This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Jedinak
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 15 Mar 14 5.19pm |
|
|
Seems to be getting worse and worse. Halts our counters by giving the ball straight back to them. Frustrates me.
|
Eagletistical Hereford 15 Mar 14 5.25pm |
|
|
Yeah he does give the ball away but he is vital when it comes to breaking up attacks and winning headers and tackles.
The problem is playing him and KG together, neither can pass a ball which is why possession is so poor. What Jedinak lacks in areas he makes up for in other areas. KG is simply awful. Looks off the pace and doesn't offer anything going forward or defensively. The only positive if we do go down is that he will be back at his level! I would much rather start with Guedioura alongside Mile.
Back to the original point though, Jedinak is key and should be the first name on the teamsheet
|
barrie2301 crystal palace 15 Mar 14 5.37pm |
|
|
Since we have started playing three defensive minded midfielders in jedi, kg and ledley we have looked s***. tired of watching the f***ing ball being humped up in the air in the hope of trying to find the 1 lone attacker...
|
slogdosh Munich 15 Mar 14 5.43pm |
|
|
He's lived off this 'great play breaker' rep too long. He does do that very well, but the rest of his game is bad and getting worse. He needs to start stepping up as skip and senior player.
Can't pass, silly fouls and you see how many of the goals we've conceeded come from midfield runners not tracked by him or KG. Oh, and for the love of God, please stop taking free kicks!
|
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 15 Mar 14 5.52pm |
|
Quote slogdosh at 15 Mar 2014 5.43pm
He's lived off this 'great play breaker' rep too long. He does do that very well, but the rest of his game is bad and getting worse. He needs to start stepping up as skip and senior player.
Can't pass, silly fouls and you see how many of the goals we've conceeded come from midfield runners not tracked by him or KG. Oh, and for the love of God, please stop taking free kicks!
This all day long he wouldn't have to break up play so much if he didn't give it away.
|
robdave2k 15 Mar 14 5.57pm |
|
|
Every team needs that break up player. The original "personification" of this is Makalele.
The break up player is only as good as who he gives the ball to. KG, at the risk of sounding racist, is a big white elephant. Doesn't seem to fulfill any role.
|
Gyro1780 Leatherhead, Surrey 15 Mar 14 5.59pm |
|
Quote EastEndPalace at 15 Mar 2014 5.52pm
Quote slogdosh at 15 Mar 2014 5.43pm
He's lived off this 'great play breaker' rep too long. He does do that very well, but the rest of his game is bad and getting worse. He needs to start stepping up as skip and senior player.
Can't pass, silly fouls and you see how many of the goals we've conceeded come from midfield runners not tracked by him or KG. Oh, and for the love of God, please stop taking free kicks!
This all day long he wouldn't have to break up play so much if he didn't give it away.
Also agree with everything said here.
|
EverybodyDannsNow SE19 15 Mar 14 6.10pm |
|
|
Very harsh, I thought he had a decent game today all things considered. Won us a few dangerous free kicks, as broke up play as well as ever.
Strange to criticise him for commiting fouls, I think it's an important part of his job to do so, he stops the flow of a lot of moves before they become dangerous in doing this.
|
Dangermouse Hastings 15 Mar 14 6.14pm |
|
|
Jedi is no worse than he's ever been at short passing in my opinion. In this team though he is not exactly alone in this department. Defenders just hoof it up field and give it away, the wingers are being dispossessed far too easily, the centre forward fails continually to hold it up, though in fairness he is often on his own and the midfield have absolutely no composure on the ball. So if you drop Jedi, you have to drop them all.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
blind eagle Covington.Tennessee 15 Mar 14 6.21pm |
|
Quote robdave2k at 15 Mar 2014 5.57pm
Every team needs that break up player. The original "personification" of this is Makalele.
The break up player is only as good as who he gives the ball to. KG, at the risk of sounding racist, is a big white elephant. Doesn't seem to fulfill any role.
No KG is now a liability and needs to be replaced. I think Pulis has two very serious problem areas. Up front and mid field. Honestly I could not make a suggestion that would solve these problems because we are totally threadbare of players when it comes to these positions.
|
IAG828 Pewsey 15 Mar 14 6.29pm |
|
|
I thought we looked far better with Guedioura. And jerome on. Added a bit of forward momentum - KG was dreadful and Ince looked lost
|
cpj Kent 15 Mar 14 6.33pm |
|
Quote blind eagle at 15 Mar 2014 6.21pm
Quote robdave2k at 15 Mar 2014 5.57pm
Every team needs that break up player. The original "personification" of this is Makalele.
The break up player is only as good as who he gives the ball to. KG, at the risk of sounding racist, is a big white elephant. Doesn't seem to fulfill any role.
No KG is now a liability and needs to be replaced. I think Pulis has two very serious problem areas. Up front and mid field. Honestly I could not make a suggestion that would solve these problems because we are totally threadbare of players when it comes to these positions.
