You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > To All Who Say Criticizing Israel is anti-Semitic
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

To All Who Say Criticizing Israel is anti-Semitic


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 09 Jun 15 12.22am

This is part of a post I submitted on another thread in response to a poster who quoted the record of Robert Kraft. I warn anyone who would accuse me of anti-Semitism; I am Jewish, my father was born in Nuremberg in 1928 and my cousin, Karl Lehrburger was one of the first murdered in Dachau in May of 1933. He was Jewish, an active opponent of the Nazis and gay. I am also material to the espionage case of Jonathon Pollard, who attempted to relay communications codes to Israel. The term "communications codes" is a euphemism. He claimed I owed loyalty not only to the US but also to Israel because of my religion. He is presently incarcerated in a maximum security Federal Home for the Very Naughty.

Given that I'm Jewish and the son of a Holocaust survivor I'm forced to agree with truggy. Zionism should not be confused with Judaism, which is a faith in God. Zionism has become all about ownership of a particular patch of real estate and turning God into the ultimate broker/agent. Originally, as proposed by Theodor Herzl, Zionism was supposed to be establishing a safe haven for Jews in Palestine so that could escape from European anti-Semitism. Herzl's speech was given at the same time the Dreyfuss Affair was roiling in France. It has since become a nationalist cause under the leadership of people like Netanyahu. Herzl wanted a democratic nation where no religion was established and all could live peacefully. Due to the Holocaust, ben-Gurion and Weizmann decided that Israel should have Judaism as the established faith. This was a mistake but, in my view given the times (1948 ), an understandable one. Now Netanyahu, in violation of UN Res 242, demands that Israel be recognized as the Jewish State with the right to speak for Jews world wide. Let me make this as clear as I can. I am an American. No foreign power speaks for me. Netanyahu and Israel are foreign powers in relation to me. I do not and cannot support policies which steal land from those who are peacefully living on it, meaning the settlements. Unless and until Israel recognizes the rights of all who live within its borders I, as an American, a Jew, the son of a Holocaust survivor and the cousin of one of the first murdered at Dachau, cannot support its present policies. Rant over.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

SamCPFC17 Flag Croydon 09 Jun 15 12.28am

Great post pal.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Jun 15 12.53am

Very interesting kenbarr, thanks for sharing that.

Edited by Seth (09 Jun 2015 2.41am)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 09 Jun 15 1.12am

Stands up and applauds.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 09 Jun 15 6.17am

Well said kenbarr!

Totally with you.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

derben Flag 09 Jun 15 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 09 Jun 15 7.27am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)


Crikey. You've mellowed somewhat. There was a time when if someone walked past a Jaffa orange without purchasing it you'd accuse them of being Marxist-Leninists intent on the destruction of Israel.

Edited by Kermit8 (09 Jun 2015 7.28am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


derben Flag 09 Jun 15 7.40am

Thought this thread would wake you up Kerm - you been hibernating? Hasn't the EU banned the import of Jaffa oranges?

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 09 Jun 15 8.39am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I'm confused. Islam and Muslim/Moslem mean the same thing. I'm hoping you mean "Islamist," which has come to mean the violent fundamentalism practiced by IS and al Qaeda among others. I maintain there are so-called fundamentalists who attach themselves to any religious faith. Actually, they really don't practice the faith but their own personal agenda of violence and hate.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Mr Palaceman Flag 09 Jun 15 8.40am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I understand the anti-Israel/Semitic bit but how can you be anti a way of life but not anti to those who live by it?

That's like someone saying they are anti-Zionism but not anti-Zionist...

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 09 Jun 15 8.41am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 7.40am

Thought this thread would wake you up Kerm - you been hibernating? Hasn't the EU banned the import of Jaffa oranges?


Gee, I hope not. Jaffa Cakes are my all time favorites. I can't eat them anymore for two reasons, they don't have them in the US except for the UK area at Epcot and I'm a diabetic.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

silvertop Flag Portishead 09 Jun 15 8.47am

Quote kenbarr at 09 Jun 2015 8.39am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I'm confused. Islam and Muslim/Moslem mean the same thing. I'm hoping you mean "Islamist," which has come to mean the violent fundamentalism practiced by IS and al Qaeda among others. I maintain there are so-called fundamentalists who attach themselves to any religious faith. Actually, they really don't practice the faith but their own personal agenda of violence and hate.


