This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
So Bradley has a great season in League One and makes his way into the Liverpool starting XI when the first choice RB is injured, but Rak-Sakyi who also had a great season in League One hasn't made his way into a much inferior starting XI, even when the first choice for his position is injured. I find it really hard to accept the difference is in the quality of the player - the difference is in how willing the manager is to give them a chance. Couldn't agree more. I guess my stance on its a a bit more business like. e.g. I want the kids to be given a chance, of course I do. But if they are not going to be, which its clear they aren't, get them out playing games so they come back in Jan/summer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
There's always so much chat about not playing the kids. Fans, the board and presumably the manager all want the academy graduates to progress to first team regulars, but the simple fact is they're not currently ready. We have the worlds most experienced manager at the club who watches them train daily, what makes any fan think they have more knowledge on this subject than Roy Hodgson? If they're good enough, they'll play. Why wouldn't they? From what we've seen, Ozoh looks like he'll develop into a first team player, but you wouldn't throw him into the starting 11 ahead of experienced pro's like Hughes or Schlupp given our precarious league position. Franca had a decent cameo against City but has otherwise looked lightweight and out of his depth and Rak-Saki has looked much the same. Anyone who went to the U21's final Vs PSV Eindhoven at the end of last season would have seen that none of the players were anywhere near Premier League level. As others have said, academy players showing potential should be shipped out on loan to experience the intensity and pressure of first team professional football. In reality, as a minimum, they need to be performing consistently well in the Championship for at least 6 months before they should be considered first team squad players at Palace. If we are comfortably away from relegation with 5 games to go, that's the time to give the likes of Ozoh, Franca and perhaps Rak-Saki more game time. Honestly I just find this take lazy - by extension, none of us can have a view on any tactics, team selections, substitutions, transfers or anything football related, because Roy knows best on all of them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Couldn't agree more. I guess my stance on its a a bit more business like. e.g. I want the kids to be given a chance, of course I do. But if they are not going to be, which its clear they aren't, get them out playing games so they come back in Jan/summer. Yeah, definitely agree re the lack of planning - we have a really poor structure for developing promising academy players into professional players. I just disagreed with the bit about a lack of U21 players knocking on the door - I think we have 2 or 3 there who another manager would've at least given an opportunity to by now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Boro, won away, lost at home. Dont forget they have also progressed in the 'International Cup' by beating Benfica, drawing with Feyenoord, beating Monaco & drawing with Athletic Bilbao. Bearing in mind the U21's also have players out on loan & by all accounts a couple more will be also going out on loan in the next week. Completely appreciate all of that. I'm not trying to say that they are toilet. More that we don't have 11 superstars waiting in the wings. And chat about the academy players quality often gets blown out of all proportion. Even looking back to players released in the summer, Boateng, Quick, Hannam, Omilabu etc. All of which were at one point or another 'recommended' for first team action by some fans, are all playing at a much lower level.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Yeah, definitely agree re the lack of planning - we have a really poor structure for developing promising academy players into professional players. I just disagreed with the bit about a lack of U21 players knocking on the door - I think we have 2 or 3 there who another manager would've at least given an opportunity to by now. Yep hard to disagree on Ozoh and JRS. Especially the latter given how much of hte season Olise has missed. Connected, under Vieria we employed Saïd Aïgoun. Who had a particular focus on individual development and ensuring the transition from the Academy to senior setup. Do we have anyone else doing that now?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pete53
If you have never watched any U21 games I would suggest taking out a subscription to Palace TV+ (only £29 for a season). There you can watch most U21 games (and under 18s) live and see for yourself which players may have 1st XI potential/prospects, or otherwise. On many occasions when supporters have said "give the kids a chance" I have responded by asking which ones they think should get a chance. A response is usually not forthcoming as they have never watched any academy football and probably couldn't name a single player. At least if you watch the U21 matches you will be in a better position to argue the case for certain players. The genuine main thing in youngsters is physicality. It's why I believe Ozoh is capable for a ball winning midfielder. It's also why I believe Ademorala is good enough - he has pace and a bit of skill. As for the others, there's a couple of nearlys - probably Imray currently. A lot of energy and stamina with some speed and skill. In a similar vein, I've always thought Ahamada and Rak-Sakyi need to add physicality. A year in the Championship would be helpful for that. At a push, League one.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Pete53
If you have never watched any U21 games I would suggest taking out a subscription to Palace TV+ (only £29 for a season). There you can watch most U21 games (and under 18s) live and see for yourself which players may have 1st XI potential/prospects, or otherwise. On many occasions when supporters have said "give the kids a chance" I have responded by asking which ones they think should get a chance. A response is usually not forthcoming as they have never watched any academy football and probably couldn't name a single player. At least if you watch the U21 matches you will be in a better position to argue the case for certain players.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2
Q? You say that you cannot see any of our youngsters getting to out 1st team, are our 1st teamers that good?
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.