You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chamach return to France?
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Chamach return to France?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 May 14 2.37am

French newspapers have a story that Bordeaux is likely to sign Zidane as new manager. First on their shopping list is Chamach who has never denied his love for the French club. Is it the end of our PL future with him leaving?

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 17 May 14 4.05am

Quote thai-eagle at 17 May 2014 2.37am

French newspapers have a story that Bordeaux is likely to sign Zidane as new manager. First on their shopping list is Chamach who has never denied his love for the French club. Is it the end of our PL future with him leaving?


[Link]

 

GorBlimey Flag Surrey 17 May 14 4.14am

Bollocks!

[Link]

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 17 May 14 6.46am

I hope that the club are getting on with the contract business before everyone leaves on a free. First it was 'we need what division we'll be in', then 'at the end of the season' and now 'we all need a break first' (from TP). I suppose they know they're doing.

Edited by bexleydave (17 May 2014 6.51am)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 May 14 7.18am

Quote bexleydave at 17 May 2014 6.46am

I hope that the club are getting on with the contract business before everyone leaves on a free. First it was 'we need to know what division we'll be in', then 'at the end of the season' and now 'we all need a break first' (from TP). I suppose they know they're doing.

This is the same club that complained bitterly last season that being promoted via the playoffs didn't give them enough time to organize the transfers as everyone else had jumped in before us.

This year we have had plenty of time but it seems that the club have decided to leave everything to the last minute for some reason or other if the media stories are to be believed and if the Chamakh's of this world receive a juicy offer and decide to take it due to inaction on our part one could hardly blame them.

Let's hope that there is actually loads going on behind the scenes as although Pulis and the players could do with a break this is the time of year when Parish and Moody should be working hard to make sure that we start the next season with the squad that Pulis wants

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 17 May 14 7.27am

You're right, Ian. Hopefully there is more going on than we know about.


Edited by bexleydave (17 May 2014 7.31am)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 May 14 7.43am

Don't see too much transfer activity across the board ! Season has just ended !
I think it was Mick McCarthy who said that he will leave his buying for later otherwise new players will get paid for doing nothing adding that even he wasn't that stupid !

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 17 May 14 8.04am

Quote Ian J at 17 May 2014 7.18am

Quote bexleydave at 17 May 2014 6.46am

I hope that the club are getting on with the contract business before everyone leaves on a free. First it was 'we need to know what division we'll be in', then 'at the end of the season' and now 'we all need a break first' (from TP). I suppose they know they're doing.

This is the same club that complained bitterly last season that being promoted via the playoffs didn't give them enough time to organize the transfers as everyone else had jumped in before us.

This year we have had plenty of time but it seems that the club have decided to leave everything to the last minute for some reason or other if the media stories are to be believed and if the Chamakh's of this world receive a juicy offer and decide to take it due to inaction on our part one could hardly blame them.

Let's hope that there is actually loads gointg on behind the scenes as although Pulis and the players could do with a break this is the time of year when Parish and Moody should be working hard to make sure that we start the next season with the squad that Pulis wants

TP and the CPFC2010 board did meet after the Fulham match and I assume a plan of action has been agreed about new signings, contracts, ground improvements, who to let go, etc. So possibly the best time for TP to take a break. A lot of the players (eg Tom Ince) have gone on holiday too.

My sense is that everything is in place to move forward pretty fast - after everyone gets back from their holidays. So I guess we'll just have to wait and see!

 

Aray Flag South London 17 May 14 8.06am

The story uses a year-old quote from MC. It's bollox as Gor Blimey points out. He's stated recently he's staying.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 17 May 14 8.43am

Chambers has had a decent season for us, and would like him to stay another year.

However...I wouldn't be the slightest bit upset if he was to leave and his wages were to go towards a better signing.

If I were him I would spend all summer working in the gym, and working on my balance...as he doesn't half piss me off the way he loses his balance all the time.

Essentially we have quite a few players who could play that holding role in the squad already, puncheon being one of them, his composure on the ball is brilliant, ledley is another.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 17 May 14 9.00am

I said on another thread 5-6 weeks ago he was looking at a return to French football, so no surprise there.