Perhaps you can be anti aspects of the faith without hating all those who observe the faith?

 

derben Flag 09 Jun 15 8.47am

Quote kenbarr at 09 Jun 2015 8.39am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I'm confused. Islam and Muslim/Moslem mean the same thing. I'm hoping you mean "Islamist," which has come to mean the violent fundamentalism practiced by IS and al Qaeda among others. I maintain there are so-called fundamentalists who attach themselves to any religious faith. Actually, they really don't practice the faith but their own personal agenda of violence and hate.

I'm happy to change it to 'Islamist', I don't see a lot of difference though.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 09 Jun 15 8.57am

Btw, I agree your comment. 2 instances spring to mind.

The Spectator was ran an article criticising Israel for its somewhat heavy handed tactics. In a discussion with a lady from the Jewish Chronicle, she tried to get him to admit [in the most strident aggressive tone] that his article was anti-Semitic by virtue only of the fact that it criticised Israel.

Further, in an article in the Telegraph [when her husband Conrad Black still owned it] the lovely and fragrant Barbara Amiel stated that any article on the problems in Israel that criticised that country's policies on settlement was anti-Semitic. She even went on to say that journalists should only print press releases from the Israeli Defence Force web site. Any other source was unreliable and probably anti-Semitic.

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Jun 15 9.00am

Quote kenbarr at 09 Jun 2015 12.22am

This is part of a post I submitted on another thread in response to a poster who quoted the record of Robert Kraft. I warn anyone who would accuse me of anti-Semitism; I am Jewish, my father was born in Nuremberg in 1928 and my cousin, Karl Lehrburger was one of the first murdered in Dachau in May of 1933. He was Jewish, an active opponent of the Nazis and gay. I am also material to the espionage case of Jonathon Pollard, who attempted to relay communications codes to Israel. The term "communications codes" is a euphemism. He claimed I owed loyalty not only to the US but also to Israel because of my religion. He is presently incarcerated in a maximum security Federal Home for the Very Naughty.

Given that I'm Jewish and the son of a Holocaust survivor I'm forced to agree with truggy. Zionism should not be confused with Judaism, which is a faith in God. Zionism has become all about ownership of a particular patch of real estate and turning God into the ultimate broker/agent. Originally, as proposed by Theodor Herzl, Zionism was supposed to be establishing a safe haven for Jews in Palestine so that could escape from European anti-Semitism. Herzl's speech was given at the same time the Dreyfuss Affair was roiling in France. It has since become a nationalist cause under the leadership of people like Netanyahu. Herzl wanted a democratic nation where no religion was established and all could live peacefully. Due to the Holocaust, ben-Gurion and Weizmann decided that Israel should have Judaism as the established faith. This was a mistake but, in my view given the times (1948 ), an understandable one. Now Netanyahu, in violation of UN Res 242, demands that Israel be recognized as the Jewish State with the right to speak for Jews world wide. Let me make this as clear as I can. I am an American. No foreign power speaks for me. Netanyahu and Israel are foreign powers in relation to me. I do not and cannot support policies which steal land from those who are peacefully living on it, meaning the settlements. Unless and until Israel recognizes the rights of all who live within its borders I, as an American, a Jew, the son of a Holocaust survivor and the cousin of one of the first murdered at Dachau, cannot support its present policies. Rant over.


kenbarr,its a sad world when you have to post that...Of course its true.Being Jewish (as I am too) doesn't somehow automatically make someone a rabid supporter of the Israeli government or the occupation or even zionism in its left wing variants,let alone the present right wing cr-p which is in the ascendancy.Any more than being a US citizen makes someone a supporter of Bush and Iraq,or the Vietnam war.

Unfortunately,that some jews feel they end up needing to say this is in part a consequence of the anti-semitic nonsense promulgated for hundreds of years where it suits those promoting it to portray jews worldwide as having no loyalty to the place they live in,only to the wider jewish "people". Hitler very much trotted out that line when influencing public opinion to go along with jews being divested of their civic rights in Germany.

I despair at what goes on in Israel ,as you do.But don't forget two things:the many thousands of Jews in Israel who oppose such insanity and the significant number off jews elsewhere who oppose zionism.

