You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis' achievements
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pulis' achievements


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
BenHarrison Flag 25 Feb 14 1.26pm

Hi all,

Thought this article might be of interest.

[Link]

It discusses how most fans assess how well their club is doing, and proposes a different way of measuring success based on:

- wage spend
- transfer spend
- consistency of leadership
- experience of Premier League

Against all of these metrics, Pulis has been up against it, and yet has led Palace to way more points than anyone could have reasonably predicted.

Manager of the season if he keeps the team up?

B

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Feb 14 3.57pm

Quite agree - Fans have a perspective that is at odds with the real facts behind the club. Not least of all their financial capacity to compete.

This, I think, has somewhat masked Pulis achievements as a manager, because the eye of celebrity in football falls on trophies (so much so that arsenal fans were questioning Wenger's capability).

My guess* would be if you rationally broke down club achievements against a wider range of variables, you'd find Pulis and Martinez ranking up there with Wenger and Ferguson, as very successful, high achieving football managers.

Meanwhile clubs like Chelsea and Manchester City are praised to the high heavens, despite a revolving door management policy, because they can effectively buy competitiveness on a regular basis.

Could Fergie have achieved two league titles with Stoke City or Wigan? Would Marino won consecutive league titles with Palace? Of course not. Anyone could get a top two finish with Celtic or Rangers.

Time for a reprise. I think, we actually have one of the most successful managers in UK football at the moment. Of course, they don't because they don't win leagues, trophies or compete in the champions league.

Yet arguably Pulis and Martinez are probably the two most overachieving managers in the premier league.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

BenHarrison Flag 25 Feb 14 6.04pm

Hi Jamie,

Really interesting views, and having looked into this area, much in line with my own.

Would you be interested in perhaps writing a piece for Hit Row Z setting out why Martinez and Pulis are underrated?

On Palace having one of the best managers in the league, I think you could definitely make a case for it, and it is being played out on the pitch.

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 25 Feb 14 9.04pm

Quote BenHarrison at 25 Feb 2014 1.26pm

Hi all,

Thought this article might be of interest.

[Link]

It discusses how most fans assess how well their club is doing, and proposes a different way of measuring success based on:

- wage spend
- transfer spend
- consistency of leadership
- experience of Premier League

Against all of these metrics, Pulis has been up against it, and yet has led Palace to way more points than anyone could have reasonably predicted.

Manager of the season if he keeps the team up?

B


and if we go down?

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 25 Feb 14 9.21pm

I think most fans are aware that there is a general rule of thumb that dictates spend = league position in the premier league

I watched the game on Sat and found it largely devoid of excitement. We were in the game for an hour but i felt Man Utd were below par.

Southampton are the only team that consistently promote youngsters into their team and for teams like us who want to prosper i feel this is the only way we can compete

I watched the game on sat and thought shame williams was not involved. Somebody not afraid

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 25 Feb 14 9.57pm

Quote maxipalace at 25 Feb 2014 9.21pm
Southampton are the only team that consistently promote youngsters into their team and for teams like us who want to prosper i feel this is the only way we can compete

While in essence I agree with you here is the Southampton team from Saturday v West Ham:

Southampton
31 Boruc - Polish, played for Polish clubs before Southampton
22 Chambers - Academy Player
23 Shaw - Academy Player

04 Schneiderlin - French, played for Strasbourg before Southampton
06 Fonte - Portuguese, was at Palace
03 Yoshida - Japanese, played in Japan and Netherlands
09 Rodriguez - Started at Burnley before Southampton
18 Cork - Chelski
07 Lambert - Million and one clubs before southampton
08 Davis - Villa, Fulham, Rangers etc
20 Lallana - Bournemouth

That's 2 players out of the 11.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

maxipalace Flag in a box 25 Feb 14 10.07pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 25 Feb 2014 9.57pm

Quote maxipalace at 25 Feb 2014 9.21pm
Southampton are the only team that consistently promote youngsters into their team and for teams like us who want to prosper i feel this is the only way we can compete

While in essence I agree with you here is the Southampton team from Saturday v West Ham:

Southampton
31 Boruc - Polish, played for Polish clubs before Southampton
22 Chambers - Academy Player
23 Shaw - Academy Player

04 Schneiderlin - French, played for Strasbourg before Southampton
06 Fonte - Portuguese, was at Palace
03 Yoshida - Japanese, played in Japan and Netherlands
09 Rodriguez - Started at Burnley before Southampton
18 Cork - Chelski
07 Lambert - Million and one clubs before southampton
08 Davis - Villa, Fulham, Rangers etc
20 Lallana - Bournemouth

That's 2 players out of the 11.


Lallana - 3 he joined them aged 12!

Edited by maxipalace (25 Feb 2014 10.11pm)

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 25 Feb 14 10.15pm

Bah humbug.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

BenHarrison Flag 26 Feb 14 10.30am

Hi all,

I think the point is well made that fans get the link between finances and performance. What is probably less well appreciated is that it's wages, rather than net transfer spend that tends to most closely govern how well a team does.

And even then, it doesn't stop us from aiming for the moon!

Re the question of how well Pulis would have done should Palace go down, I still think the answer would be very well. By rights, that's where the club "should" finish, given the constraints it faces.

In my view putting up a strong fight, which he is doing, represents good performance. Achieving safety would be a significant over-performance.

But then, a big question looms. What should Palace do if they survive? Invest further?

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 26 Feb 14 11.10am

This is Pulis' record since he arrived;

Tony Pulis W7 D1 L8

That form, if carried on over an entire season, would see us finish on 50+ points so it's clear he's currently overachieving. By contrast, here is how three of the other contenders for the job have got on since they found clubs;

Aitor Karanka W6 D6 L6
Pepe Mel W0 D4 L3
Rene Meulensteen W3 D2 L9

Clearly Karanka's record is the only one even close and the pre-season expectation for Middlesbrough in their respective league was far higher than ours was.

