You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 27 Jan 14 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 Jan 14 9.21pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

I had wondered the same myself Beagle. It seems we have a big splurge on something and then a couple of days later CPFC2010 and the manager are denying it.

 

Rubin Flag 27 Jan 14 9.26pm

I'd say so. It's easy to forget we won our last league game and are 16th in the table when reading Palace talk. Some people on here need to learn to be patient. Sign of the times, possibly.

 

Manc_Palace Flag Sydney 27 Jan 14 9.48pm

It's really difficult to come on this forum at the moment and take anything seriously.

I sincerely hope we don't have another world war and I'm not in the trenches with half of you as you'd be having breakdowns every five minutes.

Is there anything that can be said or done that can make you guys just have a little patience and wait until the 1st? Unfortunately none of us are privvy to the information that you desire and speculating is making some people really not cope very well. We need to look after these people and understand that conjecture in any form really affects their daily lives

Thank you

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 Jan 14 9.59pm

Quote Manc_Palace at 27 Jan 2014 9.48pm

It's really difficult to come on this forum at the moment and take anything seriously.

I sincerely hope we don't have another world war and I'm not in the trenches with half of you as you'd be having breakdowns every five minutes.

Is there anything that can be said or done that can make you guys just have a little patience and wait until the 1st? Unfortunately none of us are privvy to the information that you desire and speculating is making some people really not cope very well. We need to look after these people and understand that conjecture in any form really affects their daily lives

Thank you

Strange post. Everyone on this thread is being reasonable. If the 'you' is aimed at Holers in general maybe I see your point.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 27 Jan 14 10.11pm

Just over a week ago we beat Stoke and rose to 16th and everything was wonderful. I'm not quite sure what happened since then.

I would have liked to have beaten Wigan, but wasn't particularly surprised that we didn't. I found it quite complimentary that Wigan's result was seen as the biggest upset of the round, which shows how far we've come.

If (if) we can get a result against Hull, then I'm sure we'll all be happy again. If we lose however... Oh God.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 27 Jan 14 10.12pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

Interesting post but I don't think we have that much 'power' we are basically a load of Palace fans arguing about the club we love. Does anyone outside us really take it seriously?

Edited by Andy_G (27 Jan 2014 10.14pm)

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Jan 14 10.25pm

A lot of the debate on HOL has been fuelled by the newspaper ( well, The Mirror mainly ) reporting on our struggles in the transfer window. The extension of that is to report that Pulis is unhappy as a result. Until such time as we hear to the contrary, then of course we are going to do what this site is for - discuss, speculate, rant, whatever !

We all have our own views on how the club is run. This is a place where we can share those views, no matter how extreme some of them are.

So to answer the original question - it's a '' no '' from me.

If there was any genuine unrest at the club then it would be reflected in the on field performances. And I've seen no evidence of that.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Pikester Flag Worthing 27 Jan 14 10.32pm

Quote Andy_G at 27 Jan 2014 10.12pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

Interesting post but I don't think we have that much 'power' we are basically a load of Palace fans arguing about the club we love. Does anyone outside us really take it seriously?

Edited by Andy_G (27 Jan 2014 10.14pm)

I was about to post the same thing. I should think we're pretty much ignored by the rest of the world -although I do still have a secret fantasy that Steve Parish regularly laughs at all my posts and will one day send me some complementary tickets.

I think we have as much sway as people who post comments on Youtube.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 27 Jan 14 10.42pm

I don't think so. I do think that because we have very forthright and open owners who like to communicate with us about the club, when we are no longer in the loop (like right now because obviously they cannot divulge who they are targeting before it's official) a lot of people start fretting and believing the drivel in the press.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 27 Jan 14 10.43pm

Quote Pikester at 27 Jan 2014 10.32pm

Quote Andy_G at 27 Jan 2014 10.12pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

Interesting post but I don't think we have that much 'power' we are basically a load of Palace fans arguing about the club we love. Does anyone outside us really take it seriously?

Edited by Andy_G (27 Jan 2014 10.14pm)

I was about to post the same thing. I should think we're pretty much ignored by the rest of the world -although I do still have a secret fantasy that Steve Parish regularly laughs at all my posts and will one day send me some complementary tickets.

I think we have as much sway as people who post comments on Youtube.

This with bells on.

I think the OP is rather overplaying our influence. Anyone who took anything on here seriously is an idiot or a lazy journalist. The HOL rarely even has its finger on the pulse of what the matchday crowds think !

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Leicestershireeagle Flag South Leicestershire 27 Jan 14 10.55pm

I wouldn't go as far as saying we collectively influence the media, but we certainly seem to be our own worst enemy.

