Stuk Top half 24 Jul 15 3.45pm |
|
|
[Link]
Two 16 year old kill a telecoms engineer and are charged with dangerous driving.
If you cannot drive, you should not be able to be charged with dangerous driving. You've killed someone with a weapon essentially.
Optimistic as ever
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 24 Jul 15 3.59pm |
|
|
I'd guess its to do with intent to cause harm. Its basically manslaughter if you ask me, but the CPS might not be able to be certain of a conviction of manslaughter
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
OknotOK Cockfosters, London 24 Jul 15 4.05pm |
|
|
I don't care whether they call it manslaughter or not, it should carry a similar sentence.
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show
|
Stuk Top half 24 Jul 15 4.18pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jul 2015 3.59pm
I'd guess its to do with intent to cause harm. Its basically manslaughter if you ask me, but the CPS might not be able to be certain of a conviction of manslaughter
I'd argue that driving a car when you can't is intending to cause harm.
I'm fairly sure it would be the case if I took an HGV for a joyride.
Optimistic as ever
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 24 Jul 15 4.25pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 4.18pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jul 2015 3.59pm
I'd guess its to do with intent to cause harm. Its basically manslaughter if you ask me, but the CPS might not be able to be certain of a conviction of manslaughter
I'd argue that driving a car when you can't is intending to cause harm.
I'm fairly sure it would be the case if I took an HGV for a joyride.
But could you prove it beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused, intended to cause harm. Though the sentence is up to 14 years (max).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Stuk Top half 24 Jul 15 4.36pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jul 2015 4.25pm
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 4.18pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jul 2015 3.59pm
I'd guess its to do with intent to cause harm. Its basically manslaughter if you ask me, but the CPS might not be able to be certain of a conviction of manslaughter
I'd argue that driving a car when you can't is intending to cause harm.
I'm fairly sure it would be the case if I took an HGV for a joyride.
But could you prove it beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused, intended to cause harm. Though the sentence is up to 14 years (max).
Why shouldn you have to. If you haven't been trained to operate a vehicle the probability is that you will cause harm. Be it to people or property, including the car you've taken.
Optimistic as ever
|
fed up eagle Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 24 Jul 15 7.45pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 3.45pm
[Link]
Two 16 year old kill a telecoms engineer and are charged with dangerous driving.
If you cannot drive, you should not be able to be charged with dangerous driving. You've killed someone with a weapon essentially.
Very true and a common sense comment, unfortunately common sense is not used in our penal system, and most judges are away with the fairies and won't convict criminals anymore, just like they won't deport people like captain Hook and that stinking piece of shyte Choudary. Our justice system used to be the envy of the world, now it's the laughing stock of the world instead.
|
legaleagle 24 Jul 15 8.57pm |
|
|
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
|
-TUX- Alphabettispaghetti 24 Jul 15 9.38pm |
|
|
A sad story. Not much to go by from the link but personally i'd lock them up.
Time to move forward together.
|
fed up eagle Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 24 Jul 15 10.12pm |
|
|
At 16 aren't they too young to be driving? Forgive me if I'm wrong but I'm pretty certain I had to wait until 17 until being able to take driving lessons. So surely that's a charge in itself?
|
Stuk Top half 27 Jul 15 2.18pm |
|
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Optimistic as ever
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 27 Jul 15 2.25pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 4.36pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jul 2015 4.25pm
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 4.18pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Jul 2015 3.59pm
I'd guess its to do with intent to cause harm. Its basically manslaughter if you ask me, but the CPS might not be able to be certain of a conviction of manslaughter
I'd argue that driving a car when you can't is intending to cause harm.
I'm fairly sure it would be the case if I took an HGV for a joyride.
But could you prove it beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused, intended to cause harm. Though the sentence is up to 14 years (max).
Why shouldn you have to. If you haven't been trained to operate a vehicle the probability is that you will cause harm. Be it to people or property, including the car you've taken.
Its the necessity of criminal law, is proving mens and actus rae for each offence. Which means for proving manslaughter you need to show that the actions of the guilty party were intending to cause serious harm to someone.
I'm inclined to agree with you, by the way, that death by dangerous driving should carry the same sentence as manslaughter (i.e. potentially a life sentence).
