You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Speroni
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Speroni


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
jpegnall Flag Surrey 19 Jan 14 8.44pm

Unfairly took stick earlier in the season on this forum, he has to be in the top 5 of the most consistent keepers so far this season, no big costly mistakes at all. Long may it continue!

 

Palace_denizen Flag filed under " time wasters " 19 Jan 14 8.46pm

not just this season, but he has put in some splendid long spells of consistency in all his years with us. Also, his loyalty to Palace is beyond any doubt. We are lucky to have such a big man in a position that is notoriously difficult to fill in any squad - a longstanding dependable shot stopper.
.
PS before i get too carried away with the love-fest , even the best players need a whippersnapper under them trying to take their job off of them.

Edited by Palace_denizen (19 Jan 2014 8.50pm)

 


Laughing at Charlton - Every London Clyub's fourth or fifth most hated team -
[Link]

reginald_maudling Flag 19 Jan 14 8.55pm

he is in great form right now, even looks more confident with crosses and corners - only current weak spot is indecision coming out of his area

 

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 19 Jan 14 9.17pm

He didn't have a 'busy day at the office' yesterday.

But, having said that, still pulled a first class save out of the hat (the low one, that he scooped out with his right hand).

So my Speroni man-crush continues.

And, without hijacking the thread too much, his lack of a 'busy day at the office' is a great compliment to the rest of the team.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

kayjaybee Flag orpington 19 Jan 14 9.26pm

a keeper is a keeper is a keeper ,at the end of the day his job is to stop the ball crossing the line, although his dominance is suspect in the penalty area his shot stopping is superb, how many keepers out there are the opposite of jules, and how many make mistakes when coming for crosses, at the moment our defence as a whole complement each other, the job is satisfactory at the moment, and as a keeper overall he is more than adequate

 

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 19 Jan 14 9.31pm

Quote kayjaybee at 19 Jan 2014 9.26pm

a keeper is a keeper is a keeper ,at the end of the day his job is to stop the ball crossing the line, although his dominance is suspect in the penalty area his shot stopping is superb, how many keepers out there are the opposite of jules, and how many make mistakes when coming for crosses, at the moment our defence as a whole complement each other, the job is satisfactory at the moment, and as a keeper overall he is more than adequate

Yup.

Mignolet or Jules?

No brainier at the moment.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Jan 14 9.32pm

That save from the header against Stoke was a proper worldy

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jan 14 10.15pm

Anyone who knocks Speroni, needs to revisit the last 10 years or so. More than any player he's earned the right to be the Palace number 1 in the premiership. There are better keepers in this league, true, but none of them would ever consider playing for us.

And besides, we'd be a league 1 or 2 team if it weren't for him. In our very lean years he was worth more than a 20 goals a season striker.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jan 14 10.16pm

Quote kayjaybee at 19 Jan 2014 9.26pm

a keeper is a keeper is a keeper ,at the end of the day his job is to stop the ball crossing the line, although his dominance is suspect in the penalty area his shot stopping is superb, how many keepers out there are the opposite of jules, and how many make mistakes when coming for crosses, at the moment our defence as a whole complement each other, the job is satisfactory at the moment, and as a keeper overall he is more than adequate

Its not his strongest asset, but he isn't exactly poor in the area. His penalty saving leaves a bit to be desired, but if I was going to pick one attribute my ideal keeper was terrible at, it would be saving penalties.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jan 14 10.17pm

Quote Palace_denizen at 19 Jan 2014 8.46pm

not just this season, but he has put in some splendid long spells of consistency in all his years with us. Also, his loyalty to Palace is beyond any doubt. We are lucky to have such a big man in a position that is notoriously difficult to fill in any squad - a longstanding dependable shot stopper.
.
PS before i get too carried away with the love-fest , even the best players need a whippersnapper under them trying to take their job off of them.

Edited by Palace_denizen (19 Jan 2014 8.50pm)

Speroni has had a few in his time, all of whom have been rated good in their own right, most they've got is one or two games a season, and their teeth smashed out in the reserves.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 19 Jan 14 10.22pm

He has been loyal to us and I don't think Argentina have any keepers so at least should give him a go. In 2013 it is so so rare to see a testimonial and it is normally a player that is local and has come through ranks. He has his faults and I think if it wasn't for those minor faults he wouldn't be playing for us, he would have played for a bigger club long ago

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Jan 14 10.23pm

Quote jpegnall at 19 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Unfairly took stick earlier in the season on this forum, he has to be in the top 5 of the most consistent keepers so far this season, no big costly mistakes at all. Long may it continue!

