You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Sod Drugs, legalise Prostitution
November 22 2026 1.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sod Drugs, legalise Prostitution


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Stirlingsays Flag 24 Oct 15 11.17am


There's been all this focus on increasing our already liberal gay rights laws (some of which I agree with anyway) and the drugs lobby are constantly prominent in pushing for legalisation with arguments that have gained some respectability.

But nothing like the same emphasis is given to what I consider to be the most ridiculous and invasive set of laws that are still actively pursued: sex trade laws.

Very little lefty outcry on that....Too busy doing hash to be bothered no doubt.

The implementation of these laws not only criminalises people who don't intend to harm others but it puts them at greater risk of physical harm, putting them onto the street instead of brothels that can be protected....And has the sheer ridiculous situation where the State sticks its nose into a sex act and evaluates whether it's valid or not because money changed hands.

It's not illegal for young women to pursue and marry rich old men.....That's practically the same thing.

Why do we still have these laws?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 24 Oct 15 12.34pm

Been caught have you?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Oct 15 12.44pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Oct 2015 11.17am


There's been all this focus on increasing our already liberal gay rights laws (some of which I agree with anyway) and the drugs lobby are constantly prominent in pushing for legalisation with arguments that have gained some respectability.

But nothing like the same emphasis is given to what I consider to be the most ridiculous and invasive set of laws that are still actively pursued: sex trade laws.

Very little lefty outcry on that....Too busy doing hash to be bothered no doubt.

The implementation of these laws not only criminalises people who don't intend to harm others but it puts them at greater risk of physical harm, putting them onto the street instead of brothels that can be protected....And has the sheer ridiculous situation where the State sticks its nose into a sex act and evaluates whether it's valid or not because money changed hands.

It's not illegal for young women to pursue and marry rich old men.....That's practically the same thing.

Why do we still have these laws?


I agree with the sentiments, particularly for reasons like the probable lessening of sex attacks and the ability of people such as disabled people to be able to buy sex. However, there are obvious problems.
How exactly do you police prostitution so that the vulnerable are not exploited?
How do you make sure there is absolutely no sex-trafficking or under age girls forced into prostitution?
Whilst these are problems now, imagine the outcry if prostitution were legal and these kind of things popped up.
There would have to be quite a lot of thought about exactly how the overall system would work.

Even in places like Amsterdam and Germany where the sextrade is legal, there are still problems and debates, and that would perhpas be the place to start - how exactly has it worked in Holland? Whilst it seems like most are happy with the situation, I beleive that the influx of Eastern European prostitutes has caused a lot of problems. Not that I am any particular expert on the matter.

Another thing I would say is this - a bit like cannabis, it may be illegal but usually it is hardly the police's priority to arrest prostitutes or their customers. I would suspect that without being legal or decriminalised, that prostitutes openly advertise as legitimate 'escorts' and face little harrassment from law enforcement due to it.
I presume the problem is more street prostitution. I can remember seeing some sad looking girls around the docks in Hull for 15 quid a pop. I wouldn't indulge as I believed they looked like addicts - but plenty of others found that fine. That would be the kind of thing that would be barely acceptable, in my opinion.

Edited by ASCPFC (24 Oct 2015 12.47pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 24 Oct 15 12.54pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Oct 2015 11.17am


There's been all this focus on increasing our already liberal gay rights laws (some of which I agree with anyway) and the drugs lobby are constantly prominent in pushing for legalisation with arguments that have gained some respectability.

But nothing like the same emphasis is given to what I consider to be the most ridiculous and invasive set of laws that are still actively pursued: sex trade laws.

Very little lefty outcry on that....Too busy doing hash to be bothered no doubt.

The implementation of these laws not only criminalises people who don't intend to harm others but it puts them at greater risk of physical harm, putting them onto the street instead of brothels that can be protected....And has the sheer ridiculous situation where the State sticks its nose into a sex act and evaluates whether it's valid or not because money changed hands.

It's not illegal for young women to pursue and marry rich old men.....That's practically the same thing.