Everyone seems to cynical and pessimistic, and logic and reason go out the window. One rumor can lead to hysteria, and even counter-rumors prove to do nothing to stem the tide of panic.

Someone could spot an NCP warden popping into the club to use the gents, and within half an hour there would be a thirty page thread about Selhurst becoming a multistory car park.

 


RED AND BLUE ARMY!

Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 27 Jan 14 11.01pm

Certainly the HOL is not a true reflection of what is really happening at Selhurst Park.

Mainly due to many posters not attending the games.

 

Manc_Palace Flag Sydney 27 Jan 14 11.01pm

Quote Mapletree at 27 Jan 2014 9.59pm

Quote Manc_Palace at 27 Jan 2014 9.48pm

It's really difficult to come on this forum at the moment and take anything seriously.

I sincerely hope we don't have another world war and I'm not in the trenches with half of you as you'd be having breakdowns every five minutes.

Is there anything that can be said or done that can make you guys just have a little patience and wait until the 1st? Unfortunately none of us are privvy to the information that you desire and speculating is making some people really not cope very well. We need to look after these people and understand that conjecture in any form really affects their daily lives

Thank you

Strange post. Everyone on this thread is being reasonable. If the 'you' is aimed at Holers in general maybe I see your point.


Absolutely meant the HOL in general, should have made that clearer.

 

Pikester Flag Worthing 27 Jan 14 11.02pm

Quote Leicestershireeagle at 27 Jan 2014 10.55pm

I wouldn't go as far as saying we collectively influence the media, but we certainly seem to be our own worst enemy.

Everyone seems to cynical and pessimistic, and logic and reason go out the window. One rumor can lead to hysteria, and even counter-rumors prove to do nothing to stem the tide of panic.

Someone could spot an NCP warden popping into the club to use the gents, and within half an hour there would be a thirty page thread about Selhurst becoming a multistory car park.


Steve Parish would definitely laugh at that!
(Although I'd like to think he wouldn't be giving away my complementary tickets just yet)

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 27 Jan 14 11.18pm

Quote Pikester at 27 Jan 2014 11.02pm

Quote Leicestershireeagle at 27 Jan 2014 10.55pm

I wouldn't go as far as saying we collectively influence the media, but we certainly seem to be our own worst enemy.

Everyone seems to cynical and pessimistic, and logic and reason go out the window. One rumor can lead to hysteria, and even counter-rumors prove to do nothing to stem the tide of panic.

Someone could spot an NCP warden popping into the club to use the gents, and within half an hour there would be a thirty page thread about Selhurst becoming a multistory car park.


Steve Parish would definitely laugh at that!
(Although I'd like to think he wouldn't be giving away my complementary tickets just yet)


I am seeing what you are doing there...good luck!

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 27 Jan 14 11.21pm

Quote Pikester at 27 Jan 2014 11.02pm

Quote Leicestershireeagle at 27 Jan 2014 10.55pm

I wouldn't go as far as saying we collectively influence the media, but we certainly seem to be our own worst enemy.

Everyone seems to cynical and pessimistic, and logic and reason go out the window. One rumor can lead to hysteria, and even counter-rumors prove to do nothing to stem the tide of panic.

Someone could spot an NCP warden popping into the club to use the gents, and within half an hour there would be a thirty page thread about Selhurst becoming a multistory car park.


Steve Parish would definitely laugh at that!
(Although I'd like to think he wouldn't be giving away my complementary tickets just yet)


(By far the greatest Multistorey car park the world has ever seen!)

I personally love all this fuel! Multiple stories, guess work, bad comments, ridiculous comments, poor suggestions, rhubarb speculation. Makes the gaps in between the games thrilling. Well nearly thrilling.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 27 Jan 14 11.24pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 27 Jan 2014 10.43pm

Quote Pikester at 27 Jan 2014 10.32pm

Quote Andy_G at 27 Jan 2014 10.12pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

Interesting post but I don't think we have that much 'power' we are basically a load of Palace fans arguing about the club we love. Does anyone outside us really take it seriously?

Edited by Andy_G (27 Jan 2014 10.14pm)

I was about to post the same thing. I should think we're pretty much ignored by the rest of the world -although I do still have a secret fantasy that Steve Parish regularly laughs at all my posts and will one day send me some complementary tickets.

I think we have as much sway as people who post comments on Youtube.

This with bells on.

I think the OP is rather overplaying our influence. Anyone who took anything on here seriously is an idiot or a lazy journalist. The HOL rarely even has its finger on the pulse of what the matchday crowds think !


'Lazy journalism'. Boy, have I heard that used on here and the BBS when some rumour has surfaced in a tabloid.

