You are here: Home > Message Board > Away Fans > Dougie Freedman
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dougie Freedman


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Clough 1 Flag London 04 Jan 16 1.43pm


Hi Guys , hope you chaps don't mind me invading your space for some information . I'm a long standing Forest fan who is a sponsor of one of our own forums . Now to the nub of my reason for registering on here . There is a lot of debate on whether Dougie is doing an acceptable job in managing our club , not at all an easy task given we're under a transfer embargo due to breaching FFP rules . His signings have of neccessity all been frees or loans with a max salary of £10K per week.

I seem to recall when he was your manager that he signed / developed the nucleus of your team that achieved promotion whilst operating on a tight budget . Is this correct ?. Indeed how many of " his Players " are still with you today ?

Given the circumstances under which he operated do you think he did a good job ?. I realise that he left you under acrimonious circumstances for Bolton ( how he must regret that decision today ) so this may be reflected in your opinions ...

Generally speaking how would you describe your style of play under his management ...

THanks very much in advance for your reply's guys and good luck for the rest of this season ..

 

-always-an-eagle- Flag Hampshire 04 Jan 16 1.58pm

We can all look back with rose tinted glasses because he left us whilst we were at the top of the league. He is also a fans favourite from his playing days.
But that apart I personally don't think he would still be with us now. He's still wet behind the ears in regards to being a manager and still learning.
I loved him as a player but will never forget how he walked out on us for money and a 'bigger club'
In regards to his managerial style I thought considering he plyed his trade as an attacker, he set us up quite defensively.

 


Theres Only One Darren Pitcher

JohnB Flag 04 Jan 16 2.08pm

He brought in some brilliant signings on next to nothing. Bought Bolasie for about £3.50, Glenn Murray on a free, Ward for hardly anything, Delaney on a free, Jedinak on a free and helped develop Zaha into being sold to Man U for £15million.

Having said that, he played boring football and only really seemed to do well when he was politely asked to start attacking by the owners.

I thank him for what he did but am glad he went as we probably would be in the Championship now if he was still here.

 

Ulysses 04 Jan 16 2.21pm

The manner in which Freedman left sours his legacy somewhat, but there is no denying the massively positive effect he has had on the club in its present standing.

As always-an-eagle refers to, his style of football was mostly defensive, focusing more on avoiding defeat and hoping to sneak a 1-0 win. This was very much his initial approach, having taken the job with one objective: avoid relegation to League 1. It wasn't pretty to watch, but he managed it. However, there didn't seem to be much progression in his style - it was almost like he stuck to this style even once we were safe and comfortably midtable. Apparently, and who knows how much truth there is in the story, but Parish and the owners took Dougie to one side in the carpark after one particularly dull performance and said something along the lines of, "Play more attacking football, or you're out."

As stated, who knows how true it is, but there was definitely a distinct improvement in style after the 'talk': players like Zaha and Bolasie had their shackles removed and it was genuinely a treat to watch.

Memory is a little fuzzy, but one of Dougie's biggest attributes from his time here was his ability to spot a gem and polish them up - and that probably suits your current predicament perfectly. Jedinak, Bolasie, Murray (now left, of course), Ward and Delaney were all Freedman purchases with a combined cost of less than a million.

He's still a little green, but I'd give him time.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 16 2.26pm

Mention has made of some of the Freedman signings who are still at the club and also Glenn Murray.

Some of the other Freedman signings were :
Parr, Moxey,Blake,Ramage,Gabbidon,Dikgacoi,Marrow,Moritz,Banton,Easter,Wilbraham,Gardner.

 

Clough 1 Flag London 04 Jan 16 2.41pm

Many thanks for the reply's so far guys . His signings for us , given the financial constraints , have all been much better than could have been expected . He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Where most of the voices of discontent are concerned is with his style of play , solid , defensive , sometimes dour , happy with a 1-0 rather than look for more goals ... Given that we've had our 2 best strikers (Assombalonga and Fryatt ) out injured all season then maybe his negative approach is understandable ????.

His remit from our owner seems to have been to reduce the wage bill ,comply with FFP regs and stabilise the club . He has undoutedly achieved these objectives but at the expense of dour football .. Hopefully when the aforementioned strikers are fit again ( ??? February )then the shackles will be removed .. Time alone will tell.

