This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Driver blind in one eye was fit to drive
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Stuk Top half 01 Jun 15 5.26pm |
|
|
[Link]
but she went through a red light and killed someone. Who the feck thought one eye was good enough to drive?
Optimistic as ever
|
CheeseRolls Cheshire 01 Jun 15 5.55pm |
|
|
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
|
Stuk Top half 01 Jun 15 7.11pm |
|
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
Optimistic as ever
|
55 years a fan 01 Jun 15 7.26pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 7.11pm
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
And you get that information from where?
My father was born blind in one eye. Never had a fault accident in over 50 years of driving.
Seems a bit unfair,stating anyone with impaired vison is a danger.
As a retired driving instructor have seen loads of so called able bodied drivers who desereved to be called dangerous
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 01 Jun 15 7.32pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 7.11pm
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
Yeah but no so much that you'd somehow stop noticing traffic signals surely and pedestrians. Even drunk people seem to generally be able to do that.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
derben 01 Jun 15 7.34pm |
|
|
According to my mate Aldous, they drive with no eyes in Gaza.
|
TUX redhill 01 Jun 15 7.40pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 5.26pm
[Link]
but she went through a red light and killed someone. Who the feck thought one eye was good enough to drive?
Maybe the issue is being 'colour blind'?
|
Stuk Top half 01 Jun 15 7.58pm |
|
Quote 55 years a fan at 01 Jun 2015 7.26pm
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 7.11pm
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
And you get that information from where?
My father was born blind in one eye. Never had a fault accident in over 50 years of driving.
Seems a bit unfair,stating anyone with impaired vison is a danger.
As a retired driving instructor have seen loads of so called able bodied drivers who desereved to be called dangerous
It's everywhere. Try closing one eye and see if it feels the same to you. It would be less of a factor if you never had that vision in the first place admittedly.
I'm not saying there aren't plenty of idiots driving with good vision, but poor vision is a significant disadvantage to start with.
Optimistic as ever
|
Stuk Top half 01 Jun 15 8.01pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jun 2015 7.32pm
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 7.11pm
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
Yeah but no so much that you'd somehow stop noticing traffic signals surely and pedestrians. Even drunk people seem to generally be able to do that.
She said she noticed the light, but thought it was green. Nothing about whether she even noticed the bloke she hit.
Red/Green colour blind would surely be an instant ban on driving? Funny that those are the lights when it is a fairly common colour blindness.
Optimistic as ever
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 02 Jun 15 9.21am |
|
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 8.01pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jun 2015 7.32pm
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 7.11pm
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
Yeah but no so much that you'd somehow stop noticing traffic signals surely and pedestrians. Even drunk people seem to generally be able to do that.
She said she noticed the light, but thought it was green. Nothing about whether she even noticed the bloke she hit.
Red/Green colour blind would surely be an instant ban on driving? Funny that those are the lights when it is a fairly common colour blindness.
I'd imagine that most people would look at the position of the light, rather than the colour if they were colour blind.
Most accidents occur due to cognitive dysfunction where in the person 'misreads' or otherwise confused by factors outside of their immediate perception.
Everyone's made mistakes like that, not noticing a light was red until they've gone through it, or had to slam on the breaks; not noticed a car slowing down.
Whilst having one eye is a disadvantage, if it was the primary cause of the accident, then the driver wouldn't have been guilty of the crime (it would be a defense of mitigation). of course there is an argument that people who suffer a visual imparement should take a specialized driving course and test.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
npn Crowborough 02 Jun 15 10.18am |
|
|
I have limited vision in one eye - I honestly don't think it affects my driving
|
| Hoof Hearted 02 Jun 15 10.45am |
|
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 5.26pm
[Link]
but she went through a red light and killed someone. Who the feck thought one eye was good enough to drive?
Probably the same people who voted for Gordon Brown?

"In the Kingdom of the blind, the one eyed man is King!"
|
cornwalls palace Torpoint 02 Jun 15 11.37am |
|
|
..bit harsh the wording, she had no intention of hitting the man and is going to suffer with it for the rest of her life and as 721 said we have all at some stage done it, or something similar. Having only one eye would have very little to do with this incident, as mentally you pay more attention to avoid being in the situation she now finds herself!
.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!
|
derben 02 Jun 15 11.40am |
|
|
Perhaps she was winking at someone?
|
Stuk Top half 02 Jun 15 1.55pm |
|
Quote cornwalls palace at 02 Jun 2015 11.37am
..bit harsh the wording, she had no intention of hitting the man and is going to suffer with it for the rest of her life and as 721 said we have all at some stage done it, or something similar. Having only one eye would have very little to do with this incident, as mentally you pay more attention to avoid being in the situation she now finds herself!
I didn't mention there was any intent.
I've got something in my eye while driving before, loads of times when on a motorbike, and the lack of a second functioning eye would mean you're literally driving blind until you can stop.
Optimistic as ever
|
dannyh wherever I lay my hat....... 02 Jun 15 4.27pm |
|
Quote 55 years a fan at 01 Jun 2015 7.26pm
Quote Stuk at 01 Jun 2015 7.11pm
Quote CheeseRolls at 01 Jun 2015 5.55pm
The requirement to legally drive in the UK is 20/20 vision in one eye, with or without the aid of glasses/contact lenses. You are, however, restricted on vehicle class you can drive (buses, hgv's).
The 'one eye' is not the issue here, it is the careless driving.
It's still a huge mitigating factor. Field of view is reduced, as is colour recognition and spacial awareness.
On top of that you're 7 times more likely to have an incident while driving.
And you get that information from where?
My father was born blind in one eye. Never had a fault accident in over 50 years of driving.
Seems a bit unfair,stating anyone with impaired vison is a danger.As a retired driving instructor have seen loads of so called able bodied drivers who desereved to be called dangerous
Are you actually taking the piss fella ?
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"
|
Stirlingsays 02 Jun 15 5.04pm |
|
|
I have had mostly one eye vision for all of my life. One eye being massively stronger than the other
I won a couple of pool competitions in my youth, boxed, did a little work as a bouncer and I've been quite successful at driving as well.....touch wood.
One good eye is sufficient to drive.....Not ideal, but sufficient.
It kept me out of the Army as a teenager....Which is a load of outdated thinking.
Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Jun 2015 5.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
stateside Norfolk 02 Jun 15 5.12pm |
|
|
I heard that a taxi driver with one eye was given a taxi License, seems common practice.
|
Stuk Top half 02 Jun 15 5.12pm |
|
|
I had no idea this doubled up as a Palace/Pirate messageboard. 
That's probably an inappropriate smiley too! 
Optimistic as ever
|
Steptoe 02 Jun 15 8.03pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 02 Jun 2015 5.04pm
I have had mostly one eye vision for all of my life. One eye being massively stronger than the other
I won a couple of pool competitions in my youth, boxed, did a little work as a bouncer and I've been quite successful at driving as well.....touch wood.
One good eye is sufficient to drive.....Not ideal, but sufficient.
It kept me out of the Army as a teenager....Which is a load of outdated thinking.
Edited by Stirlingsays (02 Jun 2015 5.06pm)
Suddenly striving for equality now are we?
|