor up and allow him to go back to his investors with a "win" for the multi club strategy.

No proof just a feeling.

No doubt Textor was relevant to the deal, but I'd imagine O'Brien also had a big say - after a very successful season playing elsewhere in Europe, a massive European club like Lyon must have sounded very attractive to him.

I'd imagine it's more likely we did offer him an extension, but with no guarantees on playing time and Guehi and Anderson in front of him, he didn't see a path to the first team.

He's started the last 4 in a row for Lyon and had decent reports, despite the team having a horrendous season - I don't expect he'd have made 4 starts all season for us, so his decision is looking a decent one.

Expect he'll get an Ireland call up soon - he was well thought of at U21 level and now playing regular club football at a good level.

I read we have a sell-on clause for any future transfers, so hopefully he makes a success of it!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Nov 23 1.56pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Some of us wondered why O'Brien wasn't offered a new contract and a chance to fight for a place at Palace.

I just have the feeling that Parish agreed to this odd deal to shut Textor up and allow him to go back to his investors with a "win" for the multi club strategy.

No proof just a feeling.

I'm sure that I remember reading that he refused to sign a new contract

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > People's obsession with the academy