So in a way you're agreeing that we do have an influence...albeit over 'lazy journalists'

Here's the thing: if a group of, let's say, 25 HOL regulars were to meet up outside the board and come to an agreed story that, for example, Pullis and Browett were not speaking and both wanted out, and we started a thread on the subject (and we made it convincing).....well, how long would it be before Pullis and Browett were being asked about their relationship by 'the media', and before a few headlines started appearing...'palace in crisis' etc etc.

I'd give it 2 weeks before our faked story was picked up.

I think, unwittingly, we have a fair bit of influence - on a side note, but not disconnected, I'm pretty sure that, when we were last up in the prem, one of our transfers was hijacked at the airport by west brom due to those 'in the know' on the BBS talking about it (was is Gera...can't remember).


 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 27 Jan 14 11.36pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 11.24pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 27 Jan 2014 10.43pm

Quote Pikester at 27 Jan 2014 10.32pm

Quote Andy_G at 27 Jan 2014 10.12pm

Quote beagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.11pm

Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?

I put the word 'unrest' in inverted commas as Pullis has come out to the press to say not only is he going nowhere, but the board are/have been doing a top job.

Which is a strange coincidence give that both Palace boards have been a fury of speculation, whispers, information, mis-information and passionate debate on both subjects.

Extraordinarily Palace are fairly unique in having two 'thriving' (and that aint the half of it) boards.

And we all know the football press keeps a close eye on the two sites for 'stories' (A case in point is someone like The Adder editor who is a regular in terms posting links to his paper's latest Palace 'scoop'- and there's no way he aint checking out the gossip and arguments we post). The boards are a barometer and an easy newsfeed.

So if Pullis, as he says, genuinely has no problem with the board and isnt off anywhere then are we the architects of the club becomes a 'backpage story'? Pullis is fending off questions. The board is. The players will have their fingers on every media pulse and wondering if there are 'issues' etc etc and the whole 'non-story' gets ratcheted up.

On the other hand, I thoroughly enjoy the ebb and flow of the debate, but I do wonder if the popularity of both boards has a negative side and we are, unwittingly, the architects of some of the 'unrest' (which, according to TP, is non-existant btw )

Edited by beagle (27 Jan 2014 9.14pm)

Interesting post but I don't think we have that much 'power' we are basically a load of Palace fans arguing about the club we love. Does anyone outside us really take it seriously?

Edited by Andy_G (27 Jan 2014 10.14pm)

I was about to post the same thing. I should think we're pretty much ignored by the rest of the world -although I do still have a secret fantasy that Steve Parish regularly laughs at all my posts and will one day send me some complementary tickets.

I think we have as much sway as people who post comments on Youtube.

This with bells on.

I think the OP is rather overplaying our influence. Anyone who took anything on here seriously is an idiot or a lazy journalist. The HOL rarely even has its finger on the pulse of what the matchday crowds think !


'Lazy journalism'. Boy, have I heard that used on here and the BBS when some rumour has surfaced in a tabloid.

So in a way you're agreeing that we do have an influence...albeit over 'lazy journalists'

Here's the thing: if a group of, let's say, 25 HOL regulars were to meet up outside the board and come to an agreed story that, for example, Pullis and Browett were not speaking and both wanted out, and we started a thread on the subject (and we made it convincing).....well, how long would it be before Pullis and Browett were being asked about their relationship by 'the media', and before a few headlines started appearing...'palace in crisis' etc etc.

I'd give it 2 weeks before our faked story was picked up.

I think, unwittingly, we have a fair bit of influence - on a side note, but not disconnected, I'm pretty sure that, when we were last up in the prem, one of our transfers was hijacked at the airport by west brom due to those 'in the know' on the BBS talking about it (was is Gera...can't remember).



In my opinion we do. Why wouldn't the press be checking out the boards to find the "pulse" of the club.
The press are all over these boards and twitter looking for any angle to create a story if one isn't happening. Beagle your fake story would be in the papers within 3/4 days under a source said, a close friend was told etc, etc.
God help everyone if we lose tomorrow.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Jan 14 6.30am

An Internet forum is just that. It's there to provide a stomping ground for people with a common interest to get stuck in, express their opinions and even relieve their stresses. How the free world reacts isn't my problem and doesn't interest me one jot. I honestly couldn't care less if Steve Parish reads my posts or whether the Advertiser is dumb enough to mistake emotional rants for inside information. At the end of the day, this board does what it does and should be left alone to do it. I participate here to enjoy the debate. Outside influences should stay just that; outside. One reason I prefer HOL to the BBS is precisely because CPFC2010 don't have their own little sanitised column here. In that sense I'm a purist, I'm afraid.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are the HOL/BBS architects of the club's 'unrest'?