You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > the NO signings = positive thread
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

the NO signings = positive thread


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
maxipalace Flag in a box 19 Jan 14 4.48pm

For anybody who dosent care if we dont sign anybody in Jan

We have the quality already. Lets not gamble with our future again

 

Ljb Flag Sutton 19 Jan 14 4.53pm

Signing quality players is not a gamble of our future if done correctly. And I would argue we do need some more quality as we have scored the fewest goals in the league this season

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Jan 14 4.53pm

It's a gamble with our short-term future not signing anyone. There is a choice of spending:

a) nothing
b) something
c) as much as QPR

We're vulnerable with any injury or suspension at CB and we cannot definitely rely on any of Chamakh, Gayle, Jerome, Murray to get us enough goals to win us games if they don't pan out in the way we'd like (scoring 1st and alert defending thereafter)

 


COYP

Kosowski Flag Standing at the top of B Block 19 Jan 14 4.54pm

Quote Ljb at 19 Jan 2014 4.53pm

Signing quality players is not a gamble of our future if done correctly. And I would argue we do need some more quality as we have scored the fewest goals in the league this season


Is the right answer.

 


Block B comment of 2011/2012 Season:

"That's better Palace, better...but still fucking shit!"

----------------------------------------------------------------

Dann to Much, Much to Yong.

maxipalace Flag in a box 19 Jan 14 5.48pm

Positive thread! - we made 15 signings early in season

Lots of other threads for moaners ( toys / prams )

close knit squad - team spirit over reputation reputation reputation

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 6.06pm

Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.

Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

subbuteoeagle Flag Uckfield 19 Jan 14 6.17pm

I know a lot more than TP about somethings but I know nothing about managing in the EPL. Good news is that I seem to be in good company ( Poyet? Moyes? Allardyce?) We are 17 points behind last year's EPL champions! Any odds on that?

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 6.22pm

Quote subbuteoeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.17pm

I know a lot more than TP about somethings but I know nothing about managing in the EPL. Good news is that I seem to be in good company ( Poyet? Moyes? Allardyce?) We are 17 points behind last year's EPL champions! Any odds on that?

Actually, beneath the mirth there's a good point here. You don't know more about managing in the Premiership than Moyes or Allardyce, but you have about the same amount of experience as Solskjaer, Meulensteen, and Poyet. For me, that actually makes Cardiff, Fulham, and Sunderland favourites to go down. If one of those doesn't, my money's on West Ham to replace them as sometimes a team simply falls apart to a degree that it gains its own downward momentum. We do not necessarily have one of the 17 best squads in this league, but we do have one of the 5-8 best managers and I think that may be enough to keep us up.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

subbuteoeagle Flag Uckfield 19 Jan 14 6.25pm

Agree although those rookies are better looking than me

 

subbuteoeagle Flag Uckfield 19 Jan 14 6.26pm

Second thought I could just about shade it with Poyet

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 19 Jan 14 8.32pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.06pm

Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.

Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)


goldberg and jordan already made fools of us as a club. A boy from.the youth team was the difference in the play offs between us brighton and watford. Dont forget where you came from and how you got there.

being sustainable as a club means upsetting a few people then i applaud the owners. There is no definitive guide to running a club

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 19 Jan 14 8.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.22pm

Quote subbuteoeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.17pm

I know a lot more than TP about somethings but I know nothing about managing in the EPL. Good news is that I seem to be in good company ( Poyet? Moyes? Allardyce?) We are 17 points behind last year's EPL champions! Any odds on that?

Actually, beneath the mirth there's a good point here. You don't know more about managing in the Premiership than Moyes or Allardyce, but you have about the same amount of experience as Solskjaer, Meulensteen, and Poyet. For me, that actually makes Cardiff, Fulham, and Sunderland favourites to go down. If one of those doesn't, my money's on West Ham to replace them as sometimes a team simply falls apart to a degree that it gains its own downward momentum. We do not necessarily have one of the 17 best squads in this league, but we do have one of the 5-8 best managers and I think that may be enough to keep us up.

Cardiff and West Ham have spent 30m each so buy the spending rule of thumb wont go down then?

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 19 Jan 14 9.00pm

Quote maxipalace at 19 Jan 2014 8.32pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.06pm

Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.

Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)


goldberg and jordan already made fools of us as a club. A boy from.the youth team was the difference in the play offs between us brighton and watford. Dont forget where you came from and how you got there.

being sustainable as a club means upsetting a few people then i applaud the owners. There is no definitive guide to running a club


Not a very positive thread Maxi,you must be furious Bannon, Williams, Gayle played no part in out victory yesterday, sort of dispels your bollocks that you constantly bang on about.
Its clear we need more quality, its ok to spend money wisely. I trust Tony Pulis to do that As he has experience, you should do the same as should CPFC2010.

