You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Unlucky players
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Unlucky players


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 18 Feb 14 1.44pm

The recent situation concerning Lee Hills, a fantastic player with a very good future never having a chance because of injury, and eventually having to give up the game brings to mind Martin Hinchelwood. His lesser talented brother Paul (Doris-bless him) became a very useful full-back and even made it into the England U21 side, a feat that would have easily have been duplicated by his brother. Could Jonesta be destined by the same providence? This is a blight on the game.

 

andysmithcpfc1983 Flag Selsdon 18 Feb 14 1.47pm

No chance and Lee Hills plays for Whitehawk

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 18 Feb 14 1.56pm

Quote andysmithcpfc1983 at 18 Feb 2014 1.47pm

No chance and Lee Hills plays for Whitehawk


Good to see Lee hasn't completely been lost to the game. As for young Jonathan, I hope you're right

 

andysmithcpfc1983 Flag Selsdon 18 Feb 14 2.12pm

Pulis has stated he has plans for him but wants him to get out on loan for regular 1st team football. Even if he did leave (although we turned down multiple permenent offers in January, so highly unlikely) I doubt he would have to give up football given that he is a full international player for Wales.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 18 Feb 14 3.50pm

Never rated Lee Hills.

Although I'm not the biggest fan of Joniesta, there's no way he'd end up at that level. Won't be the big star like some say, but I'd imagine he'll have a similar career to Sean Scannell, possibly a bit higher. Even with his injuries.

 

Hoof Hearted 18 Feb 14 4.14pm

I think Wilf Zaha is unlucky.

I believe he would have been banging in goals for us if he hadn't been shipped out to Manure.

Moyes has destroyed his confidence.

His first game for Cardiff was quite good, but the last two games he struggled.

If he had stayed at Palace he would be going to Brazil this summer - I doubt that he will now.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 18 Feb 14 5.02pm

Once Tom Ince came in, Jonny Williams was always going to get less game time which is why Pulis wants him to go out on loan. Though, regardless of whether we stay up or not, Ince will be off somewhere else and Williams can come back jn.

He needs to be played centrally, not out on the wing (Remember the impact he had in the centre against Watford when we came back from 2-0 down).

As for unlucky players, I don't remember him fully but I think Kevin Mabbutt never fulfilled his potential due to injury.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 18 Feb 14 5.10pm

Lee Hills thought he was big time. Poor attitude which is a shame as he could have played at a reasonable level.

As big a fan of Joniesta as I am, I am not sure how / where he fits in at the moment.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

ianevansleg Flag South Norwood 18 Feb 14 5.32pm

Absolutely bang on about Martin Hinshelwood he was destined for greater things.

two others I really rated Kevin Mabbutt(already mentioned) was on the verge of a 200k move to Arsenal(big money then) when he done his knee.

The other one of course is Mike Elweiss who scored some fantastic goals Newcastle and Leicester come to mind in our 78/79 promotion. I was at Cambridge when he got injured in the December on a dodgy frozen pitch sadly never played for us again.

 

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 18 Feb 14 7.25pm

Matt Clarke,goalkeper. Was good for us until(IIRC) he trod on broken glass on a night out and damaged his foot so badly he never played for us again. Ollie's Dad,Ash.

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

Robbiecpfc Flag Eltham 18 Feb 14 7.41pm

Quote OllieMaidstoneEagle at 18 Feb 2014 7.25pm

Matt Clarke,goalkeper. Was good for us until(IIRC) he trod on broken glass on a night out and damaged his foot so badly he never played for us again. Ollie's Dad,Ash.


Did he not have to retire due to knee ligament problems?

 

TulseHillEagle Flag Tulse Hill 18 Feb 14 9.39pm

Ben Watson.
Poor lad,has just broken his leg in the Wigan vs Barnsley game tonight. Similar injury last year. Pure bad luck.

 


Member of the Keith Millen Club. COYP

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 18 Feb 14 9.44pm

Quote Robbiecpfc at 18 Feb 2014 7.41pm

Quote OllieMaidstoneEagle at 18 Feb 2014 7.25pm

Matt Clarke,goalkeper. Was good for us until(IIRC) he trod on broken glass on a night out and damaged his foot so badly he never played for us again. Ollie's Dad,Ash.


Did he not have to retire due to knee ligament problems?


You may well have be correct Robbie,but pretty sure it was connected to the incident after a night out.Ollie's Dad, Ash.