I hope the fact he got game time with us will sway him to signing again, as we do have an option of another year, if not we will miss him and the effort he put in.

 

redpalace91 Flag Bromley 17 May 14 9.07am

We don't really know about his wage demands - he may expect the kind of salary that Arsenal paid him. If he were to go it would be a shame but he's not exceptional. For me, he doesn't score enough goals to merit a really high salary.

Edited by redpalace91 (17 May 2014 9.08am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 May 14 9.10am

Quote redpalace91 at 17 May 2014 9.07am

We don't really know about his wage demands - he may expect the kind of salary that Arsenal paid him. If he were to go it would be a shame but he's not exceptional. For me, he doesn't score enough goals to merit a really high salary.

Edited by redpalace91 (17 May 2014 9.08am)

For me he has been OK but nothing exceptional and I wouldn't lose a great deal of sleep if he went.But he HAS played his part in ensuring that we survived so well done to him.


 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 17 May 14 9.13am

Not sure what clubs in France pay top players compared to England. Would be surprised if he could get more than we were paying him last season. The plus for him is finishing his career back home or is that too soon?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 May 14 9.22am

Quote palace chick at 17 May 2014 9.13am

. The plus for him is finishing his career back home or is that too soon?

I really don't know if it is important to him to finish his career back in France.What I will say is that he is now 30 so maybe he hasn't got too many years left of 'Top flight' football.


 

redpalace91 Flag Bromley 17 May 14 9.31am

Quote palace chick at 17 May 2014 9.13am

Not sure what clubs in France pay top players compared to England. Would be surprised if he could get more than we were paying him last season. The plus for him is finishing his career back home or is that too soon?


We all know that the French league leaves much to be desired. Apart from big money spenders PSG, the other clubs are average at best.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 17 May 14 11.05am

As I understand it his contract has a 1 year option on it. This was voided if he didn't play a certain number of games or we were relegated. He did and We weren't.

This story has lots of ifs in it.

If Zidane becomes manager and this is is no where near certain
Then there is a view he would like to return to the forward line that was sucessful a number of years ago

If this was the case there is no proof that Chamakh wants to go back. He has said he is happy and is playing with a smile on his face. Obviously he has an affection for the club where he made his name but going back very rarely works

As we have the one year option which I am sure club will activate same as Blackpool did with Ince this year.If Chamakh would like to return will we stand in his way? Probably not as why would we stand in his way as our strength is morale

As we have the contract option until we decide if we activate it he is not a free agent. Same as Ince last summer he could not walk away.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 17 May 14 11.22am

Well said Palace in the Blood

I see the usual suspects are trying to rekindle their conspiracy theories, just for those posters, all contracts run until the end of next month and I'm sure the ones we want to re-sign are in talks.

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 17 May 14 4.06pm

Quote Palace in the Blood at 17 May 2014 11.05am

As I understand it his contract has a 1 year option on it. This was voided if he didn't play a certain number of games or we were relegated. He did and We weren't.

This story has lots of ifs in it.

If Zidane becomes manager and this is is no where near certain
Then there is a view he would like to return to the forward line that was sucessful a number of years ago

If this was the case there is no proof that Chamakh wants to go back. He has said he is happy and is playing with a smile on his face. Obviously he has an affection for the club where he made his name but going back very rarely works

As we have the one year option which I am sure club will activate same as Blackpool did with Ince this year.If Chamakh would like to return will we stand in his way? Probably not as why would we stand in his way as our strength is morale

As we have the contract option until we decide if we activate it he is not a free agent. Same as Ince last summer he could not walk away.

That is wrong, as of the 30th June he is a free agent.

The option is a two way clause, not one way, that option has to be right for both parties or it simply wont work, Palace may or already have invoked their side of the option, it is now up to the player if he wants too carry it through, when he does not want it he can walk away with his head held high, he's honoured his side of the deal, he has a right to walk away.

 

frankiecpfc88 Flag Swindon 17 May 14 8.59pm

Doesn't score enough so know need to worry to much,not to say he aint good but played behind a better striker could work as he is very tricky and good for assists

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chamach return to France?