The problem is proving it beyond reasonable doubt with a driving offence. The solution, is to raise the sentencing of Death by Dangerous Driving to match a maximum sentence of life.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 27 Jul 15 2.27pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 2.18pm
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Of course it might be a case that their driving wasn't the cause of the death(which is probably when the charge is dangerous driving, not causing death by dangerous driving). I doubt the CPS reduced charges because they were young, or old, that tends to affect sentencing, not charging.
** Re-reading the original link, that seems unlikely unless the engineers were stood out in the middle of the road or something.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 2.30pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 27 Jul 15 2.33pm |
|
Quote fed up eagle at 24 Jul 2015 7.45pm
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 3.45pm
[Link]
Two 16 year old kill a telecoms engineer and are charged with dangerous driving.
If you cannot drive, you should not be able to be charged with dangerous driving. You've killed someone with a weapon essentially.
Very true and a common sense comment, unfortunately common sense is not used in our penal system, and most judges are away with the fairies and won't convict criminals anymore, just like they won't deport people like captain Hook and that stinking piece of shyte Choudary. Our justice system used to be the envy of the world, now it's the laughing stock of the world instead.
Yes, because the legal system should be based around a system that contradicts itself, and follows public opinion and not around fairness and reasonableness.
Also, you can only really pursue what you think you can prove. Might be a case that they can put the car in the area or the kids in the car, but not link the two events sufficiently to the accident.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Stuk Top half 27 Jul 15 3.20pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 2.27pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 2.18pm
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Of course it might be a case that their driving wasn't the cause of the death(which is probably when the charge is dangerous driving, not causing death by dangerous driving). I doubt the CPS reduced charges because they were young, or old, that tends to affect sentencing, not charging.
** Re-reading the original link, that seems unlikely unless the engineers were stood out in the middle of the road or something.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 2.30pm)
I reckon you can almost guarantee that's what they did.
These two have thought it would be a laugh to drive/mess around in a car. Unless an adult has willingly given the key and permission to do just that, then they've gotten away with minor charges for killing someone purely because of their ages.
Optimistic as ever
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 27 Jul 15 3.51pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 3.20pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 2.27pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 2.18pm
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Of course it might be a case that their driving wasn't the cause of the death(which is probably when the charge is dangerous driving, not causing death by dangerous driving). I doubt the CPS reduced charges because they were young, or old, that tends to affect sentencing, not charging.
** Re-reading the original link, that seems unlikely unless the engineers were stood out in the middle of the road or something.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 2.30pm)
I reckon you can almost guarantee that's what they did.
These two have thought it would be a laugh to drive/mess around in a car. Unless an adult has willingly given the key and permission to do just that, then they've gotten away with minor charges for killing someone purely because of their ages.
If they were sixteen though they'd be charged as minors anyhow, and unlikely to face more than four or five years.
It might be the case, but there isn't really any statement that the CPS decided to charge them with a lesser crime because they were young.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 3.52pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Sedlescombe Sedlescombe 27 Jul 15 3.58pm |
|
Quote Stuk at 24 Jul 2015 3.45pm
[Link]
Two 16 year old kill a telecoms engineer and are charged with dangerous driving.
If you cannot drive, you should not be able to be charged with dangerous driving. You've killed someone with a weapon essentially.
According to your link they haven't been charged with anything yet. They are being "held". The charge will deendo the CPS
|
Stuk Top half 27 Jul 15 5.21pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 3.51pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 3.20pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 2.27pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 2.18pm
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Of course it might be a case that their driving wasn't the cause of the death(which is probably when the charge is dangerous driving, not causing death by dangerous driving). I doubt the CPS reduced charges because they were young, or old, that tends to affect sentencing, not charging.
** Re-reading the original link, that seems unlikely unless the engineers were stood out in the middle of the road or something.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 2.30pm)
I reckon you can almost guarantee that's what they did.
These two have thought it would be a laugh to drive/mess around in a car. Unless an adult has willingly given the key and permission to do just that, then they've gotten away with minor charges for killing someone purely because of their ages.
If they were sixteen though they'd be charged as minors anyhow, and unlikely to face more than four or five years.
