This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
The NEW burial of Richard III
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
reborn 22 Mar 15 6.41pm |
|
|
Is it just me, or is this NEW funeral absolutely absurd in its scale and cost?
Tens of thousands turning out, people throwing flowers in front of the hearse for FFS...really?!
Meanwhile there are real events of consequence happening...just me?
My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs
|
Percy of Peckham Eton Mess 22 Mar 15 6.52pm |
|
|
I suppose they have to make a bit of a fuss? ...the old fella is probably going to generate £ millions in tourism and tat. I'd have him in my own backyard for a fiver a view.
Denial is not just a river in Egypt!
|
Stirlingsays 22 Mar 15 7.31pm |
|
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 6.41pm
Is it just me, or is this NEW funeral absolutely absurd in its scale and cost?
Tens of thousands turning out, people throwing flowers in front of the hearse for FFS...really?!
Meanwhile there are real events of consequence happening...just me?
No, but what exactly are you arguing for?
History is important to many people and it's an historic occasion. Turning out for such an event and taking part is perfectly fine...Many people know about the history... and to be honest I don't see what you are moaning about.
It doesn't mean people aren't interested in anything else.
Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Mar 2015 7.32pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 22 Mar 15 7.33pm |
|
|
Besides he's being buried in the wrong place.
It's slightly annoying that history is being treated as a money grab.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
reborn 22 Mar 15 7.35pm |
|
|
I think its a nonsense. He was king a thousand years ago, he had zero effect on anyone living today, its millions of pounds spent on a pointless show, all IMO of course.
I suppose I can understand people being interested in it, but I simply for the life of me cant get over people being so moved they throw flowers in front of the hearse.
Its bizarre.
What I am 'arguing' for is some perspective, that is rational and relational to his importance today.
My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs
|
reborn 22 Mar 15 7.35pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Mar 2015 7.33pm
Besides he's being buried in the wrong place.
It's slightly annoying that history is being treated as a money grab.
Ahhhh maybe you are on to the real reason there?!
My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs
|
imbored UK 22 Mar 15 7.43pm |
|
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 7.35pm
I think its a nonsense. He was king a thousand years ago, he had zero effect on anyone living today, its millions of pounds spent on a pointless show, all IMO of course.
I suppose I can understand people being interested in it, but I simply for the life of me cant get over people being so moved they throw flowers in front of the hearse.
Its bizarre.
What I am 'arguing' for is some perspective, that is rational and relational to his importance today.
It's the same attitude as when Diana died. People unable to deal with emotions in their own life projecting them onto a national event. Not ideal, but then that's some peoples way.
|
Stirlingsays 22 Mar 15 7.44pm |
|
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 7.35pm
I think its a nonsense. He was king a thousand years ago, he had zero effect on anyone living today, its millions of pounds spent on a pointless show, all IMO of course.
I suppose I can understand people being interested in it, but I simply for the life of me cant get over people being so moved they throw flowers in front of the hearse.
Its bizarre.
What I am 'arguing' for is some perspective, that is rational and relational to his importance today.
Throwing flowers is a bit bizarre I grant you but hey....People are frequently bizarre when given the opportunity and freedom.
Just because people 'get into' their history it doesn't mean that they don't have perspective or don't care about modern events......People can do both. 
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 22 Mar 15 7.45pm |
|
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 7.35pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Mar 2015 7.33pm
Besides he's being buried in the wrong place.
It's slightly annoying that history is being treated as a money grab.
Ahhhh maybe you are on to the real reason there?!
Bury the sodding child murderer in York.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
johnno42000 22 Mar 15 7.45pm |
|
|
According to Wikipedia he did do a few good things:
'In December 1483, Richard instituted what later became known as the Court of Requests, a court to which poor people who could not afford legal representation could apply for their grievances to be heard. He also improved bail in January 1484, to protect suspected felons from imprisonment before trial and to protect their property from seizure during that time. He founded the College of Arms in 1484, he banned restrictions on the printing and sale of books, and he ordered the translation of the written Laws and Statutes from the traditional French into English.
A direct but illegitimate male line still exists today, with the current Duke of Beaufort.'
I say celebrate him and support the Duke of Beaufort in a rebellion against the present lot
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'
|
PalacePhotoMan Wallington 22 Mar 15 7.50pm |
|
Quote johnno42000 at 22 Mar 2015 7.45pm
According to Wikipedia he did do a few good things:
'In December 1483, Richard instituted what later became known as the Court of Requests, a court to which poor people who could not afford legal representation could apply for their grievances to be heard. He also improved bail in January 1484, to protect suspected felons from imprisonment before trial and to protect their property from seizure during that time. He founded the College of Arms in 1484, he banned restrictions on the printing and sale of books, and he ordered the translation of the written Laws and Statutes from the traditional French into English.
A direct but illegitimate male line still exists today, with the current Duke of Beaufort.'
I say celebrate him and support the Duke of Beaufort in a rebellion against the present lot
And murder any remaining princes and princesses in the Tower while we're at it.
Zaha, Williams, Murray, Ambrose, Scannell.
A 5-man forward line who scored 3 goals in 10 minutes on 27th September 2011 at .......................
|
johnno42000 22 Mar 15 7.54pm |
|
Quote PalacePhotoMan at 22 Mar 2015 7.50pm
Quote johnno42000 at 22 Mar 2015 7.45pm
According to Wikipedia he did do a few good things:
'In December 1483, Richard instituted what later became known as the Court of Requests, a court to which poor people who could not afford legal representation could apply for their grievances to be heard. He also improved bail in January 1484, to protect suspected felons from imprisonment before trial and to protect their property from seizure during that time. He founded the College of Arms in 1484, he banned restrictions on the printing and sale of books, and he ordered the translation of the written Laws and Statutes from the traditional French into English.
