This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Glenn Murray
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
hcjbrooks 29 Apr 14 4.27am |
|
|
Having lauded his praises last year its sad to see Glen has not the pace to be effective in the Premiership,His cruciate injury has been a killer blow--such a terrible injury to totally recover from.With next season in mind CPFC should thank Murray and sell him to enhance their coffers--he will do a fine job for a championship club if he remains fit.Your views....
|
deleted9 29 Apr 14 7.04am |
|
|
I agree. Whilst he was a great servant in the Championship, it is quitr clear he isn't going to be the striker we need to push us on. We're advancing as a club and sometimes you have to move on. I think Murray is a good striker but the Championship is his limit. I'd hate for it to get to the stage where it became embarrasing for him and a waste of time being at Palace a I can't see him getting much football with us next season.
Should go to a team like Ipswich, Middlesboro or Forest and help them kick on as well.
|
norwayeagle Trondheim 29 Apr 14 7.05am |
|
|
Agreed. No room or time to be romantic in PL..
|
south coast eagle Rustington West Sussex 29 Apr 14 7.36am |
|
|
Wow The man has had hardly any game time in a side that plays the same sort of football as when he first came to the club and scored about half a dozen. Get two decent wingers/wingbacks who can cross a ball and he would score goals.
Personally i would have him in front Chamakh and Jerome. Jerome has pace and strength but cant hit a cow's bum with a banjo. Chamakh might have some nice touches but dont tell me he is better in the air than Murray or indeed quicker and i know Murray aint that fast either.
Forever Palace
|
WelshEagle London 29 Apr 14 7.39am |
|
|
Completely disagree. Nothing to do with being romantic, rather just sensible and not a kneejerk moron. Glen hasn't had a chance to prove himself at this level yet. Feed him and he will score goals IMO. Selling him after a few bench appearances would be insane.
|
Baldfella Wigan 29 Apr 14 7.42am |
|
|
Anybody that thought he was going to hit the ground running in the short time he was fully fit this season were expecting way too much ! If he can keep working on his fitness and strength throughout the summer and get a full pre season in I think he will prove a lot more of a goal threat next season. That's not clouded by sentiment it's a fact ! People can't judge a player that has never played in the "best league in the world" that's is probably only now nearing full fitness.
As for pace, he's a goal scorer and a poacher he isn't going to be playing off a defenders shoulder waiting to run onto a ball over the top. If we create for him he WILL score in this division !
|
collier row eagle romford essex via another galaxy 29 Apr 14 7.46am |
|
|
Let's keep him until next season, give him a chance to get fully fit, he at the very least deserves that, super Glenn!
|
knighteagle 29 Apr 14 8.21am |
|
|
Sorry to say cant see Glen Hacking it in the Prem. Im sure his fitness level has been there otherwise knowing TP he wouldn't be lining up. Defenders are more up to the task in the Prem and Glen looks way off the mark. Championship at best and even then not sure he will reach the heights of two seasons ago.
|
Stuart Shave Hampshire 29 Apr 14 8.33am |
|
|
Unbelievable. The bloke plays a massive part in getting us promotion. He suffers a horrific injury, from which he is still not 100% fit and won't be until the start of next season and already he is written off as not being up to The Premiership. Shocking. For the most part we have some terrific supporters, but sometimes we really let ourselves down with some nonsensical rubbish.
|
pstrutt Busselton, WA 29 Apr 14 8.34am |
|
|
Glen is slow, but as someone said when he is being fed he will get goals at any level because he finds good positions. If you can't out pace a player you can out think them.
The difference is the gulf between PL and the lower league. Wilf and Bolasie could whip a ball past most Championship defenders, but less crosses are coming from our wingers in the PL. Can anyone remember the last time a cross came in from Puncheon (not slating him though, he's just not that sort of player).
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.
|
paulose17 Sutton 29 Apr 14 8.51am |
|
|
If we could combine Jerrome's engine, speed and work rate with Glenn's goalscoring instinct we would have the perfect striker.
Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.
|
gbox82 Meols, Wirral 29 Apr 14 9.08am |
|
Quote paulose17 at 29 Apr 2014 8.51am
If we could combine Jerrome's engine, speed and work rate with Glenn's goalscoring instinct we would have the perfect striker.
...who would therfore be playing for a top 6 team! But I agree with most on this thread, Glenn deserves a fair chance in the Prem, which he wont have this season after returning on injury.
|
Y Ddraig Goch In The Crowd 29 Apr 14 9.14am |
|
|
This isn't FIFA, give the man a proper pre season and then judge him.
It takes a full year to recover from an injury like Glenn had. By recover I mean get back to some sort of fitness level similar to the one he had pre injury. Not where he is now.
the dignified don't even enter in the game
|
sydtheeagle England 29 Apr 14 9.20am |
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 29 Apr 2014 9.14am
This isn't FIFA, give the man a proper pre season and then judge him.
It takes a full year to recover from an injury like Glenn had. By recover I mean get back to some sort of fitness level similar to the one he had pre injury. Not where he is now.
Completely agree with the second paragraph. But it has to be said, this is the sort of injury that at least 50% never come fully back from. If, and it's a big if, someone -- probably a top Championship team -- offered us good money for Glenn I have to say that I would take it. But otherwise I would proceed as you suggest!
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
beagle pom tiddly om pom pom 29 Apr 14 9.24am |
|
|
I always think a whiff of hyprocracy abounds this area.
Had Murray put in a transfer request to 'move on' when we weren't doing too well in the Championship there would have been howls of indignation, with the words 'disloyal'. 'barsteward' and 'no repect for the shirt' being prominent.
However, were the club to 'move him on' then somehow that's something completely different.
When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep. Not screaming and terrified. Like his passengers.
|
Icepick Tony Chester 29 Apr 14 9.31am |
|
|
Murray deserves his chance. He is slowly coming back to fitness and the period he enters games is when our wingers are tiring so we get less into the box for him.
I also do think that the injury came at the worst time in his career, he is no spring chicken and was never the quickest across the ground. An injury like that will generally effect your speed a bit too. Unless you are very technically gifted to make up for the lack of pace, it is always going to be a big ask to make the step up and I am not sure that Murray will now be able to. I hope he proves me wrong and I guess time will tell.
"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway
|
We are goin up! Coulsdon 29 Apr 14 9.45am |
|
|
We would be mad to get rid. Give him a full pre season and see what he can do. People forget he scored more goals than AJ did in the championship and had his chance at the big time taken away from him.
The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.
|
paulose17 Sutton 29 Apr 14 9.46am |
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 29 Apr 2014 9.20am
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 29 Apr 2014 9.14am
This isn't FIFA, give the man a proper pre season and then judge him.
It takes a full year to recover from an injury like Glenn had. By recover I mean get back to some sort of fitness level similar to the one he had pre injury. Not where he is now.
Completely agree with the second paragraph. But it has to be said, this is the sort of injury that at least 50% never come fully back from. If, and it's a big if, someone -- probably a top Championship team -- offered us good money for Glenn I have to say that I would take it. But otherwise I would proceed as you suggest!
I had the same injury and it's taken me a year and a half to get back to normal running, I obviously didn't have the facilities that he has but you're right most players don't recover to even near his standard so he's done well. One more season and lot more starts and I think he'll be back to somewhere near his best.
Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.
|
jpegnall Surrey 29 Apr 14 11.09am |
|
|
The problem starts when we sign another striker. I know some people on this thread have said they would play Murray ahead of Cham and Jerome but Cham has been class for us and whilst Jerome wastes a lot of chances, he does a good job for us in difficult games. I am not sure where Murray would fit in when you add Wickham or whoever we might sign this summer, especially in terms of getting games which is what he needs.
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 29 Apr 14 11.17am |
|
|
AJ all over again.
However , Van Nistelrooy made a good fist of a recovery from a similar injury for Manyoo.
Lets be patient, and in the meantime the insurers can pick up the tab.
I disengage, I turn the page.
|