He did not take stick unfairly. Most of the comments were not insulting and were quite objective. The bottom line is that he is playing in a system which effectively has four centre backs and six defenders most of the time. The way Pulis sets the team up is going to make almost any half competent goalkeeper look good. Furthermore, the one thing Jools has always been good at (the reflex save) is the one area where he can continue to shine and, indeed, he stills pulls off the spectacular save as he always has done. But with four centre backs and six defenders, while his shortcomings as "in the box keeper" remain, they really don't cost us that much because there are plenty of bodies to clear the ball without needing to rely on the keeper. Jools is very lucky. He's playing for a team set up to make him shine though no doubt, recently, shining is what he is doing.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

laddo Flag london 19 Jan 14 10.37pm

Is there any way we can raise his profile and do something to prompt Argentina to have a look. Long shot I know but it would be a great gesture.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

jpegnall Flag Surrey 19 Jan 14 11.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 10.23pm

Quote jpegnall at 19 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Unfairly took stick earlier in the season on this forum, he has to be in the top 5 of the most consistent keepers so far this season, no big costly mistakes at all. Long may it continue!

He did not take stick unfairly. Most of the comments were not insulting and were quite objective. The bottom line is that he is playing in a system which effectively has four centre backs and six defenders most of the time. The way Pulis sets the team up is going to make almost any half competent goalkeeper look good. Furthermore, the one thing Jools has always been good at (the reflex save) is the one area where he can continue to shine and, indeed, he stills pulls off the spectacular save as he always has done. But with four centre backs and six defenders, while his shortcomings as "in the box keeper" remain, they really don't cost us that much because there are plenty of bodies to clear the ball without needing to rely on the keeper. Jools is very lucky. He's playing for a team set up to make him shine though no doubt, recently, shining is what he is doing.


Objective? Then you didn't read the same posts I did. There were plenty saying he isn't good enough at this level, is a championship keeper and people thinking he should have been saving penalties and shots struck hard from six yards when our defence was letting us down.

As for Pulis setting the team up to make him look good - that is a huge discredit to him, we defend well but he hasn't exactly been quiet in the net or limited to a type of save.

He can't win with some people, when he concedes (when most keepers wouldn't have done better) and our team isn't defending well like the first 10 games or so - he is slated for being championship quality and should be doing better, when he gets clean sheets and MotM performances it is Pulis making him look good. What a load of rubbish.

 

cpj Flag Kent 19 Jan 14 11.45pm

Quote jpegnall at 19 Jan 2014 11.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 10.23pm

Quote jpegnall at 19 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Unfairly took stick earlier in the season on this forum, he has to be in the top 5 of the most consistent keepers so far this season, no big costly mistakes at all. Long may it continue!

He did not take stick unfairly. Most of the comments were not insulting and were quite objective. The bottom line is that he is playing in a system which effectively has four centre backs and six defenders most of the time. The way Pulis sets the team up is going to make almost any half competent goalkeeper look good. Furthermore, the one thing Jools has always been good at (the reflex save) is the one area where he can continue to shine and, indeed, he stills pulls off the spectacular save as he always has done. But with four centre backs and six defenders, while his shortcomings as "in the box keeper" remain, they really don't cost us that much because there are plenty of bodies to clear the ball without needing to rely on the keeper. Jools is very lucky. He's playing for a team set up to make him shine though no doubt, recently, shining is what he is doing.


Objective? Then you didn't read the same posts I did. There were plenty saying he isn't good enough at this level, is a championship keeper and people thinking he should have been saving penalties and shots struck hard from six yards when our defence was letting us down.

As for Pulis setting the team up to make him look good - that is a huge discredit to him, we defend well but he hasn't exactly been quiet in the net or limited to a type of save.

He can't win with some people, when he concedes (when most keepers wouldn't have done better) and our team isn't defending well like the first 10 games or so - he is slated for being championship quality and should be doing better, when he gets clean sheets and MotM performances it is Pulis making him look good. What a load of rubbish.


Sorry, but I've yet to see any MOTM performances from Speroni this season. A good save yesterday from Whelan's header but any competent keeper should have saved that. Earlier in the season he should have done better with his positioning for a couple of free-kicks that went in, and he could have done better with other goals scored in particular by Swansea and Southampton. He is doing well now because the defence is playing better. Let's not get carried away.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 19 Jan 14 11.56pm

The critcism earlier in the season wasn't fair or objective.

The team was playing f***ing rubbish and couldn't even get out their half at times yet some were on here banging on about the goalkeeper constantly.

The Swansea game he kept the score respectable and wasn't to blame for either goal.

 

jpegnall Flag Surrey 20 Jan 14 12.07am

Quote cpj at 19 Jan 2014 11.45pm

Quote jpegnall at 19 Jan 2014 11.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Jan 2014 10.23pm

Quote jpegnall at 19 Jan 2014 8.44pm

Unfairly took stick earlier in the season on this forum, he has to be in the top 5 of the most consistent keepers so far this season, no big costly mistakes at all. Long may it continue!

