You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mariappa v Assaidi today
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mariappa v Assaidi today


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 18 Jan 14 7.32pm

i was so glade when the subbed there number 24 (Assaidi) i dont think mariappa could handle him he got his cross in every time . i was thinking we need to get ward back in at rb as it was cleare that assaidi was on top everytime,

i think thay subbed him for the man city stiker thay have on loan but from my view he looked a very good player i think he will be back at liverpool whern loan ends

 

jimmyc Flag 18 Jan 14 7.40pm

Quote jamescroydon09 at 18 Jan 2014 7.32pm

i was so glade when the subbed there number 24 (Assaidi) i dont think mariappa could handle him he got his cross in every time . i was thinking we need to get ward back in at rb as it was cleare that assaidi was on top everytime,

i think thay subbed him for the man city stiker thay have on loan but from my view he looked a very good player i think he will be back at liverpool whern loan ends


Agreed, mariappa was getting abused today, all traffic was going down his side. Not a knock on him because it's obviously not his natural position. Was really hoping at half time they would sub him put ward back where he belongs and put O'Keefe next to Jedi. I really want Ward back to RB, it's far better for my heart burn!

 

Sparky Flag Southampton 18 Jan 14 7.55pm

I thought Mariappa actually had one of the best games I've seen from him. He even won a few headers against Crouch.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 18 Jan 14 7.57pm

Mariappa played well but tired a bit too much in the last 15 minutes.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


stayloa Flag Beckenham 18 Jan 14 8.06pm

He's still clearly not 90 minutes match fit, and he's no Ward, but he's vastly improving out of position (as is Ward in DM). Ideally, we'd keep him as a backup CB, but I think it's a better option than starting with SOK, who is great, but a little lightweight at times?

 

pdemeagle Flag eaglebhoy - @eaglism - Cottage in ... 18 Jan 14 8.09pm

I agree and they actually subbed Assaidi for Arnautovic which had me more scared as Arnautovic is a bigger goal threat but thankfully he was poor today !

I feel Mariappa does a decent job there but I'd rather Ward back at RB soon as he's excellent in that role and has a much better final ball than Mariappa !

 


Nice one Daz: [Link]

CPFC 2010 - Stable and Realistic Owners at last ! Roll on Premier League Season 2013/2014 ! Great to be back at last !

PSN = eaglist

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 18 Jan 14 8.16pm

As the person who also started the anti-Wilbraham thread (a minute apart), you are such a sad human being.

The team wins, restricts the opposition to two shots on target, and you choose to batter two guys who are working bloody hard to get into the team. Mariappa had to deal with Assaidi (a liverpool player), and then a fresh Arnautovic (ex-Inter) (their two biggest threats) and still Crouch had no aerial service. And he's being played out of position. Wilbraham created chances, held up the ball exceptionally well and worked so hard to try and restrict their time on the ball.

I'm not saying people are ever devoid of criticism, but compare the value of their side to ours. I cannot imagine what you'd be like after a defeat. Sort out your priorities, your pure negativity is horrendous.

Edited by ambrose7 (18 Jan 2014 8.19pm)

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Jackeagle Flag London 18 Jan 14 8.23pm

Agree with Ambrose7. Assaidi is their best player imo so Mariappa had the hardest job on the pitch. I think Mariappa puts in a great shift but in an ideal world, we'll get a defensive midfielder and Ward can go back to rb. Mariappa is a very good cover for rb and cb. Wilbraham is NOT a goal scorer and for me is defiantely a player to bring in if we are winning with 10-15 mins to go, I thought he was magnificent (I'll pretend I didn't see that shot which dribbled wide). A striker, a cb for cover, and a defensive midfield is what we need. Winger might be nice too but first 3 are more important, especially striker.

 

louis01 Flag Llandudno 18 Jan 14 8.23pm

Personally didn't think Assaidi did anything until just before half time. Mariappa played well today. He needs to work on his crossing though.

 


It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye!

dumbell Flag edenbridge 18 Jan 14 8.34pm

After having to log on again after being a member for god knows how many years !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Right having watched the game on my laptop I have to agree with Tony we need players , however Mariappa is playing out of position and had no support from the trickster, I know he tries his best but feck, the result is the import thing god bless Tony!!!!!!

