You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > So all these poor sods in the Med...
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So all these poor sods in the Med...


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Apr 15 9.59am

Surprised their isn't already a thread on this, as I think it deserves one.

Firstly, RIP the thousands who've died, and good luck to all those who thankfully have survived. Christ knows what they've been through in their lives but I'm imagining they weren't exactly upping sticks from Persian palaces.

Secondly, what do we do? There is clearly very little appetite in this country to help them out, even if the only other options are to send them back to warzones, persecution, poverty etc. or to stick them up in some poor country like Greece who, to be fair, aren't really in the position we are to take in a few thousand asylum seekers.

Well, whatever we do surely has to be better than what we're doing at the moment, which is turning a blind eye to the whole thing. I brought this up a while ago on here, but our Government's withdrawal of funding from Operation Mare Nostrum was invariably going to lead to a tragedy like this. Lady Anelay in the government said that it acted as a 'pull factor', yet according to most charities, since the operation was removed, more people are attempting the crossing and more people are dying. Katie Hopkins got grief for calling these people 'cockroaches' but if we are refusing to help them, house them or even rescue them then isn't she basically just spelling out our policy on this?

I just think it's a classic example of where UKIP's rhetoric is worryingly affecting our policy. The government want to be shown as being tough on migrants, to the extent where we regard thousands drowning to death in the Mediterranean when fleeing from war as a necessary sacrifice. If Cameron did the sympathetic thing and offered to help, he'd get crucified by most. Similarly another legitimate measure for dealing with this problem - raising foreign aid funding to provide these people with temporary residency closer to home - is one of the policies UKIP want to get rid of!

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Hoof Hearted 22 Apr 15 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'

 

Rubin Flag 22 Apr 15 10.18am

If we hadn't already let everyone who wants to come here from Europe in, then we'd be in a position to offer them a home here. Same goes for Syrian refugees.

 

becky Flag over the moon 22 Apr 15 10.26am

I gather Romania, Serbia, Kosovo and Poland have a lot of free space these days........... perhaps it's time they stepped up to the mark for taking their share!

[Link]

scroll down for statistics on where they go.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Apr 15 10.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'

Which is completely irrelevant. We also were directly involved in creating the situation in Libya that these people are fleeing from, and as such bear some consequence for the now failed state that has occurred. The factions we supported and armed and helped to victory are now fighting and persecuting other factions in a bid for power.

Including factions now affiliated to IS and Al-Queda.

There is a big gap between granting them asylum (which some probably are entitled to) and washing your hands and letting innocent people fleeing persecution and war drown.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Apr 15 10.29am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'


Yes, that's exactly what I'm arguing...

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Apr 15 10.30am

Quote Rubin at 22 Apr 2015 10.18am

If we hadn't already let everyone who wants to come here from Europe in, then we'd be in a position to offer them a home here. Same goes for Syrian refugees.

Technically if they're refugees, then we are legally required to provide sanctuary under International Obligations of Asylum.

Problem is, to apply for that Asylum they have to get to the UK first (or obtain refuge in the Embassy - which isn't an option for 99% of Libyans - as they'd have to get across rival factional front lines).

So in order to claim asylum, you're basically dependent on people who can smuggle you out of the country....


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 22 Apr 15 10.32am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Apr 2015 10.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'

Which is completely irrelevant. We also were directly involved in creating the situation in Libya that these people are fleeing from, and as such bear some consequence for the now failed state that has occurred. The factions we supported and armed and helped to victory are now fighting and persecuting other factions in a bid for power.

Including factions now affiliated to IS and Al-Queda.

There is a big gap between granting them asylum (which some probably are entitled to) and washing your hands and letting innocent people fleeing persecution and war drown.



Even you would agree that getting rid of Gadaffi was a good idea at the time.

The Middle East/North Africa is full of hotheads/mad mullahs and always has been.

Get rid of one and another pops up.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Apr 15 10.34am

Quote serial thriller at 22 Apr 2015 10.29am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'


Yes, that's exactly what I'm arguing...