Why do we still have these laws?

Stirling, it's myopic to suggest that 'the left' isn't doing anything with regards to the ridiculous prostitution laws. On a global level, lots of anti-slavery action groups focus primarily on the sex trade, and counselling and refuges have been set up by a lot of left-leaning and feminist groups in an attempt to help sex workers. Nationally, a lot of grass roots feminist and LGBT work has been done in a similar vein. Cuts to local government funding have also had a massive effect on the ability of local councils to provide support to women's refuges, and of course a lot of prostitutes in this country are either here illegally, thus are given no citizen's rights, or are homeless, drug dependent etc.

I also think grouping gay rights alongside drug and prostitution laws is a bit ridiculous. Homosexuality isn't a black market commodity, its a sexual orientation rooted in our biology which around 10/20% of human beings possess. Prostitution on the other hand, is often - but not by any means exclusively - a symptom of a society with high levels of poverty or inequality. The same can be said of drug addiction and usage.

I would agree with you though, criminalising these practices does a hell of a lot more harm than good.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

johnno42000 Flag 24 Oct 15 1.42pm

Is the reason it isn't legalised because there is a secret thrill for MP's that they may be caught and punished.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Oct 15 2.48pm

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 24 Oct 2015 12.34pm

Been caught have you?

I went with one as a twenty year old as an experience.

Bad idea, it became apparent that she was a druggie....I found myself in a strange house with lots of dubious people....I regretted it.....I've never done it again.

My opinion on this isn't about me.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Oct 15 2.56pm

Quote serial thriller at 24 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Oct 2015 11.17am


There's been all this focus on increasing our already liberal gay rights laws (some of which I agree with anyway) and the drugs lobby are constantly prominent in pushing for legalisation with arguments that have gained some respectability.

But nothing like the same emphasis is given to what I consider to be the most ridiculous and invasive set of laws that are still actively pursued: sex trade laws.

Very little lefty outcry on that....Too busy doing hash to be bothered no doubt.

The implementation of these laws not only criminalises people who don't intend to harm others but it puts them at greater risk of physical harm, putting them onto the street instead of brothels that can be protected....And has the sheer ridiculous situation where the State sticks its nose into a sex act and evaluates whether it's valid or not because money changed hands.

It's not illegal for young women to pursue and marry rich old men.....That's practically the same thing.

Why do we still have these laws?

Stirling, it's myopic to suggest that 'the left' isn't doing anything with regards to the ridiculous prostitution laws. On a global level, lots of anti-slavery action groups focus primarily on the sex trade, and counselling and refuges have been set up by a lot of left-leaning and feminist groups in an attempt to help sex workers. Nationally, a lot of grass roots feminist and LGBT work has been done in a similar vein. Cuts to local government funding have also had a massive effect on the ability of local councils to provide support to women's refuges, and of course a lot of prostitutes in this country are either here illegally, thus are given no citizen's rights, or are homeless, drug dependent etc.

I also think grouping gay rights alongside drug and prostitution laws is a bit ridiculous. Homosexuality isn't a black market commodity, its a sexual orientation rooted in our biology which around 10/20% of human beings possess. Prostitution on the other hand, is often - but not by any means exclusively - a symptom of a society with high levels of poverty or inequality. The same can be said of drug addiction and usage.

I would agree with you though, criminalising these practices does a hell of a lot more harm than good.


I don't think it's ridiculous to have a go at the left for their priorities on this.

With a few notable exceptions they pay far more weight and emphasis upon the drug legalization issue than they do prostitution.

I will say that the left have done more good work on this than the right who I'm ashamed to say are mostly the problem behind these laws.

However, it's the left that keep this a minor issue. They are more interested in protecting weed growers than they are from reducing the chance that mostly young girls/women will suffer terrible abuse from any one of a number of different avenues.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 Oct 2015 2.56pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Oct 15 4.30pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Oct 2015 11.17am


There's been all this focus on increasing our already liberal gay rights laws (some of which I agree with anyway) and the drugs lobby are constantly prominent in pushing for legalisation with arguments that have gained some respectability.