 

jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 19 Jan 14 10.38pm

the only one sad is you for being so botherd by it . i made a comment on what i think about improving the team so what ?.

i

 

Green Bin Flag Carshalton Beeches 20 Jan 14 9.19am

I have to say Mariappa did have a hard job, but the wingers actually weren't able to get quality crosses in...He is also one of the best jumpers I've seen, he gets tremendous height (handy when you a little bit short for a CB) and gets good distance on headers, also very nippy down the wing and gives Puncheon good support, given that he tackles wells and recovers pretty well, if he were able to improve his crossing I would say he was almost the complete package.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 20 Jan 14 9.25am

Quote jamescroydon09 at 19 Jan 2014 10.38pm

the only one sad is you for being so botherd by it . i made a comment on what i think about improving the team so what ?.

i

It's incredibly unfair, unjustified and unnecessarily negative, that's what. They didn't have a single header at goal in open play and you're having a go at the full back for an apparently endless stream of crosses that didn't take place?

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

jcreedy Flag 20 Jan 14 9.51am

Quote ambrose7 at 20 Jan 2014 9.25am

Quote jamescroydon09 at 19 Jan 2014 10.38pm

the only one sad is you for being so botherd by it . i made a comment on what i think about improving the team so what ?.

i

It's incredibly unfair, unjustified and unnecessarily negative, that's what. They didn't have a single header at goal in open play and you're having a go at the full back for an apparently endless stream of crosses that didn't take place?

A full-back whose natural position is centre-back.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 20 Jan 14 10.51am

Was I watching a different game? I thought assaidi was one of their worst players, and was anonymous throughout?

 

jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 20 Jan 14 11.02am

you must have been watching a diffreant game mate i lost count of the number of crosses assaidi got in okay not meny of them fell on stokes players heads but that was down to gabbs a dd etc blocking them .

i do not think it was unfair, unjustified and unnecessarily negative at all.
it was meant to be constructive criticism , maybee any player that would have had the job of going up aginst assaidi would have also failed to stop the cross comming in and if that was the case i would have said the same thing .

we won the game and played well but thats not to say theres nothing to be learnt buy the last game

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 20 Jan 14 11.31am

Quote jamescroydon09 at 20 Jan 2014 11.02am

you must have been watching a diffreant game mate i lost count of the number of crosses assaidi got in okay not meny of them fell on stokes players heads but that was down to gabbs a dd etc blocking them .

i do not think it was unfair, unjustified and unnecessarily negative at all.
it was meant to be constructive criticism , maybee any player that would have had the job of going up aginst assaidi would have also failed to stop the cross comming in and if that was the case i would have said the same thing .

we won the game and played well but thats not to say theres nothing to be learnt buy the last game

Then I say the player done his job, wouldn't you, as it's the wingers job to get the ball to the head of his strikers. Considering Mariappa is a dedicated CB I think he's adjusted reasonably well to his new roll.

 

jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 20 Jan 14 11.51am

yes i to think he has done well going from a cb to a rb . but i disagree that he done his job well on the day he was good going forward

im not saying that he could have stopped every cross but from my recolection he did not block one of them from getting in the box , just feel that if he is to carry on as a rb then one of his man jobs is to prevent crosses comming in , and for my likeing he seemed like he staned off allowing the cross to come in ....you can not do this as a rb time and time agin as eventually one will land in ht right place and the cb will not be able to head it out

 

Hansy Flag 20 Jan 14 11.59am

Having Mariappa filling in for Ward is great. He has really done well for himself at right back.

He was bombing forward and supporting Puncheon on every attack, and I think that is great for someone who is a natural Centre Back (Couldn't see Rambo doing that!). You can't say he was abused by Ossaidi, alot of right backs are. He done well vs him and did really well containing Redmond vs Norwich.

It is very hard to see whether TP will use Adlene as a DM rather then a AM, just becuase of his presence. Until then I think we will continue to see Ward at CM with Jedi.

Will be nice to see Jack Hunt back though.

 

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 20 Jan 14 12.10pm

Thought Mariappa played well, a lot of good headers in particular. Very noticable at times because of his style of play that he is really a CB covering that position.

Can't say that he lost his duel with Assaidi, who didn't make any clear chances for them, while it was Mariappa bombing on and putting him under pressure that led to our goal, wasn't it?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mariappa v Assaidi today