You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > This (Cameron protest)
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

This (Cameron protest)


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
scrumpyjack Flag 10 Apr 16 2.31pm

[Link]

 

phil19750 Flag Sundridge Park 11 Apr 16 9.13am

What's the problem?

Cameron paid all owed UK taxes.

 


el burro sabe más que tú

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Apr 16 9.24am

Originally posted by phil19750

What's the problem?

You can see from the posts on that Facebook account that one of the major problems is jealousy as Cameron and his wife come from wealthy families

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 9.36am

Originally posted by phil19750

What's the problem?

Cameron paid all owed UK taxes.

Seems fair to me. There is nothing wrong with benefiting from the actions of others.

Although there is somewhat of an issue with the manner in which Cameron has handled the issue, and potentially deceived the public. He seems to have had a sliding scale of statements, that make him look as if he was hiding something.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

phil19750 Flag Sundridge Park 11 Apr 16 9.41am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Seems fair to me. There is nothing wrong with benefiting from the actions of others.

Although there is somewhat of an issue with the manner in which Cameron has handled the issue, and potentially deceived the public. He seems to have had a sliding scale of statements, that make him look as if he was hiding something.

Yeah, he hasn't handled it particularly well, but then again, what has his private finances got to do with anyone else?

If he acted illegally, then that is a matter for the courts.

Who can honestly say that they have never paid a builder cash in hand, or bought foreign fags that were not subject to import duty?

It's all b0llocks.

 


el burro sabe más que tú

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 9.46am

Originally posted by phil19750

Yeah, he hasn't handled it particularly well, but then again, what has his private finances got to do with anyone else?

If he acted illegally, then that is a matter for the courts.

Who can honestly say that they have never paid a builder cash in hand, or bought foreign fags that were not subject to import duty?

It's all b0llocks.

I think its a bit different when you're the prime minister or a MP, as you are accountable for what you say and how you represent the people. Certainly, talking big about tax avoidance, and then being caught up in a tax avoidance issue, speaks to the reliability and trust the public place in a politician to implement and stand by their word. Its like when it was 'Family Values' with MPs banging their mistresses.

Personally, I think this will go 'down an expenses route' scandal, and a lot of different people and companies will end up with egg on their face, typically after holding others up for 'inspection'.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

phil19750 Flag Sundridge Park 11 Apr 16 9.57am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think its a bit different when you're the prime minister or a MP, as you are accountable for what you say and how you represent the people. Certainly, talking big about tax avoidance, and then being caught up in a tax avoidance issue, speaks to the reliability and trust the public place in a politician to implement and stand by their word. Its like when it was 'Family Values' with MPs banging their mistresses.

Personally, I think this will go 'down an expenses route' scandal, and a lot of different people and companies will end up with egg on their face, typically after holding others up for 'inspection'.

He sold his interest before he became Prime Minister.

There can't be one rule for one and one rule for others.

The "tax avoidance" is legal and no different than investing in an ISA.

Edited by phil19750 (11 Apr 2016 9.57am)

 


el burro sabe más que tú

Hoof Hearted 11 Apr 16 10.17am

Is Corbyn and the leader of the Green Party etc going to publish their accounts?

Is that moron with the megaphone going to come clean about how he makes his money, and what tax he pays (if any) ?

I'll bet half those people on that "rally" have avoided tax buying and selling items on EBay, overdoing duty free items on trips to France helping Asylum Seekers, getting paid in cash for casual work done... the rest will be benefit scroungers helping themselves to our hard earned tax/NI spending it on weed, cider and iPhones, then turning up at the foodbank pleading poverty.

Cameron was stupid to publish his accounts, as jealous tools like this shower think they have him on the run.

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 11 Apr 16 10.24am

Originally posted by phil19750

He sold his interest when it was looking like he'd become Prime Minister.

There can't be one rule for one and one rule for others.

The "tax avoidance" is legal and no different than investing in an ISA.

Edited by phil19750 (11 Apr 2016 9.57am)

EFA.

It's a question of morality for anyone wishing to govern us, not legality.
'Avoidance', whether legal or not, is hardly the right course for ANY MP to follow.

 


Time to move forward together.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 10.28am

Originally posted by phil19750

He sold his interest before he became Prime Minister.

There can't be one rule for one and one rule for others.

