Replay due to VAR

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Replay due to VAR

Visit the current forum | Forum Rules

Teddy Eagle 26 Jan 24 9.10pm
Genk have got a replay against Anderlecht due to an error by VAR. This seems a dangerous precedent. [Link]

Teddy Eagle

26 Jan 24 9.10pm

Genk have got a replay against Anderlecht due to an error by VAR. This seems a dangerous precedent.

[Link]

HeathMan Purley 27 Jan 24 12.43pm
The thought of our having to replay any wins we might enjoy is a worry.

HeathMan

Purley 27 Jan 24 12.43pm

The thought of our having to replay any wins we might enjoy is a worry.

Teddy Eagle 27 Jan 24 1.51pm
Originally posted by HeathMan The thought of our having to replay any wins we might enjoy is a worry. That was my thought too. Just our luck to sneak past Man City then get slaughtered in the replay when Pep has done his pieces at some decision.

Teddy Eagle

27 Jan 24 1.51pm

Originally posted by HeathMan

The thought of our having to replay any wins we might enjoy is a worry.

That was my thought too. Just our luck to sneak past Man City then get slaughtered in the replay when Pep has done his pieces at some decision.

Elpis In a pub 27 Jan 24 2.33pm
I thought one of the many new laws brought in in recent times states only players directly involved in play get done for encroachment Which would make the VAR correct .

Elpis

In a pub 27 Jan 24 2.33pm

I thought one of the many new laws brought in in recent times states only players directly involved in play get done for encroachment
Which would make the VAR correct .

eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 27 Jan 24 2.55pm
Originally posted by Elpis I thought one of the many new laws brought in in recent times states only players directly involved in play get done for encroachment Which would make the VAR correct . With the exception of one goalkeeper, ALL players are 'in play' when its a penalty. This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

eagleman13

On The Road To Hell & Alicante 27 Jan 24 2.55pm

Originally posted by Elpis

I thought one of the many new laws brought in in recent times states only players directly involved in play get done for encroachment
Which would make the VAR correct .

With the exception of one goalkeeper, ALL players are 'in play' when its a penalty.

This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Elpis In a pub 27 Jan 24 3.22pm
Originally posted by eagleman13 With the exception of one goalkeeper, ALL players are 'in play' when its a penalty. Indeed thats the law BUT VAR guideline says it should only get involved if the encroachment directly affects if a goal is scored or prevented .

Elpis

In a pub 27 Jan 24 3.22pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

With the exception of one goalkeeper, ALL players are 'in play' when its a penalty.

Indeed thats the law BUT VAR guideline says it should only get involved if the encroachment directly affects if a goal is scored or prevented .

Pete53 Hassocks 18 Feb 24 1.00pm
In the game against Chelsea the other night there was a lengthy delay at the start of the 2nd half owing to the referee's comms system having a glitch. This got me to wondering what would happen if during a game the VAR comms system went down? Would the game be held up or would it continue withe the ref and assistants being endowed with the decision making powers of old?

Pete53

Hassocks 18 Feb 24 1.00pm

In the game against Chelsea the other night there was a lengthy delay at the start of the 2nd half owing to the referee's comms system having a glitch.

This got me to wondering what would happen if during a game the VAR comms system went down? Would the game be held up or would it continue withe the ref and assistants being endowed with the decision making powers of old?

Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Feb 24 1.11pm
Originally posted by Pete53 In the game against Chelsea the other night there was a lengthy delay at the start of the 2nd half owing to the referee's comms system having a glitch. This got me to wondering what would happen if during a game the VAR comms system went down? Would the game be held up or would it continue withe the ref and assistants being endowed with the decision making powers of old? Mu understanding is that the game would continue if there was a VAR technological failure.

Willo

South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Feb 24 1.11pm

Originally posted by Pete53

In the game against Chelsea the other night there was a lengthy delay at the start of the 2nd half owing to the referee's comms system having a glitch.

This got me to wondering what would happen if during a game the VAR comms system went down? Would the game be held up or would it continue withe the ref and assistants being endowed with the decision making powers of old?

Mu understanding is that the game would continue if there was a VAR technological failure.

Pete53 Hassocks 18 Feb 24 10.41pm
Originally posted by Willo Mu understanding is that the game would continue if there was a VAR technological failure. I would certainly hope so. Unless we were 0-3 down.

Pete53

Hassocks 18 Feb 24 10.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

Mu understanding is that the game would continue if there was a VAR technological failure.

I would certainly hope so. Unless we were 0-3 down.

Phil’s Barber Crowborough 19 Feb 24 1.36pm
Frightening precedent. Get rid of VAR, it is ruining the game and atmosphere and the officials are becoming a joke. Keep goal line technology and thats it.

Phil’s Barber

Crowborough 19 Feb 24 1.36pm

Frightening precedent.

Get rid of VAR, it is ruining the game and atmosphere and the officials are becoming a joke.

Keep goal line technology and thats it.

beak croydon 19 Feb 24 2.03pm
Originally posted by HeathMan The thought of our having to replay any wins we might enjoy is a worry. Do not worry we have had so few wins it is close to impossible, more likely is that we may replay some of our many loses,the odds favour us.

beak

croydon 19 Feb 24 2.03pm

Originally posted by HeathMan

The thought of our having to replay any wins we might enjoy is a worry.

Do not worry we have had so few wins it is close to impossible, more likely is that we may replay some of our many loses,the odds favour us.

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Replay due to VAR

Site Map