Create mayhem here too..... nice!

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Apr 15 10.46am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.32am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Apr 2015 10.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'

Which is completely irrelevant. We also were directly involved in creating the situation in Libya that these people are fleeing from, and as such bear some consequence for the now failed state that has occurred. The factions we supported and armed and helped to victory are now fighting and persecuting other factions in a bid for power.

Including factions now affiliated to IS and Al-Queda.

There is a big gap between granting them asylum (which some probably are entitled to) and washing your hands and letting innocent people fleeing persecution and war drown.



Even you would agree that getting rid of Gadaffi was a good idea at the time.

The Middle East/North Africa is full of hotheads/mad mullahs and always has been.

Get rid of one and another pops up.


You mean the part of the world which created maths, the guitar, our alphabet, astronomy and coffee? Those 'hotheads/mad mullahs'? Or was that someone else?

Or maybe it was those nutters who developed one of the biggest libraries in human history, the pyramids, who contributed so greatly to Western philosophy and religion, who had huge civilisations while we were still messing around worshipping trees, where 5 of the 7 wonders of the world are situated. Christ, what f*cking nutters they were.

Who knows, maybe, actually, the nutters were us Western Europeans, who took all of these incredible inventions, burnt down their library, stole their religions, invaded their land, mined their resources, enslaved their people, raped their women and ruled their land for hundreds of years, before leaving them in the lurch, mining their oil, invading their country and demonising their religion. But then I guess that would be a stupid thing to say wouldn't it...

Edited by serial thriller (22 Apr 2015 10.48am)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Apr 15 10.47am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.32am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Apr 2015 10.26am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2015 10.11am

Let's completely open our borders and ship in as many as we can..... I am confident we can pack in over 200 million people if we really try.

-.-'

Which is completely irrelevant. We also were directly involved in creating the situation in Libya that these people are fleeing from, and as such bear some consequence for the now failed state that has occurred. The factions we supported and armed and helped to victory are now fighting and persecuting other factions in a bid for power.

Including factions now affiliated to IS and Al-Queda.

There is a big gap between granting them asylum (which some probably are entitled to) and washing your hands and letting innocent people fleeing persecution and war drown.



Even you would agree that getting rid of Gadaffi was a good idea at the time.

The Middle East/North Africa is full of hotheads/mad mullahs and always has been.

Get rid of one and another pops up.

Actually I didn't, even at the time. During the whole 'Arab Spring' I was generally skeptical that the outcome would be in the best interests of the West and that it would essentially play into the interests of Islamist and Islamic Fundermentalist groups over secular authorities.

Whilst I'm no fan of Gaddaffi, the authority of state existed beyond the one man, and even then it was just a man. In the process of the revolutionary war, the apparatus and infrastructure of state and capacity of authority of state was destroyed.

Long term, he'd long since been isolated as a threat and ultimately established as an 'inconvenient' ally, given the rise of Islamist groups and the decline of leftist national liberation movements. The misguided idealism of 'democractising' the world led us to create yet another 'recruiting' ground and failed nation for our enemies to benefit from.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 22 Apr 15 10.48am

It's so awful. And loathsome the way Hammond and Cameron (and to an extent Milipede) stick to their "line to take", ie, push the blame onto the traffickers.

As if their bombing north African countries and meddling in the middle East is completely irrelevant.

I don't have the faintest idea how to solve it. Make the places they're leaving nice to live in, maybe? By not bombing or invading them or supporting nasty dictators in them. Might be a start.

I guess your solution, ST, would be to cancel world debt, abolish borders and set up a global Housing Benefit fund?

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Apr 15 11.13am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 22 Apr 2015 10.48am

It's so awful. And loathsome the way Hammond and Cameron (and to an extent Milipede) stick to their "line to take", ie, push the blame onto the traffickers.

As if their bombing north African countries and meddling in the middle East is completely irrelevant.

I don't have the faintest idea how to solve it. Make the places they're leaving nice to live in, maybe? By not bombing or invading them or supporting nasty dictators in them. Might be a start.