 

cols123 Flag beckenham 19 Jan 14 9.03pm

This whole forum should be renamed "The Moansdale"

Everywhere you look moan moan moan

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 20 Jan 14 12.28am

Quote bubble wrap at 19 Jan 2014 9.00pm

Quote maxipalace at 19 Jan 2014 8.32pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.06pm

Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.

Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)


goldberg and jordan already made fools of us as a club. A boy from.the youth team was the difference in the play offs between us brighton and watford. Dont forget where you came from and how you got there.

being sustainable as a club means upsetting a few people then i applaud the owners. There is no definitive guide to running a club


Not a very positive thread Maxi,you must be furious Bannon, Williams, Gayle played no part in out victory yesterday, sort of dispels your bollocks that you constantly bang on about.
Its clear we need more quality, its ok to spend money wisely. I trust Tony Pulis to do that As he has experience, you should do the same as should CPFC2010.


Bannan mate. its only stoke - no need to get excited

 

doublesuited77 Flag London (Camden) 20 Jan 14 12.35am

i'd rather have one big signing than several smaller ones.

remember people said the exact same thing about arsenal during the autumn transfer window

 


Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace

thebob Flag Tatebayashi (from Croydon) 20 Jan 14 1.12am

If we rush right in and sign someone at the start of a window, it looks like the player got what he asked for. Negotiating until the end of a window puts pressure on the player to possibly accept a lower fee.

Our fixtures have actually helped us with this strategy by having Stoke and Hull, two winnable matches in close proximity.

If we have our eye on a couple of prospects for the end of the window, they will be ready for the Arsenal game. In the mean time, we have the Wigan game, to run out some prospects or players recovering from injury.

I think Hull got mugged into buying a couple of players at the start of the window. Didn't have much impact against Norwich at the weekend.

I'm quietly confident that we still have enough time left in this season to move up the table into relative security, mess it all up again, and have a final day battle.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 20 Jan 14 9.50am

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.22pm

Quote subbuteoeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.17pm

I know a lot more than TP about somethings but I know nothing about managing in the EPL. Good news is that I seem to be in good company ( Poyet? Moyes? Allardyce?) We are 17 points behind last year's EPL champions! Any odds on that?

Actually, beneath the mirth there's a good point here. You don't know more about managing in the Premiership than Moyes or Allardyce, but you have about the same amount of experience as Solskjaer, Meulensteen, and Poyet. For me, that actually makes Cardiff, Fulham, and Sunderland favourites to go down. If one of those doesn't, my money's on West Ham to replace them as sometimes a team simply falls apart to a degree that it gains its own downward momentum. We do not necessarily have one of the 17 best squads in this league, but we do have one of the 5-8 best managers and I think that may be enough to keep us up.

If he's backed financially yet prudently by the board Syd I tend to agree.

To suggest we spend nothing and add nobody in the window shows a crashing unawareness of whats required.

Holloways scatttergun approach is the summer is not what we are looking at but two or three players in key positions to add depth (and also someone who can hit a cows arese with a banjo)is a must if we are serious about staying up

I saw somewhere the total value of the Dann deal with transfer and wages is £15m - thats an obvious no, but being financially prudent we can still add some quality.


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 20 Jan 14 10.24am

Quote doublesuited77 at 20 Jan 2014 12.35am

i'd rather have one big signing than several smaller ones.

Fully Agreed!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 20 Jan 14 10.47am

Quote maxipalace at 19 Jan 2014 8.32pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 6.06pm

Put another way, this the "I think I know more than Tony Pulis" thread. In other words, an open forum for people to make fool's of themselves.

Edited by sydtheeagle (19 Jan 2014 6.06pm)


goldberg and jordan already made fools of us as a club. A boy from.the youth team was the difference in the play offs between us brighton and watford. Dont forget where you came from and how you got there.

being sustainable as a club means upsetting a few people then i applaud the owners. There is no definitive guide to running a club

'' Made fools of us as a club '' ? And those guys lost most of their personal fortunes along the way.

That boy from the youth team was part of the infrastructure that was invested in - the Academy.

You are right, people are going to find the sustainable strategy tough to take, but there has to be a limit to that or the club becomes uncompetitive and starts to get a reputation for being unambitious.

The bottom line is that 2010 hired - at significant cost - a proven PL manager. If that manager says we need to bring new players in to give us a better chance of staying up, I trust his judgement.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > the NO signings = positive thread