This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Howard Webb, hero
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
peterg Anerley 01 Apr 14 8.38am |
|
|
Fresh from his scintillating display at Selhurst Park, our favourite ref denied Sunderland a clear penalty for hand-ball last night. Keep up the good work, Howard!
The right place at the right time
|
skj Bedale, North Yorkshire (Ex-Carsha... 01 Apr 14 8.46am |
|
|
To be fair to him he was blind side to the offence and he didn't get help from his assistant. Not sure how anyone would have given handball from his position on the field.
|
malbigeagle Rainham, Kent 01 Apr 14 10.35am |
|
|
There speaks a fellow referee skj ???
|
| Hoof Hearted 01 Apr 14 10.37am |
|
Quote skj at 01 Apr 2014 8.46am
To be fair to him he was blind side to the offence and he didn't get help from his assistant. Not sure how anyone would have given handball from his position on the field.
Nolan's elbow moved that far forward Webb would have easily seen it as well as the lineo and the whole ground!. I cannot imagine why he didn't give it.
Our good fortune, and Sunderland's bad luck.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 01 Apr 14 11.07am |
|
|
Webb is still a bad ref and a cvnt. He's too interested in how making big decisions will affect his image and reputation and is a bottle job too. Nothing to do with helping any side out. Just a cvnt.
3 decisions stand out this season. Us, Suarez being clattered into in the corner of the penalty box at The Emirates coffee lounge and the blatant handball last night at Sunderland.
He should be taken off the fixture list for a while but the FA would never do that to their supposedly best ref. This is the ref who lost control of the World Cup Final and was only in it because his country having one of the top leagues was knocked out early enough and expected to be.
COYP
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Apr 14 11.23am |
|
Quote Rudi Hedman at 01 Apr 2014 11.07am
Webb is still a bad ref
It is ridiculous to term a FIFA ref a "Bad ref".Yes, ALL refs make mistakes like we all do in life.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 01 Apr 14 11.26am |
|
Quote Willo at 01 Apr 2014 11.23am
Quote Rudi Hedman at 01 Apr 2014 11.07am
Webb is still a bad ref
It is ridiculous to term a FIFA ref a "Bad ref".Yes, ALL refs make mistakes like we all do in life.
A ref who lets the players boss him in a World Cup Final whould never be there in the first place. He sees big incidents happen and chooses to ignore them. That is why he is a bad ref. A good ref will see what everyone else sees and give the decision, regardless of stage, venue, opposition, live on tv, whatever it is.
COYP
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 01 Apr 14 11.54am |
|
|
Always strike me that he seems to be of the opinion that Howard Webb is the main attraction on the pitch.
|
bubble wrap Carparks in South East London 01 Apr 14 12.01pm |
|
Quote Willo at 01 Apr 2014 11.23am
Quote Rudi Hedman at 01 Apr 2014 11.07am
Webb is still a bad ref
It is ridiculous to term a FIFA ref a "Bad ref".Yes, ALL refs make mistakes like we all do in life.
Prefer the term "s*** Ref" and he deserves that tag.
Edited by bubble wrap (01 Apr 2014 12.01pm)
|
PJH Colchester 01 Apr 14 12.29pm |
|
|
Nolan might've well have picked the ball up. Webb was 10 feet away in clear sight and didn't give it..pathetic, but thank you all the same Howard. shocking decision, or non decision should I say.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Apr 14 1.36pm |
|
Quote Rudi Hedman at 01 Apr 2014 11.26am
A good ref will see what everyone else sees and give the decision, regardless of stage, venue, opposition, live on tv, whatever it is.
I certainly do not accept that Webb makes decisions on the bases you have described.He is a FIFA ref and as such it is ridiculous to term him a "Bad ref".Yes he like other refs are only human and as such will make mistakes but to reach the standard he has reached (FIFA) means that he has achieved excellent marks over a period of time. He has got to the top of his profession for a good reason.
Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2014 1.51pm)
|
cols123 beckenham 01 Apr 14 2.15pm |
|
Quote bubble wrap at 01 Apr 2014 12.01pm
Quote Willo at 01 Apr 2014 11.23am
Quote Rudi Hedman at 01 Apr 2014 11.07am
Webb is still a bad ref
It is ridiculous to term a FIFA ref a "Bad ref".Yes, ALL refs make mistakes like we all do in life.