But nothing like the same emphasis is given to what I consider to be the most ridiculous and invasive set of laws that are still actively pursued: sex trade laws.

Very little lefty outcry on that....Too busy doing hash to be bothered no doubt.

The implementation of these laws not only criminalises people who don't intend to harm others but it puts them at greater risk of physical harm, putting them onto the street instead of brothels that can be protected....And has the sheer ridiculous situation where the State sticks its nose into a sex act and evaluates whether it's valid or not because money changed hands.

It's not illegal for young women to pursue and marry rich old men.....That's practically the same thing.

Why do we still have these laws?

Entirely agree, although in fairness prostitution itself isn't actually illegal, and many get around this through 'escorting' and 'massage' fronts. Most of the laws around prostitution are about 'street walking, curb crawling and brothels'. Most offences in the uk are for solicitation and kerb crawling offences, which occur in public (and for running brothels).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 24 Oct 15 6.34pm

On a 3 month dry spell so give me the petition to sign!

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Oct 15 7.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Oct 2015 4.30pm

Entirely agree, although in fairness prostitution itself isn't actually illegal, and many get around this through 'escorting' and 'massage' fronts. Most of the laws around prostitution are about 'street walking, curb crawling and brothels'. Most offences in the uk are for solicitation and kerb crawling offences, which occur in public (and for running brothels).



As usual Jamie you manage to educate me on something.

The sooner we grow up about sex in our western culture the better for most of us......It's a hangover from religion that hurts plenty of people.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 24 Oct 15 8.42pm

Dont think prostitution is illegal - it is soliciting that is.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Oct 15 8.58pm

Quote Catfish at 24 Oct 2015 8.42pm

Dont think prostitution is illegal - it is soliciting that is.


The whole situation is ridiculous.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

becky Flag over the moon 25 Oct 15 8.27am

Quote serial thriller at 24 Oct 2015 12.54pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Oct 2015 11.17am

Stirling, it's myopic to suggest that 'the left' isn't doing anything with regards to the ridiculous prostitution laws. On a global level, lots of anti-slavery action groups focus primarily on the sex trade, and counselling and refuges have been set up by a lot of left-leaning and feminist groups in an attempt to help sex workers. Nationally, a lot of grass roots feminist and LGBT work has been done in a similar vein. Cuts to local government funding have also had a massive effect on the ability of local councils to provide support to women's refuges, and of course a lot of prostitutes in this country are either here illegally, thus are given no citizen's rights, or are homeless, drug dependent etc.

I also think grouping gay rights alongside drug and prostitution laws is a bit ridiculous. Homosexuality isn't a black market commodity, its a sexual orientation rooted in our biology which around 10/20% of human beings possess. Prostitution on the other hand, is often - but not by any means exclusively - a symptom of a society with high levels of poverty or inequality. The same can be said of drug addiction and usage.

I would agree with you though, criminalising these practices does a hell of a lot more harm than good.

Utter rot! Prostitution is driven 100% by market forces - and the largest part of that is, and always has been, that men want sex.... so it is provided by women.

Poverty and inequality have little if anything to do with it - it's not called 'the oldest profession' for nothing!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Oct 15 11.13am

Low poverty would reduce prostitution and drug addiction but it wouldn't get rid of them.

The supply and demand argument put by Becky has truth to it, plus the reality that prostitution may be a choice that women make for many different reasons.

I believe that a grown up society stays away from consensual sex.....A society that still locks up brass has its priorities wrong.

I agree that the focus should be on the sex slave element and exploitation. Any situation where a woman hasn't made this choice for herself.

Any woman who decides....for whatever reason to go this way should be taxed like a normal worker. They should have the option of a safe working environment that vets its customers.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

elgrande Flag bedford 25 Oct 15 11.31am

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Oct 2015 11.13am

Low poverty would reduce prostitution and drug addiction but it wouldn't get rid of them.

The supply and demand argument put by Becky has truth to it, plus the reality that prostitution may be a choice that women make for many different reasons.

