You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thin squad going to get thinner
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thin squad going to get thinner


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Dec 23 8.03am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

There is naivety amongst football fans in general about the level(s) involved in the game. Currently the vast majority of players in the premier league are proven international performers so we are looking at the best players in the world playing in the Premier League. It is great having a well resourced academy, that will help improvethe players that come through it, but there is no guarantee it is going to be a steady conveyor belt of premier league ready players. It will need world wide recruiting of the best young players coupled with the best coaches. Some of the players will still need to gain experience by going out on loan. Chelsea attempted something like this but then had problems blooding these players in their first team and people like Guehi end up at Palace.
At least we do produce a top player but this seems to be about once in a 3-4 year period.
People may forget that the acadamy did help produce Jake O'Brien who whilst not featuring in the first team was still sold in the summer to Lyon for 1 million pounds. This will at least help justify the role of the acadamy has in producing players that can make a living from the game and make money for the club.

Well, we could have kept him and saved £4m on Holding.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Dec 23 9.42am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Well, we could have kept him and saved £4m on Holding.


The O'Brien move has 'Textor' written all over it - possibly a sop to get him off Parish's back

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Dec 23 9.59am

Originally posted by doombear


The O'Brien move has 'Textor' written all over it - possibly a sop to get him off Parish's back

I know that the story is that O'Brien wanted a move but was that because the club didn't push to keep him?

 


One more point

Putitout Flag Oxford 14 Dec 23 10.17am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

There is naivety amongst football fans in general about the level(s) involved in the game. Currently the vast majority of players in the premier league are proven international performers so we are looking at the best players in the world playing in the Premier League. It is great having a well resourced academy, that will help improve the players that come through it, but there is no guarantee it is going to be a steady conveyor belt of premier league ready players. It will need world wide recruiting of the best young players coupled with the best coaches. Some of the players will still need to gain experience by going out on loan. Chelsea attempted something like this but then had problems blooding these players in their first team and people like Guehi end up at Palace.
At least we do produce a top player but this seems to be about once in a 3-4 year period.
People may forget that the acadamy did help produce Jake O'Brien who whilst not featuring in the first team was still sold in the summer to Lyon for 1 million pounds. This will at least help justify the role of the acadamy has in producing players that can make a living from the game and make money for the club.

There is a lot of truths there. On the issue of O’Brian, he was and still is a real improver, he could come through, and it could have been here. Then again maybe he didn’t want to stay , if other options appeared to move him on quicker..
My issue is what we ended up getting for him, because if you put that fee against what we are known to have paid to bring some lads , into our academy, it’s a bit of a joke in my MHO, the two from Derby, cost £1 million each , O’Brian 1 million Euros , a number of others came here for six figure fees.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Dec 23 2.00pm

Originally posted by Putitout

There is a lot of truths there. On the issue of O’Brian, he was and still is a real improver, he could come through, and it could have been here. Then again maybe he didn’t want to stay , if other options appeared to move him on quicker..
My issue is what we ended up getting for him, because if you put that fee against what we are known to have paid to bring some lads , into our academy, it’s a bit of a joke in my MHO, the two from Derby, cost £1 million each , O’Brian 1 million Euros , a number of others came here for six figure fees.

Absolutely agree with this. I think O’Briens value was probably 2 or 3 times what we actually got. If it transpires that Franca is a dud and O’Brien becomes a regular top league player then we can perhaps assume Textor is more of a liability than an asset.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 15 Dec 23 2.10pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Absolutely agree with this. I think O’Briens value was probably 2 or 3 times what we actually got. If it transpires that Franca is a dud and O’Brien becomes a regular top league player then we can perhaps assume Textor is more of a liability than an asset.

I read that Lyon were going to sell him in January, mainly to help balance the books.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Dec 23 3.52pm

A copy and paste from BBC, make of it what you will:

Crystal Palace manager Roy Hodgson on the January transfer window: "All clubs have a very strong department in terms of recruitment and scouting, and so it seems to me that's an ongoing process.

“Sometimes gets accelerated at a time if a club finds itself in a position where there are a lot of players that perhaps have got to be replaced for one way or another and for one reason or another and as a result, the jeopardy becomes us a bit stronger because you suddenly start to realise that our squad has been seriously depleted and in order to get back up the strength we have to do something about it.

“I would think perhaps we are in that position a bit more than some other clubs. But in terms of the work that goes on behind the scenes, which is orchestrated by Doug Freedman and lots of people are scouting and by Steve Parish himself, that's definitely an ongoing process.

“I know that the people in that position would like in January to provide some sort of reinforcements because they've seen how the squad has been depleted.

“We have, I think four players from the academy on the bench tomorrow. Now that's fine – it's good for four players on the academy on the bench – but if we're going to get through a long part of the season, it might be too early to throw those players in and say: ‘You've got to get the team up the table and start winning games.’

“That might be a big ask for them and an unfair ask.”

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

silvertop Flag Portishead 15 Dec 23 6.26pm

I am not sure if any of you heard the report on the Today Program the other day on the lack of correlation between money in and success out.

The order in the division tends to reflect wages paid, but not the expense of recruitment e.g. Brentford/Brighton v Manure/Chelsea.

The former are very selective, employ "Moneyballs" tactics on recruitment but prefer to work with settled sides. That produces better results. Note Hodgson understands this and does not seek to chop and change a team.

Man City employed two astrophysicists to do their Moneyballs work and it reaps huge rewards, They spend an absolute bomb on players, but don't buy many. They also get a settled team albeit one that costs the GDP of a middling country.

We seem to be trying a different approach. Buy few and keep the team stable; but seek to create a conveyer belt of players who will have enjoyed success against their premier league B-team counterparts and who will eventually enjoy recognition at international level meaning we don't just have superb academy players who play the other best academy players, but who also play for England U21 etc.

Well, at least that appears the plan. The new coach will need to be on board with this which is why our Welsh friend at Forest may be a rumour with legs given his success with the England academy. Until then, the academy is growing but not yet there. Hodgson provides the safe hands until we are ready, but he will not field academy players to blood them as they are not ready; and staying up is the objective until they are.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thin squad going to get thinner