That said, jews are not incapable by definition of falling for and expressing aspects of hoary anti-semitic canards,not every anti-zionist is free of being tainted by anti-semitism (and don't forget the expressions of pure anti-semitism and destruction of property because it was merely owned by jews by some demonstrating in France about events in Gaza last summer),and I sometimes get sick of people who live in oppressive countries (where they support the regimes in question) lecturing all and sundry about the seeming "unique" evils of "zionism" while turning a blind eye to events in their backyard. Very convenient.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Jun 2015 9.18am)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Jun 15 9.06am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 8.47am

Quote kenbarr at 09 Jun 2015 8.39am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I'm confused. Islam and Muslim/Moslem mean the same thing. I'm hoping you mean "Islamist," which has come to mean the violent fundamentalism practiced by IS and al Qaeda among others. I maintain there are so-called fundamentalists who attach themselves to any religious faith. Actually, they really don't practice the faith but their own personal agenda of violence and hate.

I'm happy to change it to 'Islamist', I don't see a lot of difference though.


There is a significant difference between being an Islamist (or a salafist jihadist) and being a believer in Islam.To say otherwise is a bit like tainting all Jews with being Netanyahu accolytes, or all christians with being US fundamentalist devotees of fire and brimstone and the desirability of an aopocaypse in the middle east now to being about "the saviour's" swift return, or all believers in socialism being devotees of Leninism and /or Stalin.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Jun 2015 9.23am)

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 09 Jun 15 9.12am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 8.47am

Quote kenbarr at 09 Jun 2015 8.39am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I'm confused. Islam and Muslim/Moslem mean the same thing. I'm hoping you mean "Islamist," which has come to mean the violent fundamentalism practiced by IS and al Qaeda among others. I maintain there are so-called fundamentalists who attach themselves to any religious faith. Actually, they really don't practice the faith but their own personal agenda of violence and hate.

I'm happy to change it to 'Islamist', I don't see a lot of difference though.

There's a big difference, Muslims are Islamists, they follow Islam, Islamist and extremist are two different things.

If derban had said, you can be anti-Saudi Arabia without being anti-arab it might have made sense.


 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

legaleagle Flag 09 Jun 15 9.15am

Quote silvertop at 09 Jun 2015 8.57am

Btw, I agree your comment. 2 instances spring to mind.

The Spectator was ran an article criticising Israel for its somewhat heavy handed tactics. In a discussion with a lady from the Jewish Chronicle, she tried to get him to admit [in the most strident aggressive tone] that his article was anti-Semitic by virtue only of the fact that it criticised Israel.

Further, in an article in the Telegraph [when her husband Conrad Black still owned it] the lovely and fragrant Barbara Amiel stated that any article on the problems in Israel that criticised that country's policies on settlement was anti-Semitic. She even went on to say that journalists should only print press releases from the Israeli Defence Force web site. Any other source was unreliable and probably anti-Semitic.


They are dumb, as dumb as labelling anyone who espouses vaguely left wing views as "being in bed"with Stalin or N Korea.Moral: all kinds of people of all kinds of beliefs/religions have the capability to express nonsense.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 09 Jun 15 9.22am

Quote Mr Palaceman at 09 Jun 2015 9.12am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 8.47am

Quote kenbarr at 09 Jun 2015 8.39am

Quote derben at 09 Jun 2015 6.56am

Obviously you can be anti-Israel without being anti-Semitic.
Similarly you can be anti-Islam without being anti-Muslims.

Edited by derben (09 Jun 2015 7.06am)

I'm confused. Islam and Muslim/Moslem mean the same thing. I'm hoping you mean "Islamist," which has come to mean the violent fundamentalism practiced by IS and al Qaeda among others. I maintain there are so-called fundamentalists who attach themselves to any religious faith. Actually, they really don't practice the faith but their own personal agenda of violence and hate.

I'm happy to change it to 'Islamist', I don't see a lot of difference though.

There's a big difference, Muslims are Islamists, they follow Islam, Islamist and extremist are two different things.

If derban had said, you can be anti-Saudi Arabia without being anti-arab it might have made sense.



To be fair to derben, I get what he means.

It would be the same as being vehemently against the Catholic church (and let's face it, there are many reasons you might be) without having anything against Catholics themselves

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Jun 15 9.24am

More like equating (and tainting) all followers of Catholicism with having being believers per se in the benefits of the Spanish inquisition and the "civilising" mission of the conquistadores.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Jun 2015 9.26am)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > To All Who Say Criticizing Israel is anti-Semitic