You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Woeful...
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Woeful...


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
PJH Flag Colchester 17 Mar 14 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.

 

Mstrobez Flag 17 Mar 14 9.45am

We got a point away against a team who on paper is stronger than us.

Rant over.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

FinchleyEagle Flag 17 Mar 14 9.52am

Mate, it unusual to have a seemingly knee-jerk reaction 2 days later. You need to let it go a bit, this has been done to death in other threads.

And in Borini and Johnson they have 2 potential match-winners that we (just about) managed to keep quiet.

They boo-ed their team at the end, we've got a hard won point.

Job done I reckon.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Plane Flag Bromley 17 Mar 14 9.59am

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Oh great! Yet another bollox thread that regurgitates exactly the same cr@p as all the other cr@p threads, well done.

Mods, any chance of merging this with other twenty million treads with the same content?

 

PJH Flag Colchester 17 Mar 14 10.06am

Quote FinchleyEagle at 17 Mar 2014 9.52am

Mate, it unusual to have a seemingly knee-jerk reaction 2 days later. You need to let it go a bit, this has been done to death in other threads.

And in Borini and Johnson they have 2 potential match-winners that we (just about) managed to keep quiet.

They boo-ed their team at the end, we've got a hard won point.

Job done I reckon.

As I sad, the defence played well.

 

Username Flag Horsham 17 Mar 14 10.08am

We ended the weekend 3 points above the drop, and denied one of our biggest rivals what would surely have been viewed as an essential 3 points.


Edited by Username (17 Mar 2014 2.25pm)

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

PJH Flag Colchester 17 Mar 14 10.09am

Quote Plane at 17 Mar 2014 9.59am

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Oh great! Yet another bollox thread that regurgitates exactly the same cr@p as all the other cr@p threads, well done.

Mods, any chance of merging this with other twenty million treads with the same content?


So no valid points then. Haven't read any other posts..wanted to have my ten pennysworth first. Last I'll say on the matter is I think we can do better and hate to see us play like that in a game we could have won, cos we're running out of games and still need 3 wins IMO.

Thank you and goodnight.

 

aburton Flag Cornwall 17 Mar 14 10.10am

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


All weekend? Really? Time to get a life mate.

 


[Link]

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 17 Mar 14 10.50am

I know where the OP is coming from and he isnt really wrong...but...1 point away from home anywhere is a good.

The mackems expected to whip our jacksies and have the players to do it...but they didn't.

We needed to whip their jacksies but we cant score.

So we ended up with a stalemate,didnt really do either side any good but better for us than them.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Mar 14 11.00am

I think Jedinak is looking tired. He's put in some immense shifts this season, but I think his performances recently haven't been of the standard he'd set himself previously.

Bolasie has little end product. Very frustrating because he looks the part until it comes to decision making where he is quite hopeless at times.

KG - pretty unconvincing and I think it's time to look at other options. Shocking miss on Saturday and highlights the fact that we have zero goal threat from midfield.

It's tough for the manager. I think his first thoughts are to avoid defeat rather than going out to win games, and I assume that he thinks that's the correct approach given the group of players that he has.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

silvertop Flag Portishead 17 Mar 14 11.46am

Quote NEILLO at 17 Mar 2014 11.00am

I think Jedinak is looking tired. He's put in some immense shifts this season, but I think his performances recently haven't been of the standard he'd set himself previously.

Bolasie has little end product. Very frustrating because he looks the part until it comes to decision making where he is quite hopeless at times.

KG - pretty unconvincing and I think it's time to look at other options. Shocking miss on Saturday and highlights the fact that we have zero goal threat from midfield.

It's tough for the manager. I think his first thoughts are to avoid defeat rather than going out to win games, and I assume that he thinks that's the correct approach given the group of players that he has.


Bannan

And possibly...

Ince - if we can extract from him the talent he clearly has.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Mar 14 12.15pm

A point away is always a good result for us. Recent away history for CPFC 2010 has always been poor, last season was probably our best since the Administration season.

And we were still all about our home record. Sometimes I wonder if people actually think we're a different club.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 Mar 14 12.25pm

One point away in PL is always a good point, but my God we were terrible from midfield upwards. And yes, our captain gives away the ball far too easily. Please don't deny the facts anyone (and I love this club as any given holmsdaler)

 

Taggy7590 Flag Northern Ireland 17 Mar 14 12.31pm

I've said before a few months ago when Jedinak was looking tired to give him a rest so he could recharge the batteries and I was lambasted for it.

Yes, resting your captain would give the impression that the manger has no faith in him but IMO we have to be realistic.
Do we keep playing him again teams which realistically we might not get points off meaning that he will be tired for the big 6 pointers in which we can get points?!

I'm not having a go at him but maybe giving him a rest would also send the message out that nobody position is guaranteed in the team thus making them fight for their position.

Thoughts?

 

Plane Flag Bromley 17 Mar 14 1.09pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 10.09am

Quote Plane at 17 Mar 2014 9.59am

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Oh great! Yet another bollox thread that regurgitates exactly the same cr@p as all the other cr@p threads, well done.

Mods, any chance of merging this with other twenty million treads with the same content?


So no valid points then. Haven't read any other posts..wanted to have my ten pennysworth first. Last I'll say on the matter is I think we can do better and hate to see us play like that in a game we could have won, cos we're running out of games and still need 3 wins IMO.

Thank you and goodnight.

About as valid as yours.

 

PJH Flag Colchester 17 Mar 14 1.24pm

Quote Plane at 17 Mar 2014 1.09pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 10.09am

Quote Plane at 17 Mar 2014 9.59am

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Oh great! Yet another bollox thread that regurgitates exactly the same cr@p as all the other cr@p threads, well done.

