You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Glasner vs. Hodgson
November 16 2026 2.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Glasner vs. Hodgson


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Apr 24 10.00am

Originally posted by samprior

Not winning any of our last 3 doesn't feel great however it's still 1pt extra than what we achieved under Roy.

Under Roy
Luton - erratic display, reliant on Olise's creativity.
Forest- at home, sat deep and on the back foot a lot and didn't create much.
Bournemouth - one of the worst performances of the season, nothing more to be said.

Under Glasner
Luton - dominated in most parts and should have won
Forest - fairly turgid away game, missed good chances to go 2 up.
Bournemouth - tight game for the majority, subs and squad depth the clear difference.

For me I'm very happy we've got Glasner and I can see ther seeds of change despite being further hampered by not having Guehi and Olise. There's clearly more structure to our play rather than just sit back and pray. It's obviously not there yet and I imagine the next two games are gonna be pretty painful but after that we'll collect enough points for sure. Then we can wave goodbye to this awful, injury ravaged season and onto a very busy pre-season!

Roy's future was untenable for me the second he put Olise on against Brighton, there's no argument that can be made that would change my mind. A change was absolutely needed.

This, generally (especially Olise vs Brighton) plus props to the OP.

We are certainly moving in the right direction. And it feels like we are unlucky not to win games, vs not not having a clue.

Historically Roy's team have always been rubbish going forward, but very difficult to score against. Once he lost the ability to keep teams out we were in trouble.

Even in post game interviews for me there is a clear difference in Glasner and Roy. Roy talks more generally about play and possession. Glasner looks at specific moments, e.g. highlighting Mitchells cross across the 6 yard box late on - asking why more of our players weren't in the box.

I know it sounds minor, but for me he is looking to help find relatively simple answers (to our lack of creativity). And clear he will be imploring players to have the bravery and confidence to get themselves in the right position.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Apr 24 10.21am

Originally posted by fish mitten

For me based on this season the whole Glasner or Roy argument is pointless. I have pity for both.

Roy should have left last summer, the fact he was kept on showed the Board's intent to 'try and make do'. Glasner is hampered by that this season as well, though of course we did add two additions in January.

For me the important fact is that having got a new manager in, should we stay up will the Board do what is required and rebuild a capable squad or will they make the same mistakes again.

If we don't go down this year, we will be favourites next season. Can't afford to kick the can down the road again.

I suspect Leicester fans were saying the same thing in 2014...

Seriously, Roy did enough last season to demonstrate he was capable of holding the fort for another season. This was for economic reasons, sure, but also to buy time to acquire a new coaching head and agree terms at everyone's pace. Who knew we would be ravaged by so many key long term injuries and that Roy's health would simultaneously collapse?

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 05 Apr 24 10.32am

Roy and Ollie experience(d) the same problem. Meagre resources and a squad ravaged by injuries. Ollie had the benefit of two decent purchases in the January window but has since lost others to injury. Olise should never have been on the bench for Roy to call on if he had not fully recovered from injury so I do wonder how good our background and medical staff are? Franca and Rak Sakyi may have potential but sadly, the rest of our youngsters appear out of their depth in this League and are just there to make up the numbers. Irrespective of whether we survive this season, and who our manager is, a major reorganisation of the squad was always going to be necessary this summer.

Edited by Henry of Peckham (05 Apr 2024 11.18am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

PJEagle Flag London 05 Apr 24 1.55pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Slightly surprised to immediately start seeing some references to 'if Roy was still in charge' across various threads. Given that I have nothing to do at work today, I thought I'd compare Roy's final five games to Glasner's first five games.