Prefer the term "s*** Ref" and he deserves that tag.
Edited by bubble wrap (01 Apr 2014 12.01pm)
I prefer to stick to the facts and call him a Bald ref
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 01 Apr 14 2.23pm |
|
|
I saw the game on telly and wondered who the ref was who could not have seen that clear penalty. Should have known. Perhaps, like so many 'good' refs, he was evening things up
|
Plumpton eagle East Sussex 01 Apr 14 3.03pm |
|
|
I think that he has got caught up with his own reputation. I suspect that he wants to be the ref that gives out fewest reds, awards fewest contentious penalties and does not upset the managers of the very top teams. He may then believe that makes him the best referee.
This is only my opinion. I do not have great insight or psychology qualifications. However, I did see him fail to award a clear penalty that he had a perfect view of from very close by. There have been other similar incidents this season.
I don't think that he is a cheat or deliberately sets out to engineer results. But I do think that he has become obsessed with his self image and desire to avoid contention.
|
blind eagle Covington.Tennessee 01 Apr 14 4.48pm |
|
Quote Plumpton eagle at 01 Apr 2014 3.03pm
I think that he has got caught up with his own reputation. I suspect that he wants to be the ref that gives out fewest reds, awards fewest contentious penalties and does not upset the managers of the very top teams. He may then believe that makes him the best referee.
This is only my opinion. I do not have great insight or psychology qualifications. However, I did see him fail to award a clear penalty that he had a perfect view of from very close by. There have been other similar incidents this season.
I don't think that he is a cheat or deliberately sets out to engineer results. But I do think that he has become obsessed with his self image and desire to avoid contention.
Well once you get obsessed with your self image and desire to avoid contention as a ref or in any other job I think you are farther down the slimy slope to mediocrity than many people realize . Certainly his performance was from stellar at Selhurst.!.
|
| Hoof Hearted 01 Apr 14 5.09pm |
|
|
Webb reminds me of Graham Poll.... the clown that didn't realise he had dished out 3 yellow cards to the same player.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Apr 14 6.11pm |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 Apr 2014 5.09pm
Webb reminds me of Graham Poll.... the clown that didn't realise he had dished out 3 yellow cards to the same player.
Yes Poll made a major error but it is unfair to term him a "Clown".Can we not pass comment without resorting to personal insults ?
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 01 Apr 14 6.17pm |
|
Quote Willo at 01 Apr 2014 1.36pm
Quote Rudi Hedman at 01 Apr 2014 11.26am
A good ref will see what everyone else sees and give the decision, regardless of stage, venue, opposition, live on tv, whatever it is.
I certainly do not accept that Webb makes decisions on the bases you have described.He is a FIFA ref and as such it is ridiculous to term him a "Bad ref".Yes he like other refs are only human and as such will make mistakes but to reach the standard he has reached (FIFA) means that he has achieved excellent marks over a period of time. He has got to the top of his profession for a good reason.
Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2014 1.51pm)
You talk like "FIFA" is some gold standard of probity and competence. The fact that FIFA is a maelstrom of greed, nepotism, bribery and corruption means that Webb's status as a "FIFA ref" has about as much credibility as anything Sepp Blatter has ever said.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 01 Apr 14 6.18pm |
|
Quote Willo at 01 Apr 2014 6.11pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 Apr 2014 5.09pm
Webb reminds me of Graham Poll.... the clown that didn't realise he had dished out 3 yellow cards to the same player.
Yes Poll made a major error but it is unfair to term him a "Clown".Can we not pass comment without resorting to personal insults ?
I can think of a lot worse insults for referees than that willo.
Blind, stupid, biased, cheating c*nt, for instance.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
Mapletree Croydon 01 Apr 14 6.20pm |
|
Quote Willo at 01 Apr 2014 6.11pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 01 Apr 2014 5.09pm
Webb reminds me of Graham Poll.... the clown that didn't realise he had dished out 3 yellow cards to the same player.
Yes Poll made a major error but it is unfair to term him a "Clown".Can we not pass comment without resorting to personal insults ?
Totally unfair on Charlton fans.
|