This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Keeper
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Goldfiinger Just down the road 26 Nov 16 6.22pm |
|
|
Do people think the score would have been the same if Mandanda had been playing...?
|
curlyeagle crowborough 26 Nov 16 6.26pm |
|
|
I genuinly don't think the score would have been any different if both Hennesey and Mandana had been in goal.
There is sadly a much bigger picture to this awful mess we are in! Pardew
Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days
|
Salford eagle 26 Nov 16 6.29pm |
|
|
I think our defending was poor but Hennesey has to take some of the blame. He rarely dives and is afraid to come out and claim or fist a ball! He needs to get stuck in!
Is it the coaching? We've never questioned keepers so much in my time of supporting Palace. Hennesey is a different player for Wales!
California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 26 Nov 16 6.30pm |
|
Originally posted by curlyeagle
I genuinly don't think the score would have been any different if both Hennesey and Mandana had been in goal.
There is sadly a much bigger picture to this awful mess we are in! Pardew
Very true.
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 26 Nov 16 6.35pm |
|
|
Hey I think Pards has to go. But the question is do we think Mandanda would have kept the score line lower..?
|
Durban Road Eagle 26 Nov 16 6.41pm |
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
Hey I think Pards has to go. But the question is do we think Mandanda would have kept the score line lower..?
Or Jules?
Kentish Maid, born Beckenham, Kent; lifelong Palace supporter.
|
sueagle2012 26 Nov 16 6.48pm |
|
|
I just looked at all the goals again.
Goal 1) Hennessy definetely should have done better for Goal 1. It was on his side and he either did not organise well enough or he was too slow to react. In fact he did not even dive. Goals 2: Dann is weak and then Cabaye makes a mess of the goalline clearance. Ward not tight on Fer. Hennessey not at fault. Goals 3): Mcarthur loses first header and then bad second ball defending. Probbly little Hennessey coudl have done.
Goal 4: This was bad all round play and the whole team shoudl be blamed for not seeing the game out. Montero tricked around Zaha and Ward and both Dann and Tomkin were poor as Sigurdsom got in between them. . Hennessy made a decent save before the shot went in. Goal 5: Tomkins missed header and then Beneteke was too slow to track back. Hennessy could have come out imposed himself.
So, overall bad defending and I am not sure other keepers would have done better.
Edited by sueagle2012 (26 Nov 2016 7.12pm)
|
SwordFish Peasmarsh,East Sussex 26 Nov 16 6.49pm |
|
|
Al this while speroni sits on the bench wondering what the hell he done to lose his place in the first instance!
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 26 Nov 16 6.49pm |
|
|
Yes I'd say both Jules and Mandanda would have done better today. WH just isn't good enough at this level IMO
|
susmik PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 26 Nov 16 6.57pm |
|
|
Why did not the "Arrogant one" put Jules in goal today he has far better reflexes than Wayne and does not stand there like a wet blanket. At least he can dive and make great saves unlike Wayne who today who should have stopped a couple or more of Swansea's goals. He just stands there and flaps when the ball goes flying past him. He cannot command his area and does little to arrange his defenders. I noticed on only one corner today he had a man on each post which is basic set piece protection. Jules must have really upset the "Arrogant one" to be either on the bench or back at home which proves to me and many others that he does not know his best team. I have a feeling that if Steve Parish does not do something soon we will be up to our necks in the mire. I also wonder who and what training our team actually gets during the week ????
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.
|
matthau South Croydon 26 Nov 16 7.03pm |
|
|
Dont worry, after today even I say Pards has to go and Ive been defending him forever.
However, I find it remarkable how not many are having a go at the players.
Some of our midfielders and defenders are very much due the same disrespectful insults as pardew has received imo.
|
Palace4861 Sevenoaks 26 Nov 16 7.06pm |
|
|
I think it's unfair blaming our keeper, who ever is in goal . Our defence has been going downhill since WBA away last season . Back to the goalies. Has any one else notice how Mandana used to come out and collect the high balls . But I haven't seen him do this for a number of games now . Hennessey also comes out and collects the high ball for Wales but not us . Is this down to the coach .
|
collier row eagle romford essex via another galaxy 26 Nov 16 7.13pm |
|
Originally posted by matthau
Dont worry, after today even I say Pards has to go and Ive been defending him forever.
However, I find it remarkable how not many are having a go at the players.
Some of our midfielders and defenders are very much due the same disrespectful insults as pardew has received imo.
Quite true, but the buck stops with the manager, that's the law!!
|
Dangermouse Hastings 26 Nov 16 7.14pm |
|
Originally posted by Palace4861
I think it's unfair blaming our keeper, who ever is in goal . Our defence has been going downhill since WBA away last season . Back to the goalies. Has any one else notice how Mandana used to come out and collect the high balls . But I haven't seen him do this for a number of games now . Hennessey also comes out and collects the high ball for Wales but not us . Is this down to the coach .
I'd say yes. Keeper wasn't the problem today, but both keepers will be very short of confidence now. Time for Jules I think, although he isn't commanding either.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Henry of Peckham Eton Mess 26 Nov 16 7.49pm |
|
Originally posted by Palace4861
I think it's unfair blaming our keeper, who ever is in goal . Our defence has been going downhill since WBA away last season . Back to the goalies. Has any one else notice how Mandana used to come out and collect the high balls . But I haven't seen him do this for a number of games now . Hennessey also comes out and collects the high ball for Wales but not us . Is this down to the coach .
I think you are right about Mandanda coming out and collecting the high balls ... he also use to kick pretty accurately (as I recall) out to the wingers and forward. He's stopped doing that too.
Denial is not just a river in Egypt
|
rawpalace05 Saltdean 26 Nov 16 7.56pm |
|
|
Me! Hennesy did the same f***ing exact thing last season against them! Woeful!
1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.
palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 27 Nov 16 1.48pm |
|
|
I really th Know jules needs to be number one at least until Mandanda is fit again. WH shouldn't get near the first team IMO.
As for the defence, we'll we need to go shopping
|
Painter Croydon 27 Nov 16 2.22pm |
|
Originally posted by Goldfiinger
I really th Know jules needs to be number one at least until Mandanda is fit again. WH shouldn't get near the first team IMO.
As for the defence, we'll we need to go shopping
On what basis, do you think Speroni should be back in the team, apart from you like him. He hasn't played for months, when he did against Fulham, he was shocking. WH is a competent keeper, its the defence that need to improve.
|
thegreatlardino crawley/selsey 27 Nov 16 3.07pm |
|
|
little baffled why he didnt come out for the last goal, was a straight free kick into the box, nearly on the goal line when benteke made a hash of it
Sometimes I set out for Ludlow Sometimes I end up in Chepstow
|
Brentmiester_General Front line in the battle against t... 27 Nov 16 6.23pm |
|
Originally posted by Painter
On what basis, do you think Speroni should be back in the team, apart from you like him. He hasn't played for months, when he did against Fulham, he was shocking. WH is a competent keeper, its the defence that need to improve.
Wayne hadn't played for months when a minority were calling for him to be given a go last season over the brilliant Jules. So if fair is fair, then it is only tight Jules is given a go now. Especially with Wayne letting in 7 goals in the two games he's played. Wouldn't you say?
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...
|