Hodgson final five fixtures:

Everton (Away - FA Cup) - Lost 1-0
Arsenal (Away) - Lost 5-0
Sheff Utd (Home) - Won 3-2
Brighton (Away) - Lost 4-1
Chelsea (Home) - Lost 3-1

Glasner first five fixtures:

Burnley (Home) - Won 3-0
Spurs (Away) - Lost 3-1
Luton (Home) - Drew 1-1
Forest (Away) - Drew 1-1
Bournemouth (Away) - Lost 1-0

Goals Scored Per Game

Hodgson - 1
Glasner - 1.2

Expected Goals Per Game (xG)

Hodgson - 1.05
Glasner - 1.38

Goals Conceded Per Game

Hodgson - 3
Glasner - 1.2

Expected Goals Against Per Game (xGa)

Hodgson - 1.44
Glasner - 0.90

Shots Taken Per Game

Hodgson
Shots - 11.2
Shots on Target - 4.6

Glasner
Shots - 10.6
Shots on Target - 3.2

Shots Conceded Per Game

Hodgson
Shots - 13.2
Shots on Target - 5.6

Glasner
Shots - 9.4
Shots on Target - 3.8

Average Possession

Hodgson - 40%
Glasner - 43.2%

Passes Per Game

Hodgson - 395.6
Glasner - 398.6

Average Pass Accuracy

Hodgson - 76.8
Glasner - 75.6


Since Glasner has come in we have a win, two draws and two defeats versus a win and four defeats.

We've scored 0.2 more goals a game under Glasner and our expected goals total has also increased. However, Hodgson was closer to meeting his xG which indicates that the quality of our finishing has dropped.

At the other end of the pitch, there is obviously a massive drop in the amount of goals conceded, reducing by 1.8 goals a game on average. We're also now expected to concede less than a goal a game on average, a metric that has massively dropped from 1.44 per game.

We're conceding far fewer shots and the shots that we are conceding are less often on target and less likely to result in a goal, suggesting perhaps that they are from tougher positions.

Our possession has increased by over 3% but the volume and accuracy of passes is about the same.

I think it's worth adding as well that Glasner has had less key players available in that run.

If you consider Eze, Olise and Guehi as perhaps our three 'main' players, Hodgson had Olise available twice, Eze available three times and Guehi available four times.

Glasner, on the other hand, has had Eze available in four games but hasn't been able to use Olise or Guehi once yet.

Once those guys are back you'd expect our metrics to improve further.

It's clear that we've improved under Glasner. Assuming he can keep us up, with a full summer transfer window under his belt, there is reason to believe that next season could be significantly improved.

Anyway, that's half an hour wasted. Thanks for reading if you made it this far.

30 mins well spent!

 

pssguy Flag 05 Apr 24 3.59pm

Well if we are three down to City at half-time and he brings Olise on, I will start getting worried

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 06 Apr 24 3.30am

I'm happy we replaced Roy with OG, but I guarantee that Roy would have gotten at least 2, and likely more, points from Luton, Forest, and Bournemouth.

Now we have to punt ManC and Liverpool, and hope to scrape some points after that. All in all, it's been a bad start. I still think we'll be safe, just because we're barely better than Luton, but that isn't making me feel better about next season.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

SelhurstBlockW Flag 06 Apr 24 8.53am

Injuries have been a bigger factor than Roy or OG, OG is more positive but under Roy we would’ve got more points from the last 5 games.
With so many missing and 8 tough games ahead hard to see where we will get points.
Wharton is a great prospect, so why does OG keep subbing him on 80 mins? Not convinced by Munoz - speed is an asset, but weak in tackle and loses possession too easily for me. OG needs to get Eze playing more centrally, wasted out on wing.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Apr 24 10.17am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

I'm happy we replaced Roy with OG, but I guarantee that Roy would have gotten at least 2, and likely more, points from Luton, Forest, and Bournemouth.

Now we have to punt ManC and Liverpool, and hope to scrape some points after that. All in all, it's been a bad start. I still think we'll be safe, just because we're barely better than Luton, but that isn't making me feel better about next season.

I doubt it.

The Roy of old 100%. We were hard to break down and the odd goal would likely win us a game.

The latest Roy not a chance, couldn't defend or attack.


 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Glasner vs. Hodgson