You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Martin Amis
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Martin Amis


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 26 Oct 15 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

chris123 Flag hove actually 26 Oct 15 12.40pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


While being a life long Labour supporter saying what he thinks. You seem to be tackling the man rather than the ball.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 26 Oct 15 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 26 Oct 15 1.03pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)


Yeah but are they really the greatest minds? 40% of Oxbridge graduates went to public school, so unsurprisingly it's really the richest minds that are dominating our society. And then there's the point that, especially in politics, a detailed knowledge of Classics and an ability to do well in some exams aren't necessarily going to make you a good public servant.

Democratic capitalism is built upon the idea that anyone from any background can establish themselves at the top of society through hard work. Yet when you look at our society, and see just how dominated it is by publicly educated Oxbridge graduates, you realise that it's nonsense in the main. That's why what Amis says sticks in the teeth: when you see someone like Corbyn, who has worked quietly but incredibly hard throughout his political life get close to the top, they are sneered at for not being 'one of us'. You see it in the media too, which is also made up of 50% Oxbridge graduates: the idea they can't ring up their old uni pals and ask them for the latest political scoops is terrifying.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Sportyteacher Flag London 26 Oct 15 1.03pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Martin Amis has too high opinion of himself. His views of Corbyn are only his own in that he doesn't speak or think on my behalf. Jog on, Martin!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Oct 15 1.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.



Quite true.

Unfortunately, if you were to replace the ruling class with plumbers all that would happen is that their kids would get a private education and so on and we would soon be back to square one.

Survival of the fittest extends to offspring even when they aren't really up to it.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 26 Oct 15 1.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

I call bulls*** Jamie, Richard Branson left school at 16, is now worth 5.1 Billion, Price Edward had the best education money could by and left school with one C and two D's at a level. Point being its not about money buying you an education sure better schools help, but there are thousands of people who had a state school education and went on to get degrees and become masters of industry, you juct choose to ignore them as it goes against the lefty ideal of elitism in education.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

The best Pupils are not always the wealthy ones either. A good school does not garuntee a good pupil.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

Summation on your part. How do you explain the kids that come from broken homes that go on to get degrees ?

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.

So your saying a plumber with city and guild should be on trade delagations to gain foreign investment to their ward or constituancey !? they'd all end up pissed in the dam with a various amouont of extenisve STD's !



 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

matt_himself Flag Matataland 26 Oct 15 2.30pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


He is not being a 'prick'. He is giving his opinion on something important - whether someone who could (God forbid) become PM has the mental dexerity to do the job.

Your problem is that Amis is crititising someone who you clearly associate with and instead of defending Corbyn's abilities, have reverted to type and launched an attack 'Oxbridge' and the establishment.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 26 Oct 15 2.47pm

Quote Sportyteacher at 26 Oct 2015 1.03pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Martin Amis has too high opinion of himself. His views of Corbyn are only his own in that he doesn't speak or think on my behalf. Jog on, Martin!


And what you're saying is that he shouldn't be allowed to express that opinion?

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

JL85 Flag London,SE9 26 Oct 15 2.49pm

Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.55pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

I call bulls*** Jamie, Richard Branson left school at 16, is now worth 5.1 Billion, Price Edward had the best education money could by and left school with one C and two D's at a level. Point being its not about money buying you an education sure better schools help, but there are thousands of people who had a state school education and went on to get degrees and become masters of industry, you juct choose to ignore them as it goes against the lefty ideal of elitism in education.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

The best Pupils are not always the wealthy ones either. A good school does not garuntee a good pupil.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

Summation on your part. How do you explain the kids that come from broken homes that go on to get degrees ?

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.

So your saying a plumber with city and guild should be on trade delagations to gain foreign investment to their ward or constituancey !? they'd all end up pissed in the dam with a various amouont of extenisve STD's !



The difference being Branson is from a wealthy background and had the capital to cover any losses in his start up businesses, a luxury that doesn't extend to your average person.