I believe that a grown up society stays away from consensual sex.....A society that still locks up brass has its priorities wrong.

I agree that the focus should be on the sex slave element and exploitation. Any situation where a woman hasn't made this choice for herself.

Any woman who decides....for whatever reason to go this way should be taxed like a normal worker. They should have the option of a safe working environment that vets its customers.


Bit unfair stirling.....some hokers are quite attractive....

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 25 Oct 15 12.32pm

Quote becky at 25 Oct 2015 8.27am

Quote serial thriller at 24 Oct 2015 12.54pm


Stirling, it's myopic to suggest that 'the left' isn't doing anything with regards to the ridiculous prostitution laws. On a global level, lots of anti-slavery action groups focus primarily on the sex trade, and counselling and refuges have been set up by a lot of left-leaning and feminist groups in an attempt to help sex workers. Nationally, a lot of grass roots feminist and LGBT work has been done in a similar vein. Cuts to local government funding have also had a massive effect on the ability of local councils to provide support to women's refuges, and of course a lot of prostitutes in this country are either here illegally, thus are given no citizen's rights, or are homeless, drug dependent etc.

I also think grouping gay rights alongside drug and prostitution laws is a bit ridiculous. Homosexuality isn't a black market commodity, its a sexual orientation rooted in our biology which around 10/20% of human beings possess. Prostitution on the other hand, is often - but not by any means exclusively - a symptom of a society with high levels of poverty or inequality. The same can be said of drug addiction and usage.

I would agree with you though, criminalising these practices does a hell of a lot more harm than good.

Utter rot! Prostitution is driven 100% by market forces - and the largest part of that is, and always has been, that men want sex.... so it is provided by women.

Poverty and inequality have little if anything to do with it - it's not called 'the oldest profession' for nothing!


Firstly, prostitution is by no means exclusively a female occupation. Particularly in some of the poorer areas of the world, young boys, transgender and men are pretty commonly found doing sex work.

As for your last comment, this is a very interesting fact page based on prostitution in the UK: [Link] As it reads, '74% of women involved in prostitution cited poverty, the need to pay household expenses and support their children, as a primary motivator for entering sex work.' These are women who have almost all experienced domestic abuse, rape, are highly drug dependent, have almost no protection, and are incredibly likely to be murdered. They aren't doing it for pleasure, they are doing it either to fund their drug habits or to pay the bills.

Obviously it's very difficult to collect data on these things, as the women involved are often very hesitant to come forward, but there's fairly good evidence that prostitution is increasing in the UK, particularly among young single women who are being disproportionately affected by the government's welfare cuts, and female students who are struggling to find part-time work as companies are cutting back.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

elgrande Flag bedford 25 Oct 15 2.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 25 Oct 2015 12.32pm

Quote becky at 25 Oct 2015 8.27am

Quote serial thriller at 24 Oct 2015 12.54pm


Stirling, it's myopic to suggest that 'the left' isn't doing anything with regards to the ridiculous prostitution laws. On a global level, lots of anti-slavery action groups focus primarily on the sex trade, and counselling and refuges have been set up by a lot of left-leaning and feminist groups in an attempt to help sex workers. Nationally, a lot of grass roots feminist and LGBT work has been done in a similar vein. Cuts to local government funding have also had a massive effect on the ability of local councils to provide support to women's refuges, and of course a lot of prostitutes in this country are either here illegally, thus are given no citizen's rights, or are homeless, drug dependent etc.

I also think grouping gay rights alongside drug and prostitution laws is a bit ridiculous. Homosexuality isn't a black market commodity, its a sexual orientation rooted in our biology which around 10/20% of human beings possess. Prostitution on the other hand, is often - but not by any means exclusively - a symptom of a society with high levels of poverty or inequality. The same can be said of drug addiction and usage.

I would agree with you though, criminalising these practices does a hell of a lot more harm than good.

Utter rot! Prostitution is driven 100% by market forces - and the largest part of that is, and always has been, that men want sex.... so it is provided by women.