I guess your solution, ST, would be to cancel world debt, abolish borders and set up a global Housing Benefit fund?

Like you Johnny, the issues which leave us in a situation where we willingly allow asylum seekers to drown is a massively complex issue, and I of course couldn't definitely say what short-term policies would improve the situation.

You're suggestion is one I would support, even if it compromises Western society. A bloke who used to work for Shell came out and said that democracy won't exist while we depend on oil so greatly. One of the costs of, for example, withdrawing support for the Saudis (who financed IS, behead people etc) would be oil prices would rocket. Hence why it's easy to say 'let's stop supporting dictators' but much harder to actually do so as a politician who wants to win elections and keep people happy.

It would be easy to sit here and just say 'nothing will change until we reconfigure global capitalism', put my feet up and look smug while the Middle East's basket case status continues. I acknowledge that practical solutions are necessary for the short term, so humanitarian aid in Syria has to be upped, we need to make it easier to assist the Kurdish fightback in Northern Syria against IS, and obviously, we need to fund search and rescue missions in the Med, and take in a much higher share of refugees and asylum seekers. Sadly, the rhetoric surrounding foreign policy is so warped that even these things are now pie in the sky, and will only result in thousands more innocent deaths in the next decade.

As you say, it's awful, and the lack of human empathy shown by most as the world's poorest die in unspeakable conditions is staggering.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

npn Flag Crowborough 22 Apr 15 11.23am

Quote serial thriller at 22 Apr 2015 11.13am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 22 Apr 2015 10.48am

It's so awful. And loathsome the way Hammond and Cameron (and to an extent Milipede) stick to their "line to take", ie, push the blame onto the traffickers.

As if their bombing north African countries and meddling in the middle East is completely irrelevant.

I don't have the faintest idea how to solve it. Make the places they're leaving nice to live in, maybe? By not bombing or invading them or supporting nasty dictators in them. Might be a start.

I guess your solution, ST, would be to cancel world debt, abolish borders and set up a global Housing Benefit fund?

Like you Johnny, the issues which leave us in a situation where we willingly allow asylum seekers to drown is a massively complex issue, and I of course couldn't definitely say what short-term policies would improve the situation.

You're suggestion is one I would support, even if it compromises Western society. A bloke who used to work for Shell came out and said that democracy won't exist while we depend on oil so greatly. One of the costs of, for example, withdrawing support for the Saudis (who financed IS, behead people etc) would be oil prices would rocket. Hence why it's easy to say 'let's stop supporting dictators' but much harder to actually do so as a politician who wants to win elections and keep people happy.

It would be easy to sit here and just say 'nothing will change until we reconfigure global capitalism', put my feet up and look smug while the Middle East's basket case status continues. I acknowledge that practical solutions are necessary for the short term, so humanitarian aid in Syria has to be upped, we need to make it easier to assist the Kurdish fightback in Northern Syria against IS, and obviously, we need to fund search and rescue missions in the Med, and take in a much higher share of refugees and asylum seekers. Sadly, the rhetoric surrounding foreign policy is so warped that even these things are now pie in the sky, and will only result in thousands more innocent deaths in the next decade.

As you say, it's awful, and the lack of human empathy shown by most as the world's poorest die in unspeakable conditions is staggering.


This is one of those situations where I just can't see how you get a decent outcome.

Intervention in Iraq - humanitarian disaster
Interference in Libya - humanitarian disaster
Hands off approach (sort of) in Syria - humanitarian disaster
Not helping the Kurds - humanitarian disaster

It seems whatever we do we cannot prevent these disasters from happening, and you certainly can't blame the people fleeing for doing so. I really don't think we should take as much blame as many seem to think is appropriate. As highlighted above, whichever way it is played (hands on or hands off) we can be seen to be at fault, so it's really a lose-lose for us).

The fact remains that people are dying needlessly and that is truly appalling, but what to do about it?

