You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Everton match thread


Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Nov 23 10.55am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I note with interest that of the home games against teams currently below us, Fulham, Forest, and Everton, we didn't win a single one. Two lame 0-0 draws and a defeat. Two point out of a possible nine. That's form that will see you slide done the table, as we appear to be doing.
It's not all Roy's doing of course. Despite his overall defensive viewpoint of the game, he's been hard hit bit injuries to key players, and all the replacements are sub-standard. No doubt Parish thought he could squeeze another season out of players like Ward, given Roy's game plan and experience. Parish was mistaken. One Eze doesn't make up for two mediocre full backs. One Olise doesn't make up for a paper thin squad, that one has only to scratch the surface to see there's nothing there.
Games coming up in December and early January against the top sides, and I don't envisage us getting much out of them. currently 13th, and 15th/16th a real possibility. Managers have been sacked for less.
The blame ultimately falls on Parish. Money spent on players who are not essential to the current well being of the team: a keeper whose first meaningful action is to injure himself making a standard clearance, a young Brazilian 5700 mile from home, family, and friends, a centre back who Arsenal were only too happy to get a minimal fee for - the list goes on - Hughes, a bit part player even at Watford, and yet we expect him to fill a key midfield position. Mateta - can we get a refund?
It's ludicrous.

Can't disagree with much of this.

When Roy was appointed for this season, to me it signalled that the club were not spending much in the transfer market. So I was surprised that the best part of £40m was spent. Unfortunately at least half on a goalkeeper which seems over the top to me. Can't blame him or the club for his unfortunate injury though. Franca is a huge gamble given the fee and the fact that we needed ( imo ) Premier League ready players rather than unproven teenagers to bolster the squad.

As for Saturday's game, if you concede 3 goals at home to Everton then you probably deserve nothing. A fully fit Doucoure was much missed in the midfield. I thought we were too easy to play against in that area. I like Hughes's feistyness but he's too one paced and I thought he had a bit of a stinker on Saturday, gave the ball away too often. Edouard continues to frustrate. His work rate, or rather lack of, combined with his powder puff approach to the physical side of the game, gives the impression that we are playing with a man short at times.

I'm not sure what more Roy can do given the resources available. He's there as part of a holding pattern by the looks of it, but without actually knowing what Parish's strategy is, it's all speculation.

For once I'm glad there's an international break ahead !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Nov 23 11.06am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Well made points and I totally agree.
We have around six players who form the core group of the side, each one good enough to progress to a side higher up the table, everyone else is either bit part or not good enough. As Dubai Eagle commented in reply to a post of mine, we have spent just to stand still. Astute, and very true.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (13 Nov 2023 9.52am)

It's a situation which can be looked up on in different ways, very much glass half empty/full.

The lack of excitement is obviously the 'half empty' when we're not reaching latter stages of cups or the top half of the table (or just losing to a Sean Dyche Everton at home) but the 'half full' whilst we remain a PL outfit.

What it does provide however is plenty of fuel for a moan at the troughs! I'll just continue hoping for a new manager who proves revolutionary, new wing backs, a new winger and new striker. I'd rather not get too involved in ignorantly speculating or suggesting how that might/will come about but I'll put in on a list and send to St. Nick for now

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

OAPeagle Flag 13 Nov 23 11.38am

I agree all the comments re Ward and Mitchell. For me it did seem like someone had put superglue on the soles of a number of players boots, but the main problem is of course finishing up front. On paper, when we bought him, Edouard looked a good bet and tbf he is a good finisher (OK, only when he's had plenty of advance warning and space). Unlike soccer computer games, players aren't programmed robots. Moves to other teams can transform or ruin reputations. In reality the most successful strikers must have a sixth sense, to start running on to a through ball - or to anticipate a cross - before the playmaker has indicated their intention - and the playmaker themselves know before they play the pass where the striker will be. This only comes with practice and an innate understanding and respect between key players. The body language says everything. My hope is that Franca will be more in tune with Eze and Olise's mindset which means - for better or worse - give him much more game time (ie s*** or bust as my old coach used to say). If it works we could be in for one of the most exciting attacking lines since Wrighty and Brighty. Then, with more goals and points this might (please god) be the trigger and incentive for SP to spend a few bob and fill in the missing gaps necessary to make us top quartile team.