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 19 Feb 14 12.01pm

Quote TulseHillEagle at 18 Feb 2014 9.39pm

Ben Watson.
Poor lad,has just broken his leg in the Wigan vs Barnsley game tonight. Similar injury last year. Pure bad luck.

Poor old Ben, injured again. The only bit lacking in his game was midfield bite, but he was an agressive player at youth level. SaW HIM V lORDSWOOD at 16 and he dominated the middle of the park with his tackling, but I suppose fear of injury inhibited his style. His passing was critisized, but I think this was due to the range and frequency of them. The passes that succeeded were remarkable.
Mabbutt and Elweisse also so unlucky, but they were like that when bought I believe, and the usual clever advice of the Palace staff couldn't make a difference here. Anton Outalowski (remember him?), was a crock, missold by the ooligans at Millwall, who was a hopeless case. He played against Palace and tore us apart. Blinded Palace ,who immedialtly wanted to sign him up. Millwall sure saw their chance!

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Feb 14 12.08pm

Totally agree re: Martin and Mick Elwiss. The other I'd add to the list, although he did make it a little further than those two, is John Salako. I believe Salad would have had a 50 cap England career minimum were it not for his serious injury. When he was hurt, he was very close to moving to Liverpool which, in my view, would have sprinboarded him to real greatness. He was the really genuine talent in the Bright/Wright/Thomas years.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Bin Liner Flag London , Southfields 19 Feb 14 12.17pm

I used to feel sorry for Neil Smillie, pacy tricky winger usually confined to the bench and unable to make a first team spot his own.

 


Portillo's teeth removed to boost pound

Boy roasts himself in sacrifice to Chris Kelly

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Feb 14 1.00pm

Quote Bin Liner at 19 Feb 2014 12.17pm

I used to feel sorry for Neil Smillie, pacy tricky winger usually confined to the bench and unable to make a first team spot his own.

One trick pony, though. He could knock the ball past anyone and win a foot race to it but the trouble is, once defenders figure out that's your only move they just play back off you and you cease to be effective. He had a haircut for his time, too!

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Hoof Hearted 19 Feb 14 1.06pm

Quote ianevansleg at 18 Feb 2014 5.32pm

Absolutely bang on about Martin Hinshelwood he was destined for greater things.

two others I really rated Kevin Mabbutt(already mentioned) was on the verge of a 200k move to Arsenal(big money then) when he done his knee.

The other one of course is Mike Elweiss who scored some fantastic goals Newcastle and Leicester come to mind in our 78/79 promotion. I was at Cambridge when he got injured in the December on a dodgy frozen pitch sadly never played for us again.

Kevin Mabbutt was rated more highly than his brother Gary.

 

HOLden Flag Grays: Essex 19 Feb 14 1.08pm

Matt Jansen - His good form led to an England call-up for the friendly game against Paraguay. However he missed out on what would be his only International football match for his nation due to a stomach bug.

Then of course, that motorcycle accident in Rome, Italy during the summer of 2002, which nearly killed Jansen and long-term hospitalisation followed (he spent sometime in a coma).

Geoff Thomas - Battle with Leukemia.

Neil Shipperley & Kevin Phillips - Both scored in Our last two P/O Finals, yet were rarely featured in the Premiership.
AJ - Not being selected for the 2006 World Cup!

 


................E
C' mon U GLAZIERS
................G
................L
................E$$ex by birth,
................Selhurst Park by the grace of god!
F0110w...@paulholden84

Only one Salako Flag London 19 Feb 14 1.29pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Feb 2014 12.08pm

Totally agree re: Martin and Mick Elwiss. The other I'd add to the list, although he did make it a little further than those two, is John Salako. I believe Salad would have had a 50 cap England career minimum were it not for his serious injury. When he was hurt, he was very close to moving to Liverpool which, in my view, would have sprinboarded him to real greatness. He was the really genuine talent in the Bright/Wright/Thomas years.


Too right, Salako could have had the left wing birth for years in that England set-up.

Can't feel Ben Watson is too unlucky, he did score a winning goal in an FA Cup final!

 


"they gave it everything, every ounce of blood, sweat and guts. They battled, they never ducked a challenge and, as their fans ripped their T-shirts off in the stands, creating the kind of heady atmosphere that has turned Selhurst Park into an amphitheatre" Matthew Syed

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Unlucky players