You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis or Brendan Rodgers? manager of the year..
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pulis or Brendan Rodgers? manager of the year..


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
billtheglazier Flag twickenham 29 Apr 14 10.01pm

Rodgers has had at his disposal top class international players and has unquestionably done the business with Liverpool,thus proving his value and credibility as a top manager.However,in achieving the accolade of manager of the year,I believe the question should be asked,'could he have achieved the level of success that Tony Pulis has done at Palace with the limited resources Pulis has had available to him? I dont think so!!

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

jpegnall Flag Surrey 30 Apr 14 1.43pm

Quote billtheglazier at 29 Apr 2014 10.01pm

Rodgers has had at his disposal top class international players and has unquestionably done the business with Liverpool,thus proving his value and credibility as a top manager.However,in achieving the accolade of manager of the year,I believe the question should be asked,'could he have achieved the level of success that Tony Pulis has done at Palace with the limited resources Pulis has had available to him? I dont think so!!

Equally you could ask could Pulis have turned Liverpool around and achieved the level of success that Rodgers has at Liverpool. I have no idea if he could have - it is actually an interesting question for us long term (I hope) TP may be able to establish us like he did with Stoke, could he then take us to the next level (Stoke didn't think so)?

Two very different jobs, I personally think TP should get it. He hasn't had to rely on two exceptional players and the Palace turnaround was in my opinion, much less likely than Liverpool competing for the title.

 

AussieJedinak Flag Folkestone 30 Apr 14 1.49pm

TP simply because he has managed something very special.

 

jason7 Flag croydon 30 Apr 14 2.29pm

A lot of managers could have guided Liverpool to the top with there current squad.But few could achieve and motivate the squad inherited by Pullis.

 

keith whitfield Flag 30 Apr 14 2.33pm

I would take TP over Rodgers, but I think steve Bruce might be in with a shout. Survival and a cup final.

 

bodge Flag 30 Apr 14 3.18pm

In the same position as BR would TP have his team go all out for a win or make sure they were solid at the back and kept the title in your own hands. Liverpool have had no champions league or euro games while Man Utd Chelsea and Arsenal are not at their best so if they do not win it this season then he can not be moty leaving TP to take the award.

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 30 Apr 14 3.18pm

Could be decided on Saturday. If we win it will be Pulis.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

eaglesmad Flag Tonbridge with all the other mad c... 30 Apr 14 3.24pm

Er try Monday u go saturday your on ya own

 


and now Fred Davis will try for the pink, for those watching in black n white its just behind the green..........

Red-Blue-Yellow Flag Surrey 30 Apr 14 3.34pm

The League's not been won yet, but Palace have won the right to play in the Premiership next season. Tony got us there with WEEKS to spare, got us there when most commentators had us as relegation fodder, got us there with style, pace, tactical wisdom, self belief and teamwork. No Luck involved, which was always an accusation to which we were open after the play-offs ( not that I agree). So, yeah at the moment Pulis has the edge over Rodgers for me.
I'm not too sure Rodgers is even the best manager on Merseyside just that he has the best squad.

 


I also enjoy posting on: Love Everton Forum, the Acceptable Face of Scouse Football.
[Link]
twitter.com/LuvEvertonForum
Come and give it a look, new members would be lovely.
Come and JOIN.
Or they'll nick your telly.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 14 3.36pm

Tony Pulis - Because Rodgers did it with a squad he's built over a few transfer windows, that was a decent competing team. Suarez cost Liverpool 22.5m plus a fortune in wages and an established world class player.

Pulis did it with a team that was bottom, comprised of players who no other premiership team were interested in, and over months rather than years. Jason Puncheon, top goal scorer, was on loan from Southampton and largely regarded as a failure.

Rodgers has done well, but the impact of the manager was only to turn a good team, that had been poorly managed by his predessors, into a really good one with a few very good additions (into a squad that featured noted internationals).

Pulis deserves it because he took a s**t team, with aboslutely no hope of staying up, and is currently sitting pretty at 11th in the table, with 44 points.

Had they had the same resources and capacity to attract players. All Rodgers has done is get Liverpool to compete at the level they should be competing at, and had been competing at. He's done well, but if done as well as Pulis has with Palace, then he'd already have lifted the Premier League.

Pulis achievement at Palace won't win, but all Liverpool have really achieved is to return to where they were five or six years or so ago. But they're 'footballing royalty' and every c**t will bang on about how they're great again - but they never should have gotten so s**t in the first place.

Where as Palace, who the f**k are Palace!

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Plane Flag Bromley 30 Apr 14 4.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2014 3.36pm

Tony Pulis - Because Rodgers did it with a squad he's built over a few transfer windows, that was a decent competing team. Suarez cost Liverpool 22.5m plus a fortune in wages and an established world class player.

Pulis did it with a team that was bottom, comprised of players who no other premiership team were interested in, and over months rather than years. Jason Puncheon, top goal scorer, was on loan from Southampton and largely regarded as a failure.

Rodgers has done well, but the impact of the manager was only to turn a good team, that had been poorly managed by his predessors, into a really good one with a few very good additions (into a squad that featured noted internationals).

Pulis deserves it because he took a s**t team, with aboslutely no hope of staying up, and is currently sitting pretty at 11th in the table, with 44 points.

Had they had the same resources and capacity to attract players. All Rodgers has done is get Liverpool to compete at the level they should be competing at, and had been competing at. He's done well, but if done as well as Pulis has with Palace, then he'd already have lifted the Premier League.

Pulis achievement at Palace won't win, but all Liverpool have really achieved is to return to where they were five or six years or so ago. But they're 'footballing royalty' and every c**t will bang on about how they're great again - but they never should have gotten so s**t in the first place.