Alan Sugar is much better example. Not the point though, the point is the percentage. The working class, make up a vast majority of the population yet account for such a tiny percentage of MP's, Barristers, City Traders etc.

The point is, the opportunities are there, just not for everyone.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 3.57pm

Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.55pm

I call bulls*** Jamie, Richard Branson left school at 16, is now worth 5.1 Billion, Price Edward had the best education money could by and left school with one C and two D's at a level. Point being its not about money buying you an education sure better schools help, but there are thousands of people who had a state school education and went on to get degrees and become masters of industry, you juct choose to ignore them as it goes against the lefty ideal of elitism in education.

Branson tends to leave out the fact his parents were actually quite well off, and that the success of Virgin records was based on a 'tax fraud' that would have bankrupted his company, had his mother not remortgaged her house to pay the unpaid tax bills. By that point the Virgin Brand for mail order records was established, but his success was essentially based on a failed tax fraud.

Income helps a lot, because contrary to popular opinion, you can buy your kids a better education. It won't turn an dim witted kid into a genius, but as a generalization people who attend private school, even on scholarships or sponsor programs, achieve higher academic achievement, on the whole, compared to people who don't.

Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.55pm

The best Pupils are not always the wealthy ones either. A good school does not garuntee a good pupil.

Of course not, but it will generally also give you much better contacts in terms of networking and access generally to better teachers, smaller classes and more focused instruction and so on. It won't make you more 'intelligent' but it will make much more of what you have (and if you happen to be behind, have dyslexia or learning disorders, then specialist private education is even more valuable).

Where as the traditional comprehensive tends towards factors such as large classes, a broader range of teacher quality, lower standards of individual tutoring and so on.

Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.55pm
Summation on your part. How do you explain the kids that come from broken homes that go on to get degrees ?

Its a generalization, but in my experience, they tend to work harder than other pupils, or pursue education because they see it as a way out. Also its worth noting that a dysfunctional family can serve to 'accelerate the maturity' of children, as they become more functional in fulfilling traditional adult roles, such as helping siblings with homework etc.

Quote dannyh at 26 Oct 2015 1.55pm
So your saying a plumber with city and guild should be on trade delagations to gain foreign investment to their ward or constituancey !? they'd all end up pissed in the dam with a various amouont of extenisve STD's !

Yes, if he's the MP, as the role of the MP is representation of the people. The actual work of the trade delegation is largely done by civil servants and those the MP oversees.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 4.04pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 1.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.



Quite true.

Unfortunately, if you were to replace the ruling class with plumbers all that would happen is that their kids would get a private education and so on and we would soon be back to square one.

Survival of the fittest extends to offspring even when they aren't really up to it.

My problem with private schools has never been that they exist, but that the a lot of very talented kids miss out on the benefits because of the expense, where as plenty of 'Nice but Dim' Tims will massively benefit because of the people they meet there, just because their father could pay.

These people often do well at university, because they'll benefit from a lot of one on one tuition, in return for the 'new library wing'.

In theory I think the idea of grammar schools is fine provided the entry remains unbiased, and entirely based on pupils achievements. In reality, grammar schools tended towards being selective by their locations, costs of uniforms and so on.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 26 Oct 15 4.26pm

Martin Anus must have a new book coming out, . . .yawn

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Oct 15 4.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 4.04pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 1.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.



Quite true.

Unfortunately, if you were to replace the ruling class with plumbers all that would happen is that their kids would get a private education and so on and we would soon be back to square one.

Survival of the fittest extends to offspring even when they aren't really up to it.

My problem with private schools has never been that they exist, but that the a lot of very talented kids miss out on the benefits because of the expense, where as plenty of 'Nice but Dim' Tims will massively benefit because of the people they meet there, just because their father could pay.

These people often do well at university, because they'll benefit from a lot of one on one tuition, in return for the 'new library wing'.

In theory I think the idea of grammar schools is fine provided the entry remains unbiased, and entirely based on pupils achievements. In reality, grammar schools tended towards being selective by their locations, costs of uniforms and so on.

