This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Might have to make a special k ace for that bill.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
It does underline the absurdity of the UK policy, which does fly in the face of evidence and research from the last 30 years showing that the war on drugs (Labour weren't any better). An absurd piece of legislation that essentially won't make much difference except to criminalise people unnecessary and to stimulate the black market in recreational drugs, and create greater problems for society. Its also questionable how this would be enforceable with countries not in the UK, that don't enforce this legislation. At a time when even the most vocal and ardent Anti-Drug nation (the US) is moving in the opposite direction and benefitting, the UK seems to be stuck in the past. The idea that maybe you could purchase recreational drugs from a legal, government registered source, on line at a reasonable price would present a more viable solution (allowing control of quality, price, distribution and manufacture - which would arguably be good for users, addicts, police resourcing and the victims drug related crime).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
so these poppers - any good?
|
|
|
Quote npn at 21 Jan 2016 10.52am
so these poppers - any good?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
Keep drugs illegal. The fact is that all drugs are damaging to the individual and society. Drugs break up families, destroy individuals and cause communities to dissolve. I'm not sure that's necessarily true in a literal sense. Drugs themselves don't break up families, people in families do that all the time. I think it becomes a convenience to blame the drug rather than the person, because it permits us to abscond responsibility to individuals we care for. Certainly addiction destroys families and kills individuals, but the problem of addiction is only representative of a few of the banned drugs. In terms of communities, the illegality is probably more damaging - notably the crime caused by gangs financed by drug money, and crime committed to obtain money for drugs. Its notable that primarily in terms of community the problem is heroin and cocaine both rather expensive drugs (who's price is massively inflated by the black market). By criminalising drugs I would argue that greater pressures are put on families, individuals and communities than the drugs themselves. Prison and fines put a greater stress on families, the high expense of the black market and the risk in terms of quality are more threatening to individuals, than the drug itself and communities suffer more because of the social impacts of a very lucrative black market than the cost of treating addicts. Also people who have been caught up in the criminal justice approach, find themselves having to deal with criminal records and the impact on employment as well as losing jobs and income. Attempts to deal with the problems of alcohol via prohibition, created a greater social problem than alcohol and addiction; which affected people who didn't have a problem. Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
I am sure that proponent's of drug liberalisation can provide many studies that 'prove' that drugs are more harmful illegal than legal but I just do not buy it. They aren't, there are just less impacts and risks. Heroin as a drug is more or less as harmful if produced legally or illegally. The difference is that legally its easier for the user to control the risks and reduce the costs very significantly (Heroin is sold at profit to the NHS for 1/35th the price of its street equivalent. Its also especially for those not involved. A very significant number of people who have no interest in drugs and don't even know someone with a drug problem, experience robbery, muggings, burglary, theft etc by addicts seeking to fund their addiction to crack and heroin (Finding 80-200 a day, means committing generally 240-600 a day in crime). Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
The amount of people I have personally seen had their lives f***ed up through drugs and wish they had never come into contact with them is enough for me. Me too, but I also grew up in an AA family, and saw those same kinds of stories from alcoholics as well - Its a problem. Banning the drugs in question hasn't helped any of those people either - And plenty of people have their lives f**ked up by the criminal justice factor, receiving criminal records because they like to get stoned rather than drunk, even in some cases spending time in prison.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 2.17pm
Quote The Sash at 21 Jan 2016 1.32pm
Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
Keep drugs illegal. The fact is that all drugs are damaging to the individual and society. Drugs break up families, destroy individuals and cause communities to dissolve. I am sure that proponent's of drug liberalisation can provide many studies that 'prove' that drugs are more harmful illegal than legal but I just do not buy it. The amount of people I have personally seen had their lives f***ed up through drugs and wish they had never come into contact with them is enough for me.
Tobacco yes, alcohol no. We destroyed a perfectly good system of control of alcohol by allowing all and sundry to flog it, rather than just the publican, the offy and the restaurant. Whilst I hear what you are saying about alcohol, imagine what society would be like if all and sundry had access to heroin or crack. It would be horrendous. I'm inclined to agree that alcohol should be restricted to off-licences, pubs and restaurants. I'm not entirely sold on the idea of heroin and crack -A part of me is wary about that. But I'd say the same doesn't follow for Weed, Ecstasy, LSD, Mushrooms, Speed, Cocaine (rather than crack) etc - which is where most of the drug use in the UK occurs. Heroin and crack use is quite low by comparison, and has generally been stable - Its a tiny fraction of UK drug use. People I've known who have gone down the heroin and crack route tended towards being 'f**k ups', not all of them, but for the most part they had issues to which those drugs appealed.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 2.19pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Jan 2016 1.57pm
Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
Keep drugs illegal. The fact is that all drugs are damaging to the individual and society. Drugs break up families, destroy individuals and cause communities to dissolve. I'm not sure that's necessarily true in a literal sense. Drugs themselves don't break up families, people in families do that all the time. I think it becomes a convenience to blame the drug rather than the person, because it permits us to abscond responsibility to individuals we care for. Certainly addiction destroys families and kills individuals, but the problem of addiction is only representative of a few of the banned drugs. In terms of communities, the illegality is probably more damaging - notably the crime caused by gangs financed by drug money, and crime committed to obtain money for drugs. Its notable that primarily in terms of community the problem is heroin and cocaine both rather expensive drugs (who's price is massively inflated by the black market). By criminalising drugs I would argue that greater pressures are put on families, individuals and communities than the drugs themselves. Prison and fines put a greater stress on families, the high expense of the black market and the risk in terms of quality are more threatening to individuals, than the drug itself and communities suffer more because of the social impacts of a very lucrative black market than the cost of treating addicts. Also people who have been caught up in the criminal justice approach, find themselves having to deal with criminal records and the impact on employment as well as losing jobs and income. Attempts to deal with the problems of alcohol via prohibition, created a greater social problem than alcohol and addiction; which affected people who didn't have a problem. Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
I am sure that proponent's of drug liberalisation can provide many studies that 'prove' that drugs are more harmful illegal than legal but I just do not buy it. They aren't, there are just less impacts and risks. Heroin as a drug is more or less as harmful if produced legally or illegally. The difference is that legally its easier for the user to control the risks and reduce the costs very significantly (Heroin is sold at profit to the NHS for 1/35th the price of its street equivalent. Its also especially for those not involved. A very significant number of people who have no interest in drugs and don't even know someone with a drug problem, experience robbery, muggings, burglary, theft etc by addicts seeking to fund their addiction to crack and heroin (Finding 80-200 a day, means committing generally 240-600 a day in crime). Quote matt_himself at 21 Jan 2016 10.53am
The amount of people I have personally seen had their lives f***ed up through drugs and wish they had never come into contact with them is enough for me. Me too, but I also grew up in an AA family, and saw those same kinds of stories from alcoholics as well - Its a problem. Banning the drugs in question hasn't helped any of those people either - And plenty of people have their lives f**ked up by the criminal justice factor, receiving criminal records because they like to get stoned rather than drunk, even in some cases spending time in prison. I completely disagree with you. I think your view is slanted by your politics and not the reality of drug abuse or the experience of those affected by drugs. Not so much my politics, but my experience with drugs and rehab.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.