A direct but illegitimate male line still exists today, with the current Duke of Beaufort.'
I say celebrate him and support the Duke of Beaufort in a rebellion against the present lot
And murder any remaining princes and princesses in the Tower while we're at it.
Exactly. Either that or make them drive through a tunnel in Paris.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'
|
Percy of Peckham Eton Mess 22 Mar 15 8.02pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Mar 2015 7.45pm
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 7.35pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Mar 2015 7.33pm
Besides he's being buried in the wrong place.
It's slightly annoying that history is being treated as a money grab.
Ahhhh maybe you are on to the real reason there?!
Bury the sodding child murderer in York.
Leicester made a big play for R3 to be interred there as a tourist magnet. York already has enough attractions so let the upcoming Championship football city have him to regenerate the place. It has been steadily going downhill - W**kers crisps are cr*p too!!!!
Denial is not just a river in Egypt!
|
Stirlingsays 22 Mar 15 8.19pm |
|
Quote Percy of Peckham at 22 Mar 2015 8.02pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Mar 2015 7.45pm
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 7.35pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 22 Mar 2015 7.33pm
Besides he's being buried in the wrong place.
It's slightly annoying that history is being treated as a money grab.
Ahhhh maybe you are on to the real reason there?!
Bury the sodding child murderer in York.
Leicester made a big play for R3 to be interred there as a tourist magnet. York already has enough attractions so let the upcoming Championship football city have him to regenerate the place. It has been steadily going downhill - W**kers crisps are cr*p too!!!!
In a modern sense I agree......But...It's just historically wrong to have the Yorkist king buried there.
Everything in its place.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Sir James Hird Mount Martha 22 Mar 15 8.26pm |
|
|
Whats so special about this procession? I pass a Richard the Third every day. But then my wife says I speak a load of crap anyway. I'll get my coat ( and the toilet paper.)
|
Lakeview Lincoln 22 Mar 15 8.42pm |
|
|
The events today were probably inspired by the Richard III Society. Personally, what I've read about Richard III suggests he was a potentially great king-his name was blackened by the Tudor dynasty's spin doctors, Shakespeare among them. Henry VII killed many more rivals than Richard apparently, and the Richard III Society are convinced Richard was not behind the princes' murders. The book "The Daugher of Time" deals with the debate really well. What struck me as weird was the involvement of a Sikh & Muslim section to the ceremonies and a woman priest at one point- all very modern England, but, if the ceremony was meant to be for Richard in some way, he would have found it completely alien to his own ideas and beliefs-something to be avoided in funerals/commemorations don't you think?
|
PeatlingPalace Peatling Leicestershire, UK 22 Mar 15 9.34pm |
|
Quote Lakeview at 22 Mar 2015 8.42pm
What struck me as weird was the involvement of a Sikh & Muslim section to the ceremonies and a woman priest at one point- all very modern England, but, if the ceremony was meant to be for Richard in some way, he would have found it completely alien to his own ideas and beliefs-something to be avoided in funerals/commemorations don't you think?
It is indeed all very modern England. But the ceremony was also very much we are Leicester. There has been huge pressure for them to give him up to York or Westminster. So this is Leicester making their mark and rightly so. As an SE19 boy who has now lived in Leicester for 25 years I hope I carry some balance of bias. And well happy that Leicester are going down even if they have king...
When they kick out your front door. How you gonna come ?
|
becky over the moon 23 Mar 15 7.31am |
|
Quote Lakeview at 22 Mar 2015 8.42pm
The events today were probably inspired by the Richard III Society. Personally, what I've read about Richard III suggests he was a potentially great king-his name was blackened by the Tudor dynasty's spin doctors, Shakespeare among them. Henry VII killed many more rivals than Richard apparently, and the Richard III Society are convinced Richard was not behind the princes' murders. The book "The Daugher of Time" deals with the debate really well. What struck me as weird was the involvement of a Sikh & Muslim section to the ceremonies and a woman priest at one point- all very modern England, but, if the ceremony was meant to be for Richard in some way, he would have found it completely alien to his own ideas and beliefs-something to be avoided in funerals/commemorations don't you think?
At least they did give him the full pre-Reformation Catholic rites, which is what he would have had if he had been buried properly at the time of his death.
I think it would have been fine for Sikhs, Muslims and women priests to be present, but I hope they didn't actually take part in the service!
It's true about the Princes in the Tower, I believe some evidence came to light years ago that implied that Richard had them placed in the Tower for their own safety from the Tudor factions that were trying to take the Crown.
Still think they should have taken him home to York though.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Mar 15 10.40am |
|
|
Why do they keep trying to alter history?
When I was at school he was represented as a very evil man.
Now he's being painted in a very different light.
Boadicea is now pronounced "Boodicker" and Marathons are now Snickers!
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 23 Mar 15 10.54am |
|
Quote reborn at 22 Mar 2015 6.41pm
Is it just me, or is this NEW funeral absolutely absurd in its scale and cost?
Tens of thousands turning out, people throwing flowers in front of the hearse for FFS...really?!
Meanwhile there are real events of consequence happening...just me?
That's exactly what I said when I saw the news. Some people are bizarre. I didn't get the Diana hysteria but at least people sort of knew her through the media. Richard Turd died 530 years ago.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|