Mods, any chance of merging this with other twenty million treads with the same content?


So no valid points then. Haven't read any other posts..wanted to have my ten pennysworth first. Last I'll say on the matter is I think we can do better and hate to see us play like that in a game we could have won, cos we're running out of games and still need 3 wins IMO.

Thank you and goodnight.

About as valid as yours.


Sorry, had to answer that.Er I meant you don't think I have any valid points ? (you really didn't make any except slag my post off !!) If you don't agree with the points I made, then great, that's what this forum's all about isn't it...different opinions ? Or I guess in your book 'bollux thread' is a valid and intelligent point ? Answer that one Einstein....

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 17 Mar 14 4.59pm

It was pretty ugly. However, our goal is to finish in 17th place with one more point than the team in 18th. So we took a step in the right direction. I think you have to realise that the sole mission from here on in is to avoid the relegation zone and every week we are not in 18th place or lower is a time to be happy. Next season is the time to worry about points for artistic merit. Not now.

With that said:

The tactics were spot on. We got on a point and prevented a direct opponent from getting three (at home). And we did it by sticking to a system the players are now familiar with. Not pretty, but no complaints. But I do totally agree with you about Bannan. He could fit into the tactics and his creativity would help.

Jedinak. I agree with you. What you are now seeing is why he wasn't picked up by a top team before he came to Palace. In one dimension, his game is brilliant. But that is not enough to play at the very top. And in other dimensions, like passing, his game is rank poor.

Don't agree with you about Yannick, but sort of do about KG. Not really a Premiership player. To me, the Jedi-KG axis is why we've scored so few goals this season despite being defensively robust; there is no fulcrum of creativity from which to launch attacks. I would have Ledley and Bannan in there myself.

Defence: easily Mariappa's best game for Palace.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Mar 14 5.15pm

Quote PJH at 17 Mar 2014 9.41am

I've been stewing on this all weekend and it's time to face facts. We're going down. And we're going down bottom of the pile unless something changes.

What were the tactics for Saturday ? Bearing in mind we were playing a team in the bottom three with an awful home record (albeit better than ours away !). Surely this was a game where 3 points were there for the taking. I guess anyone can argue that 1 point is a means to an end but the simple truth is that if we don't score we're not going to get a point every time.Bannan not even on the bench ? Is he injured or is he sh*gging TP's daughter ?

Also :

Jedders : WTF is going on with him ? What is the point of having a 'ball winning' midfielder if he just gives it straight back to them to have another go ? The guy cannot pass for toffee whether it be 30 yards or three. It's got to be the worst passing performance I've seen in a Palace shirt since the days of Neil Emblen (yes, THAT bad !). I'm sorry but if by some miracle we stay up TP will be offloading him. You simply cannot have a player who gives the ball away so consistently.

Yannick : All bluster and pace but flatters to deceive and is quite frankly a liability when he get near their 18 yard box and is coming across to me as all mouth and trousers. To be fair, tackles back very well and puts in a proper shift.

KG : Have defended him for ages but I'm afraid after Saturday he's worn me down. Not good enough, and I was saying that before he blasted the ball wide from 2 yards out near the end.

Positives :

Jules : Outstanding as usual. two great saves (one was offside, but he wasn't to know that).

Defence. Outstanding also, especially as both full backs booked in the first 15 which could have made for a long afternoon if one of them had picked up another yellow. They must get well p*ssed off that they're doing their but but we can't create anything up the other end.

Answers ? No idea, but we have to treat each game differently surely. If it had been Anfield, fair enough, but we need to be more of a threat, and we'll need to be also at Cardiff, West Ham and Fulham or our season is just going to fade away.

You are in my heart Palace and I love you deeply. Always have, always will but jesus christ you make me sooo angry sometimes !.

Rant over.


Mate, we are one of 3 promoted teams - we weren't even convincingly promoted - we were the 6th best team in the league and were a game away from not even making 6th.

Sunderland, although having a bad season, are an established, premiership team!

Our line up in terms of experience is probably the least and our squad overall was a mess due to Holloway. Things could have been so much different had we started the season in a more 'experienced' manner, but hey, it's done...

I have beef with a lot of things, but it isn't over until the whistle goes at fulham.

This season has been a random one, look at United, Liverpool, the way cardiff have suffered with the board - west ham were poor, we were poor, sunderlad were poor, norwich look in trouble. We just need to ignore the what ifs and treat each game as a new one.

 


This was once a quality forum....

JeffBourne Flag 17 Mar 14 6.36pm

Have to agree with the OP.

The overall picture is to stay up, but Sunderland had to be one of our targets for 3 points as realistically we are not going to pick up too many other points until the end of the season.

By not attempting to get 3 points against a very poor Sunderland team, it means that we will most probably have to get 3 points against more difficult opposition to give ourselves a chance of staying up.

Many have defended the way we played saying that we are not as established as Sunderland, and we do not have such good players. I disagree with this and believe that our players should have been instilled with confidence and a game plan to attack Sunderland.

Instead we just sat back and let a terrible team come on to us.

I really don't think Pulis even contemplated any attacking, as the players had no idea what to do when they got over the half way line.

A point gained but 2 lost in my opinion.

UP THE PALACE!

 


A new era of total football is on the way to Selhurst Park!!

arthur_wait Flag 17 Mar 14 8.32pm

Was a terrible game to watch, especially after going all that way. But the tactics worked almost to perfection. Stop them scoring, tire them out, then pounce for a last-minute winner. As I said, almost perfect!

Edited by arthur_wait (17 Mar 2014 8.33pm)

 


All-knowing, all-seeing

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Woeful...