 

Part Time James Flag 04 Jan 16 2.46pm

I personally don't question that he did a good job in his tenure. I wonder how long we'd have lasted at the top but it's easy to say that when you can't be proved wrong or right.

I have/have had various gripes about him and in particular the way in which he left, but in answer to the very specific question, he did a good job I think.

 




Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 16 2.54pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm

He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Clough

I might be wrong but I have a feeling that most of his signings have been on 'Loan; ie Williams,Trotter,Mendes,Ebicilio,O'Grady,Oliveira,Barrow,Akpom etc.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 04 Jan 16 3.37pm

The team he put together and the style he played meant that Tony Pulis could come in and keep us up as the team were already schooled in a Pulis' style. We have a lot to thank him for but it looks a bit like he got a little lucky and hasn't been able to repeat anything like that since. It now seems he's an average Championship manager.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 16 3.44pm

Quote Andy_G at 04 Jan 2016 3.37pm

The team he put together and the style he played meant that Tony Pulis could come in and keep us up as the team were already schooled in a Pulis' style. We have a lot to thank him for but it looks a bit like he got a little lucky and hasn't been able to repeat anything like that since. It now seems he's an average Championship manager.

When one looks at his signings at Bolton, it doesn't appear that he had a great deal to spend given that many were 'Loan' signings. And of course Bolton's financial woes have been well documented. At Nottm For at the present time he is also operating under financial contraints.

 

Clough 1 Flag London 04 Jan 16 3.54pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 2.54pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm

He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Clough

I might be wrong but I have a feeling that most of his signings have been on 'Loan; ie Williams,Trotter,Mendes,Ebicilio,O'Grady,Oliveira,Barrow,Akpom etc.

No you're not wrong Willo , excepting Mills and Ward all his signings this season have been loans ..
He simply could not have spent a penny due to the FFP embargo even if our owner wished to give him it ...

Personally speaking I think the guy has performed extremely well in getting the players he has , but , and there's always a but , the football could have been a tad more attractive !!!


 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Jan 16 3.56pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm

Many thanks for the reply's so far guys . His signings for us , given the financial constraints , have all been much better than could have been expected . He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Where most of the voices of discontent are concerned is with his style of play , solid , defensive , sometimes dour , happy with a 1-0 rather than look for more goals ... Given that we've had our 2 best strikers (Assombalonga and Fryatt ) out injured all season then maybe his negative approach is understandable ????.

His remit from our owner seems to have been to reduce the wage bill ,comply with FFP regs and stabilise the club . He has undoutedly achieved these objectives but at the expense of dour football .. Hopefully when the aforementioned strikers are fit again ( ??? February )then the shackles will be removed .. Time alone will tell.


It's worth noting that he took over from George Burley who had us playing an open, passing game. So open in fact that we were bottom of the table and had just lost 0-3 at Millwall when GB was fired.

DF came in and made us harder to beat. He played a defender in front of the back 4 and we were grinding results out. It wasn't pretty but we stayed up.

When he left us, we were top of the table and playing some great football.

He was succeeded by Ian Holloway.

Now there is one you want to steer clear of !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 16 3.56pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 3.54pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 2.54pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm

He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Clough

I might be wrong but I have a feeling that most of his signings have been on 'Loan; ie Williams,Trotter,Mendes,Ebicilio,O'Grady,Oliveira,Barrow,Akpom etc.

No you're not wrong Willo , excepting Mills and Ward all his signings this season have been loans ..
He simply could not have spent a penny due to the FFP embargo even if our owner wished to give him it ...

Personally speaking I think the guy has performed extremely well in getting the players he has , but , and there's always a but , the football could have been a tad more attractive !!!


Isn't Pinillos one of his 'Permanent' signings as well ?


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 16 4.03pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm


Where most of the voices of discontent are concerned is with his style of play , solid , defensive , sometimes dour , happy with a 1-0 rather than look for more goals

In actual fact in Freedman's first 6 games in charge, Nottm Forest scored 19 goals ! Maybe Assombalonga and Fryatt were playing !

Edited by Willo (04 Jan 2016 4.13pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Jan 16 4.08pm

Think that like McClaren a better coach than a manager

As mentioned a very good eye for a player but we played some real dross under him, that if it had been anyone else, he would have been lynched. I was gutted when he left, he sold us a dream on the last day of the season (funnily enough after the game against you) that made fans believe in him.

