You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > tonights Ref.
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

tonights Ref.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
black eagle. Flag south croydon. 28 Jan 14 10.51pm

In a word shocking.discuss

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 28 Jan 14 10.54pm

I don't agree.

Most referees would of given Long falling down in the box as a penalty. Replays showed he was looking for it and hooked his leg up to make contact with Gabbidon.


Other then not booking McCgregor when he needlessy squared up to Jerome, he had a good game. He made up for his error by sending him off later either way.

All in all, good refereeing all round. Better then that idiot against Wigan by all accounts.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 28 Jan 14 10.54pm

Could've easily given Hull a pen which would've most likely seen them get something out the game. Seemed a bit hasty with yellows for us but I didn't think he was that bad really. From a TV view.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 28 Jan 14 10.56pm

Quote black eagle. at 28 Jan 2014 10.51pm

In a word shocking.discuss

Shocking IS the word. Hull were filthy and they cheated. Both strikers should have had a yellow for diving. The keeper should have been booked if Jerome was. He missed so many fouls by them and consistently gave strange decisions against us. He was utter pony.

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 28 Jan 14 10.58pm

Some strange decisions and looked like he was a bit nervous.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 28 Jan 14 10.58pm

Agreed. The Long penalty scenario was a brilliant judgement and will earn him points on the referee panel.

Delaney and O'Keefe deserved yellows and it was totally justified to send Mcgregor off. Yeah, he'd been harrassed a couple of times but his reactions were totally over the top.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 28 Jan 14 10.58pm

Ref had great game but cudda booked Long for trying to con a penalty

 


The right place at the right time

Mapletree Flag Croydon 28 Jan 14 11.00pm

Quote rossboss29 at 28 Jan 2014 10.54pm

I don't agree.

Most referees would of given Long falling down in the box as a penalty. Replays showed he was looking for it and hooked his leg up to make contact with Gabbidon.


Other then not booking McCgregor when he needlessy squared up to Jerome, he had a good game. He made up for his error by sending him off later either way.

All in all, good refereeing all round. Better then that idiot against Wigan by all accounts.


Blimey. I thought I managed to get to SP tonight in the end. Turns out I must have been watching a different match. The one I saw had totally one sided refereeing that was truly shocking.

 

rchrd Flag The Heath 28 Jan 14 11.00pm

Got the big one correct, at this level it's really all that matters. So, good game.

 


Make haste, 'cause predators precede.

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 28 Jan 14 11.03pm

Ref was s***e for both sides. Missed some very bad challenges throughout the game. Whilst Hull were dirty our players held there own. Worst ref I have seen since Saturdays ref.

 

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 28 Jan 14 11.05pm

They were going nuts at the ref on Palace Player commentary!

Still, seems like we got the big decisions (no pen & red card), they got all the little ones. So we came out on top!

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Jan 14 11.29pm

Just shows the benefit of slow motion replays! I watched it on a streamed link and he got just about everything spot on. There were obviously occasions which were a matter of judgement but he didn't have a good game. He had a great game. The only real dispute I would have would be that Long should have been booked for simulation.

Having just read the report on this site, which seems to think that Hull should have been given a penalty I can assure you it was not. In real time, and at first, the commentators were convinced it was. In slow motion, and from a variety of angles, it was crystal clear that Long angled his legs into Gabbidon, who did not even attempt to tackle him.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 28 Jan 14 11.51pm

I was at the match and he seemed to give them everything.

ok he sent there w**ker off a a keeper i'll give him that.

 

SirPeanut Flag Keston 28 Jan 14 11.56pm

Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.

Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.

 


There are two kinds of person in this world:
1) Those who can extrapolate from incomplete data

FinchleyEagle Flag 28 Jan 14 11.57pm

He made a couple of decisions that were really strange, but agree he got the big decisions right. never a penalty in a million years and the lunatic keeper sealed his own fate.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

FinchleyEagle Flag 28 Jan 14 11.58pm

Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm

Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.

Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.

He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

EagleLee79 Flag Mablethorpe, Lincs 29 Jan 14 12.06am

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.58pm

Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm

Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.

Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.

He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.

I agree. At first it did look like a penalty which shows Shane Long being 'clever' and could have resulted in putting his side a goal up.

Unfortunately for him, the tv slo-mo replays show him getting infront of Gabbidon, falling across the defender whilst leaving a trailing leg to appear contact has been made.

Absolute correct decision and for that the ref must be applauded in my view. Should have booked Long for diving though but at least he got the main decision correct and isn't that what we all want from refs at the end of the game??


 


Add me on Xbox One or PS4 - Eaglelee79

SirPeanut Flag Keston 29 Jan 14 12.07am

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.58pm

Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm

Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.

Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.

He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.

I was about 10m away from the incident and when I got home I watched the highlights on sky. 9 times out of 10 that is given, because it was a penalty!

Put it this way, if that was Jerome being brought down in the box like that, everyone on here would be going mental.

 


There are two kinds of person in this world:
1) Those who can extrapolate from incomplete data

EagleLee79 Flag Mablethorpe, Lincs 29 Jan 14 12.13am

Quote SirPeanut at 29 Jan 2014 12.07am

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.58pm

Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm

Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.

Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.

He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.

I was about 10m away from the incident and when I got home I watched the highlights on sky. 9 times out of 10 that is given, because it was a penalty!

Put it this way, if that was Jerome being brought down in the box like that, everyone on here would be going mental.

I agree 9/10 a penalty would be given because in real-time it DID look like a penalty. As ive said if u analyse the slo-mo Long has tried to con the ref.

If it was Jerome who went down, sure i would be screaming for a penalty but after the game id have viewed it differently.

Anyway, chillout mate it werent a penalty and we won! Im sure we'll get a dodgy penalty given against us next week at Arsenal.


 


Add me on Xbox One or PS4 - Eaglelee79

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 29 Jan 14 12.14am

Quote SirPeanut at 29 Jan 2014 12.07am

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.58pm

Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm

Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.

Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.

He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.

I was about 10m away from the incident and when I got home I watched the highlights on sky. 9 times out of 10 that is given, because it was a penalty!

Put it this way, if that was Jerome being brought down in the box like that, everyone on here would be going mental.

It looked like a stonewall in realtime but if you still think it is penalty after looking at the replay from behind then I am astonished. Long and Gabbidon are running parallel and Long swerves across him and dives into his legs. Very clever but still a dirty cheating dive.

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > tonights Ref.