You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Speroni on your all time keepers list
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Speroni on your all time keepers list


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 07 May 14 7.49pm

I never fault Martyn would be topped but I have come to the conclusion that Jules was better then Martyn and Jackson *Ducks For Cover*

 

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 07 May 14 7.52pm

Matt Clarke could have been up there, injuries apart

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 07 May 14 8.03pm

Our best goalie ever going by the stats was John Burridge 78/79. -24 goals 42 games.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


kayjaybee Flag orpington 07 May 14 8.15pm

speroni is indeed a great keeper but martyn is still a better keeper overall, only because he commanded his area which is jules only weak point

 

bicycle repair man 07 May 14 8.22pm

I've been going down the palace since 1968 and although Jules,Nigel,budgie etc have been brilliant keepers,in my humble opinion the best of all was John Jackson.
he played a huge part in keeping us in the old top division for 3 years.

 

martinb75 Flag Tampere 07 May 14 8.33pm

Chris Day - Boom !
On a more sensible note. Matyn was fantastic and did command his area better than Speroni, but Speroni has pulled off so many saves that have you thinking "how the f*** did he get to that ?"

Vary hard choice I would have them level

Edited by martinb75 (07 May 2014 8.35pm)

 

Itatian Flag Slough 07 May 14 8.44pm

Great as Jules has been, I have to agree with the bicycle repair man - Jacko for me and they had less protection from referees in those days. Talk about commanding the area - He commanded half the pitch.

 

Vim Fuego Flag Haywards Heath 07 May 14 8.49pm

Nigel Martyn. He just is the best. Speroni is great too but not quite as great.

I seem to remember an amazing save from Andy Booth at home to Huddersfield in a 0-0 in in hmmmmm 95/96ish that actually got a standing ovation for about 2 minutes.

 

skatman Flag 07 May 14 8.53pm

Jules is the best for me. Simply wonderful.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 07 May 14 9.23pm

Missed John Jackson...just

For me in my time (since 1974)

1. Big Nige
2. Jules
3. Budgie

Honourable mention to Matt Clarke who I thought could have been great for us

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

skatman Flag 07 May 14 9.26pm

Not forgetting Fraser Digby, he was immense.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 07 May 14 10.31pm

According to this site Jules and Martyn both level on 349 appearances.

 

Ron Noades Mother Flag 07 May 14 10.35pm

Has to be Martyn, Speroni and Budgie since I started watching Palace in 1979... all 3 are sheer class and it is hard to decide.

 

Bahrain Eagle Flag Manama 07 May 14 10.49pm

How many times did NM win player of the year? That's the measure of how well Speroni has done for our club over 10 plus years. No argument on best keeper.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 07 May 14 10.50pm

Well, no one will ever surpass Jacko for me; my favourite ever Palace player. But I have to say, Jools runs him about as close as anyone is ever likely to and from me, that's a high compliment given how I feel about Jacko.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 07 May 14 10.51pm

The Palace have had several excellent keepers and I pick,Martyn,Jules,Jackson and Burridge as being exceptional.I suppose each one has his strengths and weaknesses but the aforementioned four seldom if ever let us down and I enjoyed watching them all in action.

 

cpj Flag Kent 07 May 14 11.33pm

Quote Bahrain Eagle at 07 May 2014 10.49pm

How many times did NM win player of the year?
That's the measure of how well Speroni has done for our club over 10 plus years. No argument on best keeper.


Because we had Wright, Bright, Thomas, Salako etc then. Jackson for me, then Martyn, then Suckling (great before his confidence went after the 9-0).

 

Bahrain Eagle Flag Manama 07 May 14 11.37pm

Exactly my point. The others played in more competitive teams and didn't have to do as much work as Speroni. Without him we would not be where we are now.

 

Bahrain Eagle Flag Manama 07 May 14 11.38pm

and Suckling better than Jules _ have you been at the Sherry?

 

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 10 May 14 6.21pm

Quote Vim Fuego at 07 May 2014 8.49pm

Nigel Martyn. He just is the best. Speroni is great too but not quite as great.

I seem to remember an amazing save from Andy Booth at home to Huddersfield in a 0-0 in in hmmmmm 95/96ish that actually got a standing ovation for about 2 minutes.

Was that when he got from one post to the other as the striker thought he had a simple tap in? If so, I remember thinking that it was IMPOSSIBLE.

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Speroni on your all time keepers list