Search and rescue? Well, you could say "why us?" as we don't even border the med. If there is to be a mission it should be funded centrally from the EU purse. The counter argument to that, of course, is do your search and rescue missions encourage more people to attempt the trip? And what do you do with the people you rescue? Again, this would seem to be something that should be a result of a central EU policy - 'we' (the EU) will take refugees, and allocate them to wherever they will be safe and is best suited for them, and the EU will compensate the nations receiving them for the expense incurred.

As I said, I don't really have any answers, just a long list of questions, and a clawing sadness that somehow we are allowing this to happen

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Apr 15 11.35am

I think that its inevitable that any civil war will result in a humanitarian disaster (or any war for that matter), the problem is when you pick a side you aquire a responsibility in the outcome, especially when you tip the balance.

In Libya or Syria, arguably the best solution would be to invest in creating and supporting half decent refugee camps on the borders of those countries, which could function as communities until such time as an outcome can be achieved. Then we should progress towards creating a new stablised nation for those individuals to return to, and engaging with that new national politically.

The sovereignty of other nations isn't for us to determine, its for the people in those nations to determine. By intervening in the Libyan civil war we essentially ensured a loose collective of dispirit factions, notably many opposed sectarian ones, would replace the state authority, and that almost always results in a civil war.

Throw in an air bombing campaign against the core regime and the infrastructure of state authority is almost certainly going to be destroyed (meaning the incoming state authority will have no power to implement authority, resulting in criminality and regionalized power).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 22 Apr 15 12.23pm

Catch 22.

You don't help- people die
You help- more people try their luck die

It's mot an easy situation. Personally I think the onus should be on the med countries to resolve, it's not like we get any assistance back with people trafficking over the channel.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Apr 15 12.29pm

Save the people from drowning should be number 1 priority.
Then I just don't know... A very complex situation.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 22 Apr 15 12.46pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 22 Apr 2015 12.23pm

Catch 22.

You don't help- people die
You help- more people try their luck die

It's mot an easy situation. Personally I think the onus should be on the med countries to resolve, it's not like we get any assistance back with people trafficking over the channel.


Thing is, that's been proven not to be the case. We announced that we would be withdrawing our support from rescue operations in the Med in October last year, and so far this year well over half the number of people that attempted the journey last year have tried in less than 4 months.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Apr 15 12.47pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 22 Apr 2015 12.23pm

Catch 22.

You don't help- people die
You help- more people try their luck die

It's mot an easy situation. Personally I think the onus should be on the med countries to resolve, it's not like we get any assistance back with people trafficking over the channel.

I'm not sure that people fleeing civil war will generally see the boat as a risk, where as staying put is generally an almost certainty of death (remember most of those who board those boats don't drown).

Civil wars tend to be very brutal, somewhat genocidal affairs, with the end goal generally being the virtual extermination of opposition (even those not murdered or killed typically face long imprisonment, exile or oppressive restrictions).

Indeed the stance of the UK parties is rather absurd given that the boats will set off regardless of the risk, and that reducing patrols and efforts, will only result in greater chances of those vessels not being intercepted.

Also calling them migrants is absurd, as they're refugees, few of whom will actually end up in the UK anyhow (Britain has accepted 300 or so Libyan and Syrian Asylum claims).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Apr 15 12.49pm

Quote serial thriller at 22 Apr 2015 12.46pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 22 Apr 2015 12.23pm

Catch 22.

You don't help- people die
You help- more people try their luck die

It's mot an easy situation. Personally I think the onus should be on the med countries to resolve, it's not like we get any assistance back with people trafficking over the channel.


Thing is, that's been proven not to be the case. We announced that we would be withdrawing our support from rescue operations in the Med in October last year, and so far this year well over half the number of people that attempted the journey last year have tried in less than 4 months.

I suspect people fear the certainty of civil war far more than the possibility of death. Its a rational perspective, when weighing up the odds, to select the possible risk over the certain risk.

Faced with being shot, or shot at, you'd pick shot at. It has the prospect of hope.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > So all these poor sods in the Med...