Where as Palace, who the f**k are Palace!


This, but we know Big Tone won't get it.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 30 Apr 14 4.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2014 3.36pm

Tony Pulis - Because Rodgers did it with a squad he's built over a few transfer windows, that was a decent competing team. Suarez cost Liverpool 22.5m plus a fortune in wages and an established world class player.

Pulis did it with a team that was bottom, comprised of players who no other premiership team were interested in, and over months rather than years. Jason Puncheon, top goal scorer, was on loan from Southampton and largely regarded as a failure.

Rodgers has done well, but the impact of the manager was only to turn a good team, that had been poorly managed by his predessors, into a really good one with a few very good additions (into a squad that featured noted internationals).

Pulis deserves it because he took a s**t team, with aboslutely no hope of staying up, and is currently sitting pretty at 11th in the table, with 44 points.

Had they had the same resources and capacity to attract players. All Rodgers has done is get Liverpool to compete at the level they should be competing at, and had been competing at. He's done well, but if done as well as Pulis has with Palace, then he'd already have lifted the Premier League.

Pulis achievement at Palace won't win, but all Liverpool have really achieved is to return to where they were five or six years or so ago. But they're 'footballing royalty' and every c**t will bang on about how they're great again - but they never should have gotten so s**t in the first place.

Where as Palace, who the f**k are Palace!


I fully concur with your post jamie, but in the interests of pedantry I am obliged to point out that we're currently on 43 points not 44

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 30 Apr 14 4.08pm

If Liverpool win the league, Rodgers should get it. If he doesn't then Pulis deserves it.

There's no way of knowing which of them could have done the other's job. However Liverpool winning it for the first time in however long having not even qualified for the Champions League in years would be a superb achievement. Failiing that though, our turnaround would be a far greater achievement than City or Chelsea struggling to the title considering the money they've spent.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Red-Blue-Yellow Flag Surrey 30 Apr 14 5.10pm

I wonder if the result of the head-to-head will have a bigger impact on Manager of the Year than it does on the league? Both teams and both managers have earnt a lot of respect this season, having surprised most people in their respective achievements.
It would be a shame (conditional on LFC actually finishing top) for either manager not to get the recognition they deserve.....if it's a draw on Monday, perhaps TP & BR could toss a coin or have a penalty shoot out against each other...well, I can fantasise if I want to.

 


I also enjoy posting on: Love Everton Forum, the Acceptable Face of Scouse Football.
[Link]
twitter.com/LuvEvertonForum
Come and give it a look, new members would be lovely.
Come and JOIN.
Or they'll nick your telly.

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 01 May 14 1.41am

Quote Red-Blue-Yellow at 30 Apr 2014 5.10pm

I wonder if the result of the head-to-head will have a bigger impact on Manager of the Year than it does on the league? Both teams and both managers have earnt a lot of respect this season, having surprised most people in their respective achievements.
It would be a shame (conditional on LFC actually finishing top) for either manager not to get the recognition they deserve.....if it's a draw on Monday, perhaps TP & BR could toss a coin or have a penalty shoot out against each other...well, I can fantasise if I want to.


Rock paper scissors?

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

adrianjacob Flag bournemouth 01 May 14 5.12am

Pulis all the way he didn't have a prem team and created a side that did so much better than predicted we were down and out last November and to be safe with three games to go remarkable and my dream come true.

 


I first went to palace when I was 4 a wooden box to sit/stand on and monkey nuts at half time, now 46 years later come on you Eeeeeagles,I

NI_palace_fan Flag Newtownards 01 May 14 9.04am

Pulis for me has done the far better job.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 01 May 14 9.45am

Quote Seth at 30 Apr 2014 4.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2014 3.36pm

Tony Pulis - Because Rodgers did it with a squad he's built over a few transfer windows, that was a decent competing team. Suarez cost Liverpool 22.5m plus a fortune in wages and an established world class player.

Pulis did it with a team that was bottom, comprised of players who no other premiership team were interested in, and over months rather than years. Jason Puncheon, top goal scorer, was on loan from Southampton and largely regarded as a failure.

Rodgers has done well, but the impact of the manager was only to turn a good team, that had been poorly managed by his predessors, into a really good one with a few very good additions (into a squad that featured noted internationals).

Pulis deserves it because he took a s**t team, with aboslutely no hope of staying up, and is currently sitting pretty at 11th in the table, with 44 points.

Had they had the same resources and capacity to attract players. All Rodgers has done is get Liverpool to compete at the level they should be competing at, and had been competing at. He's done well, but if done as well as Pulis has with Palace, then he'd already have lifted the Premier League.

Pulis achievement at Palace won't win, but all Liverpool have really achieved is to return to where they were five or six years or so ago. But they're 'footballing royalty' and every c**t will bang on about how they're great again - but they never should have gotten so s**t in the first place.

Where as Palace, who the f**k are Palace!


I fully concur with your post jamie, but in the interests of pedantry I am obliged to point out that we're currently on 43 points not 44

Sorry to be a pedant but you don't fully concur with his post!!

 

paperhat Flag croydon 01 May 14 10.22am

Could one argue that Poyet (if he keeps them up) has done as good a job with Sunderland as Tone has with us?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 May 14 10.32am

Quote paperhat at 01 May 2014 10.22am

Could one argue that Poyet (if he keeps them up) has done as good a job with Sunderland as Tone has with us?

When Poyet took charge, Sunderland were bottom of the table with 1 point after 8 games.
During his 28 games in charge they have accrued 31 pts and are now 4th from bottom.Not done badly at all !!!!

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis or Brendan Rodgers? manager of the year..