When you see his teams play you understand the phrase "Dour Scotsman"

Also likes to chase a pound - just saying

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 04 Jan 16 4.10pm

Keep him, be patient and I think you could reap the rewards. Has an eye for a player and seems to be doing OK with the situation he's inherited. He was cut a lot of slack here because of his playing career with us, but he built a side that still has his mark on it to a certain extent.

I think it was in April last season, we beat West Ham 3-0 away, and seven of the starting XI came from the Championship side that he built.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Clough 1 Flag London 04 Jan 16 4.20pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 3.56pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 3.54pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 2.54pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm

He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Clough

I might be wrong but I have a feeling that most of his signings have been on 'Loan; ie Williams,Trotter,Mendes,Ebicilio,O'Grady,Oliveira,Barrow,Akpom etc.

No you're not wrong Willo , excepting Mills and Ward all his signings this season have been loans ..
He simply could not have spent a penny due to the FFP embargo even if our owner wished to give him it ...

Personally speaking I think the guy has performed extremely well in getting the players he has , but , and there's always a but , the football could have been a tad more attractive !!!


Isn't Pinillos one of his 'Permanent' signings as well ?


Yes he is Willo , and the best left back we've had in years . Such a tragedy for the lad that he's ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament , an injury occuring with increased frequency in todays game ..


 

Clough 1 Flag London 04 Jan 16 4.23pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 4.03pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm


Where most of the voices of discontent are concerned is with his style of play , solid , defensive , sometimes dour , happy with a 1-0 rather than look for more goals

In actual fact in Freedman's first 6 games in charge, Nottm Forest scored 19 goals ! Maybe Assombalonga and Fryatt were playing !

You're correct they were playing for most if not all of those games .. How I long for them to be back in tandem leading our forward line .

Edited by Willo (04 Jan 2016 4.13pm)


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Jan 16 4.25pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 4.20pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 3.56pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 3.54pm

Quote Willo at 04 Jan 2016 2.54pm

Quote Clough 1 at 04 Jan 2016 2.41pm

He does seem to have an eye for a player and an extensive knowledge of the European " market " ..

Clough

I might be wrong but I have a feeling that most of his signings have been on 'Loan; ie Williams,Trotter,Mendes,Ebicilio,O'Grady,Oliveira,Barrow,Akpom etc.

No you're not wrong Willo , excepting Mills and Ward all his signings this season have been loans ..
He simply could not have spent a penny due to the FFP embargo even if our owner wished to give him it ...

Personally speaking I think the guy has performed extremely well in getting the players he has , but , and there's always a but , the football could have been a tad more attractive !!!


Isn't Pinillos one of his 'Permanent' signings as well ?


Yes he is Willo , and the best left back we've had in years . Such a tragedy for the lad that he's ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament , an injury occuring with increased frequency in todays game ..

But not as good as Stuart Pearce ! I've heard that Pinillos is a decent player - not a bad "Free" from Cordoba.


 

georgey wood Flag South London and Proud 04 Jan 16 4.28pm

Dear Cloughy Freedmans Footballing philosophy was best described in a radio interview I remember when he said: "You start with a point every match and you have to at least keep it! " Basically that if you don't concede you always gain a point and you have gained something.....,

Amazing signings Delaney, Bolasie and Ward ( all for peanuts) are still the heart beat of our team and we honestly struggle if any are missing to this day. As willo mentioned the signings of Moritz, Gardener and especially Murray were master strokes and players that in my opinion were exceptional in their time at Selhurst.

A very good coach, scout, motivator in my opinion I agree maybe still hasn't got the know how yet to get a promotion but your in very good hands. Also despite the consensus that he is a dour gaffer the couple of month run from losing at Bristol City to going top of the league at Peterborough (I think ) in our promotion season, was some of the best football I've seen in my 30 years supporting palace and I attended every game in that run ( I think only surpassed by our Football under Steve Bruce and Pardiola at the moment)

Good luck at forest a truly great club! I will never forget my memories of the city ground as a kid with Stuart Pearce saluting the crowd when he scored a free kick against us with the biggest thighs I've ever seen and John Salako lobbing one in from the half way line in the last minute in a cup tie in early 90s. I think after the initial game had been postponed due to fog that came down on the Trent 10 minutes before kick off. I had bunked school, got the train up and ended up grounded for a game that never actually happened ha, ha.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Away Fans > Dougie Freedman