Which is incredible given the number of players in those positions that we've signed since last summer. Quantity over quality has proved to be the case.
|
Geoff Thomas Tonbridge - 15 Mar 14 6.37pm |
|
|
Ledley has really dissapointed me, I was quite excited by him as a signing but not sure what he adds or what position he is actually playing in? Perhaps thats the issue does he know himself? Playing with nine behind the ball is not good to watch or look like getting us goals or more imprtantly wins. Something has to change and fast.
GT
Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls, La La La La,! La La La La!
|
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 15 Mar 14 6.43pm |
|
Quote Geoff Thomas at 15 Mar 2014 6.37pm
Ledley has really dissapointed me, I was quite excited by him as a signing but not sure what he adds or what position he is actually playing in? Perhaps thats the issue does he know himself? Playing with nine behind the ball is not good to watch or look like getting us goals or more imprtantly wins. Something has to change and fast.
GT
Ledley is much better then KG and Jedi. He spends half of his time having to clean up Jedi and KG's s*** rather then doing what he wants to which is creating.
|
madpalacefan Bradford, 248.4(ish) miles from Se... 15 Mar 14 8.02pm |
|
|
Back from the game, Jedi was poor today. His passing is none existent On another note I thought Dann played great. Liking him a lot. Think it's time to maybe rest Jedi for 1 and see if he. Comes back stronger. Hard I know but he's not great at moment
Remembering staffie for ever!, a gentleman and true great. unfortunately the HOL will never be the same without him.
|
big_palace_fan 15 Mar 14 8.06pm |
|
|
Say what you like about Jedinak's passing ability etc. but we would not be where we are without him. I might even say we wouldn't have broken Derby's points tally, he is simply that important to the team.
We play a defensive style (the fact not the ideal) and he is one of the best defensive midfielders in the league statistically.
Also out captain and leader
Bear in mind he wins practically every header also.
A powerhouse in midfield, all the problems lie in KG, can't pass, is overwieght and doesnt do anything
|
Dangermouse Hastings 15 Mar 14 8.27pm |
|
|
I have never been KG's biggest fan, but I also will not blame one player for all the ills in the side. As a footballer he is no worse than 90% of the others and as a worker he does what the others do otherwise he wouldn't be consistently picked. He also isn't overweight, otherwise again he wouldn't be picked and if you are telling me TP picks an overweight player and allows him to be so then surely the manager must be sacked as a matter of fact. Pulis would never allow it, so come on cut out the weight s***e as it clearly ain't true. He wouldn't be in my team, but I don't pick the team.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
big_palace_fan 15 Mar 14 8.30pm |
|
Quote Dangermouse at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm
I have never been KG's biggest fan, but I also will not blame one player for all the ills in the side. As a footballer he is no worse than 90% of the others and as a worker he does what the others do otherwise he wouldn't be consistently picked. He also isn't overweight, otherwise again he wouldn't be picked and if you are telling me TP picks an overweight player and allows him to be so then surely the manager must be sacked as a matter of fact. Pulis would never allow it, so come on cut out the weight s***e as it clearly ain't true. He wouldn't be in my team, but I don't pick the team.
I forgot KG was the picture of health, always has tonnes of running in him, he's normally everywhere on the pithc
|
Dangermouse Hastings 15 Mar 14 8.41pm |
|
Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.30pm
Quote Dangermouse at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm
I have never been KG's biggest fan, but I also will not blame one player for all the ills in the side. As a footballer he is no worse than 90% of the others and as a worker he does what the others do otherwise he wouldn't be consistently picked. He also isn't overweight, otherwise again he wouldn't be picked and if you are telling me TP picks an overweight player and allows him to be so then surely the manager must be sacked as a matter of fact. Pulis would never allow it, so come on cut out the weight s***e as it clearly ain't true. He wouldn't be in my team, but I don't pick the team.
I forgot KG was the picture of health, always has tonnes of running in him, he's normally everywhere on the pithc
So you are saying that KG is overweight, allowed to be so and being regularly picked by the manager in spite of this?
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
big_palace_fan 15 Mar 14 8.47pm |
|
Quote Dangermouse at 15 Mar 2014 8.41pm
Quote big_palace_fan at 15 Mar 2014 8.30pm
Quote Dangermouse at 15 Mar 2014 8.27pm
I have never been KG's biggest fan, but I also will not blame one player for all the ills in the side. As a footballer he is no worse than 90% of the others and as a worker he does what the others do otherwise he wouldn't be consistently picked. He also isn't overweight, otherwise again he wouldn't be picked and if you are telling me TP picks an overweight player and allows him to be so then surely the manager must be sacked as a matter of fact. Pulis would never allow it, so come on cut out the weight s***e as it clearly ain't true. He wouldn't be in my team, but I don't pick the team.
I forgot KG was the picture of health, always has tonnes of running in him, he's normally everywhere on the pithc
So you are saying that KG is overweight, allowed to be so and being regularly picked by the manager in spite of this?
Yes, he simply looks overly heavy on his feet. Compare his to Southamptons midfielders last week who were just as strong but far leaner. How many other footballers of KG's build can you think of playing in central midfield in the premier league?
|