This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
He was OK in midfield for a game or two but the cup game at home to Everton exposed how little he can give offensively, as a centre back he looks OK but every time he makes a mistake it seems to lead to a goal far too often, and as a right back the other night he answered the question why he was not put there earlier. Don't like to be negative but I think this is the one buy Vieira got wrong, his recruitment was excellent otherwise - he's had plenty of chances but I now regretfully have to conclude that he is poor, I prefer Riedewald. Perhaps I'll come across as a bit too prejudiced here but for all his athleticism, technical ability and commitment, I am beginning to see him as an American who perhaps doesn't understand football to the extent other players from around the globe instinctively will. He still looks a bit lost and unsure sometimes. This can be perilous in the PL.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
He was OK in midfield for a game or two but the cup game at home to Everton exposed how little he can give offensively, as a centre back he looks OK but every time he makes a mistake it seems to lead to a goal far too often, and as a right back the other night he answered the question why he was not put there earlier. Don't like to be negative but I think this is the one buy Vieira got wrong, his recruitment was excellent otherwise - he's had plenty of chances but I now regretfully have to conclude that he is poor, I prefer Riedewald.
Edited by doombear (02 Feb 2024 2.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
IMO the criticism is a little unfair. He's a CB first and foremost. Not as gifted on the ground as Marc, but bigger and better in the air. If we got a bid in for Anderson I'd have no issue in him stepping in to partner Marc. Midfield and RB he is not. He's doing a job, and its not really his faut that he's trusted more to play out of position than e.g. Hughes. The different positions require such different skills and positioning. (hopefully people can stop asking for Anderson to be given a go in centre mid too) I would agree, and I reckon he's a decent enough centre back too. He's our third best but could improve with a bit more experience.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
IMO the criticism is a little unfair. He's a CB first and foremost. Not as gifted on the ground as Marc, but bigger and better in the air. If we got a bid in for Anderson I'd have no issue in him stepping in to partner Marc. Midfield and RB he is not. He's doing a job, and its not really his faut that he's trusted more to play out of position than e.g. Hughes. The different positions require such different skills and positioning. (hopefully people can stop asking for Anderson to be given a go in centre mid too) All very true.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by CT Charlie
Clearly as an American supporter I'm unable to understand the game as instinctively as others on this board. Nevertheless, to counter the criticism of a player who by his own admission and general agreement is a center back by profession, I raise this question: How do we think Guehi or Andersen would look if asked to play RB or DM? I'll throw my apparently undersized hat in with the majority of you who acknowledge his ability and contributions. He was, after all, named Player of the Month last January in his first extended run. The next Virgil van Dijk? No, but he has served the club well.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CT Charlie
Clearly as an American supporter I'm unable to understand the game as instinctively as others on this board. Nevertheless, to counter the criticism of a player who by his own admission and general agreement is a center back by profession, I raise this question: How do we think Guehi or Andersen would look if asked to play RB or DM? I'll throw my apparently undersized hat in with the majority of you who acknowledge his ability and contributions. He was, after all, named Player of the Month last January in his first extended run. The next Virgil van Dijk? No, but he has served the club well. I’m not sure if you mean that seriously Charlie but if so, and my post had any influence upon that statement, I’d just like to clarify that I was only and deliberately exposing my own prejudiced thinking there. I make you right, and MrRobbo stated so quite competently, he does both play sporadically but also typically out of position. I like Chris, i don’t doubt him with any sincerity. I’d put Hodgson in the blame for the aforementioned as I’m often under the impression he picks players/personalities in favour of more strategic thinking. If Richards constantly played CM, Schlupp played on the wing and so on, we’d think they were terrible players. I thought it might also sincerely affect Ozoh vs Sheffield United as he seemed to come on under completely spontaneous instruction outside of his comfort zone.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
He was OK in midfield for a game or two but the cup game at home to Everton exposed how little he can give offensively, as a centre back he looks OK but every time he makes a mistake it seems to lead to a goal far too often, and as a right back the other night he answered the question why he was not put there earlier. Don't like to be negative but I think this is the one buy Vieira got wrong, his recruitment was excellent otherwise - he's had plenty of chances but I now regretfully have to conclude that he is poor, I prefer Riedewald. Anyone but Riedewald. You have answered the question, why Roy picks the same players, as the others in the squad arent really good enough to start.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
You have to laugh sometimes with the stuff on here. Eddie Howe converts Joelinton from a misfiring striker to dynamic midfield player and he's a tactical genius. In actual fact, the midfield berth for Joelinton was found by accident when Newcastle went down to 10 men against Norwich after 9 mins and they had to shuffle their team around.Jolinton performed well and the rest as they say is history. Edited by Willo (03 Feb 2024 10.37am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In actual fact, the midfield berth for Jolinton was found by accident when Newcastle went down to 10 men against Norwich after 9 mins and they had to shuffle their team around.Jolinton performed well and the rest as they say is history. He was s*** up front which was perhaps a clue that he wasn't a striker.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
You have to laugh sometimes with the stuff on here. Eddie Howe converts Joelinton from a misfiring striker to dynamic midfield player and he's a tactical genius. Hodgson experiments with Richards as a DM and it's a square peg in a round hole. Richards doesn't seem to have quite the skillset for midfield. A better option would have been Ward - but obviously he's injured. Arguably, a lot of central defenders can play as an anchor in defence but not really Richards as he doesn't have the passing range. At best he can break up attacks - which he did ok at.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
He was s*** up front which was perhaps a clue that he wasn't a striker. He played wide in a front three at Hoffenheim and had spent most of his career out wide rather than as an out-and-out No 9.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
He played wide in a front three at Hoffenheim and had spent most of his career out wide rather than as an out-and-out No 9. In case you aren't aware this thread is about Chris Richards and not Newcastle players
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.