It might be the case, but there isn't really any statement that the CPS decided to charge them with a lesser crime because they were young.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 3.52pm)
They shouldn't be, and it simply shows that age is a massive factor in deciding punishment of a crime.
Or in this case which crime to arrest them for (not been charged yet as pointed out).
Optimistic as ever
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 28 Jul 15 10.37am |
|
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 5.21pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 3.51pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 3.20pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 2.27pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 2.18pm
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Of course it might be a case that their driving wasn't the cause of the death(which is probably when the charge is dangerous driving, not causing death by dangerous driving). I doubt the CPS reduced charges because they were young, or old, that tends to affect sentencing, not charging.
** Re-reading the original link, that seems unlikely unless the engineers were stood out in the middle of the road or something.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 2.30pm)
I reckon you can almost guarantee that's what they did.
These two have thought it would be a laugh to drive/mess around in a car. Unless an adult has willingly given the key and permission to do just that, then they've gotten away with minor charges for killing someone purely because of their ages.
If they were sixteen though they'd be charged as minors anyhow, and unlikely to face more than four or five years.
It might be the case, but there isn't really any statement that the CPS decided to charge them with a lesser crime because they were young.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 3.52pm)
They shouldn't be, and it simply shows that age is a massive factor in deciding punishment of a crime.
Or in this case which crime to arrest them for (not been charged yet as pointed out).
Its not about punishment, but rehabilitation, the option exists in certain cases to try them as adults, but there is a definite case for people in their youth doing reckless and stupid things they grow out of rather quickly.
I don't really see that punishment serves any real tangible process except as a means towards rehabilitation.
I suppose of course it'll depend on what the CPS feel they can prove and charge.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Stuk Top half 28 Jul 15 2.25pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Jul 2015 10.37am
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 5.21pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 3.51pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 3.20pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 27 Jul 2015 2.27pm
Quote Stuk at 27 Jul 2015 2.18pm
Quote legaleagle at 24 Jul 2015 8.57pm
Funny old world we live in,but Courts tend to go by what the law actually is rather than a lynch mob mentality.
If you do want to blame anyone,blame governments,they pass laws.
We can't possibly say on what we know from the link whether there was or wasn't any legal basis to charge for manslaughter.A number of things can come into it,some to do with the particular "state of mind" of the driver.
What is interesting is that if they are being charged with dangerous driving,they are not being charged with the offences of "Causing Death By Dangerous Driving" or "Causing Death By Careless or Inconsiderate Driving".Though even then,there can be good reason why not.
It's not a good reason, it's their age.
The law becomes total s*** when the CPS decide someone is a bit on the young, or old, side.
Of course it might be a case that their driving wasn't the cause of the death(which is probably when the charge is dangerous driving, not causing death by dangerous driving). I doubt the CPS reduced charges because they were young, or old, that tends to affect sentencing, not charging.
** Re-reading the original link, that seems unlikely unless the engineers were stood out in the middle of the road or something.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 2.30pm)
I reckon you can almost guarantee that's what they did.
These two have thought it would be a laugh to drive/mess around in a car. Unless an adult has willingly given the key and permission to do just that, then they've gotten away with minor charges for killing someone purely because of their ages.
If they were sixteen though they'd be charged as minors anyhow, and unlikely to face more than four or five years.
It might be the case, but there isn't really any statement that the CPS decided to charge them with a lesser crime because they were young.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Jul 2015 3.52pm)
They shouldn't be, and it simply shows that age is a massive factor in deciding punishment of a crime.
Or in this case which crime to arrest them for (not been charged yet as pointed out).
Its not about punishment, but rehabilitation, the option exists in certain cases to try them as adults, but there is a definite case for people in their youth doing reckless and stupid things they grow out of rather quickly.
I don't really see that punishment serves any real tangible process except as a means towards rehabilitation.
I suppose of course it'll depend on what the CPS feel they can prove and charge.
I disagree. Initially it is about punishment and there's no real rehabilitation required in this case. They probably wont be that stupid to do something like this again, but you don't just say "oh well, lesson learned. Carry on with your lives."
The family of the bloke who's been killed might feel a bit miffed otherwise.
Optimistic as ever
|