This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
We need someone greedy in front of goal. Puncheon?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
benchharp 27 Jan 14 9.07pm |
|
|
Bound to divide opinion but hear me out.
I absolutely love Chamakh, he wins a lot of headers, rarely loses the ball and is ridiculously unselfish, what we lack is someone who can do something with his little lay offs, neither Jerome nor Gayle seem to be that person.[Gayle too weak, Jerome shoots like a donkey, Wilbs can't finish either, please do not call his goal against Wigan "finishing"]
I can't see this happening in a month of Sundays but would love to see Puncheon in front of Chamakh, he has a thirst for scoring, perhaps to the point of annoyance, we've all seen him try and take that extra man just to make space for a shot and he has got a good strike on him, if he was in that advanced position i think he could hit the back of the net at least as an interim solution.
This would also allow Bannan a place back in the team who i believe is just about the only player we have who can put in a quality cross.
|
Jamesrichards8 27 Jan 14 9.33pm |
|
|
Not the worst idea. But as you said will never happen. Gayle could be that person. We haven't seen him in that position yet.
When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...
|
Jackeagle London 27 Jan 14 10.02pm |
|
|
Yeah, we could do worse, but wwould never happen.
|
alffy 27 Jan 14 10.29pm |
|
|
I think Gayle should play rather than Jerome. At least Gayle can shoot. Think back to Villa Park, Jerome would have run the ball into the corner. It was good to see someone attack the defender and have a shot.
|
youngbilla Toronto, Canada 27 Jan 14 11.00pm |
|
|
I like it. However, I wouldn't risk experimenting at this point. I'd rather have Gayle out there instead of Jerome.
|
pstrutt Busselton, WA 27 Jan 14 11.07pm |
|
|
Greedy? Neil Shipperley!
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.
|
babylonjohn St Leonards-on-Sea 28 Jan 14 12.37am |
|
|
Shefki Kuqi liked a pie
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 28 Jan 14 12.39am |
|
Quote pstrutt at 27 Jan 2014 11.07pm
Greedy? Neil Shipperley!
Thomas Brolin liked a pie or four as well.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
sprites Auckland 28 Jan 14 12.43am |
|
|
Gayle.
Enough said.
|
moylerg Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 28 Jan 14 2.54am |
|
Quote sprites at 28 Jan 2014 12.43am
Gayle.
Enough said.
Indeed, time to unleash the Gayle!
Most certainly not European.
|
sydtheeagle England 28 Jan 14 7.47am |
|
|
Totally agree. This was the line-up I proposed in the thread before the Stoke match when Jerome was suspended. Thierry Henry went from an average winger to a clincal front man. Why not see if Puncheon can do the same thing?
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
EagleRider Seasalter, Kent 28 Jan 14 8.21am |
|
|
To hit the side note of this post, whatever it takes to get Bannan regular minutes! I still don't get Pulis' aversion to the man. And Puncheon, whether anyone here likes hearing it or not, is our best scoring option at the moment every time.
|
sueagle2012 28 Jan 14 8.22am |
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 7.47am
Totally agree. This was the line-up I proposed in the thread before the Stoke match when Jerome was suspended. Thierry Henry went from an average winger to a clincal front man. Why not see if Puncheon can do the same thing?
Agree Puncheon seems more likely to score...The easiest and most practical way to implement this would be for Jerome to swap roles with Puncheon for 10-15 m periods during a couple of games. Jerome may turn out to be a better wide player...he has already done well going to by line and crossing Wingers often swap sides so striker and winger swapping could also be tried out.
|
bubble wrap Carparks in South East London 28 Jan 14 9.04am |
|
Quote sueagle2012 at 28 Jan 2014 8.22am
Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 7.47am
Totally agree. This was the line-up I proposed in the thread before the Stoke match when Jerome was suspended. Thierry Henry went from an average winger to a clincal front man. Why not see if Puncheon can do the same thing?
Agree Puncheon seems more likely to score...The easiest and most practical way to implement this would be for Jerome to swap roles with Puncheon for 10-15 m periods during a couple of games. Jerome may turn out to be a better wide player...he has already done well going to by line and crossing Wingers often swap sides so striker and winger swapping could also be tried out.
More likely to score because he actually has a shot now and again. For all his hard work and endeavour Chamach just doesn't take enough shots.Jerome is not good enough full stop. Would play Bannon out wide and Puncheon and Chamach in the centre.
|
silvertop Portishead 28 Jan 14 9.09am |
|
Quote EagleRider at 28 Jan 2014 8.21am
To hit the side note of this post, whatever it takes to get Bannan regular minutes! I still don't get Pulis' aversion to the man. And Puncheon, whether anyone here likes hearing it or not, is our best scoring option at the moment every time.
There is a theory that he does not like any player unless he suffers neck pain talking to him. And let's not mention Joniesta.
|
cornwalls palace Torpoint 28 Jan 14 9.12am |
|
|
...I know a granny.
.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!
|
sydtheeagle England 28 Jan 14 11.13am |
|
Quote bubble wrap at 28 Jan 2014 9.04am
More likely to score because he actually has a shot now and again. For all his hard work and endeavour Chamach just doesn't take enough shots.
Not sure I agree with this. What Chamakh does is, I think, a by-product of the role Pulis has given him -- quite recessed in a "hold-the-ball-up-and-lay-it-off" position rather than playing him as an in-the-box striker. I think if Chamakh played further up or in a different formation, he would score more goals. For instance, if we had someone else in the position Chamakh is presently playing I think Chamakh would be quite capable of playing Jerome's current role and would score more goals while doing it. I'm not saying he's a prolific, 20-goals-a-season man but I do think he has 12-15 in him, and he won't get that from the role he's been given now. Jerome wouldn't score 15 a season if we made him the penalty taker and we got 15 penalties.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
jimmyc 28 Jan 14 11.21am |
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.13am
Quote bubble wrap at 28 Jan 2014 9.04am
More likely to score because he actually has a shot now and again. For all his hard work and endeavour Chamach just doesn't take enough shots.
Not sure I agree with this. What Chamakh does is, I think, a by-product of the role Pulis has given him -- quite recessed in a "hold-the-ball-up-and-lay-it-off" position rather than playing him as an in-the-box striker. I think if Chamakh played further up or in a different formation, he would score more goals. For instance, if we had someone else in the position Chamakh is presently playing I think Chamakh would be quite capable of playing Jerome's current role and would score more goals while doing it. I'm not saying he's a prolific, 20-goals-a-season man but I do think he has 12-15 in him, and he won't get that from the role he's been given now. Jerome wouldn't score 15 a season if we made him the penalty taker and we got 15 penalties.
Yea but Chamakh is showing to be very good in that position, I would hate to take him out of a role that he is doing very well. I would rather just sort out the striker issue by hopefully picking up a striker in the window or giving Gayle, Puncheon or even Guedioura a chance to play off him.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 28 Jan 14 2.00pm |
|
|
Problem with most of these ideas is that whilst Puncheon probably does have a better eye for goal than Jerome, he isn't physically capable of performing the role that Jerome does up front for the team.
Ideally we want Jerome to do what Jerome does, but with the chances falling to Chamakh or well anyone else really. Problem is, what Jerome does for the team is generally what creates those chances. He's a big target man, strong in the air etc. Gayle is about a foot too small, and built like a 8 year old girl by comparison. No way he is out musculing or jumping a six foot and change center back.
We'd be stretchering either one off by half time.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
CroydonPenny Croydon 28 Jan 14 3.02pm |
|
|
Puncheon will become Henry
|