Poverty and inequality have little if anything to do with it - it's not called 'the oldest profession' for nothing!


Firstly, prostitution is by no means exclusively a female occupation. Particularly in some of the poorer areas of the world, young boys, transgender and men are pretty commonly found doing sex work.

As for your last comment, this is a very interesting fact page based on prostitution in the UK: [Link] As it reads, '74% of women involved in prostitution cited poverty, the need to pay household expenses and support their children, as a primary motivator for entering sex work.' These are women who have almost all experienced domestic abuse, rape, are highly drug dependent, have almost no protection, and are incredibly likely to be murdered. They aren't doing it for pleasure, they are doing it either to fund their drug habits or to pay the bills.

Obviously it's very difficult to collect data on these things, as the women involved are often very hesitant to come forward, but there's fairly good evidence that prostitution is increasing in the UK, particularly among young single women who are being disproportionately affected by the government's welfare cuts, and female students who are struggling to find part-time work as companies are cutting back.


Jesus is their nothing you won't blame the government for.
show the evidence

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Oct 15 2.20pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Oct 2015 11.13am

Low poverty would reduce prostitution and drug addiction but it wouldn't get rid of them.

The supply and demand argument put by Becky has truth to it, plus the reality that prostitution may be a choice that women make for many different reasons.

I believe that a grown up society stays away from consensual sex.....A society that still locks up brass has its priorities wrong.

I agree that the focus should be on the sex slave element and exploitation. Any situation where a woman hasn't made this choice for herself.

Any woman who decides....for whatever reason to go this way should be taxed like a normal worker. They should have the option of a safe working environment that vets its customers.

I think you have to see prostitution as being several different motivations. These tend to be economic, although the problem has never really been so much with prostitution but the exploitation of sex workers in society and their 'ostracisation' from social protection (forcing sex workers closer to organised crime).

In the rise of sex trafficking fear also plays a serious role (both of the traffickers and of the authorities - who are often interested in only the conviction of the traffickers, not the future of the girls trafficked).

Its unlikely that many sex workers make a deliberate choice, to do what they do (but that's by no means true of all those in the trade), but they all do make an economic one. Its not a career of initial choice, the lure is always the economic factor.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 25 Oct 15 2.27pm

Quote johnno42000 at 24 Oct 2015 1.42pm

Is the reason it isn't legalised because there is a secret thrill for MP's that they may be caught and punished.

Don't be silly ...they are all part of the "Establishment" and therefore above the law!!!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Oct 15 8.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Oct 2015 2.20pm

I think you have to see prostitution as being several different motivations. These tend to be economic, although the problem has never really been so much with prostitution but the exploitation of sex workers in society and their 'ostracisation' from social protection (forcing sex workers closer to organised crime).

In the rise of sex trafficking fear also plays a serious role (both of the traffickers and of the authorities - who are often interested in only the conviction of the traffickers, not the future of the girls trafficked).

Its unlikely that many sex workers make a deliberate choice, to do what they do (but that's by no means true of all those in the trade), but they all do make an economic one. Its not a career of initial choice, the lure is always the economic factor.


I think the economic element is obviously the largest part to this.

Most of us have bills to pay, many of us don't do our ideal jobs. In situations where a person has chosen the sex trade (without compulsion) we should always keep our minds open as too their particular motivations

It's important not to stereotype (not that you have) with people who choose the sex trade....Sometimes they aren't defenseless, poor innocents who have no other options and need to be protected....But in many instances they are......For others, the reason why can be a sliding scale.....I imagine.

Some will see the amount they can earn an hour compared to cleaning toilets or working in Tescos and draw the obvious conclusions or view it as an easy wage top up or a way to pay off a debt.....Many don't think of the risks....Or have addictions or shock horror for some a high sex drive does factor in...The list of reasons is probably endless.

Obviously there is a crime/drugs problem linked to this and this is entirely the fault of the criminalising of the sex trade.

The law should be working to keep these workers safe.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Oct 2015 8.09pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Sod Drugs, legalise Prostitution