 

Hilaire Flag Send, Nr Guildford 13 Nov 23 11.55am

Originally posted by OAPeagle

I agree all the comments re Ward and Mitchell. For me it did seem like someone had put superglue on the soles of a number of players boots, but the main problem is of course finishing up front. On paper, when we bought him, Edouard looked a good bet and tbf he is a good finisher (OK, only when he's had plenty of advance warning and space). Unlike soccer computer games, players aren't programmed robots. Moves to other teams can transform or ruin reputations. In reality the most successful strikers must have a sixth sense, to start running on to a through ball - or to anticipate a cross - before the playmaker has indicated their intention - and the playmaker themselves know before they play the pass where the striker will be. This only comes with practice and an innate understanding and respect between key players. The body language says everything. My hope is that Franca will be more in tune with Eze and Olise's mindset which means - for better or worse - give him much more game time (ie s*** or bust as my old coach used to say). If it works we could be in for one of the most exciting attacking lines since Wrighty and Brighty. Then, with more goals and points this might (please god) be the trigger and incentive for SP to spend a few bob and fill in the missing gaps necessary to make us top quartile team.

We will spend next to nothing until the new stand is completed - the quicker everyone realises that the better we can move on and make do with what we have. Until then, keep your fingers crossed!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 Nov 23 12.08pm

Originally posted by OAPeagle

I agree all the comments re Ward and Mitchell. For me it did seem like someone had put superglue on the soles of a number of players boots, but the main problem is of course finishing up front. On paper, when we bought him, Edouard looked a good bet and tbf he is a good finisher (OK, only when he's had plenty of advance warning and space). Unlike soccer computer games, players aren't programmed robots. Moves to other teams can transform or ruin reputations. In reality the most successful strikers must have a sixth sense, to start running on to a through ball - or to anticipate a cross - before the playmaker has indicated their intention - and the playmaker themselves know before they play the pass where the striker will be. This only comes with practice and an innate understanding and respect between key players. The body language says everything. My hope is that Franca will be more in tune with Eze and Olise's mindset which means - for better or worse - give him much more game time (ie s*** or bust as my old coach used to say). If it works we could be in for one of the most exciting attacking lines since Wrighty and Brighty. Then, with more goals and points this might (please god) be the trigger and incentive for SP to spend a few bob and fill in the missing gaps necessary to make us top quartile team.

You may have some points, yet, you and everyone else knows we won't be seeing much of Franca. Schlupp all season more like. France might get 90 or so minutes over the course of the entire season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Hilaire Flag Send, Nr Guildford 13 Nov 23 12.23pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

You may have some points, yet, you and everyone else knows we won't be seeing much of Franca. Schlupp all season more like. France might get 90 or so minutes over the course of the entire season.

Yup, after Franca put that corner into orbit against Spurs, he was dead to Roy for the rest of the season! The manager is a stop gap and a convenient body to fill the role for the owners whilst they muddle on with the rebuilding of the main stand. My money is on Roy being here again next season - no one else will do the role with zero investment.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Nov 23 12.27pm

Originally posted by Hilaire

We will spend next to nothing until the new stand is completed - the quicker everyone realises that the better we can move on and make do with what we have. Until then, keep your fingers crossed!

Most likely, and we'll be Championship fodder by that time. Parish will wonder why, when he had the opportunity, he didn't invest in the right type of player at the right time.

 

OAPeagle Flag 13 Nov 23 12.28pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

You may have some points, yet, you and everyone else knows we won't be seeing much of Franca. Schlupp all season more like. France might get 90 or so minutes over the course of the entire season.

Probably right unfortunately. I blame Mrs Hodgson, I understand she had an aversion to a Brazilian.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 Nov 23 12.29pm

Originally posted by OAPeagle

Probably right unfortunately. I blame Mrs Hodgson, I understand she had an aversion to a Brazilian.

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace chick Flag South Croydon 13 Nov 23 1.04pm

Originally posted by Hilaire

Yup, after Franca put that corner into orbit against Spurs, he was dead to Roy for the rest of the season! The manager is a stop gap and a convenient body to fill the role for the owners whilst they muddle on with the rebuilding of the main stand. My money is on Roy being here again next season - no one else will do the role with zero investment.