Yes it seems unfair but how can we stop people at the top of society seeking to gain advantage for their children ? We would all do it if we could.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Oct 15 4.41pm

Quote JL85 at 26 Oct 2015 2.49pm

The difference being Branson is from a wealthy background and had the capital to cover any losses in his start up businesses, a luxury that doesn't extend to your average person.

Alan Sugar is much better example. Not the point though, the point is the percentage. The working class, make up a vast majority of the population yet account for such a tiny percentage of MP's, Barristers, City Traders etc.

The point is, the opportunities are there, just not for everyone.

Additionally, I'm not so sure that Branson is necessarily particularly clever or intelligent - These aren't characteristics common in self made people, they tend to be risk takers, and risk mitigators, who as they succeed tend to employ the kind of people who do rather well educationally.

Usually when you look at people who have made a lot of money, they usually have failed once or twice before, but they keep going. Ultimately, they either hit the success or give up (and you never hear of them).

Then when successful, they tend to continue on a similar pattern and technique. The great businessmen don't generally succeed because they're clever, or intelligent, but because they take risks others don't, and are driven. For many its not even about the money (they could retire and live a life of luxuary) but they don't, they keep going (when everyone else would choose to retire at 30, people like Branson keep making more and more money, that they could never really spend).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

on me shed son Flag Krakow 26 Oct 15 5.38pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 4.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 4.04pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 1.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.



Quite true.

Unfortunately, if you were to replace the ruling class with plumbers all that would happen is that their kids would get a private education and so on and we would soon be back to square one.

Survival of the fittest extends to offspring even when they aren't really up to it.

My problem with private schools has never been that they exist, but that the a lot of very talented kids miss out on the benefits because of the expense, where as plenty of 'Nice but Dim' Tims will massively benefit because of the people they meet there, just because their father could pay.

These people often do well at university, because they'll benefit from a lot of one on one tuition, in return for the 'new library wing'.

In theory I think the idea of grammar schools is fine provided the entry remains unbiased, and entirely based on pupils achievements. In reality, grammar schools tended towards being selective by their locations, costs of uniforms and so on.

Yes it seems unfair but how can we stop people at the top of society seeking to gain advantage for their children ? We would all do it if we could.

Bring back Grammar schools, I would say. To mitigate the postcode lottery element make it so that all local councils have to provide a certain amount of coverage. I think it's the only way to restore something resembling a meritocracy. Every PM from 1964-1997 went to grammar school.

[Link]

 

elgrande Flag bedford 26 Oct 15 5.40pm

Quote on me shed son at 26 Oct 2015 5.38pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 4.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 4.04pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 1.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.



Quite true.

Unfortunately, if you were to replace the ruling class with plumbers all that would happen is that their kids would get a private education and so on and we would soon be back to square one.

Survival of the fittest extends to offspring even when they aren't really up to it.

My problem with private schools has never been that they exist, but that the a lot of very talented kids miss out on the benefits because of the expense, where as plenty of 'Nice but Dim' Tims will massively benefit because of the people they meet there, just because their father could pay.

These people often do well at university, because they'll benefit from a lot of one on one tuition, in return for the 'new library wing'.

In theory I think the idea of grammar schools is fine provided the entry remains unbiased, and entirely based on pupils achievements. In reality, grammar schools tended towards being selective by their locations, costs of uniforms and so on.

Yes it seems unfair but how can we stop people at the top of society seeking to gain advantage for their children ? We would all do it if we could.

Bring back Grammar schools, I would say. To mitigate the postcode lottery element make it so that all local councils have to provide a certain amount of coverage. I think it's the only way to restore something resembling a meritocracy. Every PM from 1964-1997 went to grammar school.