The "tax avoidance" is legal and no different than investing in an ISA.

Edited by phil19750 (11 Apr 2016 9.57am)

Tax Avoidance might be legal, there is no guarantee that many of these off shore schemes are legal, because they haven't been tested. The ISA scheme is well established as legal, because it specifically within the legal definitions.

However, when you're talking about funds transferred to a shell company, overseas, which has phony members to hide its ownership, then you're into questionable legality, especially if you didn't haven't declared it as earnings. And here in lies the important aspect, that would be potentially criminal.

And even if criminal charges aren't brought, that doesn't mean the scheme is legal either, charges only relate to the criminal offence of tax evasion. To reclaim such income as tax, doesn't require 'beyond reasonable doubt', only that its established as having been eligible for taxation payments.

Its even possible that people weren't even aware how their money was being handled - as a lot of people will have accountants and firms that 'deal with that for them' and their interest is strictly about the return (which would make proving a criminal intent difficult).

That is also known as common method of money laundering (where in you disguise income, take a small loss on it, in order to convert it back from a seeming legitimate source at a later date).

The problem many of these people may well face is that the methods used abroad would be illegal within the UK (in fact they'd be money laundering and tax evasion within the United Kingdom). HMRC would likely try to make the case that as such, because the funds were from the UK, by UK citizens, resident in the UK for more than x length of time each year, then they represent evasion rather than avoidance.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 11 Apr 16 10.36am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Is Corbyn and the leader of the Green Party etc going to publish their accounts?

Is that moron with the megaphone going to come clean about how he makes his money, and what tax he pays (if any) ?

I'll bet half those people on that "rally" have avoided tax buying and selling items on EBay, overdoing duty free items on trips to France helping Asylum Seekers, getting paid in cash for casual work done... the rest will be benefit scroungers helping themselves to our hard earned tax/NI spending it on weed, cider and iPhones, then turning up at the foodbank pleading poverty.

Cameron was stupid to publish his accounts, as jealous tools like this shower think they have him on the run.

Bizarre to criticise those rallying, particularly when your argument is made up entirely of speculation and guesswork.

You have no idea the employment status, financial status or lifestyle of these people, so to generalise them as such because they have an opinion different to your own is very weak.

 

Hoof Hearted 11 Apr 16 10.37am

Originally posted by -TUX-

EFA.

It's a question of morality for anyone wishing to govern us, not legality.
'Avoidance', whether legal or not, is hardly the right course for ANY MP to follow.

Why can't MP's have ISA's, or any other legally constructed tax efficient saving vehicles that the rest of the UK population can have then TUX?

What's immoral about what he did?

As we speak I have investments all over the globe contained within my ISA's and SIPP (Self Invested Personal Pension).

I paid zero tax last year by taking an income from the SIPP just below the Nil rate threshold and paid it into my ISA, where it continues to grow tax free and I can draw down on it when I choose to without paying any tax.

Anyone that is criticising Cameron is probably a hypocrite and/or doesn't understand that tax planning is a legitimate exercise that creates wealth for the country from companies like Hargreaves Lansdown and other fund managers being successful making a profit and paying corporation tax as well as employing thousands of staff.

 

Hoof Hearted 11 Apr 16 10.41am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Bizarre to criticise those rallying, particularly when your argument is made up entirely of speculation and guesswork.

You have no idea the employment status, financial status or lifestyle of these people, so to generalise them as such because they have an opinion different to your own is very weak.

Just making a point comrade.

It's okay for Mr Megaphone to speculate about Cameron when he knows only what his imagination tells him and Socialist Worker journalists print in their lefty rag.

If my opinion is weak, then so is Mr Megaphones.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 11 Apr 16 10.45am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Tax Avoidance might be legal, there is no guarantee that many of these off shore schemes are legal, because they haven't been tested. The ISA scheme is well established as legal, because it specifically within the legal definitions.

However, when you're talking about funds transferred to a shell company, overseas, which has phony members to hide its ownership, then you're into questionable legality, especially if you didn't haven't declared it as earnings. And here in lies the important aspect, that would be potentially criminal.

And even if criminal charges aren't brought, that doesn't mean the scheme is legal either, charges only relate to the criminal offence of tax evasion. To reclaim such income as tax, doesn't require 'beyond reasonable doubt', only that its established as having been eligible for taxation payments.

