This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 06 Aug 2015 8.42am
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2015 8.31am
It was a real life medical experiment without anaesthetic by the US. They could have quite easily have dropped the bombs 40 miles from Tokyo in a non-populated area and warned that the city would be next on the list if they didn't surrender. The population of Hiroshima at the time was mostly kids, women and old people as the men were away soldiering. Something the US would also have obviously known. A heinous act. The only flaw is that the Japanese didn't surrender after Hiroshima, laying waste to a forest would not have made any difference to the Japanese position. Given that Nagasaki was bombed three days later, its hard to be certain whether Japan would have surrendered or not. Its important to remember that Japan would have essentially had almost no idea what happened at Hiroshima as the bomb destroyed all communications and logistics, whilst creating a humanitarian disaster to cope with. Was it necessary, probably, and it probably saved US Service men's lives, but that doesn't mean it wasn't a war crime. Most war crimes can be justified in those kinds of terms to some extent. But it was also an experiment as well, and the option was specifically taken to hit land targets with civilian populations, rather than a number of available military targets, including the remains of the Japanese fleet (both targets had some military value, although when dropping nuclear bombs, it is kind of hard not to hit something that can be classed as having military value, especially after six years of a war). The US, in preparation for the invasion of Japan, produced Purple Heart medals, in such quantity, that they would not have to manufacture any new medals until the 21st Century (During the Iraq Insurgency).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
I think it underlines the nature of war where in necessary isn't the same as being right, or just, and the longer it goes on, the more the atrocities tend to stack up, and the horror is perpetuated. Ultimately, you have to win, especially when you consider the stakes involved in those wars, where national existence was at stake. Winner takes all. Dresden, Hiroshima and Nagasaki, were probably all war crimes, as was most of what the SOE did, resistance groups were terrorist groups. The real danger I suspect is that we tend to see it in a myopic view (Dresden justified by the Blitz, because the Germans did it first), but in truth both were arguably indiscriminate massacres of civilians. The moral or ethical argument doesn't really hold up. They killed ours, we killed theirs, necessary isn't the same as right. Wars aren't fought on ethics or morality, but on the need to survive and to win.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history. Considering that the japanese were trying to surrender before the bomb was even dropped i'd say it was pretty unnecessary.
|
|
|
Quote ghosteagle at 06 Aug 2015 3.17pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history. Considering that the japanese were trying to surrender before the bomb was even dropped i'd say it was pretty unnecessary.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote ghosteagle at 06 Aug 2015 3.17pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history. Considering that the japanese were trying to surrender before the bomb was even dropped i'd say it was pretty unnecessary. That some of the Japanese government were talking about surrender doesn't necessarily mean that they were intending to surrender. Even after Hiroshima, there was still discussion of surrender and continuation. Nagasaki pretty much cleared the argument up (although had the Japanese known the US only had maybe three more bombs, they might have held out).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Aug 2015 3.25pm
Quote ghosteagle at 06 Aug 2015 3.17pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history. Considering that the japanese were trying to surrender before the bomb was even dropped i'd say it was pretty unnecessary. That some of the Japanese government were talking about surrender doesn't necessarily mean that they were intending to surrender. Even after Hiroshima, there was still discussion of surrender and continuation. Nagasaki pretty much cleared the argument up (although had the Japanese known the US only had maybe three more bombs, they might have held out). I don't think they even had one more, let alone three. Anyway, it's pointless trying to apply present day attitudes and moralise about it so long after the event. Point is, it shortened a war which the Japanese, a particularly nasty bunch of c*nts, had no hesitation in starting.
|
|
|
Quote Cucking Funt at 06 Aug 2015 3.20pm
Quote ghosteagle at 06 Aug 2015 3.17pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Aug 2015 10.33pm
70 years ago. Always thought it was a necessary evil but not so sure now. Then again the Japanese still refused to surrender and of course the atrocities they committed were absolutely horrific. Worryingly there is a significant movement within Japan trying to rewrite history. Considering that the japanese were trying to surrender before the bomb was even dropped i'd say it was pretty unnecessary.
I have no idea of the veracity of this site though
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 3.33pm
My position is this. To see human suffering on that scale is terrible but it has to be put in contest. Well arguably we were weak and cowardly, as we dropped the Atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. As a result, the US probably avoided at least 100,000 casualties (probably closer to at least 500,000+). The Japanese would of course have said they fought honorably and bravely, rather than ruthless and cruelly. But that's all irrelevant when you can vaporize an entire city (and to them it would have seemed 'almost at will' Probably less than 100 people knew what happened that day, and none of them were in Japan. Edited by jamiemartin721 (06 Aug 2015 3.47pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 06 Aug 2015 3.36pm
Quote TheJudge at 06 Aug 2015 3.33pm
My position is this. To see human suffering on that scale is terrible but it has to be put in contest.
With some success. I suspect the Russians wouldn't really have balked at the idea of losing a million men in the invasion of Japan either. Compared to the Eastern front, those were fairly light casualties compared to Stalingrad, Moscow and Leningrad
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.