This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by silvertop
You are not wrong in what the FA need to achieve, but a few points. Luton, Man City and Everton/Forest are/were charged under 3 separate sets of regulations with their own discrete rules so it is hardly surprising there is no consistency between their respective treatments. You are not comparing apples. Why Man City and Chelsea have not had their FFP issue determined by now is vexing and does not credit the FA. However, on Everton and Forest, which relates to accounting breaches rather than transfer irregularities, these are new rules where the FA is still finding its way. It needs to build up a set of precedents and fine tune its procedure so the clubs fully understand what they can and can't do, how to avoid it, and what the likely penalty and process will be if they flout the rules. This requires time and plenty of clubs trying to bend the rules. That is a very fair point. At the same time, there is a lot of rhetoric around "this being a unique situation" which is "without precedent". I call BS (no, not BFS. A Freudian slip, perhaps) on that. If you want to look through the narrow prism of the prevailing regulations in place at the time, then sure, this set of charges on Everton is unique. But the inference there has been no previous example of clubs engaging in fiscal mismanagement - specifically spending more on players and agents than they can responsibly afford - is disingenuous at best. I would also argue there is an intersect between accounting breaches and transfer irregularities: the accounting breaches would understate losses and enable certain transfers to be considered/undertaken which would not be possible with true and fair balance sheets and cash flow statements. Edited by RubinsCube (26 Feb 2024 7.37pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Excellent post. I think fans would be a lot happier if they understood how penalties are calculated and when they apply. I am not even certain that if found guilty Everton and Forest's punishment will apply this season? As for Man City, will they take away trophies? Edited by Badger11 (26 Feb 2024 5.47pm) Exactly right. According to the BBC (https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/68273436): "That case must be heard by 8 April, however, any appeal could take that process to 24 May, the week after the season has concluded." Does this mean that if it gets to early April and Everton win a few games in March they take a punt and decline to appeal? Conversely, if they have a poor March and are less than five points above the drop zone, do they appeal to delay the proceedings until after the end of the season? Essentially, it seems to give them the power to take a hit either this season or next season. An unrelated question but it also springs to mind: do clubs who delay points deductions this way - assuming they can - still get the same Premier League revenue each year? It would be worth delaying any and all hearings to preserve another season in the top flight. A total mess. Edited by RubinsCube (26 Feb 2024 7.38pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by stancummins
So the new cases have to be heard by 8th April that means anytime between now and then, i would imagine now the appeal decision has been announced it will be sooner rather than later Forest's hearing is next Thursday(BBC sport)
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
It’s all a fiasco, no clear rules and punishment, it’s made up as they go. The offences occurred last year, but Leicester went down, as no penalty given Everton then, is that fair? I'd argue not. There is too much of a 'make it up as you go along' feel to it alongside the seeming disparity in decisions and action taken against the obvious, big club perpetrators and the smaller, perhaps more easily punished ones. I'm probably right at the end of the queue for any persons to afford sympathy or provide a defence for fans of other PL clubs however the line 'feels like a punishment for fans' is apt in my book. There's enough in-season drama, heartache and despair without the looming and incoherent prospect of points deductions hanging. Takes away from the playing and competition of the sport/league, the whole purpose.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by RubinsCube
That is a very fair point. At the same time, there is a lot of rhetoric around "this being a unique situation" which is "without precedent". I call BS (no, not BFS. A Freudian slip, perhaps) on that. If you want to look through the narrow prism of the prevailing regulations in place at the time, then sure, this set of charges on Everton is unique. But the inference there has been no previous example of clubs engaging in fiscal mismanagement - specifically spending more on players and agents than they can responsibly afford - is disingenuous at best. I would also argue there is an intersect between accounting breaches and transfer irregularities: the accounting breaches would understate losses and enable certain transfers to be considered/undertaken which would not be possible with true and fair balance sheets and cash flow statements. Edited by RubinsCube (26 Feb 2024 7.37pm) That is fair but I do not know enough about the rules and the criteria applied to say whether you can import procedure, principles and sanctions from one set of rules to another to help out. What will really build a solid book of rules is years of clubs breaking them and developing a healthy body of precedents. That is, precisely what the rules are designed to deter. Until then, they are all finding their way in relative darkness.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
It’s all a fiasco, no clear rules and punishment, it’s made up as they go. The offences occurred last year, but Leicester went down, as no penalty given Everton then, is that fair?
None of that, of course, helps Leicester and the other clubs who suffered because Everton weren't punished earlier.
|
|
|
I wonder if Fa and Premier League can be charged with bring the game into disrepute.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sansbup
Been said before, but in my view the fairest penalty would be points deduction at the start of the season following judgement. Hopefully Citeh start with minus 40 points next season and we might just finish above them. Interesting point. If for example City have been cheating for 10 years shouldn't their punishment be spread over the same period? You could fine them 40 points next season and they would still finish mid table not much punishment for the trophies they did not deserve to win. Edited by Badger11 (27 Feb 2024 8.22pm)
One more point |
|
|
I dont see how that would be considered fair - this benefits the cheating side as they get another season in the same league & leaves those teams still relegated by actions that included cheating from teams within their league - The fairest way is for any penalty to be applied to the season which the offence took place & the new season doesn't start until the previous season has been completed including any judgements or appeals. Clearly for any judgement / appeals to be concluded before any new season starts the whole rules / process/ application situation would have to be a lot clearer & streamlined. Originally posted by Sansbup
Been said before, but in my view the fairest penalty would be points deduction at the start of the season following judgement. Hopefully Citeh start with minus 40 points next season and we might just finish above them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Profit & Sustainability could feasibly introduce / implement a kind of fixed price menu for penalties imposed - Expenditure £5-£10 million in excess of guidelines = penalty deduction 4 points Expenditure £10-£20 million in excess of guidelines = penalty deduction 6 points - Clearly it would need some streamlining but you get the picture - The other issue that I can see happening is club X buys player Y knowing it will put them over the profit & sustainability guidelines by £Z but they gamble that having this player in the team will bring them more success than the recognised imposed penalty- A fixed penalty system with strict liability principles (i.e. doesn't matter if it was intended or not) could work, but not based on fixed monetary sums. That favours the big clubs too much. Man City lose more than £5m a month down the back of their sofa. I am sure there are financial rules that can be imported from elsewhere that will avoid a 3 day hearing with forensic accountants called; but it needs to be a % of something. Turnover? BTW on timing, the nature of accounting means you are always publishing finalised data at least a year after the event. Thus, while it would be nice to try, convict and hang in the same season the offence was committed, while fair it is not realistic.
|
|
|
I would have thought that conventional accounting guidelines meaning the below mentioned delay could be supplemented by having a monthly running total submission of accounts to provide broad based numbers of the current situation, thereby providing a snapshot of the current picture & projected end of season outcome so that the likelihood of a profit & sustainability transgression can be seen / forecast & if any action needs to be taken that can be prepared for - In the event that the final audited accounts when submitted carry significant differences then they will need to be explained & if necessary penalised accordingly. In circumstances where it can be clearly seen that the differences between the running total submission & the year end accounts vary significantly because of clearly deceitful actions the penalty should be increased (perhaps doubled) Originally posted by silvertop
BTW on timing, the nature of accounting means you are always publishing finalised data at least a year after the event. Thus, while it would be nice to try, convict and hang in the same season the offence was committed, while fair it is not realistic.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.