You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Would relegation be such a bad idea?
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Would relegation be such a bad idea?


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 12 Feb 24 3.05pm

Yes

 

pssguy Flag 12 Feb 24 3.39pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Relegation would a terrible fate after 11 years in the top flight both in financial terms and for the future well being of the club. We could not guarantee allan immediate bounce back as the author has suggested because as other have already said we would lose our 7/8 quality players and will then be left with the unproven, sick notes and bunch of players who would struggle to make a championship squad. The rebuild of the team would take years and we may well further down the football pyramid like other have done before us when a team has been allowed to slowly decline because of disagreements amongst its investors. Palace rightly belong in the EPL. Any suggestion otherwise is senseless and this really is a silly thread!

As the OP, I did not guarantee promotion (who could) but you don't just lose players you sell them and can re-invest. The only players that are out of contract are the poorer ones like Ward and Schlupp. All the best players are on longer-term contracts unless they have release clauses: hence the income

Leicester 'lost' Maddison, Barnes, Tielemans and Castagne and their icon, Vardy, was cleatly in the twilight of a Premier league career (he scored 3 league goals last season).

Their highest-profile signing for this season was probablyHarry Winks who cost them 10 million,

Don't bother looking at the foot of the Championship table to see how they must be struggling. They are 11 points clear at the top

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 12 Feb 24 7.05pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

There is no comparison between Roy's England or Liverpool and the current teams. Anyone who knows anything about football knows that much.

Meanwhile, you can whinge about Hodgson all you like but anyone wanting us to stay up will be supporting him and the team until he is replaced.

You are right - that Roy may have had more quality and depth at his disposal.

But the common denominator you are missing and completely overlooking is that he still didn’t make best use of those resources and under achieved - hence he got sacked..!!

Which is exactly the same position/scenario we are in now..!!

We all want us to stay up - but think you’ll find your support and confidence in Hodgson being a positive factor in us achieving that scenario is very much in the minority - see my straw poll thread for confirmation/validation..!!

COYP

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 12 Feb 24 11.42pm

Originally posted by Painter

That is your problem, you dont know, when the club is run properly. Lets look at the previous owners.
Bloye sold off land to Sainsburys, then went to QPR taking best players with him.
Noades made a fortune from Palace taking a £1m a year minimum to finance his other interests.
Goldberg no sense got eaten by sharks into administration.
Jordan, huge ego limited success, then administration.
Parish longest period at top level and sound financial shape, but you want him out!

"sound financial shape" ok babes, ok...

when Parish is out and we have a chairman who has some money to spend, which will happen in the future... we will look back and think "parish had ten+ years in the prem and did what exactly?"

anyways, you'll come back with something, you always do - but I ain't playing your games - I want parish out, that's my opinion - he's holding the club in limbo.. that's not enjoyable as a fan.

Cheers...

 


This was once a quality forum....

Den1923 Flag 13 Feb 24 11.31am

Originally posted by pssguy

As the OP, I did not guarantee promotion (who could) but you don't just lose players you sell them and can re-invest. The only players that are out of contract are the poorer ones like Ward and Schlupp. All the best players are on longer-term contracts unless they have release clauses: hence the income

Leicester 'lost' Maddison, Barnes, Tielemans and Castagne and their icon, Vardy, was cleatly in the twilight of a Premier league career (he scored 3 league goals last season).

Their highest-profile signing for this season was probablyHarry Winks who cost them 10 million,

Don't bother looking at the foot of the Championship table to see how they must be struggling. They are 11 points clear at the top

On the other hand look at Sunderland, we have been there before in the 80's. Saying relegation is not a bad idea is madness. All good players will have big wages and release clause in their contracts if a team gets relegated and anyway in the lower leagues you can't afford the wages of EPL. As for leicester they have been much better funded by their owners over the years than we ever have.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Feb 24 1.47pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

You are right - that Roy may have had more quality and depth at his disposal.

But the common denominator you are missing and completely overlooking is that he still didn’t make best use of those resources and under achieved - hence he got sacked..!!

Which is exactly the same position/scenario we are in now..!!

We all want us to stay up - but think you’ll find your support and confidence in Hodgson being a positive factor in us achieving that scenario is very much in the minority - see my straw poll thread for confirmation/validation..!!

COYP

How could you know that?

Can you be certain that another available manager would do better with our depleted squad?
If Steve Parish was sure, we would have a new guy already.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Feb 24 1.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

How could you know that?

Can you be certain that another available manager would do better with our depleted squad?
If Steve Parish was sure, we would have a new guy already.

Strong rumour is that Parish wants Cooper but doesn't want to pay severance to Nottingham Forest.

 


COYP

Aray Flag South London 13 Feb 24 3.46pm

Not a bad idea, an awful one.

We are not financially viable outside the PL. Unless we go straight up - we're stuffed. Could take a decade or two to return.

Bonkers

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Would relegation be such a bad idea?