[Link]


Is the correct answer,where kids from not so good backgrounds could thrive.
But Labour stopped them.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Oct 15 9.05pm

Quote elgrande at 26 Oct 2015 5.40pm

Quote on me shed son at 26 Oct 2015 5.38pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 4.30pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 4.04pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 26 Oct 2015 1.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Oct 2015 1.07pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Only if you assume a meritocracy exists. It doesn't, essentially they aren't 'the best minds' they're the people generally who's parents bought them the best education and had the best access to 'cultural capital'. Excepting maybe a very small percentage of people, what matters more than 'your mind' is the socio-economic background, access to common culture, being able to read well and educational access children have.

There is a reason why people pay very big fees to get their kids a 'private education', and the best schools in the country, generally aren't comprehensives.

We tend to assume that everyone is well educated, but its not really true, children with parents of a high educational standard tend to achieve much higher levels of education themselves, as they are exposed to 'cultural influences' and of course their own parents capacity to provide educational input to their child. Its not a genetic thing, its the fact that bright, educated parents tend to expose their children to far more intellectual stimulation and culture than those who's own education was limited.

In a democracy it should not matter what your educational standard is, anyone should 'be considerable' for a role as an MP or even PM. Their job is to represent the people, not to rule them. A prime minister who was a plumber with only his city and guilds should be as valid as one who went to Eton and Oxford.



Quite true.

Unfortunately, if you were to replace the ruling class with plumbers all that would happen is that their kids would get a private education and so on and we would soon be back to square one.

Survival of the fittest extends to offspring even when they aren't really up to it.

My problem with private schools has never been that they exist, but that the a lot of very talented kids miss out on the benefits because of the expense, where as plenty of 'Nice but Dim' Tims will massively benefit because of the people they meet there, just because their father could pay.

These people often do well at university, because they'll benefit from a lot of one on one tuition, in return for the 'new library wing'.

In theory I think the idea of grammar schools is fine provided the entry remains unbiased, and entirely based on pupils achievements. In reality, grammar schools tended towards being selective by their locations, costs of uniforms and so on.

Yes it seems unfair but how can we stop people at the top of society seeking to gain advantage for their children ? We would all do it if we could.

Bring back Grammar schools, I would say. To mitigate the postcode lottery element make it so that all local councils have to provide a certain amount of coverage. I think it's the only way to restore something resembling a meritocracy. Every PM from 1964-1997 went to grammar school.

[Link]


Is the correct answer,where kids from not so good backgrounds could thrive.
But Labour stopped them.


The trouble is that roughly 80% of the population are not deemed clever enough to attend them. They get much better results that comprehensives mainly because they are selective of course. Many better off parents pay for private tutoring to get their kids through the 11 plus, so for some money still plays a part.

My two got in without any paid for help I should add.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Oct 2015 9.08pm)

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 27 Oct 15 7.05am

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 2.47pm

Quote Sportyteacher at 26 Oct 2015 1.03pm

Quote We are goin up! at 26 Oct 2015 12.45pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Oct 2015 12.33pm

Not dead, just being a prick: [Link]

The positions of power in this country are overwhelmingly held by people from Oxbridge. Nearly 3 out of 4 judges went there, 1 in 2 diplomats, 60% of the cabinet. The very idea that the most senior political position in the country may go to someone who isn't one of their own is clearly pretty scary for people like Amis, who of course defied his own public school/intellectual family/Oxbridge education and became a complete f*cking idiot churning out dull novels.


I don't really have a problem with our best minds running the country, personally. Do you think there should be an MP with a meeja studies degree from the Staines Metropolitan Roundabout University in their place instead?

Edited by We are goin up! (26 Oct 2015 12.46pm)

Martin Amis has too high opinion of himself. His views of Corbyn are only his own in that he doesn't speak or think on my behalf. Jog on, Martin!


And what you're saying is that he shouldn't be allowed to express that opinion?

I'm saying that he is not worthy enough to warrant front page of The Observer. He is being dressed up as some divine, intellectual, modern day 'listen to my profundity' philosopher. Machiavelli and Hobbes have every right to roll in their graves at such a prospect.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Martin Amis