So performance wise he is undoubtedly up there with the best in the league. Having said that, I don't really think you can compare someone managing a club trying to scrap for points to stay up with with someone like Mourinho who is expected to win the league. It's like a totally different job and David Moyes is an example of someone who can be fantastically successful at a certain level over a long period of time and then struggle after making the step up in size.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

BenHarrison Flag 26 Feb 14 2.37pm

That's also a great question - can managers work their way up the different levels in the Premier League?

Not many examples, but Moyes and Martinez would be two worth considering. Very different fortunes this season...

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 26 Feb 14 7.47pm

Quote BenHarrison at 26 Feb 2014 10.30am

Hi all,

I think the point is well made that fans get the link between finances and performance. What is probably less well appreciated is that it's wages, rather than net transfer spend that tends to most closely govern how well a team does.

And even then, it doesn't stop us from aiming for the moon!

Re the question of how well Pulis would have done should Palace go down, I still think the answer would be very well. By rights, that's where the club "should" finish, given the constraints it faces.

In my view putting up a strong fight, which he is doing, represents good performance. Achieving safety would be a significant over-performance.

But then, a big question looms. What should Palace do if they survive? Invest further?



The most cost effective route to success has come from our youth. Zaha got us up in the play offs. He wasnt the finished article but he gained a level of consistency through continuity ; same with Moses. Clyne was consistent from go. If we invest further then we may never see Innis or Kaikai in a palace kit. A sustainable model is a mixture.

I think the next 3 games against ball playing teams will give us an indication wether or not we will survive

 

BenHarrison Flag 26 Feb 14 10.16pm

Great point too re. youth development.

Challenge for most managers I suspect is that if the average tenure in the Premier League is now less than 18 months, how many of them believe they will get the chance to benefit from investing in youth?

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 26 Feb 14 11.07pm

Quote BenHarrison at 26 Feb 2014 10.16pm

Great point too re. youth development.

Challenge for most managers I suspect is that if the average tenure in the Premier League is now less than 18 months, how many of them believe they will get the chance to benefit from investing in youth?


if you put a 2 million bonus in a managers contract to stay up and then spend a million securing Ince on loan; assume it comes with a garauntee to start. That is short term!

If premier football comes at the expense of seeing the next generation coming through then for me it is wasted ; and it becomes irelevant whether we stay up. Williams loan pretty much confirms that outcome for me

 

BenHarrison Flag 07 Mar 14 3.35pm

I suppose it is about building a platform to develop from though no?

Staying in the Premier League this season is worth so much money it's incredible. For better or for worse, the development of the whole club Palace can do with those funds would be significantly more than if they went down.

Do you expect to stay up given recent results?

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 Mar 14 3.52pm

Really football is too short term for managers to be successful, except where they are kept on because of success (Wenger, Fergie). Think of a manager suggesting a larger stadium to accommodate larger gates to get bigger receipts, to pay attractive wages. Then, the team gets relegated and within a few years they are out of the league (Luton). What is his incentive to improve the stadium? Apply the same set of facts to improving the academy, getting in more scouts, buying better players. With the trap door nature of our leagues there is no incentive for anyone to do more than the most conservative things for fear of losing it all. Maybe we should be looking to set up the game in the American manner. Then all those factors mentioned in this thread could be pursued with confidence.

 

BenHarrison Flag 07 Mar 14 4.03pm

How do you mean "the american manner" Adrian?

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 Mar 14 4.37pm

Quote BenHarrison at 07 Mar 2014 4.03pm

How do you mean "the american manner" Adrian?


Well they have a system of two main league that all the major teams buy a franchise into. This costs them quite a bit each season, but it's based on a team owning at least one 40,000 stadium, getting full houses, having to sign players from minor leagues, veterans or in rote for the best college players. No one team can buy all the 'top' players and wages are controlled as part of the club turn-over. The only way a team loses its place in the league is due to not providing the above thresholds. Teams can move to places where they can sell more 'seats'. But its agreed on a league basis, taking all members into account, no two teams in a town that couldn't support the two. And each team will get some success in due course. It takes a bit of the giant-killer out of it, but it does make the sport much stronger. When you watch the Super Bowl, every player is a millionair. There are rebates for teams at the season end if they have reached the figures of business adequacy.

 

est1905 Flag 07 Mar 14 6.30pm

Quote adrian b at 07 Mar 2014 4.37pm

Quote BenHarrison at 07 Mar 2014 4.03pm

How do you mean "the american manner" Adrian?


Well they have a system of two main league that all the major teams buy a franchise into. This costs them quite a bit each season, but it's based on a team owning at least one 40,000 stadium, getting full houses, having to sign players from minor leagues, veterans or in rote for the best college players. No one team can buy all the 'top' players and wages are controlled as part of the club turn-over. The only way a team loses its place in the league is due to not providing the above thresholds. Teams can move to places where they can sell more 'seats'. But its agreed on a league basis, taking all members into account, no two teams in a town that couldn't support the two. And each team will get some success in due course. It takes a bit of the giant-killer out of it, but it does make the sport much stronger. When you watch the Super Bowl, every player is a millionair. There are rebates for teams at the season end if they have reached the figures of business adequacy.

How dull!


 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 07 Mar 14 10.01pm

If we end up relegated at the end of the season Pulis will still have done a good job considering the position we were in when he took over. At the time I couldn't see us overtaking Derby's record low points tally. I would question why Bannan is no longer considered good enough but apart from that if we finish on 35 points or more it has to be considered a massive achievement..

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis' achievements