Its even possible that people weren't even aware how their money was being handled - as a lot of people will have accountants and firms that 'deal with that for them' and their interest is strictly about the return (which would make proving a criminal intent difficult).

That is also known as common method of money laundering (where in you disguise income, take a small loss on it, in order to convert it back from a seeming legitimate source at a later date).

The problem many of these people may well face is that the methods used abroad would be illegal within the UK (in fact they'd be money laundering and tax evasion within the United Kingdom). HMRC would likely try to make the case that as such, because the funds were from the UK, by UK citizens, resident in the UK for more than x length of time each year, then they represent evasion rather than avoidance.

All seems a bit contrived to me.

Yes, he's very wealthy (no surprise to anyone that an Eton boy may have a bit of cash, surely).
The cash was invested in a tax efficient manner (presumably on the advice of a Financial Advisor and/or accountant).
He paid all tax due.

I once sold a house I rented out, and minimised my CGT liability by cross-claiming losses I made on a business venture. Efficient. Legal. Fine, surely?

I'm all for loopholes in tax legislation being investigated, plugged (where they are proven to be dodgy), and preferably something put in place to prevent accountants just inventing new ones, and I firmly believe we should be pumping billions into HMRC to do just that, but claiming immorality is a false argument, just as it would be to claim it's immoral to either utilise your entire ISA allowance every year, or to gift your children cash to avoid eventual inheritance tax.

All in my own opinion, of course - I'm sure others will disagree.

 

Hoof Hearted 11 Apr 16 10.49am

Originally posted by npn

All seems a bit contrived to me.

Yes, he's very wealthy (no surprise to anyone that an Eton boy may have a bit of cash, surely).
The cash was invested in a tax efficient manner (presumably on the advice of a Financial Advisor and/or accountant).
He paid all tax due.

I once sold a house I rented out, and minimised my CGT liability by cross-claiming losses I made on a business venture. Efficient. Legal. Fine, surely?

I'm all for loopholes in tax legislation being investigated, plugged (where they are proven to be dodgy), and preferably something put in place to prevent accountants just inventing new ones, and I firmly believe we should be pumping billions into HMRC to do just that, but claiming immorality is a false argument, just as it would be to claim it's immoral to either utilise your entire ISA allowance every year, or to gift your children cash to avoid eventual inheritance tax.

All in my own opinion, of course - I'm sure others will disagree.

Well said npn.

Morality shouldn't come into it.

If Cameron, or any other MP or celebrity has invested in a totally legal tax efficient instrument that is their business and HRMC's - nobody elses.

If you don't like it, form your own political party, get elected and change the tax laws.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 11 Apr 16 11.08am

The complete tw*t in that video went on This Week (political programme that's on after Question Time) trying to convince everyone that they shouldn't vote. He was also privately educated, nice place to have socialist views from, isn't it? BBC's wet dream. Watch Andrew Neil tearing him apart here:

[Link]

When will the left learn that the more they moan, the less appealing their cause is to the average man? It's pathetic. They think because they shout the loudest that they are winning the argument, even though time and again this is proved to not be the case.

Cameron has clearly not done anything wrong, his crime is to wisely manage his personal finances. I'd be more worried if he hadn't. Having said that, he hasn't covered himself in glory in his handling of it. Calls for him to resign are ludicrous.


Edited by We are goin up! (11 Apr 2016 11.25am)

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Hoof Hearted 11 Apr 16 11.36am

Originally posted by We are goin up!

The complete tw*t in that video went on This Week (political programme that's on after Question Time) trying to convince everyone that they shouldn't vote. He was also privately educated, nice place to have socialist views from, isn't it? BBC's wet dream. Watch Andrew Neil tearing him apart here:

[Link]

When will the left learn that the more they moan, the less appealing their cause is to the average man? It's pathetic. They think because they shout the loudest that they are winning the argument, even though time and again this is proved to not be the case.

Cameron has clearly not done anything wrong, his crime is to wisely manage his personal finances. I'd be more worried if he hadn't. Having said that, he hasn't covered himself in glory in his handling of it. Calls for him to resign are ludicrous.


Edited by We are goin up! (11 Apr 2016 11.25am)


Hahaha... what a cock.

