You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Going forward
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Going forward


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Jan 24 1.27pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Ridiculous comments yourself. So how come we have been able to attract Johnstone, Guehi, Anderson, Olise, Eze and Doucoure to the club in the first place? The very model that you describe as basic has been followed by Brighton for the last few years, identifying under the radar players, attracting them to the club, bringing them on and turning big profits on them.

It ain’t rocket science ffs but you obviously think it is.

I haven’t even mentioned the onward sale of players which is of course a vital part of keeping finances on an even keel and I have advocated previously that selling one star player per year and replacing with a couple of decent improving youngsters is vital for a club our size. The very thing that you see as impossible to achieve has been successfully achieved by many clubs over the years.

I find your intransigence to the simple idea of buying low and selling for more baffling myself. It is how all forms of investment work and you are either good at it or you are not. I would say we are pretty average and we certainly need to improve on the sales side of things.

For sure.

I think our problem is that having signed some excellent young players such as Guehi, Andersen, Olise and Eze, in an ideal world we would build a team around them. That could be from Academy players developed through to first team, some existing squad players and some prudent, experienced signings.

But we haven't done that. If you accept that financially that hasn't been possible then a solution is to raise funds by selling.And we haven't done that either.

With the inevitable Brighton comparisons, let's start at the top, Bloom v. Our Board.

Bloom with huge personal wealth. His data driven formula has been a big success. Prior to that they were buying relatively expensive flops from the Dutch league. Bloom has surrounded himself with experts - CEO Paul Barber recruited from Spurs. Dan Ashworth now at Newcastle as examples. They have provided the expertise upon which Bloom has been able to translate into the winning formula that we are currently seeing.

At Palace, Parish is the CEO. That's where he has positioned himself. Best man for the job ? Well you can't argue with his record but how much challenge and fresh insight / different perspective does he get in that position ? While Bloom recruited experts Parish recruited former players. Best men for the job ? I honestly don't know. With Harris and Blitzer seemingly passive, only Textor has challenged Parish and look how that's playing out. ( that's not to say I support Textor btw ).

So I guess my conclusion is that I think a fresh perspective is needed at the top. I'm not saying I want Parish gone, I am saying that he needs some expert help. I don't think he's getting that sat next to Mark Bright.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

CpfcWeTrust1 Flag 21 Jan 24 1.28pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Jeez, you’re arguing with yourself here. All those points you are making about those players totally proves my point that we have identified players at low value and they are now high value. They are not the only players in the world that are undervalued and it is Dougies job to continue to identify them.

You are arguing points that I didn’t even make. I’ve always advocated selling to buy, but not selling to line shareholders pockets.

Your last comment is a typical straw man argument that gets peddled on here far too often and which I’ll choose to treat with the contempt it deserves.

Stick to football manager, that's about as far as your linear thinking goes.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 24 1.57pm

Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1

Stick to football manager, that's about as far as your linear thinking goes.

What’s that? I used to play subbuteo, is it the same?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 24 2.12pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

True.

One of our main problems is that we have hardly ever raised finance through the sale of players, money to re-invest in the playing side. Parish has offered many a past it duffer another year's contract to save the effort and fees of actually getting out there and scout some fresh blood. These players munch up funds through exorbitant salaries, have no resale value, and offer very little on the pitch. I think it's to do with making us look as though we have a full squad of 25.
His modus operandi I always found a bit suspect and now we're paying the price. Perhaps he had this fantasy that many of the U21s would make the breakthrough all at the same time and save his sorry arse...

I agree, I think this is because we have always survived right on the edge with a lot of our squads made up of players that were at the end of their careers or only borderline capable of playing at this level hence no real future value.

We have finally managed to get a spine of players bought at x total value and now worth a much higher total value. I am all for getting maximum fees for our players and using that to reinvest in the squad. For instance the sale of Olise and Edouard or Mateta would almost certainly fund a completely new front 3 which a manager can work with. I also think we could afford to lose Guehi and use that money to bring in say Edwards, Munoz and a second left back and still have money in the bank.

Will our current board allow this or just want to sell players and pocket the money? I guess we’ll find out.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Going forward