He did not take stick unfairly. Most of the comments were not insulting and were quite objective. The bottom line is that he is playing in a system which effectively has four centre backs and six defenders most of the time. The way Pulis sets the team up is going to make almost any half competent goalkeeper look good. Furthermore, the one thing Jools has always been good at (the reflex save) is the one area where he can continue to shine and, indeed, he stills pulls off the spectacular save as he always has done. But with four centre backs and six defenders, while his shortcomings as "in the box keeper" remain, they really don't cost us that much because there are plenty of bodies to clear the ball without needing to rely on the keeper. Jools is very lucky. He's playing for a team set up to make him shine though no doubt, recently, shining is what he is doing.


Objective? Then you didn't read the same posts I did. There were plenty saying he isn't good enough at this level, is a championship keeper and people thinking he should have been saving penalties and shots struck hard from six yards when our defence was letting us down.

As for Pulis setting the team up to make him look good - that is a huge discredit to him, we defend well but he hasn't exactly been quiet in the net or limited to a type of save.

He can't win with some people, when he concedes (when most keepers wouldn't have done better) and our team isn't defending well like the first 10 games or so - he is slated for being championship quality and should be doing better, when he gets clean sheets and MotM performances it is Pulis making him look good. What a load of rubbish.


Sorry, but I've yet to see any MOTM performances from Speroni this season. A good save yesterday from Whelan's header but any competent keeper should have saved that. Earlier in the season he should have done better with his positioning for a couple of free-kicks that went in, and he could have done better with other goals scored in particular by Swansea and Southampton. He is doing well now because the defence is playing better. Let's not get carried away.

He was MOTM in the cup game against west brom just 2 weeks ago. As for the free kicks - it's nothing to do with his positioning, the only ones he has conceded the wall has either failed and/or has been struck into the top corner with pace. But maybe you should go down to the training ground to give him advice, I mean it can't be hard for you to show him where to stand for a free kick and you obviously know far more about goalkeeping than the coaching staff who obviously must get him to stand in the wrong place.


Edited by jpegnall (20 Jan 2014 12.08am)

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 20 Jan 14 4.05am

I see a player who has improved both in terms of his ability to deal with crosses and his self belief in being able to make it at the highest level.

Speroni's recent performances have been due to a vast improvement in our defence but then the vast improvement in our defence must be, in part, down to their confidence in the man between the posts.

He turns up every week, he puts in a very good shift regularly and hardly ever has an off day. He makes breathtaking saves and for me is the most improved player in our team this year.

He is coming for more crosses and taking them. He is never going to be a keeper who dominates the entire penalty area as that is not his style or strength. However, I honestly believe he is proving to be one of the stars of this season.

If the player of the season vote was today I would be suggesting JS. Consistently good performances throughout the campaign and is now, for me, an absolute Palace legend - not a word I use often.

Edited by james03 (20 Jan 2014 4.06am)

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

burtmacp Flag 20 Jan 14 6.18am

By far our most consistent player.
He should have in the tank 4 to 5 more years at this level
Let's enjoy his legacy, a true Palace jewel.
If we count the games from the day Ian H. Left, Jules would be top 3 in PL, no doubts in my view and the stats.
Argentina should look at him and we should help him to realize his dream, he deserves our respect and admiration.
A classy Eagles player.
Thank you "Mano de Dios"

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 20 Jan 14 7.40am

The key is stability and confidence.

The full backs have been tinkered with but, against most of our expectations at the start of the season, Gabbidon and Delaney have been automatic choices and have been injury free (and competition free) for weeks now. Having the same pairing in front of you brings understanding and, strangely, confidence. When, as a unit, you then start keeping clean sheets, this grows.

Gabbidon's looked our most dangerous striker at times (at the wrong end) but overall they've performed way above expectations this season.

Jules has always been a top quality keeper. Of course he's got weaknesses, as have all of our defence, but as a unit they've adapted well and cover for each other (and have been well protected by the likes of Jedinak and KG). Apart from Newcastle we haven't suffered a hammering this year (again, against most of our expectations I'd have thought) and although individually they'd struggle to get into most Premiership sides, our central defence has performed admirably.

When one of these two is suspended/injured/replaced we can expect to be nervous. In the meantime Jules has grown in confidence, benefitted from the stability and continues to be one of a handful of our squad who would automatically get into most Premiership teams.

Oh, and I suspect that anyone who was criticising Jules earlier in the season and calling for him to be replaced were supporting "newbies" in relative terms. The thing that worries me is that the most recent newbie at Palace is Pulis.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Speroni