He trumpets the advantage he and his cohorts have in being able to check facts on the internet then the 'old guys' memories prove to be far superior than his instant facts by pointing out to him that Suez and Iraq were similar events whereas he thought they weren't.

Then Portillo stuffs him with his textbook definition of Austerity which confounds him completely and the guy just pulls a face when he realises that he is only just another angry 'Russell Brand' type spouting hot air/bollocks.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (11 Apr 2016 11.38am)

 

legaleagle Flag 11 Apr 16 11.40am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Is Corbyn and the leader of the Green Party etc going to publish their accounts?

Is that moron with the megaphone going to come clean about how he makes his money, and what tax he pays (if any) ?

I'll bet half those people on that "rally" have avoided tax buying and selling items on EBay, overdoing duty free items on trips to France helping Asylum Seekers, getting paid in cash for casual work done... the rest will be benefit scroungers helping themselves to our hard earned tax/NI spending it on weed, cider and iPhones, then turning up at the foodbank pleading poverty.

Cameron was stupid to publish his accounts, as jealous tools like this shower think they have him on the run.

Careful Hoof,or people might attribute your ignorance about duty free within the EU to all your views..There is no duty free for trips to France...abolished in 1999!

 

Hoof Hearted 11 Apr 16 11.53am

Originally posted by legaleagle

Careful Hoof,or people might attribute your ignorance about duty free within the EU to all your views..There is no duty free for trips to France...abolished in 1999!

[Link]

But... there are still limits as to what you can bring in to the UK from France or any other EU nation for it to be deemed "personal use".

Pulling me up on the term "duty free" doesn't change the sentiment (and I noticed your usual attempts to discredit my posts with reference to general ignorance, even though you did it in a light hearted fashion.... if you think I'm generally an ignorant person at least have the cojones to say it openly )

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Apr 16 12.05pm

Originally posted by npn

All seems a bit contrived to me.

Yes, he's very wealthy (no surprise to anyone that an Eton boy may have a bit of cash, surely).
The cash was invested in a tax efficient manner (presumably on the advice of a Financial Advisor and/or accountant).
He paid all tax due.

The key is untested schemes, which rely on obfuscation rather than necessarily fitting into the law or spirit of the law. The advice of a Financial Advisor or Accountant doesn't mean a scheme is necessarily legal. For example, an ISA is legal, as are cash gifts if you don't die within 7 years, because they're established in UK law.

A lot of tax avoidance schemes are in a grey area that they have not been tested in law, and with these offshores they also rely on obfuscation using laws in those countries that are different to the UKs. For example, a lot of these Panama exposed schemes seem to rely on fraudulent practices that would be against the law in the UK (such as fake employees and shareholders) or withholding the names of directors of a company (or using the name of someone who isn't a director to acts as the director and paying them to do so).

Originally posted by npn

I once sold a house I rented out, and minimised my CGT liability by cross-claiming losses I made on a business venture. Efficient. Legal. Fine, surely?

Yes, definitely legal, provided those cross claimed losses were on a legitimate venture. Now if that venture was specifically set up to make a loss, in order to minimalise capital gain taxes (ie the loss of the venture was lower than the savings on CGT, then it could very well be illegal, as it falls into areas of fraud).

Originally posted by npn

I'm all for loopholes in tax legislation being investigated, plugged (where they are proven to be dodgy), and preferably something put in place to prevent accountants just inventing new ones, and I firmly believe we should be pumping billions into HMRC to do just that, but claiming immorality is a false argument, just as it would be to claim it's immoral to either utilise your entire ISA allowance every year, or to gift your children cash to avoid eventual inheritance tax.

I'm not even that draconian, I don't really have a problem where people are say adopting a scheme in the UK that reduces their tax earnings a bit, provided they're not taking the p*ss. Kind of like if someone on benefits, earns a few quid doing labour on the side, or someone occasionally does some private work to make ends meet.

I think inevitably everyone will game the system to an extent, same as when people throw a sickie for a day off, or pay someone cash for a discount.

But this isn't to make ends meet, top up or save a bit here and there, its enormous and many of them would be illegal where they conducted in the UK, where these people are resident and earning the money from. It seems a lot of them aren't about 'saving a bit' but as much as is humanly possible - and hiding it entirely.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > This (Cameron protest)