Wonder what he will do with Olise then after putting that last free kick into orbit? :-) Franca will play if and when he is good enough. Hodgson obviously feels he isn’t ready yet. I expect he is correct?

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Nov 23 1.55pm

Originally posted by sprites

Funny how people see things differently. For me, Hughes has shown over the last few weeks how good he is. Breaks things up keeps things tidy. He wasn't at his destructive best yesterday, but thought he did well. Schlupp for me is a left sided attacking player - if he's anything at all. But yes probably bench utility is his best role.

I actually thought we were decent yesterday. Some of the build up play was exquisite. Just one of those things were bad finishing and a few defensive lapses cost us.

I want Dwight Gayle back. As an aside. He'd be banging in some of those chances Eduoard is fluffing.

Franca looks similar to Dwight Gayle in the few minutes I have seen.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Nov 23 1.57pm

Dont agree with the Eze yellow card. There was definite foot contact. At the speed he was going and twisting he was bound to drop. Where was VAR. What were they looking at???
VAR everywhere is proving it is terrible for the flow of the game and no better than leaving it to the ref and linesman.

Edited by dreamwaverider (13 Nov 2023 2.01pm)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Nov 23 1.58pm

We really need to bring in two wing backs in January. It is really bad now. Left and right.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Nov 23 2.00pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Is that a good thing or a bad thing? I note with interest the stats of Nketiah, who a few here wanted - nothing better than Edouard, and he plays for a better team.
Don't get me wrong, Edouard isn't particularly brilliant, but he is scoring and is responsible for around half our goal tally. What does that say about how we line up and play the game?

It says keep him in the line up until we find someone better. But I very much doubt we can afford anyone better. In the meantime get him to practise ball control. He keeps tripping over it.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Nov 23 2.16pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

It says keep him in the line up until we find someone better. But I very much doubt we can afford anyone better. In the meantime get him to practise ball control. He keeps tripping over it.


Worth noting that the transfer fees alone between him and Mateta come to upward of the £30m mark. Someone in recruitment is doing a piss poor job.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 13 Nov 23 3.07pm

Losing to Everton at home was no doubt a bad result.

We do seem to struggle against the latest Fulham team

Forest result was the best we could hope for given the players we had out.

It does go to show that without Eze and Olise we are relegation fodder, as the have no creativity without them. Although we have been unfortunate with both having injuries at same time, we should count ourselves fortunate that they are still at club.

Again, it all points back to recruitment.

No creative replacement for Zaha (you simply can't include Franca yet).
No decent or even half decent striker brought in

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 13 Nov 23 3.23pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Losing to Everton at home was no doubt a bad result.

We do seem to struggle against the latest Fulham team

Forest result was the best we could hope for given the players we had out.

It does go to show that without Eze and Olise we are relegation fodder, as the have no creativity without them. Although we have been unfortunate with both having injuries at same time, we should count ourselves fortunate that they are still at club.

Again, it all points back to recruitment.

No creative replacement for Zaha (you simply can't include Franca yet).
No decent or even half decent striker brought in

Yep. £30m transfer fees between Edouard and Mateta alone, another £40m on a sicknote keeper and a Brazilian teenager who may or may not come good in the future. Chuck in Ahamada for another £10m and that's £80m of poorly judged scouting and investment. Meanwhile, areas that are crying out for back up are ignored.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 13 Nov 23 4.13pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yep. £30m transfer fees between Edouard and Mateta alone, another £40m on a sicknote keeper and a Brazilian teenager who may or may not come good in the future. Chuck in Ahamada for another £10m and that's £80m of poorly judged scouting and investment. Meanwhile, areas that are crying out for back up are ignored.

100pc. However well the club is being run I can’t argue with that. Most of this is recent spend.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Nov 23 1.40pm

Originally posted by Paaalaaace

And what was the issue with HF today....didn't get what was with the banner complaining about Croydon Council.....did the Council confiscate their drum 1st half?

This might clear that up . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Nov 23 1.44pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

This might clear that up . . . [Link]

A banner against the banning of banners. I like that

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread